Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance

434 replies

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:16

I have a DSD. We previously had her 2-3 nights a week in general. Sometimes it was more and sometimes less.

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

DSD has her own room with us and has friends round and we take her to all her hobbies and clubs etc.

DH pays for half her uniform and we buy her clothes and trainers and electronics etc.

DH has approached DSD mum and suggested that maintenance shouldn't be paid anymore. He's happy to go half's on anything she needs as well as continue to buy her things but really monthly maintenance is no longer appropriate.

DSD mum doesn't agree and is really shocked he has suggested this as we are a 2 income household and she will really struggle without it.

DH has suggested paying a lesser amount for now as a transition period which I think is really reasonable. DSD mum is really unhappy about it and can't even believe its been suggested.

My PILs also think DH is unreasonable and should continue to pay.

Am I going mad? Maintenance isn't appropriate in these circumstances is it? Or are we wrong?

OP posts:
Bellyblueboy · 27/08/2023 14:36

I don’t see why your husband should be paying maintenance when he is the the primary resident parent. But run it all through CMS.

I do have to say I found it odd you said your step daughter has her own room at your house and she is allowed friends round. Surely that is basic parenting and didn’t need to be stated?

Luxell934 · 27/08/2023 14:35

How much did the ex sacrifice whilst they were together? If your saying she always worked full time when they were together who looked after the child? Nursery? Who paid for the fees? Did the ex have to change her hours to fit around his job? Did she put off re training so she could do school runs etc etc

PuzzledObserver · 27/08/2023 14:35

Have CMS ever been involved? I think it would be worth looking at their website to see the basis on which calculations are made - so all parties know what they would say if they were involved. Also, use an online benefit calculator to see what both households would be entitled to, if the CMS rules were followed.

That could be an eye opener, and pave the way for a fairer outcome for all involved.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 14:33

MarshyMcMarshFace · 27/08/2023 14:30

Father’s rarely take the career progression / wages / pension hit that mothers do.

Maybe so, but in this case, the ex has always worked full-time and OP and her DH have been the ones to cover the school pick-ups etc.

MarshyMcMarshFace · 27/08/2023 14:30

FloydPepper · 27/08/2023 13:51

How come where it’s a mother who is now the NRP there’s loads of concern that she has a low salary and shouldn’t be in hardship.

male NRPs rarely get that concern on here

Father’s rarely take the career progression / wages / pension hit that mothers do.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 14:30

Also adding your DSD is 12, if it's a 3 year couse she will be 15 when it finished, only 3 years away from uni. If she wants to go those costs have to considered too!

Thisismynewusername1 · 27/08/2023 14:30

EscapeeFromGumtreesMadhouse · 27/08/2023 13:40

The double standards on here are something else.

I'd take it to CMS OP. Why should it be different for her because she's a woman. She's not he NRP so should be treated exactly the same as a NRP father.

This.

if a father decided to retrain and not pay cms, there’d be hell on.

take it to the cms. She pays her contribution to you, as the resident parent.

she should have thought it through when she decided to retrain and have dd stay more at yours to facilitate that.

Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 14:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Phleghm · 27/08/2023 14:29

If I was your DH, I'd tell the ex that maybe they should use the CMS calculator and do it properly, seeing as they aren't seeing eye to eye on this. Be kind and cordial but it is really silly for you to be paying CM when the daughter is with you most of the time.

2weekstowait · 27/08/2023 14:29

It isn't unreasonable. But if it had happened to me it would have tipped me over the edge financially so I can completely understand her shock and worry.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 14:29

SunRainStorm · 27/08/2023 14:18

I agree with this.

Also how long is the retraining period? Presumably not longer than a few months. I don't think it's worth resetting everything for a temporary set up.

DSD should come first. It would be a very positive and healthy thing if her father decided to keep paying maintenance to provide for her in both her homes, not cut back just because he technically can.

Like most women his Ex probably took a career hit to have DSD, while DH was able to keep climbing the ladder with her support.

The ex worked FT, there's no evidence of that.
YANBU OP.
Ex is really out of order for bringing your income into it, but also what happens when the retraining finishes? Is she going to continue to want maintenance on the higher salary?

I wouldn't go so far as to look at the 'legal' CMS position as you have a good relationship maybe come to an agreement. What happens when she's done with this training - will things be re-configured with her new income? Etc.

Your DH doesn't seem, like a disney Dad who has dumped all duties to the NRP so I think she hasn't gotten the short end of the straw here. It's very hard to 'side' with anybody

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 14:27

JudgeRudy · 27/08/2023 14:21

If you're wealthy I think it would be mean but essentially daughter lives 50/50 with each parent. I'll assume mum has the benefit of the CB and any tax credits/UC that might attract. I don't think you owe anything. In fact you could say why doesn't SD live with you full time and visit her mum when her shifts permit. That way mum only has to support herself.
I think the interim reduced payments is a great idea and a generous one at that. Mum should also be made aware that a portion of the 'childcare' is being done and paid for by you, something you have not responsibility for.

the tax credits/UC is a great point. It’s possible this puts her in same financial position as ex, given she receives the CB as well and also doesn’t pay maintenance to ex.

She’s a right CF. Shocked my arse.

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 14:25

For clarity we are very far from wealthy!

We are not trying to be mean as somebody has suggested. That is why I have posted to ask what people think is reasonable. As it is we are already financially stretched.

Somebody has said I haven't considered DSD being away from her mum. Of course I have! However that wasn't the point of the thread and as it is her mum's choice there isn't much I can do about that other than be as supportive as possible to DSD.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 27/08/2023 14:25

Fraaahnces · 27/08/2023 13:22

Run it by CMS. I imagine she didn’t get the new job just for the love of it. Her income will have risen at the same time that she has less custody of DSD. Who knows, maybe she might discover that she had to pay YOU, and then she will STFU.

I doubt her income has risen, I'd imagine she's re training and attending uni/placements. Unfortunately she probably made decisions assuming due had the CS.
You're right though, OPsOH likely owes nothing snd she might need to pay herself.

Ilovegoldies · 27/08/2023 14:23

Morally speaking? Utter tosh. My brother never missed a month's CMS despite being a single income and ex wife remarried to a high earner. No one gave two fucks that the children were living in a two person household then. The double standards on here. Morally his ex wife should have said we don't need your money. It doesn't work like that.

Shinyandnew1 · 27/08/2023 14:22

Citizens advice says this

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance
Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 14:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 14:22

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/08/2023 14:20

This.

She's been doing the donkey work and took the hit career wise. Now she's trying to better herself whilst being a lone parent meanwhile you've clearly been comfortable enough to go on and have more children but want to pull the rug from under her.

You also seem to not be considering the impact on the child and how she may end up going without whilst at her mums.

I'd keep paying whilst she's training and maybe set a date for withdrawal of maintenance for sometime in the future (if DD is still with you).

She has worked full time throughout.

She also could have asked ex to have dc more YEARS ago.

JudgeRudy · 27/08/2023 14:21

If you're wealthy I think it would be mean but essentially daughter lives 50/50 with each parent. I'll assume mum has the benefit of the CB and any tax credits/UC that might attract. I don't think you owe anything. In fact you could say why doesn't SD live with you full time and visit her mum when her shifts permit. That way mum only has to support herself.
I think the interim reduced payments is a great idea and a generous one at that. Mum should also be made aware that a portion of the 'childcare' is being done and paid for by you, something you have not responsibility for.

Willyoujustbequiet · 27/08/2023 14:20

MarshyMcMarshFace · 27/08/2023 13:48

Was her Mum putting this training and eventual new career on hold until her Dd is at secondary and able to see to herself after school etc?

Until now has her Mum been maintaining a lower paid job to enable school runs / holidays etc? Disadvantaged herself in any way career wise and pension wise due to motherhood?

If so I think that morally your DH should continue maintenance until her training is completed.

Your DH has enough income to have started a new family, pay half the upkeep of new Dc, has his Ex been able to afford the same while being a resident parent?

This.

She's been doing the donkey work and took the hit career wise. Now she's trying to better herself whilst being a lone parent meanwhile you've clearly been comfortable enough to go on and have more children but want to pull the rug from under her.

You also seem to not be considering the impact on the child and how she may end up going without whilst at her mums.

I'd keep paying whilst she's training and maybe set a date for withdrawal of maintenance for sometime in the future (if DD is still with you).

Spirallingdownwards · 27/08/2023 14:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

This smacks of what I want and not what the law is!

OP just ognore this for the nonsense it is.

Use the CMS calculator and show Mum he owes nothing so if he is prepared to pay something then she should be happy he isn't claiming off her.

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 14:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

No way, in OP’s situation, where they are not well off, no court in the country is going to require him to give ex maintenance when he has dc 5 nights a week.

Cherrycola29k · 27/08/2023 14:18

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 14:10

It’s probably true when there is a material difference in lifestyles.

If the dad is a multimillionaire the court will want the child to have a similar lifestyle at mum’s home to some extent.

Yes, exactly this!

SunRainStorm · 27/08/2023 14:18

Singleandproud · 27/08/2023 13:31

Did the mum put her career on hold to support your DH when they were together or to provide care for DDin the intervening years?

If so, as an act of good will (and if you can afford to) if they get on well it would be nice if he could support her whilst she completes her training. Once she starts her new career properly then reduce maintenance.

Or, go through CMS calculator and work out the minimum but it's likely to have a negative impact on their relationship.

I agree with this.

Also how long is the retraining period? Presumably not longer than a few months. I don't think it's worth resetting everything for a temporary set up.

DSD should come first. It would be a very positive and healthy thing if her father decided to keep paying maintenance to provide for her in both her homes, not cut back just because he technically can.

Like most women his Ex probably took a career hit to have DSD, while DH was able to keep climbing the ladder with her support.

SpilltheTea · 27/08/2023 14:17

It's child maintenance, not ex maintenance. It's not his responsibility to fund her. She's no longer the primary carer, so she shouldn't be expecting him to give her anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread