Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Escalating work issue to HR/legal advice

117 replies

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 17:35

Hello 👋,

Posted this in the Work chat but didn't get any response. Seeking a bit of advice here.

I started a new role 14 weeks ago that has a three month notice period. The contract wording is:

"Your probationary period is specified in section X (which says 3 months). Should either you or the company wish to terminate your employment during your probationary period, the notice required will be one week. Your probationary period may be extended at the direction of the company."

The notice period beyond probation is 3 months.

So this week my manager informed me that my probation was to be extended, 2 weeks after the 3 month probation period.

I have to be honest I was completely blindsided by this as I have a weekly 1-2-1 with this person and there has never been anything negative raised. Yet at my last meeting they announced that they still needed more time to decide, and in particular I needed to finish a strategy document, and a few issues with my "engagement" and "not being bubbly enough". Again, nothing along these lines has ever been raised in any of the 12 previous 1-2-1s.

As for the strategy document I was told to put it to the side for a few weeks to focus on bigger projects that had tight deadlines. I was never informed that passing my probation was contingent on completing this strategy document. In fact the opposite, I have been told that it is not a priority. If I had been informed of the consequences on my probation I would have worked a lot more extra hours. I'm also just shocked that there have been any issues with my performance or attitude as this has never come up before.

I now have a few questions as a one week notice period is extremely stressful.

I basically want to know if they are able to extend my probation period after the deadline has ended, and with no prior warnings or written confirmation. I have still not been asked to sign anything and some of the feedback, like being "bubbly" and "engaged" feel a bit like subjective measures to improve on rather than concrete achievements, and again these issues have never come up before. So it is not a clear performance improvement plan or official document and I don't want to be blindsided again.

I am also wondering if they do try to sack me if I am entitled to three months notice/pay. I have been looking at other cases and it does seem to me that they have to inform you before the probation period has ended if they are going to extend. Also, my contract does not say I need verbal or written confirmation when this period has passed so it feels like this is done automatically.

Any advice? Thanks.

OP posts:
rwalker · 27/08/2023 20:07

What I’ve read doesn’t sound too bad tbh

I’m presuming the document thing you need to finish to complete your probation wasn’t to a timeline
not what you want to hear but from a business point of view it makes sense for you to finish time critical work extend your probation to let you finish the documents they want to assess you on
the comments she made referring to you minority I think were related to your pervious job not your personal heritage

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 19:57

PinkFootstool · 27/08/2023 19:56

Reading between the lines, is is possible they just wanted you in for this busy period and to complete specific pieces of work? And now they will try to implement processes to get you out the door as cheaply as possible....

Seems they are a bit shady and if it isn't deliberate, it's incompetent.

Edited

This has occurred to me...

OP posts:
PinkFootstool · 27/08/2023 19:56

Reading between the lines, is is possible they just wanted you in for this busy period and to complete specific pieces of work? And now they will try to implement processes to get you out the door as cheaply as possible....

Seems they are a bit shady and if it isn't deliberate, it's incompetent.

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 19:46

Thanks.

I would rather have the security of three months notice or pay than one week so I wanted to know where I stand if they try to formally extend/give me a week's notice in 8 weeks.

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 19:44

filka · 27/08/2023 19:23

@WanOvaryKenobi Two bits stuck out for me:

"This means that, as long as provision is made within the contract of employment to extend any trial period, this right can be exercised at a manager’s discretion. However, the right to extend probation periods must be clearly set out in writing prior to the start of this period."

Nothing set in writing as of yet, and conversation happened after the three month period was up.

You're mis-reading this. It's saying that they are allowed to extend the probation period if they say they can, in writing, in advance - which you said in the first post was in your contract. So they have the right.

But to exercise that right they have to give notice of intention to extend before the standard probation period expires. Which it seems like they didn't. So you should be on 3 months notice automatically, because they have screwed up.

How important is the strategy document for them? Clearly if they try to give you one week's notice then you aren't going to feel inclined to do/finish it. Or are they extending the notice period in order to enable you to complete it before they let you go? I don't think that's a plausible reason to extend probation, there has to be real concern about your suitability for the job.

Can you contact ACAS, or is there a union rep?

Ah thank you.

They verbally suggested a two month extension to finish the strategy document then implement it. There hasn't been any negative feedback about my output, attitude, or skills until this meeting after the probation period ended. Which I'm quite surprised about to say the least. There was a suggestion that it would then "give them more time to see" about my performance which I do sort of understand but I was also told to discard the document in favour of working on bigger campaigns with tight deadlines. They never mentioned the document needed to be completed before the probation period ended. I also feel like if they didn't like me for whatever reason they would have let me go by now/I would have received negative feedback already. I'm genuinely baffled. Never had this happen before.

OP posts:
FleetwoodMacAttack · 27/08/2023 19:29

I think I’m missing something obvious. Assuming you want to leave surely you’d prefer one week’s notice.

There is no need for the employer to make a PILON - they can just require you to work the full 3 months even if they decide to terminate you.

filka · 27/08/2023 19:23

@WanOvaryKenobi Two bits stuck out for me:

"This means that, as long as provision is made within the contract of employment to extend any trial period, this right can be exercised at a manager’s discretion. However, the right to extend probation periods must be clearly set out in writing prior to the start of this period."

Nothing set in writing as of yet, and conversation happened after the three month period was up.

You're mis-reading this. It's saying that they are allowed to extend the probation period if they say they can, in writing, in advance - which you said in the first post was in your contract. So they have the right.

But to exercise that right they have to give notice of intention to extend before the standard probation period expires. Which it seems like they didn't. So you should be on 3 months notice automatically, because they have screwed up.

How important is the strategy document for them? Clearly if they try to give you one week's notice then you aren't going to feel inclined to do/finish it. Or are they extending the notice period in order to enable you to complete it before they let you go? I don't think that's a plausible reason to extend probation, there has to be real concern about your suitability for the job.

Can you contact ACAS, or is there a union rep?

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 19:19

ewright86 · 27/08/2023 19:11

Legally they can’t dismiss you without clear reason and they should always make sure your targets can be measured, so they can’t just say you need to be more bubbly. However, you do have different rights when you’re in a probationary period when it comes to employment tribunals so you are unable to claim unfair dismissal however you can claim wrongful dismissal.
they can legally dismiss you with a weeks notice or immediately depending on circumstances.

Edited

It seems like I am automatically through the probation period as there is nothing in my contract about verbal or written confirmation, just the length of time. Never had any official warnings or anything so will keep this in mind if they try to sack me.

OP posts:
ewright86 · 27/08/2023 19:11

Legally they can’t dismiss you without clear reason and they should always make sure your targets can be measured, so they can’t just say you need to be more bubbly. However, you do have different rights when you’re in a probationary period when it comes to employment tribunals so you are unable to claim unfair dismissal however you can claim wrongful dismissal.
they can legally dismiss you with a weeks notice or immediately depending on circumstances.

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 19:06

LittleMousewithcloggson · 27/08/2023 19:00

“The EAT, in Przybylska v Modus Telecom Ltd, has found that an employer cannot imply a contractual term to extend a probationary period in order to carry out a performance review.
It was held that the employer was only allowed to extend the probationary period if it informed the employee of the extension during the probationary period, even if circumstances made it impractical to carry out a performance review before the end of the probationary period.
Facts
The employee was dismissed after failing her probationary period but was not informed of the decision until three weeks after the probationary period had ended. She was, therefore, entitled to three months notice rather than the one week that would have applied if she had been informed of the decision within the probationary period.”

Never, in over 20 years of working in employment law have I ever known a company to successfully have been able to extend a persons probation after the expiry date if they had not informed them before the end of it .
However, it is going to be difficult to make a case for anything until you have suffered detrimentally. For example, if you did not get a higher rate of pay because your probation wasn’t passed or you were dismissed and paid the wrong amount of notice. To pursue this, even then, takes time and money.

I would speak to HR and potentially put in a grievance if you want to stay there.

Edited

Thank you so much for this. I have one question though, which is if I want to stay will putting in a grievance to HR not be detrimental?

OP posts:
LittleMousewithcloggson · 27/08/2023 19:00

“The EAT, in Przybylska v Modus Telecom Ltd, has found that an employer cannot imply a contractual term to extend a probationary period in order to carry out a performance review.
It was held that the employer was only allowed to extend the probationary period if it informed the employee of the extension during the probationary period, even if circumstances made it impractical to carry out a performance review before the end of the probationary period.
Facts
The employee was dismissed after failing her probationary period but was not informed of the decision until three weeks after the probationary period had ended. She was, therefore, entitled to three months notice rather than the one week that would have applied if she had been informed of the decision within the probationary period.”

Never, in over 20 years of working in employment law have I ever known a company to successfully have been able to extend a persons probation after the expiry date if they had not informed them before the end of it .
However, it is going to be difficult to make a case for anything until you have suffered detrimentally. For example, if you did not get a higher rate of pay because your probation wasn’t passed or you were dismissed and paid the wrong amount of notice. To pursue this, even then, takes time and money.

I would speak to HR and potentially put in a grievance if you want to stay there.

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:59

R4ID · 27/08/2023 18:44

  1. I’d leave anywhere where my contribution was not valued and they could not give any reason for their low opinion of me
  2. They can’t extend your probation after the expiry date.
  3. Quote the case law and say you don’t agree to them extending your probation.
  4. If they dismiss you try to get 3 months notice but if you don’t I’d let it go. The cost, time, expense of an employment tribunal will far outweigh 2 months and 3 weeks wages.

This is fantastic thank you. The three month wages would be about £7,500.

OP posts:
R4ID · 27/08/2023 18:44
  1. I’d leave anywhere where my contribution was not valued and they could not give any reason for their low opinion of me
  2. They can’t extend your probation after the expiry date.
  3. Quote the case law and say you don’t agree to them extending your probation.
  4. If they dismiss you try to get 3 months notice but if you don’t I’d let it go. The cost, time, expense of an employment tribunal will far outweigh 2 months and 3 weeks wages.
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:40

IhateJan22 · 27/08/2023 18:36

I missed the date of an employees end of probation period and wanted to extend it but HR said I couldn’t and the automatically pass if you go past the end date.

That is very interesting. What happened? I wonder if my higher up has gone to HR. Is it worth speaking to them?

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:39

VisionsOfSplendour · 27/08/2023 18:35

I think I'd be cutting my losses and looking for a new job,, too many red flags to be wasting anymore time there

It's so frustrating as I just want to get my feet under the table and do what I have been hired to do.

OP posts:
IhateJan22 · 27/08/2023 18:36

I missed the date of an employees end of probation period and wanted to extend it but HR said I couldn’t and the automatically pass if you go past the end date.

VisionsOfSplendour · 27/08/2023 18:35

I think I'd be cutting my losses and looking for a new job,, too many red flags to be wasting anymore time there

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:33

MumUndone · 27/08/2023 18:24

No it's the opposite - if there is nothing in writing to say you haven't passed your probation before the end date then the probation period is deemed to have ended at that date.

This is the impression I was under. There's a case from 2007 that sets a precedent.

"Impact on employers
Depending on the terms of the employment contract, employees are likely to have increased notice rights (and perhaps the right to receive certain contractual benefits) after the probationary period has expired. Where an employee’s performance is unsatisfactory, the employer will need to extend the probationary period or dismiss the employee before the probationary period (or any extension) has ended. Otherwise, the employer is likely to have to give a longer period of notice to terminate their employment."

shepwedd.com/knowledge/extension-probationary-period-must-be-made-within-probationary-period

OP posts:
MumUndone · 27/08/2023 18:24

catgirl1976 · 27/08/2023 17:40

It’s not great but given they didn’t confirm you’d passed your probation they can extend it and your shorter notice period still applies. You could kick up a fuss that none of these issues were raised and your probation outcome was late but unless there’s more to it eg discrimination there’s not a lot you can do. Look for another job if they are flakey which they seem to be

No it's the opposite - if there is nothing in writing to say you haven't passed your probation before the end date then the probation period is deemed to have ended at that date.

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:24

Oblomov23 · 27/08/2023 18:16

This sounds awful. I'd ask for clarification at a meeting.

The not getting probationary because of this document they'd asked you to sideline. Bubbly. MH admission. Ethnicity comments.

Do you think I should go to HR to ask what the craic is? Even on an informal basis?

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:24

Totaly · 27/08/2023 18:14

Happened to me recently.

You have a choice here. Either take a negative attitude and risk them being right to fire you - or take a positive attitude and get stuck in.

Being positive is a lot harder and you are Almost starting on the back foot- but you can make it work and make changes

However, it really depends on your situation, my own theory was a senior manager taking a dislike to me and quite honestly I wanted to prove her wrong (she was), she has since received multiple complaints about her attitude towards staff …. And yes I’m smug about it.

That's interesting. My DH thinks I should just keep my head down as there is a possibility this is just an oversight they are trying to get signed off (the document) and I run the risk of rocking the boat. Then if they do try to sack me see if I can get three months rather than a week due to how they have handled this. And if I pass I pass. It's the not knowing I find extremely stressful.

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:21

whatwasIgoingtosay · 27/08/2023 18:13

'Bubbly' is one of these profoundly sexist terms like 'bossy', that are only ever applied to women. I would be deeply offended to be asked to be more bubbly (or told that I was too bossy) - how misogynistic! I don't know if you've got any comeback, though.

I know, of all the bloody things! Even stranger is apparently sometimes I'm "bubbly" and sometimes I'm not? Isn't that fecking everyone?

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:19

Merryoldgoat · 27/08/2023 18:13

What ‘interesting’ things have they said about your ethnicity?

Edited

Full disclosure I am mixed race South Asian in Scotland. She asked me about an event I was going to with some former colleagues in community arts/heritage/women's shelters (previous career in another city). I talked a bit about the work I have done in ethnic minority group settings and she interrupted me to say "No wonder you have to go to X place for it because you aren't a minority here" referring to the fact we live in a city with a sizeable (yet still obviously minority) South Asian population. It just struck me as totally unnecessary and incredibly dismissive.

OP posts:
Oblomov23 · 27/08/2023 18:16

This sounds awful. I'd ask for clarification at a meeting.

The not getting probationary because of this document they'd asked you to sideline. Bubbly. MH admission. Ethnicity comments.

Totaly · 27/08/2023 18:14

Happened to me recently.

You have a choice here. Either take a negative attitude and risk them being right to fire you - or take a positive attitude and get stuck in.

Being positive is a lot harder and you are Almost starting on the back foot- but you can make it work and make changes

However, it really depends on your situation, my own theory was a senior manager taking a dislike to me and quite honestly I wanted to prove her wrong (she was), she has since received multiple complaints about her attitude towards staff …. And yes I’m smug about it.