Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance

434 replies

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:16

I have a DSD. We previously had her 2-3 nights a week in general. Sometimes it was more and sometimes less.

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

DSD has her own room with us and has friends round and we take her to all her hobbies and clubs etc.

DH pays for half her uniform and we buy her clothes and trainers and electronics etc.

DH has approached DSD mum and suggested that maintenance shouldn't be paid anymore. He's happy to go half's on anything she needs as well as continue to buy her things but really monthly maintenance is no longer appropriate.

DSD mum doesn't agree and is really shocked he has suggested this as we are a 2 income household and she will really struggle without it.

DH has suggested paying a lesser amount for now as a transition period which I think is really reasonable. DSD mum is really unhappy about it and can't even believe its been suggested.

My PILs also think DH is unreasonable and should continue to pay.

Am I going mad? Maintenance isn't appropriate in these circumstances is it? Or are we wrong?

OP posts:
GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 14:55

If this was me and my DH in this situation with his ex, we would stop paying any maintenance at all as the mum barely has the kids now. We would also claim the child related benefits. It's not about being horrible, that money is for the children and if the children are not with the mum; then the money is being spent on herself.

I would probably also claim maintenance off her if it was needed.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 27/08/2023 14:55

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

If this was temporary situation then I’d say to keep it as it is.

However, as this is ongoing then it needs to change.

As she is still training I would reduce the payments and then after that stop it completely.

She will be getting child benefit and UC top ups on top of the maintenance and she’s not even having her child 50% of the time, so of course he needs to stop paying maintenance.

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 14:54

TheHateIsNotGood · 27/08/2023 14:52

You mention that she is a single-income LP hh and works FT, well that would put the kibosh on any chances of becoming a 2 income household (eg: finding the time and energy to form a relationship) - unlike your DP who had the time and energy to find you and have more dc.

And now your SDD is of an age where her DM can consider further improving her income chances - by OPs reckoning the LP in question would be better off finding a DP to help with the bills instead.

How far we women have come....

Er, when did I say that?

OP posts:
londonmummy1966 · 27/08/2023 14:54

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:35

In answer to this, no they broke up when DSD was really young and I've been in her life since she was 3. She is 12 now.

I'm a bit torn on this one. Your DH is right legally BUT... for the first 12 years or so of DSDs life - which are the years when childcare is a major issue - her mother has been the one doing most of the childcare pick ups drop offs working around school hours or paying for after school clubs etc. This will have had an impact on her career/earning potential etc. Now that DSD is in secondary school her mother understandably sees this as a time she can now focus on her career (which has been the case all along for DH). SHe's taken the income hit from the need to have child freiendly hours all these years and now your DH wants to inflict another one. I'm guessing that she's retraining for nursing or something similar so she will still have a few years of struggling with childcare around her shifts and on shit wages too. YOur DH may have the law on his side but morally I do think he owes her for shouldering the income hit of a child-friendly job for so many years. I'd suggest he offers to calculate the new maintenance based on the old one less any expenses he now has that she doesn't eg afterschool club. The cost of a couple of packed lunches seems a bit petty though - 4 slices of bread, a bit of cheese, two packets of crisps and a couple of pieces of fruit a week - unless you are really struggling financially.

CherryCokeFanatic · 27/08/2023 14:52

Surely she should pay as has now become the NRP only a couple nights a week

TheHateIsNotGood · 27/08/2023 14:52

You mention that she is a single-income LP hh and works FT, well that would put the kibosh on any chances of becoming a 2 income household (eg: finding the time and energy to form a relationship) - unlike your DP who had the time and energy to find you and have more dc.

And now your SDD is of an age where her DM can consider further improving her income chances - by OPs reckoning the LP in question would be better off finding a DP to help with the bills instead.

How far we women have come....

MorningOclock · 27/08/2023 14:51

dreamingbohemian · 27/08/2023 13:28

I can't believe people are making such firm judgments when you haven't divulged your salaries. If she's on 20K and your household is on 100K (for example) then yes he should keep paying some maintenance so that his DD can keep a roof over her head. Reducing, fine, ending completely is dickish.

If this was the other way round (primary carer Mum who earned £100k and non primary parent Dad earned less) MN would be crying out that why should Dad should still pay, it’s his responsibility and so on. The step parents salary is not taken into account and why should it be.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 14:50

Backagain23 · 27/08/2023 13:33

Maintenance is owed by the NRP to the RP.
It's not "churlish" or "in theory" or "maybe".
A child deserves to be supported by both parents and this principle doesn't change just because in this case the NRP is the mother. It's also not a step mothers job to subsidise a child just so the mother is "more comfortable" 🙄

Agree with this.

It's the bio-mothers job to sort her own livelihood.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 14:48

WaltzingWaters · 27/08/2023 13:24

no, he shouldn’t be needing to pay maintenance if she’s spending equal or more time at yours (the ex should probably be paying you maintenance if dsd spends more time with you! But probably best not to go there!)

I can understand it will be difficult for her as a single income household but ultimately, it doesn’t have to be his responsibility anymore as long as dsd spends equal/more time at yours.

Why is it "best not to go there"?? Would the same apply if she were a man?

She shouldn't be able to dodge her responsibility.

Insommmmnia · 27/08/2023 14:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

🙄

Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 14:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 14:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Bagpuss2022 · 27/08/2023 14:46

Your DH suggestion sounds more than fair. Can I just also say you sound like a lovely step mum and care about your DSD

SunWorshipping · 27/08/2023 14:45

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 13:48

Definitely not unreasonable.

Technically shouldn't she be paying maintenance now if she only has her daughter 2-3 nights a week?

I thought this, she'll be needing to cover his expenses as he has his daughter more. I find it bizarre that people seem to think he has his daughter more and then still subsidises the ex anyway? He isn't responsible for keeping his ex, her deciding to career change is her choice, it's not his responsibility to cover her shortfall, he's having his child more to help.

Insommmmnia · 27/08/2023 14:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

So your first line is that you aren't blaming the OP and the second line is that you are blaming the OP and her DH.

I wouldn't say anything you have said has been particually supportive to the OP given you have misquoted the rules, complained of being flamed when pulled up on this and spent several posts telling the OP it is her fault.

If this is you in supportive mode...

Iwasafool · 27/08/2023 14:43

BibbleandSqwauk · 27/08/2023 13:24

Are you actually saying that your DH would become the resident parent, in receiving child benefit etc? If it's going to be 4/5 out of every 7 nights then that would be technically the position. Does she regard your place as her home or somewhere she stays?
Thing is technically, you may be right. But if you are a dual income family and the mum is not, and retraining to provide a better quality of life for her and the DD, would the morally right thing not be to just keep the status quo to support this? If you can do it without significant hardship? How is the DD going to feel if suddenly mums house is much tighter for money and you've got extra? I know your income as a step parent is not relevant for CMS maintenance purposes but ultimately you have created a blended family that ought to be about mutual support and doing the best thing for all concerned..if that means your household can accommodate a couple of extra meals a week for the DD without a stretch, why not keep things as they are at least until the mum is qualified?

I've never seen anyone say this the other way round. If the mum had a new partner and dad was single but having DD 2 or 3 nights a week do you think the mum should say don't bother with child maintenance as you need it more than us? Does anyone ever suggest the mother is just providing a few extra meals a week. Usually I hear housing/electric/gas/food etc etc etc.

landbeforegrime · 27/08/2023 14:41

Don't get the moral argument at all people are bringing up at all. There are plenty of single mums having to cope without any maintenance because the "father" is useless or being dishonest. your dh has paid and sounds like contributed more than he technically had to along the way. he has a moral duty to all his children. paying for his ex partner's bills puts her above his family and all the children. if you're letting her continue with child benefit and not claiming cms (it sounds like she should be paying it) then you're already being more than fair. she's being ridiculously entitled to think your dh should pay CHILD maintenance when it's hard to see what her justification is now. She may have made sacrifices but I'm sure you and your husband have as well. she surely knows that child maintenance is connected to a child living with you most of the time. she's treating it like spousal maintenance and thinks it's ok to be taking money away from a household with multiple children to fund her household in which a child will only be living 2 days a week, whilst she claims the child benefit. i think she's being ridiculous and selfish tbh. she sees it as her money and not the child's. I'd question what she's been spending it on all this time given her attitude.

Jaxhog · 27/08/2023 14:41

As several people have said, she should have discussed the impact with her ExH before committing to this decision, since it clearly impacts him too. They need to sit down and discuss what is now 'reasonable'. Looking at what CMS would suggest is also useful.

Gh12345 · 27/08/2023 14:41

I can understand the status quote aspect from he ex but if you went to CMS he probably wouldn’t be required to pay anything anymore (ex cms worker here). However if he wants to pay a lesser amount then that would be the next step and she’ll have to suck it up I’m afraid

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 14:39

Bellyblueboy · 27/08/2023 14:36

I don’t see why your husband should be paying maintenance when he is the the primary resident parent. But run it all through CMS.

I do have to say I found it odd you said your step daughter has her own room at your house and she is allowed friends round. Surely that is basic parenting and didn’t need to be stated?

I think what OP is trying to express is that their house is also DSD's 'home'.
A step above a parent's house that she just 'visits'.

Nanny0gg · 27/08/2023 14:38

Tessabelle74 · 27/08/2023 13:48

But she's a single income with a child only 2 nights a week. She should be paying HIM maintenance technicallly. The maintenance is for the child, not to keep your ex so if the child is with you more then quite rightly you need the money more

And towards keeping a roof over the child's head?

avocadotofu · 27/08/2023 14:38

Phleghm · 27/08/2023 14:29

If I was your DH, I'd tell the ex that maybe they should use the CMS calculator and do it properly, seeing as they aren't seeing eye to eye on this. Be kind and cordial but it is really silly for you to be paying CM when the daughter is with you most of the time.

I think this is a very sensible solution.

SunWorshipping · 27/08/2023 14:37

Sounds like you are keeping her not his children. If you are having her half if not more of the time and paying for the bulk of things anyway she's clearly using that money to subsidise herself not their shared child. She's been lucky you have been paying her anything up to now, I'd stop paying it, it isn't up to you to fund her whilst she retrains, that's up to her to figure out.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 14:37

MarshyMcMarshFace · 27/08/2023 14:30

Father’s rarely take the career progression / wages / pension hit that mothers do.

But there are also many mothers who never had much of a 'career' in the first place. It would be silly to argue that they gave anything up.
IMO in the scenarios about fathers posted on here the NRP is usually a complete deadbeat and tries to get away with doing as little as possible.

Both parties here are reasonable, the ex has worked FT, OP's DH pays his share and they're not precious or calculative (as the DSD stays more or less with them) so I think it's the ideal and they have a good relationship.

What the 'majority' of people do isn't relevant here as this is great unlike most other posts...

Nevermind31 · 27/08/2023 14:36

Doyoumind · 27/08/2023 13:53

But the reality is that the difference in outgoings between her DD being with her say 2 days a week and 4 days a week is minimal. She still needs to put a roof over her head, pay for clothes etc. The amount she will save on bills is negligible, and likely not huge on food.

With this sort of reasoning all those dead beat fathers that have their child EOW shouldn’t need to pay maintenance, and should really receive some from the mother, as it doesn’t make a difference that they only have their child 1 day out of 7. They still need to put a roof over their child’s head during those times…

Swipe left for the next trending thread