Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance

434 replies

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:16

I have a DSD. We previously had her 2-3 nights a week in general. Sometimes it was more and sometimes less.

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

DSD has her own room with us and has friends round and we take her to all her hobbies and clubs etc.

DH pays for half her uniform and we buy her clothes and trainers and electronics etc.

DH has approached DSD mum and suggested that maintenance shouldn't be paid anymore. He's happy to go half's on anything she needs as well as continue to buy her things but really monthly maintenance is no longer appropriate.

DSD mum doesn't agree and is really shocked he has suggested this as we are a 2 income household and she will really struggle without it.

DH has suggested paying a lesser amount for now as a transition period which I think is really reasonable. DSD mum is really unhappy about it and can't even believe its been suggested.

My PILs also think DH is unreasonable and should continue to pay.

Am I going mad? Maintenance isn't appropriate in these circumstances is it? Or are we wrong?

OP posts:
Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 17:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 27/08/2023 17:25

Fraaahnces · 27/08/2023 13:22

Run it by CMS. I imagine she didn’t get the new job just for the love of it. Her income will have risen at the same time that she has less custody of DSD. Who knows, maybe she might discover that she had to pay YOU, and then she will STFU.

Yes, and I say this as the mum in the situation. You can't expect someone to take care of your child more often that you do and also pay you for the pleasure.

Ohhbaby · 27/08/2023 17:25

Doyoumind · 27/08/2023 13:53

But the reality is that the difference in outgoings between her DD being with her say 2 days a week and 4 days a week is minimal. She still needs to put a roof over her head, pay for clothes etc. The amount she will save on bills is negligible, and likely not huge on food.

That's not the point.
If a woman said, 'my ex used to have my child full time/the most, now she's with me, but he still wants maintenance'

People would scream stop it immediately. No one would say. Ahh bless, poor guy, he's a single income household, he needs te money and shame he's just started studying something.

They would say he should have thought about that before he started studying etc.

It shouldn't be different, we shouldn't have more compassion because she's a women.
I've always heard layers said men are treated unfairly in child court and this thread shows me why

Shinyandnew1 · 27/08/2023 17:25

Countdown2023 · 27/08/2023 17:23

Surely child benefit needs to go to where the child is spending most of its time.

Absolutely!

Countdown2023 · 27/08/2023 17:23

Surely child benefit needs to go to where the child is spending most of its time.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 17:22

Offyoupoplove · 27/08/2023 16:36

In my experience it’s very rare even with 50-50 time spent with daddy that the father is actually meeting 50% of their needs. Unless they really are, they should pay maintenance in my view.

Who books the dentist? Who schedules a repeat prescription? Who books the hobbies or makes sure they have the right kit? Who knows when it’s parents evening? Who knows what reading level their child is on and what sounds they are working on? Who know’s their best friends names and what they should buy them for their birthday?

Exactly @FloydPepper I'm starting to thing some people have an agenda.
Fair enough to say that mental load should be morally accounted for even though legally that's not the purpose of maintenance. However to decide that the DH probably doesn't do this simply because he's a man is absurd.

People are spouting off about 'their experience' without bothering to read all the OP's updates. It's she and her DH who do the school pickups, and the DSD has friends over at their house. How does any of that imply less mental load?

'Most men' don't do this, therefore they shouldn't be judged by the standards of 'most men'. When a man does something right - 'nah it's just his responsibility doesn't matter that most men don't.' When they're trying to make out that he does something wrong they happily lump him in with most men.

It's called aggregation bias in case anybody's interested....
https://www.statisticshowto.com/aggregation-bias-ecological-fallacy-definition/

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 17:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:18

oP how long has the child been staying with you more than her mother?

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:17

@Milkkbottles your agenda is showing.
Cms don't change calculations because of a recent change. If OP meets cms criteria for a change then of course the change to maintenance should happen.
The point being made is that if cms criteria for length of time has not yet been met, then the circumstances may change back so the child is spending more time with her mother.
Cms want to be sure the change of primary parent is a permanent one and not just a very temporary change.

Thisismynewusername1 · 27/08/2023 17:15

Insommmmnia · 27/08/2023 16:46

Well given the ex thinks they are being mean, her DHs parents think they are being mean and at least 1/4 of the posters think she is mean and petty I would imagine they are not financially acting that way because enough people are telling them that the DH is responsible for supporting his ex financially regardless of where the child lives

Why is the man responsible for supporting the woman?

why doesn’t a mother have a financial responsibility for her child or her ex?

Embarrassingparent · 27/08/2023 17:14

If you are now resident parents (4-5 nights a week) she owes you maintenance...

tiredmama23 · 27/08/2023 17:13

GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 15:11

Let's reverse this:

NRP father wants to retrain and further his career so he asks his ex (who has the kids most of the time) if he can stop his maintenance payments to her and she pay it him instead so he could afford to retrain even though he wouldn't be having the kids much.

There is no way anyone on here would agree to the above.

Exactly this. You can imagine the outrage!

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 17:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

BungleandGeorge · 27/08/2023 17:08

How long have you been having her the extra nights? I think csa calculations use quite a long time period so she would be entitled to a reducing rate and it would be based on average nights including school holidays etc. if she needs the money perhaps she’ll just reduce the number of nights down again as a 12 year old would be fine with early start/ late finish shifts and possibly grandparents will help
out if they think it’s unfair

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 17:05

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:04

@Milkkbottles then you are reading a very different MN to me.

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 17:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:01

I understand not wanting to financially cripple exes. I gave ex his maintenance backin cash and some cash to pay for costs of taking our child out for the day. He was unemployed for a bit, a decent man, and struggling to cope financially.
But they were gifts that I controlled. I did not act financially as if I was not the primary parent.
And yes I do think it is idd behaviour

MeridianB · 27/08/2023 17:00

Why are your PILs chiming in on this, OP?

How do they even know about financial arrangements between your DH and the ex?

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 16:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

Yep you're not wrong.

I am just pointing out what the dilemma is as a pp seems to think I have some weird agenda and I'm lying.

OP posts:
asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:58

@Milkkbottles behave yourself. How can you read MN and claim people think mums can do no wrong. If the mother in this situation posted on MN she would be heavily criticised for not having her child with her more.

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 16:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:56

@Tiamaria86 but you can as I said act financially as primary parent, and if you wish gift her money to help out. I understand not everyone hates their ex and some of us would still want to help out. So why not just do that?

Milkkbottles · 27/08/2023 16:56

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the OP's request.

GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 16:55

@Tiamaria86 You sound like a very caring and kind person which is admirable. Crippled in what sense? Are we talking not being able to afford food etc?

Swipe left for the next trending thread