Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Escalating work issue to HR/legal advice

117 replies

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 17:35

Hello 👋,

Posted this in the Work chat but didn't get any response. Seeking a bit of advice here.

I started a new role 14 weeks ago that has a three month notice period. The contract wording is:

"Your probationary period is specified in section X (which says 3 months). Should either you or the company wish to terminate your employment during your probationary period, the notice required will be one week. Your probationary period may be extended at the direction of the company."

The notice period beyond probation is 3 months.

So this week my manager informed me that my probation was to be extended, 2 weeks after the 3 month probation period.

I have to be honest I was completely blindsided by this as I have a weekly 1-2-1 with this person and there has never been anything negative raised. Yet at my last meeting they announced that they still needed more time to decide, and in particular I needed to finish a strategy document, and a few issues with my "engagement" and "not being bubbly enough". Again, nothing along these lines has ever been raised in any of the 12 previous 1-2-1s.

As for the strategy document I was told to put it to the side for a few weeks to focus on bigger projects that had tight deadlines. I was never informed that passing my probation was contingent on completing this strategy document. In fact the opposite, I have been told that it is not a priority. If I had been informed of the consequences on my probation I would have worked a lot more extra hours. I'm also just shocked that there have been any issues with my performance or attitude as this has never come up before.

I now have a few questions as a one week notice period is extremely stressful.

I basically want to know if they are able to extend my probation period after the deadline has ended, and with no prior warnings or written confirmation. I have still not been asked to sign anything and some of the feedback, like being "bubbly" and "engaged" feel a bit like subjective measures to improve on rather than concrete achievements, and again these issues have never come up before. So it is not a clear performance improvement plan or official document and I don't want to be blindsided again.

I am also wondering if they do try to sack me if I am entitled to three months notice/pay. I have been looking at other cases and it does seem to me that they have to inform you before the probation period has ended if they are going to extend. Also, my contract does not say I need verbal or written confirmation when this period has passed so it feels like this is done automatically.

Any advice? Thanks.

OP posts:
PhilomenaFunbags · 07/09/2023 10:25

In my experience when a company puts you on a pip it is to gather documentary evidence so they can terminate you.

If you do decide to stay, best advice is to ensure your pip is very prescriptive in terms of exactly what you have to do and by which timescale so that there is no ambiguity as to whether or not you have achieved the actions.

I would also suggest having it documented in the pip the specific support your line manager intend to give and if you have a regular cadence of meetings that any shortfalls are discussed and raised during these. I would insist that hr also attend these meetings because of the inconsistencies to date

WanOvaryKenobi · 07/09/2023 10:11

Hi everyone again. Giving an update.

Basically nothing happened for a week. I went to HR yesterday for a different reason (the confirming my notice period was a total coincidence due to human error) and while there saw my employee file which had a letter about a probation extension. Because there is something in writing I have never seen I pointed this out.

Basically HR confirmed that I have passed my probation and she was sympathetic to the fact I have had no prior warnings, passed through my probation period, then was told it would be extended, then I have had to go to ACAS to get some advice because it's breach of contract, then I have had a week with absolutely no update and have had to travel (I'm mostly remote with occasional travel to the office) to a different city with absolutely no idea what to expect.

HR spoke to my manager and then have confirmed to me that I am going to be put on a PIP. Again, no warnings. Apparently HR are sure I will "smash it".

Honestly I am fucking furious at this point and basically said as much and I am really unhappy with how this has been handled. It has really soured my experience with the company.

Any advice about this is more than welcome. I've never been put on a PIP, I'm quite convinced this manager just hates me, and I'm wondering if I should just quit, or even if I should complain about being on a PIP out of nowhere.

OP posts:
R4ID · 29/08/2023 20:59

TheThinkingGoblin · 29/08/2023 16:01

This is not great advice.

You don't need to resign to move on to another job. Given the ample evidence in this cause I would negotiate PILON (Payment en Lieu of Notice) before leaving for another job.

If they want OP out, they are going to have to pay up first.

I’ve suggested they resolve the issue there is ample evidence for which is that they are in breach of contract if they don’t pay her 3 months notice. Very very unlikely for any company to offer you PILON without a clear incentive?

WanOvaryKenobi · 29/08/2023 16:37

Diorama1 · 29/08/2023 16:28

OP two things strike me, apologies if this was mentioned and I missed it.

3 months probationary period is 3 calendar months not 12 weeks. I know you mentioned 14 weeks and attempt to extend was made in week 13 or 14. Just ensure the date they tried to extend was past 3 calendar months.

Secondly, I would clear this up now as if you "accept" the extension by keep quiet about it and working towards the targets set, you could be seen to have accepted the attempt to extend your probation period.

If you had gone past the 3 calendar months, I would raise this with your manager and confirm that your contract doesn't provide for an extension of the probation and therefore same cant be imposed and you are not accepting such an extension and consider your probation passed.

I would also be looking for another job, the situation there will not improve. Good luck

https://www.partnerslaw.co.uk/news/is-three-months-notice-a-week-longer-than-12-weeks-in-the-context-of-calculating-statutory-notice-pay

They were beyond 14 weeks when the extension was mentioned. I have not signed any extension period nor will I as ACAS have advised this is breach of contract. The main point being I have three month's notice rather than a week.

Is three months' notice a week longer than 12 weeks in the context of calculating statutory notice pay?

News & Insights, Employment Lawyers London. HR Consultancy & Employment Law Training UK, Partners Employment Lawyers: The latest legal blogs, news & insights. Partners Solicitors are based in London and offer legal advice on all areas of employment law...

https://www.partnerslaw.co.uk/news/is-three-months-notice-a-week-longer-than-12-weeks-in-the-context-of-calculating-statutory-notice-pay

OP posts:
Diorama1 · 29/08/2023 16:28

OP two things strike me, apologies if this was mentioned and I missed it.

3 months probationary period is 3 calendar months not 12 weeks. I know you mentioned 14 weeks and attempt to extend was made in week 13 or 14. Just ensure the date they tried to extend was past 3 calendar months.

Secondly, I would clear this up now as if you "accept" the extension by keep quiet about it and working towards the targets set, you could be seen to have accepted the attempt to extend your probation period.

If you had gone past the 3 calendar months, I would raise this with your manager and confirm that your contract doesn't provide for an extension of the probation and therefore same cant be imposed and you are not accepting such an extension and consider your probation passed.

I would also be looking for another job, the situation there will not improve. Good luck

TheThinkingGoblin · 29/08/2023 16:01

R4ID · 29/08/2023 15:00

It’s perfectly ok that you are not the right person for the job and they are not the right company for you but you deserve to be treated respectfully! It’s clear your manager is trying to get you to resign by now being a bully.

Personally I’d be moving on asap. Get the issue with length of notice period sorted so they understand you won’t be accepting anything less than 3 months, find a new job and resign.

Edited

This is not great advice.

You don't need to resign to move on to another job. Given the ample evidence in this cause I would negotiate PILON (Payment en Lieu of Notice) before leaving for another job.

If they want OP out, they are going to have to pay up first.

R4ID · 29/08/2023 15:00

WanOvaryKenobi · 29/08/2023 14:53

Spoke to ACAS today.

Only took a few minutes as it is absolutely clear after going through the documentation that if they try to extend the probation period they are in breach of contract.

I was advised to wait and see what they do before escalating a grievance and then speaking to a solicitor.

Manager is being an absolute CF to me today. Cutting me off in calls, shutting down any ideas, has not responded to me for a week (I have screenshots of this) and had not even acknowledged that I have sent in the strategy document that apparently my "extended probation" was beholden to.

Absolutely baffled. I've had nothing but positive interactions with this person until last week when they decided I was neither a good person nor good at my job. Not a single verbal or written warning, no KPIs set, no PIP, no issues, nothing. Nothing at all that suggested I wasn't going to pass my probation in the past 14 weeks.

One of the strangest situations I've had professionally.

It’s perfectly ok that you are not the right person for the job and they are not the right company for you but you deserve to be treated respectfully! It’s clear your manager is trying to get you to resign by now being a bully.

Personally I’d be moving on asap. Get the issue with length of notice period sorted so they understand you won’t be accepting anything less than 3 months, find a new job and resign.

WanOvaryKenobi · 29/08/2023 14:53

Spoke to ACAS today.

Only took a few minutes as it is absolutely clear after going through the documentation that if they try to extend the probation period they are in breach of contract.

I was advised to wait and see what they do before escalating a grievance and then speaking to a solicitor.

Manager is being an absolute CF to me today. Cutting me off in calls, shutting down any ideas, has not responded to me for a week (I have screenshots of this) and had not even acknowledged that I have sent in the strategy document that apparently my "extended probation" was beholden to.

Absolutely baffled. I've had nothing but positive interactions with this person until last week when they decided I was neither a good person nor good at my job. Not a single verbal or written warning, no KPIs set, no PIP, no issues, nothing. Nothing at all that suggested I wasn't going to pass my probation in the past 14 weeks.

One of the strangest situations I've had professionally.

AIBU? Escalating work issue to HR/legal advice
OP posts:
marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 28/08/2023 22:52

What a ridiculous term "bubbly" is. I've heard it around a bit recently. It's completely meaningless. It makes me think chatty but vacuous.

TheThinkingGoblin · 28/08/2023 21:16

WanOvaryKenobi · 28/08/2023 19:11

I'm not too sure what the benefit would be for them to send me another contract with a longer notice period?

Makes you less likely to leave as you would have to find another job that was willing to wait x months for your notice period to expire.

SavBlancTonight · 28/08/2023 20:44

Personally, if I was told I needed to be more "bubbly" in order to pass my probationary period, I would be reconsidering the entire decision to work there.

The phrasing suggested by the in House lawyer is good. It politely makes the point that "bubbly" is not exactly a professional term and it sets a precedent of their attitude being not ok.

As for the dismissive tone regarding your volunteering, that might not be legally actionable in itself, but it points to an overall dismissive attitude towards you that I find concerning.

blueshoes · 28/08/2023 20:32

Ok, you have a plan. Good.

You still have to put things in writing. Formal and polite as @PhilomenaFunbags says. I am a lawyer too (though not employment) and I would advise exactly the same. HR will be more willing to negotiate and manage the manager if you are in the strong legal position. You are in a stronger legal position if you put things in writing. If you are in a weak legal position because you let water under the bridge without querying, they are more likely to walk all over you because you are on the legal back foot.

Locutus2000 · 28/08/2023 20:24

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 20:47

That I do understand but it absolutely should have been communicated along with any concerns before my probation ended. The disorganisation is what I find unnerving.

No I think you have misunderstood. I am the only person of colour in my team and beyond. They were referring explicitly to the fact the city we live in has more South Asian people than the previous city I lived in, and implied my community work is not as needed because of that.

Either way, I don't think bullying or diminishing the efforts of people about their choice of volunteer work when it relates a protected characteristic is a good look. Can you imagine if I was openly LGBT+ and spent my time volunteering with related causes and they said "x city is so progressive not sure why you bother".

If they are explicitly racist it doesn't speak well for their bias, unconscious or otherwise.

MotherOfGodWeeFella · 28/08/2023 19:53

I think HR have contacted you because they know the manager has stuffed up. Keep your powder dry, get the ACAS advice then respond. But be quick.

WanOvaryKenobi · 28/08/2023 19:13

Totaly · 27/08/2023 23:58

Also have they given a written statement of where you need to improved and how they are doing to help you achieve this?

example X is to keep written records of y and report all findings to A by Y deadline?

A previous manager told me it’s extremely difficult to fire someone - they must prove they have offered every type of Supper available to them. With weekly meetings on progress etc

What have you been offered?

Nothing written at all. I checked the employee handbook and they make a point that if there is to be an extension it needs to be a very detailed document with plans and support for improvement. So far I've had nothing other than the word of the manager and that was on Thursday.

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 28/08/2023 19:11

TheThinkingGoblin · 28/08/2023 18:39

I have seen this thing before.

If you had a 1 month notice period, they would have sent you a new contract with a 3 month period to sign.

At that point, you can either sign or not.

They push people to do this to reduce turnover costs, which can be an issue in a labour shortage environment.

Its 100% for the benefit of the company. Not you.

I'm not too sure what the benefit would be for them to send me another contract with a longer notice period?

OP posts:
WanOvaryKenobi · 28/08/2023 19:09

PhilomenaFunbags · 28/08/2023 18:33

I am an in-house lawyer and deal with these types of matters.

If an employer had been treated the same as you the best thing from your perspective would be to reply to your line manager and cc HR. If you have emails where you have been told that work was deprioritised, attach that.

Keep the tone formal but polite in 'working together to resolve this' type approach.

I would specify that in line with your contract you had believed the probationary period had passed, as the extension wasn't issued or any matter raised with you prior to its expiry. Could they provide some further context or policy under which this is being extended.

I would also ask them to clarify what they meant by you "need to be more bubbly" stating that it's obviously a subjective term and your keen to understand what is meant by this in context. Maybe it was an ineloquent way of saying that people have found you rude or standoffish (I'm not saying you are) but frame it again that you're looking to work together to clarify expectations.

The reason I say this is if its in writing, its more difficult to get rid of you where you've queried these points.

In relation to the comment about race, I suppose it would depend on whether the area you live and work in now is more ethnically diverse. I wouldn't immediately be concerned by that comment on its own, unless there was more that had been said (not saying it wasn't rude or dismissive, just how I would view it in terms of legal risk)

In the end you may wish to move anyway but shorter periods on cvs look worse so I'd maybe try to clarify this and make them work to do better, then if you don't see an improvement look for new roles after you'd been there a year.

Thanks for this. I'll see what ACAS advise me to do tomorrow. I feel like at this point there may be a chance for us all to save face and I might be putting the manager in shit if I point out the error. Really not sure.

OP posts:
catgirl1976 · 28/08/2023 18:56

TheThinkingGoblin · 28/08/2023 18:36

This is 100% wrong.

If the contract says 3 months, you are deemed to have passed your probationary period if they do not say anything after 3 months.

Thats why in most companies you have a probationary review right before the 3 or 6 month deadline.

It depends what it says in the contract. If it says your probationary period is 12 weeks but will continue until it’s been confirmed I writing that you’ve passed then they can extend it after the 12 weeks.

pilates · 28/08/2023 18:49

I agree with your DH, keep your head down and get on with the job in hand. If they are going to pull a snidey on you you’re best off out. With regard to the bubbly comment, is that a polite way of saying you are moody?

TheThinkingGoblin · 28/08/2023 18:39

WanOvaryKenobi · 28/08/2023 18:09

Update. Had a surprise call from HR today to "check the details of my contract and notice period" apparently (and this could be bullshit) they have been looking at contracts and were concerned they sent me a one month notice period when it should be three. I had the contract in front of me and confirmed it was three, they seemed pleased.

I then followed up that I was through my probation period as we are in week 14 of a 12 week probation period and was told someone was going to speak to me about that. Was overall a very friendly call but very strange. ACAS has been closed today for the BH so will call tomorrow. All very odd.

I have seen this thing before.

If you had a 1 month notice period, they would have sent you a new contract with a 3 month period to sign.

At that point, you can either sign or not.

They push people to do this to reduce turnover costs, which can be an issue in a labour shortage environment.

Its 100% for the benefit of the company. Not you.

TheThinkingGoblin · 28/08/2023 18:36

catgirl1976 · 27/08/2023 17:40

It’s not great but given they didn’t confirm you’d passed your probation they can extend it and your shorter notice period still applies. You could kick up a fuss that none of these issues were raised and your probation outcome was late but unless there’s more to it eg discrimination there’s not a lot you can do. Look for another job if they are flakey which they seem to be

This is 100% wrong.

If the contract says 3 months, you are deemed to have passed your probationary period if they do not say anything after 3 months.

Thats why in most companies you have a probationary review right before the 3 or 6 month deadline.

PhilomenaFunbags · 28/08/2023 18:33

WanOvaryKenobi · 27/08/2023 18:40

That is very interesting. What happened? I wonder if my higher up has gone to HR. Is it worth speaking to them?

I am an in-house lawyer and deal with these types of matters.

If an employer had been treated the same as you the best thing from your perspective would be to reply to your line manager and cc HR. If you have emails where you have been told that work was deprioritised, attach that.

Keep the tone formal but polite in 'working together to resolve this' type approach.

I would specify that in line with your contract you had believed the probationary period had passed, as the extension wasn't issued or any matter raised with you prior to its expiry. Could they provide some further context or policy under which this is being extended.

I would also ask them to clarify what they meant by you "need to be more bubbly" stating that it's obviously a subjective term and your keen to understand what is meant by this in context. Maybe it was an ineloquent way of saying that people have found you rude or standoffish (I'm not saying you are) but frame it again that you're looking to work together to clarify expectations.

The reason I say this is if its in writing, its more difficult to get rid of you where you've queried these points.

In relation to the comment about race, I suppose it would depend on whether the area you live and work in now is more ethnically diverse. I wouldn't immediately be concerned by that comment on its own, unless there was more that had been said (not saying it wasn't rude or dismissive, just how I would view it in terms of legal risk)

In the end you may wish to move anyway but shorter periods on cvs look worse so I'd maybe try to clarify this and make them work to do better, then if you don't see an improvement look for new roles after you'd been there a year.

blueshoes · 28/08/2023 18:24

Interesting update with HR. I would only trust HR as far as I can throw them.

What a coincidence that they are 'looking at contracts'. They might be fishing for info to see how clued up you are on the contract (yes, you are). Then they said that someone would speak to you about the end of your probation. Looks like they already have some plan in mind otherwise they will say oh really, let me check because I did not realise the probationary period has expired.

I would suggest you continue to keep your guard up and paper everything, send emails to preserve your position. Yes, speak to ACAS and ideally an employment lawyer.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 28/08/2023 18:20

Hmm, how do they work out their "3 months" in actual weeks though, since a month isn't an exact number of weeks, its 4 and a few days. Yes 14 full weeks would take you beyond 3 months, but i would have expected to be told based on my start date, what exact date was the last day of my probation period, as "3 months" is a bit too vague.
If i were you i'd ask for the new end date of your probation period extension in writing, then if they do try to extend your probation again or not to keep you on after that date passes, you've got written evidence you were past your probationary period and so are now a full employee and they cant extend, or are now are entitled to 3 weeks notice etc.

Dearly89 · 28/08/2023 18:17

This is awful. You are there to do a job, not please others by being 'bubbly.' How silly.
Sounds like they do not value you and have issues with communicating with their staff on expectations, something that will not get better unfortunately. I would take it on the chin and very quickly start searching for another job and hand your notice in. You are worth more than that place!