Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to DSDs mum

946 replies

RoarRoarBoom · 27/08/2023 20:03

I am taking my kids to Disneyland Paris next year with my mum. My mum is paying for half the trip and I’m paying the other half.

My partner is not coming and isn’t paying towards it. It’s just a trip with my mum and kids. He is all the kids father.

We dropped DSD back home today and she’s told her mum that I’m taking my kids to Disneyland and she’s sent my partner a Whats app asking if I would consider taking DSD on the trip too.

If I say no then she is going to kick off but I don’t want to take her. This is a trip with my mum and her grandkids.

AIBU to say not consider this at all

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 20:38

BathingBeauty · 29/08/2023 16:54

  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

I don’t understand this, what’s the problem. Is someone suggesting they aren’t a family when SD isn’t there. Is SD also not in a family when she is with her mum?

You'd understand it if you'd been subject to as many "aren't you a unit/your whole family isn't there" type comments from people on here complaining when a step parent does something without their SC.

RoarRoarBoom · 29/08/2023 20:35

MeetMyCat · 29/08/2023 19:36

What a nasty post.

I just found it laughable. They must be a clown for a living.

OP posts:
MeetMyCat · 29/08/2023 19:36

paulaparticles · 29/08/2023 18:47

Your boyfriend isn't invited as then dsd would have to be invited and you don't want her there. As dsd has already been and likely talks of it you now want your children to go and experience it. Nothing wrong with that apart from you seem to be getting some thrill from upsetting dsd and boyfriends ex. Which is the whole point of the holiday. The End.

What a nasty post.

paulaparticles · 29/08/2023 18:47

Your boyfriend isn't invited as then dsd would have to be invited and you don't want her there. As dsd has already been and likely talks of it you now want your children to go and experience it. Nothing wrong with that apart from you seem to be getting some thrill from upsetting dsd and boyfriends ex. Which is the whole point of the holiday. The End.

MeetMyCat · 29/08/2023 18:28

SavetheNHS · 29/08/2023 17:01

This thread is very OTT. I hope you have a lovely holiday OP and ignore anyone who judges you.

Hear hear!

liverpoolgal82 · 29/08/2023 17:31

Yep it’s bonkers here! I think the problem like many threads is that many don’t read properly and comprehend what’s being said and go with their own narrative instead. Op of course it’s normal to go away with your own children on your own. If husband was going then it’s normal for all children to go or not fair.

I wouldn’t go with the angle that it’s a holiday for your mum to spend time with grandkids as that excludes dsd as a grandchild. That seems mean. In our family my step nephew is as much a grandchild to my parents as the rest. Same value money/presents etc spent. But if you’re going with your kids without husband then it’s fair enough I think.

CrabbyMcPatty · 29/08/2023 17:17

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:04

Like many people have said - no issue with you doing what you are doing - just the way you talk and the constant drip feed nd justification of your actions - now of course DSD has been to Disneyland - why not say that at the start.

I quote from your other post - which really emphasises your attitude to your DSD which is where I object to this.

  • We go on days out when she’s not here and never reserve days out for only times she’s here.
  • We go out more when she’s not here as it’s cheaper.
  • We only have here EOW which seemed to be standard when the arrangement was made but from what I read closer to 50/50 seems normal now.
  • I don’t do child care or pick ups/drop offs
  • She doesn’t leave clothing here and takes it all home and brings a bag each week. Her choice but suits me as no laundry for me.
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

What's wrong with any of those statements?

SavetheNHS · 29/08/2023 17:01

This thread is very OTT. I hope you have a lovely holiday OP and ignore anyone who judges you.

BathingBeauty · 29/08/2023 16:54
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

I don’t understand this, what’s the problem. Is someone suggesting they aren’t a family when SD isn’t there. Is SD also not in a family when she is with her mum?

CharlotteUnaNatalieThompson · 29/08/2023 15:26

Honestly I think some people will twist things every which way to make you look like an arsehole OP.

I see precisely nothing wrong with you taking your children away with you and your mum. You'd (as a couple) be unreasonable if all of you, including DSD's dad, were going not to include her unless she was already away with her mum, but neither of her biological parents will be there!

And if the issue is it's so unfair not to include half siblings every time there is a treat, why does that not also hold true regarding all the holidays DSD goes on with her Mum? Because OP's DC are her step siblings afterall, why doesn't she take them too? I mean if that argument holds true it goes both ways surely?

OP if I was you I'd step away from all those on the thread determined to paint you as the devil simply because you are a step mum....

Hibiscrubbed · 29/08/2023 15:09

Ixoral · 29/08/2023 10:46

Have a lovely time with your mum OP and take plenty of photo’s of her with her daughter & her grandchildren. Perhaps print some photo’s and put them in an album as a surprise Christmas present for your mum as a thank you.

Some of the posts on this thread are crazy, you could say the sky was blue & some would argue that it wasn’t

Some of the posts on this thread are crazy, you could say the sky was blue & some would argue that it wasn’t

They would argue that you must see what colour the stepkids think it is, and if they think the sky is pink, then it is, and that by denying that you’re both neglectful and overstepping and you should stay in your lane, but also accommodate every whim of your stepchildren and their mother, at the cost of your own children and yourself. At all costs. Otherwise you’re a cunt.

CherryMaDeara · 29/08/2023 14:58

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:04

Like many people have said - no issue with you doing what you are doing - just the way you talk and the constant drip feed nd justification of your actions - now of course DSD has been to Disneyland - why not say that at the start.

I quote from your other post - which really emphasises your attitude to your DSD which is where I object to this.

  • We go on days out when she’s not here and never reserve days out for only times she’s here.
  • We go out more when she’s not here as it’s cheaper.
  • We only have here EOW which seemed to be standard when the arrangement was made but from what I read closer to 50/50 seems normal now.
  • I don’t do child care or pick ups/drop offs
  • She doesn’t leave clothing here and takes it all home and brings a bag each week. Her choice but suits me as no laundry for me.
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

So bizarre, why do you need OP to be doing laundry and the school run?

What need does it fulfil in you for a step-mother to be doing these domestic tasks which the child's own parents are more than capable of doing?

fgsstopbs · 29/08/2023 14:53

@uneffingbelievable are we reading the same OP's posts.

Enjoy your break with your mum and kids OP. I wouldn't be bringing my SD either. Let your partner deal with his ex.

WildFlowerBees · 29/08/2023 14:53

I always find it amusing to see the same posters posting over and over to doggedly argue their point. It's tedious and who has time for that? Some folk have way too much time on their hands.

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:47

The facts were not given at the start - DSD now has been to Disneyland - if you had set that at the start it is so less confrontational but then I think you like winding people up.
Your posts come across as DSD is an inconvenience - we all get doing things with your DCS is your priority ( hell you keep on saying it) but not reserving the odd special trip for when she is there seems intentionally cruel.

Agree you do not need to provide child care but when she is only there 2/ 14 then little chance you are going to be asked to anyway.

Your general attitude comes across as really hard towards this child - it is not her fault and not yours that her parents split up. However, you come across as showing your DSD, what life would be like if she did have parents who lived together as a point of pride and to win one over on a child.

Maybe a little less aggression in your manner would help - am sure this girl knows, she gets very little from her Dad and his family - because that is what you are saying repeatedly.

Sugarfree23 · 29/08/2023 14:41

Op I don't think your being unreasonable not taking her. Its a bit cheeky to have been asked.

It would be totally different if the Dad was going but he's not going.

Tirediam · 29/08/2023 14:31

This thread is fecking bonkers. So many perfect parents here 🙄
Enjoy Disney land.. this trip has nothing to do with DSD.
I absolutely love going away or out for lunch with my mam and sister. Husband isn’t invited neither is my dad. I don’t understand how some people can’t get their heads around your partner not going.

RoarRoarBoom · 29/08/2023 14:27

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:04

Like many people have said - no issue with you doing what you are doing - just the way you talk and the constant drip feed nd justification of your actions - now of course DSD has been to Disneyland - why not say that at the start.

I quote from your other post - which really emphasises your attitude to your DSD which is where I object to this.

  • We go on days out when she’s not here and never reserve days out for only times she’s here.
  • We go out more when she’s not here as it’s cheaper.
  • We only have here EOW which seemed to be standard when the arrangement was made but from what I read closer to 50/50 seems normal now.
  • I don’t do child care or pick ups/drop offs
  • She doesn’t leave clothing here and takes it all home and brings a bag each week. Her choice but suits me as no laundry for me.
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

Right… I stand by everything I said there and this is the third time it’s been brought up so keep up.

-It’s already been made very clear pages ago we do EOW.
-I won’t let my kids miss out on days out if dsd isn’t around.
-It’s her choice to bring clothing each time she comes instead of leaving it here. No one makes her do it.
-Idon’t do picks and drop offs or childcare as I’m not her mum and she has 2 able parents!

We are indeed still a family when dsd isn’t around.

Not sure what drip feeding I have done. The facts were given at the start…. Why my partner isn’t coming is not relevant… how dsd mum talks to him is not relevant!
Also not sure how dsd going to Disneyland when she was in primary school is relevant.
We are talking about a here and now trip, not the past.

OP posts:
notlucreziaborgia · 29/08/2023 14:07

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:04

Like many people have said - no issue with you doing what you are doing - just the way you talk and the constant drip feed nd justification of your actions - now of course DSD has been to Disneyland - why not say that at the start.

I quote from your other post - which really emphasises your attitude to your DSD which is where I object to this.

  • We go on days out when she’s not here and never reserve days out for only times she’s here.
  • We go out more when she’s not here as it’s cheaper.
  • We only have here EOW which seemed to be standard when the arrangement was made but from what I read closer to 50/50 seems normal now.
  • I don’t do child care or pick ups/drop offs
  • She doesn’t leave clothing here and takes it all home and brings a bag each week. Her choice but suits me as no laundry for me.
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.

Not sure why any of that is a problem. A stepparent doesn’t have to provide childcare, and they are still a family whether the stepdaughter is there or not. Life doesn’t stop for them just because she isn’t there.

uneffingbelievable · 29/08/2023 14:04

Like many people have said - no issue with you doing what you are doing - just the way you talk and the constant drip feed nd justification of your actions - now of course DSD has been to Disneyland - why not say that at the start.

I quote from your other post - which really emphasises your attitude to your DSD which is where I object to this.

  • We go on days out when she’s not here and never reserve days out for only times she’s here.
  • We go out more when she’s not here as it’s cheaper.
  • We only have here EOW which seemed to be standard when the arrangement was made but from what I read closer to 50/50 seems normal now.
  • I don’t do child care or pick ups/drop offs
  • She doesn’t leave clothing here and takes it all home and brings a bag each week. Her choice but suits me as no laundry for me.
  • We are very much a family still when dsd is not here.
Tandora · 29/08/2023 13:57

BadNomad · 29/08/2023 11:53

Or has she told her mum who has decided this is a huge injustice and asked for her?

I'm guessing it's that. Why would the girl wait until she is with her mother to ask if she can go to Disney with the others? Surely she would ask her SM or dad. What's likely happened is she has gone home, Mum has said "So tell me about your weekend." SD then told her "Blah blah they're going to Disney next year blah blah". Then mum thought "WHAT! They're going to Disney without my DD. This is OUTRAGEOUS!" and started messaging the DH who has nothing to do with it. She's been before. This isn't something new for her.

That may well be the case, but it shouldn’t just be assumed.

Tandora · 29/08/2023 13:56

Uterusbegone · 29/08/2023 13:08

Bloody hell, there are some rabid first wives on this thread.

The op is taking her children away with her mum, so no the DSD doesn't need to be considered. You wouldn't expect DHs ex to consider OPs kids when she takes her daughter away but they are just as much half siblings that way round

The only time all children should be considered is when DH is involved as all of them are his children

Bloody hell, there are some rabid first wives on this thread

So if someone disagrees with your opinion they must be a “rabid first wife”? Are you a raging misogynist?

Ihaveated · 29/08/2023 13:41

Wow!
This thread is insane.
My opinion- you are perfectly fine not to invite your stepdaughter! It all comes down to one simple fact;

She is not your daughter.

You have no responsibility to take her/pay for her/include her.

Personally think it's cheeky of her mum to ask! If she thinks she's missing out then she should take her.

Absolute bollocks to all this blended family treat all kids the same rubbish. It's not possible in almost all situations.

notlucreziaborgia · 29/08/2023 13:36

sandyhappypeople · 29/08/2023 13:12

so did you not think she may be a bit hurt by not being thought of (again, I don’t mean not being asked), I mean not even considering how it would make her feel to find out she’s not invited?

Your justification is perfectly reasonable, and think it’s sensible not to take her without her legal guardians.

But why not sit her down and tell her what you’d planned to save her from finding out the way she did and to save any confusion/ shut down any potential silly business with his ex, it’s been booked for months, were you ever going to tell her?

Quite the assumption that, upon finding out that OP and her daughter were going on holiday, she either expected to be invited, or was in fact hurt by not being.

Beechtreenuts · 29/08/2023 13:35

No I didn’t think of her as she’s not my child, she’s not my mums grandchildren and her dad isn’t going.

This whole thing has left me baffled, OP! I have three grown up children. I have taken each of them away separately or in twos at various times when they were growing up for all sorts of reasons. I took each of them on city breaks and those one to one times are some of my best memories. One teen missed out on a big family holiday because she didn’t want to go when we were booking and by the time she changed her mind there were only business class seats left so she had to stay home.

Not every child has to be included in every event. As long as over-all they get similar then that’s fine. And your step-daughter obviously get similar because she goes away with her mother and her mothers family, not that it’s your responsibility if she didn’t but it just makes the bashing you’re getting here even more bizarre.

None of my children has a blended family (yet). Should it happen then I’d be nice to any step-children, as I would be to any visiting children, but I wouldn’t have the same relationship with them as my own grandchildren whom I have known and helped care for since birth. I put myself out for them, sometimes it’s bloody hard work and I’d rather not but I do it because I love them enough to want to. I would not do the same for another child. I’d have no more bond to them than other children in the extended family and there’s nothing wrong with that at all.

Anyway, enjoy your holiday with your mother and children, you’re doing nothing wrong at all