Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is at best dangerous and worse lethal

65 replies

Mammajay · 27/08/2023 17:51

Yesterday we took grandchildren by train and had to change at Clapham Junction ( London) and the gap between the train and platform was huge..about 40cns. Trying to get off with a baby in a buggy and a toddler on foot was frightening. Please share your experiences. AIBU to think this is a danger for many people.. including the less able;elderly;mum's with buggies and children etc. I had to jump across the gap,not being tall like my husband,as did my little granddaughter. I saw a lady on TV last week who had fallen between the train and track and lost an arm and leg as a result of the accident. Surely something can and should be done to improve this.

OP posts:
Daisychainsandglitter · 28/08/2023 06:59

I totally agree. To my horror I saw this at Birmingham New Street a couple of weeks ago. A father had a baby in one arm and a small child around aged 4 and was trying lift the older child onto the platform but the child fell through the gap and was dangling until myself and another man about to board the train took the child and lifted them onto the platform. Terrifying! It's made me really wary of them now.

whereismysleep · 28/08/2023 02:28

Mammajay · 27/08/2023 18:55

Sorry Skinnermarink..how do you know where the disabled save carriage is..I have never heard of this before.

On Southern and most trains through Clapham I think, it's the carriage with red on the door.

I always used to get on that carriage with a buggy as there is a seat next to the space for wheelchairs and if no one in a wheelchair needs that space, it's perfect for parking your buggy in.

(The downside is it's next to the toilet so if you have a sensitive nose it might not be for you!)

truthhurts23 · 28/08/2023 01:47

yes i worry about people with mobility issues

misssunshine4040 · 28/08/2023 01:44

Platform 8 at Clapham Junction isn't allowed to be used now as the gap is so wide. Trains can only stop for passengers if their is an emergency.
A man was crushed to death falling down the gap at Waterloo also. It was during lock down and no one was left on the platform to notice and help him and he got struck by the next oncoming train.
I think tubes should have some sort or ramp that unfolds as they pull in at stations to cover the gap.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 28/08/2023 01:30

Stations I'm familiar with there didn't used to be such big gaps - in both height and distance from the platform. I don't know whether it's due to new types of trains, or the way the track has been relaid after maintenance work, or a bit of both.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 28/08/2023 00:50

The gap at Clapham is notorious. I have actually seen a drunk guy fall down a gap like that (not at Clapham) and thankfully he was unhurt when they got him out. So I agree there is a risk, but short of relaying the tracks and rebuilding the platform, what can be done?

OnGoldenPond · 28/08/2023 00:28

Ffs! Raynes Park!

OnGoldenPond · 28/08/2023 00:27

Raynes Parked

OnGoldenPond · 28/08/2023 00:22

Rayners Park station is equally terrifying. A few years back I had to change there when on crutches after an operation and I literally couldn't get off the train. Two very kind men had to lift me off or I would have been stuck!

Zanatdy · 27/08/2023 21:08

Yep the gap is huge at Clapham. I still hate getting off there even though I’ve got no young kids now. I always reversed the buggy off but other passengers always offer happy to help

Araminta1003 · 27/08/2023 21:06

All they would need to do is retrofit a retractable ramp from the trains. Like they do in many other countries. Would that really be so difficult?

NowWhattt · 27/08/2023 21:03

pinkyredrose · 27/08/2023 17:53

YANBU. I've often had to jump to get off a train, it's ridiculous.

Agree.

Norbiton station is terrible too.

My Mum met me there once as I had to go to Kingston hospital nearby when pregnant with my son.

She vowed she was never going to meet me there again as she practically did the splits getting off the train and on to the platform.

Its very bad as it is so dangerous.

poorlyarm · 27/08/2023 20:58

I once saw a kid fall down the gap at Richmond station. It was terrifying! They were fine though.

Mammajay · 27/08/2023 20:53

I think all you younger mums and dads and all of us not so young grandparents should start making a fuss about safety and accessibility on trains. When we had one granddaughter, now have two, we had to carry her and buggy up the stairs at Wimbledon Park station and someone who used it often said the lift was always broken.

OP posts:
Motnight · 27/08/2023 20:40

Skinnermarink · 27/08/2023 20:18

So there are usually two on a 12 coach train. I know exactly where to get on at my ‘home’ station, but Whenever I’m travelling from somewhere else I ask. Sometimes it’s marked on the platform, sometimes a safe bet is where the wheelchair ramp is stored, but I always ask, the stewards if there are any about will know because they’d have to help in the event of someone in a wheelchair needing to get on. As a general rule of thumb for me it’s usually the last coach but one. That’s South eastern trains.

Edited

I did not know that!

Agree that the gap at Clapham Junction between train and platform can be huge. I witnessed an elderly lady too scared to get off the train at Clapham, although other passengers were offering help 😞

RubiRage · 27/08/2023 20:39

I thought it was just me who had to make a jump for it. Then there’s the people who get off & suddenly stop so you risk crashing in to them. Or they rush past far too close to where you’re about to land. So even if you clear the gap you still have the worry of being flung backwards & into the gap.

Skinnermarink · 27/08/2023 20:38

ChillysWaterBottle · 27/08/2023 20:27

The transport system in London is not suitable for parents with prams or young children. It is very inaccessible.

Actually, lots of it is, the stations that aren’t are the old Victorian ones that really I’m not sure realistically what could be done. I don’t drive and I live in London so I had to get pretty savvy about it, no money for taxis, and I know a lot of the stations inside out. My local station is a nightmare. No disabled access whatsoever. I’m lucky that there’s usually someone to help or I take a light buggy, baby under I’ve arm and pick up the buggy with the other. Or walk 25 min to use a step free station. But I agree, loads of it is so inaccessible it puts people off, and a lot of the time it’s only possible for me to navigate as I’ve only got the one baby to deal with.

Sigmama · 27/08/2023 20:30

Didn't the woman who lost an arm and a leg, slip on a wet platform

ChillysWaterBottle · 27/08/2023 20:27

The transport system in London is not suitable for parents with prams or young children. It is very inaccessible.

Mariposa26 · 27/08/2023 20:26

YANBU. It fills me full of dread sometimes getting my buggy off and makes me not want to travel around. I can’t imagine how scary it must be for some people who use wheelchairs or crutches etc. Even the doors marked for disabled entry are still not level at many stations even on the brand new (allegedly step free) Elizabeth line!

Skinnermarink · 27/08/2023 20:21

Bear in mind it took them 11 months to sort a lift at Clapham junction (before that I was lugging the buggy up and down stairs, sometimes with help, sometimes not) so it’s not a station where anything gets sorted quickly.

Skinnermarink · 27/08/2023 20:18

Mammajay · 27/08/2023 18:55

Sorry Skinnermarink..how do you know where the disabled save carriage is..I have never heard of this before.

So there are usually two on a 12 coach train. I know exactly where to get on at my ‘home’ station, but Whenever I’m travelling from somewhere else I ask. Sometimes it’s marked on the platform, sometimes a safe bet is where the wheelchair ramp is stored, but I always ask, the stewards if there are any about will know because they’d have to help in the event of someone in a wheelchair needing to get on. As a general rule of thumb for me it’s usually the last coach but one. That’s South eastern trains.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 20:17

Hellsbellsandspidersankles · 27/08/2023 19:11

The gap is big enough for a buggy to fall down?

On one of the platforms I've used there, it's big enough for a buggy and parent to fall down after it. Seriously, a step ladder would have been handy.

Mammajay · 27/08/2023 20:15

I think something needs to be done about this. I emailed Network Rail so will be interested to see what reply I get. They keep going on about needing guards on trains but there doesn't seem much being done about this hazard. They have ramps off buses ..there might be something they can do with trains or build up areas of platform. And if it costs money it will be money well spent. The poor woman who lost her arm and her leg on her way home from work would be testimony to that.

OP posts:
ohtowinthelottery · 27/08/2023 19:49

At my local station there's a huge drop rather than gap. About 10 years ago they built a hump on part of the platform to raise it up but it doesn't always coincide with the doors nor is the hump long enough for a 2 carriage train. Very difficult for elderly/infirm or anyone with a pushchair and totally impossible for a wheelchair user. I worry that I'll twist my ankle or knacker my knee jumping down at some point.