Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To agree that DH should reduce maintenance

434 replies

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 13:16

I have a DSD. We previously had her 2-3 nights a week in general. Sometimes it was more and sometimes less.

Her Mum has decided to retrain in a different career and this has meant late nights and early starts so we now have DSD more like 4-5 nights a week.

DSD has her own room with us and has friends round and we take her to all her hobbies and clubs etc.

DH pays for half her uniform and we buy her clothes and trainers and electronics etc.

DH has approached DSD mum and suggested that maintenance shouldn't be paid anymore. He's happy to go half's on anything she needs as well as continue to buy her things but really monthly maintenance is no longer appropriate.

DSD mum doesn't agree and is really shocked he has suggested this as we are a 2 income household and she will really struggle without it.

DH has suggested paying a lesser amount for now as a transition period which I think is really reasonable. DSD mum is really unhappy about it and can't even believe its been suggested.

My PILs also think DH is unreasonable and should continue to pay.

Am I going mad? Maintenance isn't appropriate in these circumstances is it? Or are we wrong?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RememberTheWaybaloos · 30/08/2023 02:58

No, not at all unreasonable.

By rights, you should be receiving the child benefit, any additional financial support. I agree that would be harsh and think it shows massive love and respect that you're not going to disadvantage DSD in that way.

However... Its a disadvantage to DSD if you guys are scrimping and scraping and she's with you more often than not. So, Yes, a conversation is needed between them/you three that addresses how all these things will be paid for from now on. For me, I'd work out how much more this is costing you from when the agreement was first put in place and adjust accordingly.

HamBone · 30/08/2023 00:16

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 20:01

What would constitute an adverse effect on DD? OP & spouse are covering most of her needs.

If mum moves to a bedsit & DD has to sleep on an inflatable bed 2x a week, that's not an undue hardship.

Technically you might be right, @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune but I know I’d be uncomfortable knowing that my child was in that situation.
The Dad has done what he feels is best for his child.

Tandora · 29/08/2023 20:17

Tiamaria86 · 27/08/2023 19:43

Thanks for everybody's input. There's been some really interesting points made and some posters have made me think about things I hadn't really considered.

Just to address some questions, this arrangement has been in place since January. There have been the odd weeks where DSD has been with Mum more but on average she is more with us.

As an update DH has popped round to see her and it turns out DSD has told her that she really hates an activity she has been doing for a couple of years. She had brought this up before but apparently now she really wants to stop doing it. This activity costs about £120 a month plus costumes and competition fees and DH and her mum split this. They have agreed DSD will stop this activity and DH will reduce maintenance by £60 a month for now. This means that her Mum won't be any worse off but we will save around £120 a month.

We are going to leave it at that for now. DH told me that once they sat down together his ex had calmed down and they were able to have a chat. Apparently her finances are bad so tbh we both would feel bad making them worse and we absolutely don't want her to quit her course as some previous posters have suggested.

I think some PP were right in that this should have been discussed earlier and maybe money reduced gradually but look none of us are perfect in these situations.

I'm happy with what they have come up with and I'm glad I posted as I did get some interesting perspectives.

You all sound wonderful ❤️. What a civilised and decent way to behave from everyone.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 20:01

What would constitute an adverse effect on DD? OP & spouse are covering most of her needs.

If mum moves to a bedsit & DD has to sleep on an inflatable bed 2x a week, that's not an undue hardship.

Thisistyresome · 29/08/2023 17:53

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 17:35

She's had 10 years to transition.

Clearly she's been living well above her means and the time to cut her cloth is now. Why should her ex subsidize her lifestyle for additional years? It's absurd.

Legally I agree. I also agree she should have transitioned before not but she has not been made too. My only concern would be if she suddenly would there be an adverse impact on the DSD which then causes more issues than it is worth.

Sometimes doing the right thing gets you more pain than something else.

If there was no change that there would be an adverse impact on DSD or the couple currently paying her maintenance I would say cut if off now, but I can imagine circumstances when it gives them more pain than it is worth.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 17:35

Thisistyresome · 29/08/2023 14:03

As you are average earners it is legally simple. If she is retraining then presumably she is going to be earning more. Also the idea that his ex has the right to be supported by him (at a cost to his DC with you) seem rather entitled.

Though for the sake of everyone it may make sense to have a transition to the new situation where he no longer pays. The maintenance has only 6 years to run so a year (or absolute max two) of reducing payments inline with the ex’s career ramping up would make the change easier.

If she is now working presumably she is in some kind of probationally year so salary should rise at the end. You are now picking up the bulk of the costs of the additional costs, you can’t fund his ex indefinitely.

She's had 10 years to transition.

Clearly she's been living well above her means and the time to cut her cloth is now. Why should her ex subsidize her lifestyle for additional years? It's absurd.

MalcolmsMiddle · 29/08/2023 17:29

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/08/2023 23:56

Well you were having her 3/7 nights, now it’s 5/7 nights. That’s an increase of 28%, therefore reduce maintenance by 28%.
You can’t just stop it, her mother still has expenses for her, you have the agreed maintenance, just adjust it.

That's not how it works.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 29/08/2023 14:39

Thelnebriati · 29/08/2023 00:20

The inequality between the mother who has to be the default parent and limit their earning potential and pension, and the non resident father who can outsource his parenting responsibilities is lost on so many posters. No wonder so many older women live in poverty.

why haven't you actually read the thread though? She was not the default parent, they co-parenting fairly and not parents worked full time, with Dad and StepMum collecting from school and activities often. The mother has had the same opportunity to work as the father has. Now she has more opportunity and free time, less expenses, she should receive less and eventually nothing.They were not together long after the child was born.

Thisistyresome · 29/08/2023 14:03

As you are average earners it is legally simple. If she is retraining then presumably she is going to be earning more. Also the idea that his ex has the right to be supported by him (at a cost to his DC with you) seem rather entitled.

Though for the sake of everyone it may make sense to have a transition to the new situation where he no longer pays. The maintenance has only 6 years to run so a year (or absolute max two) of reducing payments inline with the ex’s career ramping up would make the change easier.

If she is now working presumably she is in some kind of probationally year so salary should rise at the end. You are now picking up the bulk of the costs of the additional costs, you can’t fund his ex indefinitely.

aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 13:06

Hi @Backagain23 👋, didn't know you'd name changed!

Yes me too actually, but it always goes down like a lead balloon and "people have a duty to provide for the children they produce, it doesn't matter how wealthy the other household is" is quoted near unanimously. Plus as you say, not at all reasonable when neither household has surplus money!

Backagain23 · 29/08/2023 12:55

aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 12:41

Role reverse here - There are hundreds of women bleeding men dry a month and they don't care. The guy could and should stop maintenance and demand from her. Consideration of each others finances never hapens with the CMS

Exactly. Next time I see a thread where a RP mum is discussing claiming maintenance from a NRP dad I will point out that his income might not be high and she could be putting him in financial hardship, and refer them to this thread. I wonder what response I will receive!

You'll have seen me arguing exactly that on more than one occasion (It's Yousee) as I do believe that if the RP household is actually wealthy (not just about scraping by for now like OP) then it's morally, if not legally, wrong to be taking money from an involved NRP, which is just going to sit in a bank account somewhere instead of benefiting the child with their NRP.
The OPs situation though is completely outrageous and detrimental to all the children involved if it carries on.

aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 12:41

Role reverse here - There are hundreds of women bleeding men dry a month and they don't care. The guy could and should stop maintenance and demand from her. Consideration of each others finances never hapens with the CMS

Exactly. Next time I see a thread where a RP mum is discussing claiming maintenance from a NRP dad I will point out that his income might not be high and she could be putting him in financial hardship, and refer them to this thread. I wonder what response I will receive!

eminem120176 · 29/08/2023 12:33

cannaecookrisotto · 27/08/2023 13:39

It really all depends on the financial situations of both households.

The rule is he shouldn't pay anymore if you're having her 50/50 or more and she could even be required to give him maintenance, however, if her salary isn't that high then this isn't really practical and could put her into financial difficulty.

Likewise, she could rely on the maintenance to pay bills and put food on the table and by stopping maintenance you could put her financial security into jeopardy- aka your DSDs way of life.

In reality, I (as in your DH) would want to understand the consequences of removing the maintenance before I did it and if I was in a financial position where I could comfortably carry on paying (and stopping would cause detriment to her finances) then I would continue.

If it's a middle ground kind of situation where you really need the money to support the extra time DSD is staying with you then I would taper the maintenance off rather than just stopping completely.

It's hard to say who is BU without the financial status of both households.

Role reverse here - There are hundreds of women bleeding men dry a month and they don't care. The guy could and should stop maintenance and demand from her. Consideration of each others finances never hapens with the CMS

T1Dmama · 29/08/2023 11:58

Also surely DSD’S mum is entitled to benefits to help her during her studies. She maybe entitled to universal credit, help with rent and significantly reduced council tax etc!
I think you’re both extremely kind to still pay maintenance.

T1Dmama · 29/08/2023 11:42

Also as the main carers your husband is well within his writes to apply for the family allowance payment. You don’t get to have your child for 2 days a week only and still claim the benefits for looking after them. I’d apply for a change in the custody terms and get it written up that you now have the main parental responsibility … if this changes in the future and she lives back with mum majority of the time again once she’s qualified then obviously payments restart. Until then, sorry no but that isn’t what maintenance is for…. It’s CHILD MAINTENANCE not SPOUSAL PAYMENTS.

T1Dmama · 29/08/2023 11:35

This is just my opinion, but if the daughter is living with you more than half of the week and you’re paying towards clothes etc then maintenance is not appropriate… surely if you are providing the majority of the care then mum should be paying maintenance to you!!
Maybe it would be appropriate to go to the child support agency for advice regarding this. Maintenance is for the child and not to support the mother to go back to college, if child is living with you then maintenance isn’t applicable??
(Presuming you are now doing the majority of feeding and clothing, washing her clothes etc) what expense has mum actually got??

CrabbyMcPatty · 29/08/2023 09:21

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/08/2023 23:56

Well you were having her 3/7 nights, now it’s 5/7 nights. That’s an increase of 28%, therefore reduce maintenance by 28%.
You can’t just stop it, her mother still has expenses for her, you have the agreed maintenance, just adjust it.

Hahahahahahaha

Fact is she's no longer the RP, she is the NRP. NRPs pay maintenance to RPs because they naturally have more expenses than a NRP. The fact this RP has a penis shouldn't mean the ex doesn't need to pay maintenance but actually receive it instead!!!

drpet49 · 29/08/2023 08:13

Mumuser124 · 28/08/2023 21:35

I'm honestly appalled at the women who are justifying the mother receiving payments based on morality. It actually makes me feel embarrassed to be a women when so many of my gender justify sponging off a family and their children to support her choices.

The payments need to stop, I think op and her husband suggesting a reduction in the short term is a very kind thing to do considering they are providing well beyond what the non resident parent is contributing.

This

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 29/08/2023 07:39

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/08/2023 23:56

Well you were having her 3/7 nights, now it’s 5/7 nights. That’s an increase of 28%, therefore reduce maintenance by 28%.
You can’t just stop it, her mother still has expenses for her, you have the agreed maintenance, just adjust it.

Comments like this are just unbelievable. WTF is wrong with people?

Yes, the mother has expenses. She has expenses because she has a child and she is responsible for paying for 50% of the costs of that child. As her ex now has the child for more than 50% of the time, he is already covering more than 50% of the costs.

So why the fuck would he need to pay any maintenance to the child's mother, who only has her for 2 nights a week?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 02:08

SD1978 · 28/08/2023 22:19

As far as I'm concerned he should be reducing and potentially stopping it. You have your SD 4-5 nights a week, and will continue to going forward. You will have the extra costs involved in that, which mum no longer does. I don't understand where feeding, heating and housing the mother becomes your responsibility?! Yes it should be reduced/ stopped and I can not understand why people think that it shouldn't!

Agree. This woman had had a decade to figure it out. Enough is enough.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 02:07

Toomuchtrouble4me · 28/08/2023 23:56

Well you were having her 3/7 nights, now it’s 5/7 nights. That’s an increase of 28%, therefore reduce maintenance by 28%.
You can’t just stop it, her mother still has expenses for her, you have the agreed maintenance, just adjust it.

The RP isn't required to foot all expense. The bio-mother needs to finance her own household ffs.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 29/08/2023 02:06

Thelnebriati · 29/08/2023 00:20

The inequality between the mother who has to be the default parent and limit their earning potential and pension, and the non resident father who can outsource his parenting responsibilities is lost on so many posters. No wonder so many older women live in poverty.

It's been 10 years. And she was not the default parent.

RTFT.

Thelnebriati · 29/08/2023 00:20

The inequality between the mother who has to be the default parent and limit their earning potential and pension, and the non resident father who can outsource his parenting responsibilities is lost on so many posters. No wonder so many older women live in poverty.

Backagain23 · 29/08/2023 00:12

aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 00:08

What this thread really shows is that many people on here simply cannot compute the notion of the woman not automatically being the one to receive maintenance.

Indeed, this thread has been a peach.
"The mother has expenses" indeed. What the fuck do people think the dad is doing -spending Monopoly money feeding and clothing and housing his child the majority of the time? 🙄

aSofaNearYou · 29/08/2023 00:08

What this thread really shows is that many people on here simply cannot compute the notion of the woman not automatically being the one to receive maintenance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread