Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to have a garden?

61 replies

AffableApple · 27/08/2023 17:05

AIBU to think moving to a house we've found, which needs work, but for a number of reasons is a good price for us - is a good idea despite having no outdoor space? Would it be hard to resell in a few years once we've added value to it without a garden? I have two very young children who would benefit from a garden - but in an area with plenty of outdoor walks and parks - is this necessary? Would you buy a nice period house, newly renovated, but without outdoor space? Thank you for your thoughts. House buying is really tough at the moment and we can't afford to get this wrong.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jackstini · 28/08/2023 13:50

Any way to add a roof terrace or one of those Velux balconies?

Doingmybest12 · 28/08/2023 13:49

I think if you are on a limited budget and you need living space and can't afford a garden still consider it if you have access to parks etc. You are moving from a flat so maybe it's a step up. Just beware of putting too much money into it and accept that you'll sell it to the next person cheaply and it might take a while and you might have limited interested people.

Mountainhowl · 28/08/2023 13:42

If I was buying a house a garden would be an absolute must. We rent and have a tiny concrete yard not big enough to do anything in (about 1.5x2.5m), my parents have a smallish garden but staying there with my DC is so nice, getting up and making a brew then sitting in the garden watching them play is lovely

Movinghouseatlast · 28/08/2023 13:12

No, I wouldn't buy without a garden through choice.

I lived in a flat without a garden for 13 years. When I came to upgrade to a house my no 1 requirement was a garden.

gabsdot · 28/08/2023 13:08

I don'#t necessarily need a garden but I would have to have some outdoor space for a BBQ, sitting outside and putting out the clothes dryer.
An apartment balcony would be fine with me.
But with kids a garedn is so handy, you can just pop them outside to play and lock the door 😁

KajsaKavat · 28/08/2023 12:58

I live in a row of town houses without gardens (town centre location) and it’s mostly ok but we all miss outside space. I might consider doing it again if there was a balcony but not without any outside space.

AffableApple · 28/08/2023 12:56

Thank you all. That's me told! Just to say there are positives which are too outing which I haven't gone into - things which we would be able to fix that others would baulk at - which is also why it's affordable. But it was really the garden thing I wanted advice on. I mean, I knew the answer really - but thanks for confirming! Back to the drawing board!

OP posts:
BringOnSummerHolidays · 28/08/2023 09:11

Depends on what is normal in the area isn’t it? I prefer a small garden. Low maintenance but have the space for drying clothes, bbq, paddling pool, a table. This does not need to be big at all.

If it’s a prime city centre location, it could be normal to not have a garden?

rwalker · 28/08/2023 06:28

It would really limit who’d buy it and also limit the price
Period houses can be very expensive to renovate

if your looking to make money in a house this isn’t the one

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 28/08/2023 06:23

i don’t think this is the house for you. Unless there really are no other options.

It’s a decent price, despite having 5 bedrooms, because it has no garden. Whatever you do to it, however nice you make it, you won’t get the return you are seeking. Large family homes without any outside space are just not desirable. You could find yourself stuck there, unable to sell at a price that would enable you to move on.

Good luck in finding something else.

NashvilleQueen · 28/08/2023 06:15

I could see the potential for resale in a small two bed property for older people who may not want the hassle of keeping a garden but in 5/6 bedroom house I imagine it's going to be hard. I assume it's very heavily discounted to reflect the lack of outdoor space.

Theraffarian · 28/08/2023 05:49

If it’s on a village high street , does that also mean issues with parking ? In my experience children benefit most from the garden during the pre school / primary years , by secondary school you’ve missed the most used years , by then mine used it for friends to come over for BBQs , sun bathing (!) and reading , maybe the odd game of football and badminton, but not the daily use they had while younger.

Beetlebuggy · 27/08/2023 23:11

I'd need some kind of outdoor space, not necessarily even a garden, but enough for some pots and somewhere to sit. When the kids were young I'd definitely have needed green space, a park nearby is nice, but not always practical.

AffableApple · 27/08/2023 23:05

There's no outdoor space, just an alley for the bins.

OP posts:
AffableApple · 27/08/2023 23:04

Sorry, said children kept me busy! Right so a few questions here - to explain better the house is on the high street of a nice village, so it's never had a garden. Has five or six decent bedrooms so easy to have family to stay. Lovely local school which feeds into a bigger school in a bigger town. (The bigger town is where we'd want to move but we've struggled to find anywhere suitable in this mad property climate). Perhaps doing this place up would mean we could afford somewhere lovely with a garden in the bigger town by the time thry were at secondary school. The problem is the garden. Trying to work out if we can get past it, despite the house being really quite big. (Sounds like a first world problem, I know. But we've had a really difficult year or so in a tiny flat we've struggled to sell, so please forgive me. Where you live is precious.) Thank you all so much for replying x

OP posts:
knobkopf · 27/08/2023 18:13

No, not when you've got kids, definitely not.
If you can possibly afford it and you have children, you need a garden. They need to be able to get outside. You have a lot more washing than a single person or couple without children and it's helpful to be able to put it outside.
The children need it to be able to play and get some fresh air.
It would be a total pain having to go to the park every single time they want to play out. With a garden you can have a table and chairs and sit there with a coffee and a book while they play out, or you can be doing stuff in the kitchen when they are old enough to play unsupervised.

I'm single and I have a one-bed flat with a balcony. I like not having a garden as it saves work for me but I really need the balcony to be able to sit out in the fresh air (and dry clothes!). I live in the countryside and have fantastic walks and places to go on my doorstep but there are times when you actually can't be bothered to do that and still want to sit outside.
I'd imagine it would be the same with children. You'd get sick of having to get everyone organized to go to the park all the time.

Don't do it.

LadyOfTheCanyon · 27/08/2023 18:01

Mews houses often don't have gardens.
We're considering one at the moment but it does have a tiny balcony big enough for a cafe table and a couple of chairs. Honestly that's all we need ( no kids) as I can't bear gardening.

Doopydoo · 27/08/2023 18:00

I could never buy a house without any outside space to call my own.
Its lovely to have nice nearby parks you can visit but it’s better to be able to open your own back door and lets the kids run in and out knowing they are safe in the garden.
I couldn’t be bothered to have to get us all dressed every time we wanted to go outside to play.

C152 · 27/08/2023 18:00

I would never buy a house without a garden. For me, that's the main point of a house (the other is the benefits of freehold). If you're looking to sell it on as a 'family home' at some point in the future, it really won't appeal to those with young children, regardless of how many parks there are locally.

yikey · 27/08/2023 17:44

Most people will want a garden, but the house will be priced to reflect - so someone will buy it. Is a Juliette balcony an option? Might make a difference when coming to sell.

Countdown2023 · 27/08/2023 17:43

Just for my own mental health the option of being able to sit outside for morning coffee, evening drink, put washing out, grow something is important. So for me even a patio or balcony garden would be a minimum. Luckily I have a decent size garden which I treasure.

NotAsAnonymousAsYouThinkYouAre · 27/08/2023 17:42

What is outside the house if there is no garden? Is it pavements directly in front & back or is it back to back semi detached with another house?

I couldn’t live somewhere where I couldn’t have washing out and at least a few pots to grow things.

AuntyMabelandPippin · 27/08/2023 17:41

I had three years without a garden. It was the three years my children were ill the most. Once we moved, I rarely saw the GP.

cardibach · 27/08/2023 17:40

I detest gardening.
Nevertheless, I wouldn’t buy anywhere with no outdoor space.

mondaytosunday · 27/08/2023 17:39

I have pets so a garden is a must. I think most families would have a garden as top of their list of requirements too.