Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance

434 replies

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:16

I have a DSD. We previously had her 2-3 nights a week in general. Sometimes it was more and sometimes less.

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

DSD has her own room with us and has friends round and we take her to all her hobbies and clubs etc.

DH pays for half her uniform and we buy her clothes and trainers and electronics etc.

DH has approached DSD mum and suggested that maintenance shouldn't be paid anymore. He's happy to go half's on anything she needs as well as continue to buy her things but really monthly maintenance is no longer appropriate.

DSD mum doesn't agree and is really shocked he has suggested this as we are a 2 income household and she will really struggle without it.

DH has suggested paying a lesser amount for now as a transition period which I think is really reasonable. DSD mum is really unhappy about it and can't even believe its been suggested.

My PILs also think DH is unreasonable and should continue to pay.

Am I going mad? Maintenance isn't appropriate in these circumstances is it? Or are we wrong?

OP posts:
smartiesneberhadtheanswer · 27/08/2023 16:17

Did she compromise her career to enable your husband's earning power?

If so, then it is right he supports whilst she retrains. He has benefited from her raising his daughter until now.

MeridianB · 27/08/2023 16:17

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 16:11

if the mum continues to expect maintenance she’s taking from her child twice. Once the payment to her, and second the amount she should be paying for the child.

Excellent point.

This is true. Plus OP and her DH still have to cover the costs of having DD with them.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 16:16

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:12

Stopping maintenance will probably lead to you spending more on the child.
It is perfectly normal if you are poor to not pay for lots of after school activities, to only have basic clothes and electronics for your children. So be aware she may simply not be able to pay half of what you would want to give this child.
I am not saying you should pay maintenance, I would be surprised if you did. Just be aware there are some complexities around the situation

The thing is if OP and her DH are financially stretched their other children might not have all this either. Actually it would be really odd to have DSD practically living there, getting all of these extra benefits at the expense of her siblings.

Of course this is speculation but OP has said they have to be fair toe everyone... including their other children so I suspect there's a bit of an imbalance already. Would it be 'morally' ok for the other kids to go without to fund non-essentials for DSD? If the entire family has had to cut back, that includes her, as part of it.

drpet49 · 27/08/2023 16:15

StrawberryLemonade2 · 27/08/2023 13:20

If you're having her 4-5 nights a week then you've got her more often, so the maintenance should stop and in theory, you could claim it against the mum.

This

Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 16:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:14

@FloydPepper only one parent receives child benefit. This should legally be the resident parent.

LifeIsShambolic · 27/08/2023 16:12

babyproblems · 27/08/2023 15:46

I also think you should ask CMS and officially decide who is the primary carer.
I always feel there is an underlying note of cruelty in these posts - it’s their child fgs. He should be happy to pay and also ensure her mum is not some run ragged woman which I suspect she is. There’s always an element of keeping the single parent in a tough place which I think is horrible. You said you can afford to pay - I personally think you should just continue paying it. If you are primary carers officially then you could rethink it but her mum clearly needs more support.

In what way are they being cruel?
The child is living with them, they pay for clothing, footwear, electronics etc. They do pick ups/drop offs.....almost as if they are the resident parents and the mother is the NRP no? Isn't it normally the NRP (usually dad) that pays maintenance?
Honestly the double standards on here sometimes are mind blowing. Mum will have to do what other adults do and live within her means or put the training on hold until her daughter is older.
The father of her child is not an income stream to allow her to live a certain lifestyle, now the child is with the father the majority of the time the money can be spent directly supporting her.
The OP has already said they intend to let the mother continue to claim child benefit which I think is more than generous considering they will now have to pay the majority of the costs associated with dsd.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:12

Stopping maintenance will probably lead to you spending more on the child.
It is perfectly normal if you are poor to not pay for lots of after school activities, to only have basic clothes and electronics for your children. So be aware she may simply not be able to pay half of what you would want to give this child.
I am not saying you should pay maintenance, I would be surprised if you did. Just be aware there are some complexities around the situation

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 16:11

if the mum continues to expect maintenance she’s taking from her child twice. Once the payment to her, and second the amount she should be paying for the child.

Excellent point.

FloydPepper · 27/08/2023 16:11

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 27/08/2023 15:23

I agree.

The mother is also still receiving child benefit and UC top ups, despite the fact that she’s not having the child as often as the dad.

Rp should also receive child benefit surely?

FloydPepper · 27/08/2023 16:10

GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 15:11

Let's reverse this:

NRP father wants to retrain and further his career so he asks his ex (who has the kids most of the time) if he can stop his maintenance payments to her and she pay it him instead so he could afford to retrain even though he wouldn't be having the kids much.

There is no way anyone on here would agree to the above.

Exactly

that this is even a debate shows how skewed mumsnet is

an nrp should pay an rp in line with (or preferably more than) the cms payment. To fail to do that makes them a deadbeat parent. Is that only true for men on here?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 16:10

What is her living situation, OP? Does she have enough space to take in a lodger? Could she downsize to a smaller flat?

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 16:09

GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 16:05

Plenty of non resident fathers can't afford to pay maintenance but have to anyway. So why should the mother get to keep it when it's not being spent on the children? If she can't afford to live without the CM then she will have to cut her cloth so to speak.

Exactly this.

Thisismynewusername1 · 27/08/2023 16:09

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 16:06

I think this is it really. Try and have an open conversation. If the situation is the electric bill can't be paid or there won't be food on the table without the amount that's already paid then maybe it will need to stay as it is.

If the situation is maybe the maintence goes on some luxuries then it can be reduced.

I don't know the answer the really! Hence the post.

If she can’t pay her electric bill it’s not your responsibility to pay it for her.

before she decides to retrain she should have calculated the affordability of doing so. If she hasn’t, she’s an adult and shouldn’t expect hand outs from you.

Floweryx123 · 27/08/2023 16:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 16:06

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 16:01

Well it really depends on what the maintenance is used for, isn't it?
Being unable to fund essentials, such as utility bills is different from being unable to afford any extras.

Of course this is just an example but if DSD Mum can no longer afford to pay her half of all activities some might have to be dropped. Many, many families have had to do this with the cost of living crisis anyway.

I think this is it really. Try and have an open conversation. If the situation is the electric bill can't be paid or there won't be food on the table without the amount that's already paid then maybe it will need to stay as it is.

If the situation is maybe the maintence goes on some luxuries then it can be reduced.

I don't know the answer the really! Hence the post.

OP posts:
Thisismynewusername1 · 27/08/2023 16:05

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 15:58

I think it's better morally to facilitate her career change, rather than effectively force her to stay in the previous role that would have been dictated at least in part by her needing to care for her child - especially as removing maintenance would be screwing her over for another 5-10 years when she could be established and earning far more, fully self sufficient and support her DD in University/early adult life if you continue as you are.

He's proposing pretty much sweeping her feet out from under her financially just when she's trying to do something better.

So if the child’s dad decided to retrain, stop paying maintenance AND expect a contribution from mum that would be ok?

he’s only trying to better himself and will be in a better position to support the child through uni.

bottom line is it’s nothing to do with the parents situation or income.

cms is for the CHILD. it’s payable to whoever has main responsibility for that child.

if the mum continues to expect maintenance she’s taking from her child twice. Once the payment to her, and second the amount she should be paying for the child.

deadbeat mum not paying her share of her child’s costs.

GrannyGoggins · 27/08/2023 16:05

Plenty of non resident fathers can't afford to pay maintenance but have to anyway. So why should the mother get to keep it when it's not being spent on the children? If she can't afford to live without the CM then she will have to cut her cloth so to speak.

LoveThisUsername · 27/08/2023 16:04

Nevermind31 · 27/08/2023 14:36

With this sort of reasoning all those dead beat fathers that have their child EOW shouldn’t need to pay maintenance, and should really receive some from the mother, as it doesn’t make a difference that they only have their child 1 day out of 7. They still need to put a roof over their child’s head during those times…

I know of quite a few fathers that can't afford a roof over their heads because they are paying so much maintenance, plus going halves on one off costs and buying things themselves for the children.

They live with aunts, in garden rooms, shared houses.

How is that acceptable? They have no chance of having their kids stay with them for any length of time, but I suspect that's the aim to keep the maintenance rolling in.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 27/08/2023 16:04

A decent person would have proactively said "hey, as you're having the DC most of the time, no need to continue the maintenance." Not act surprised and shocked that guidelines are being followed.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 16:02

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 15:58

I think it's better morally to facilitate her career change, rather than effectively force her to stay in the previous role that would have been dictated at least in part by her needing to care for her child - especially as removing maintenance would be screwing her over for another 5-10 years when she could be established and earning far more, fully self sufficient and support her DD in University/early adult life if you continue as you are.

He's proposing pretty much sweeping her feet out from under her financially just when she's trying to do something better.

We don't KNOW that, unless we know what she's spending the maintenance on. She could be really struggling to cover essentials. She may just be unable to afford extras. We don't know.

CwmYoy · 27/08/2023 16:02

Agree with using the CMS calculator. She's taking the piss.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 16:02

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 15:58

I think it's better morally to facilitate her career change, rather than effectively force her to stay in the previous role that would have been dictated at least in part by her needing to care for her child - especially as removing maintenance would be screwing her over for another 5-10 years when she could be established and earning far more, fully self sufficient and support her DD in University/early adult life if you continue as you are.

He's proposing pretty much sweeping her feet out from under her financially just when she's trying to do something better.

No, she's doing that to herself.

aSofaNearYou · 27/08/2023 16:01

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 15:58

I think it's better morally to facilitate her career change, rather than effectively force her to stay in the previous role that would have been dictated at least in part by her needing to care for her child - especially as removing maintenance would be screwing her over for another 5-10 years when she could be established and earning far more, fully self sufficient and support her DD in University/early adult life if you continue as you are.

He's proposing pretty much sweeping her feet out from under her financially just when she's trying to do something better.

She should never have expected maintenance to continue if she was having her child less than half, the rug hasn't been pulled from under her, she should have assumed and expected this.

And nobody is being screwed over by not being bolstered up by money that isn't owed to them.

FasciaDreams · 27/08/2023 16:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Well it really depends on what the maintenance is used for, isn't it?
Being unable to fund essentials, such as utility bills is different from being unable to afford any extras.

Of course this is just an example but if DSD Mum can no longer afford to pay her half of all activities some might have to be dropped. Many, many families have had to do this with the cost of living crisis anyway.