Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be depressed that he preferred life without me

114 replies

CustomMade · 27/08/2023 11:20

I would like to know if I'm being stupid, or if other people would feel the same as me.

My OH isnt from the UK and he emigrated here to live with me a year ago.

He hates it.

Before he emigrated he had been here many times to stay with me, often for extended periods and we had a fantastic time. However since he moved he's been a nightmare.

I get that England isn't paradise especially lately, but here are my problems with it.

He keeps suggesting we move together to another country

This is upsetting because logistically due to family reasons, I can't do this.

He's not given things a reasonable chance. He complains but makes no effort of any kind to improve things

For example:

He complains all the time that he hates working free overtime, but he keeps doing it. For example he did 12 hours yesterday when it's meant to be a break.

He complains he has no friends, but he doesn't ever want to do anything with anyone but me. When he first got here we had invitations and he always made excuses.

He complains he wants hobbies he enjoys but then says he's too knackered from working the free overtime to do anything.

The worst one is, he keeps harking back to how amazing and wonderful life was with his ex!!!

He hates his job. He hates the weather. He hates the noise and crowds. He hates that he makes much less money. He complains he has no friends. He complains he has no hobbies anymore. He complains he keeps getting colds. He complains everything is so expensive.

He had a life before me, which he loved. He loved his mates, he loved his well paid job with private office. He loved the weather and spending weekends at the beach. He had a much nicer house. He had a lot less stress.

Now, I understand all this. I've emigrated myself several times and I appreciate living in the UK right now is no picnic and I'm happy to encourage him and help him to feel more settled.

However, I find it extremely upsetting that the "old life" he keeps saying he misses, was a life with his ex. The house he shared with her. The friends. The hobbies. It was all with her. Which I find massively upsetting and I'm sick and tired of him acting like life with me is a chappy consolidation prize.

Before responding:

No, I am not the "other woman". He was done with her before we met.

No, I do not think he wants to be with her, as it was him who broke it off as he said he didn't love her and she tried for a very long time to beg him back.

Yes, I have told him if he hates it so much to leave (he says it would be impossible to be happy without me)

I know if he wants to stay here and create a valued life with me that he has to help create this and stop being so negative.

But what I want to know is: AIBU to be deeply hurt that he's spent the first year of our life "together" telling me that his life with his ex was better - massively- by almost every measurable metric???

He honestly says the ONLY good thing about his life now is me.

OP posts:
Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 15:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 15:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

CustomMade · 27/08/2023 15:58

To those telling me to tell him to go back: I have. Several times. He says no way can he live without me. He says on balance an awful life with me there is better.

Where he was living was not really his home. He was an expat there. The group of friends he had, he'd known only a couple of years from work, hobbies and "down the pub" - he could easily have made a new life if he'd tried.

His kids are at university here. We see them every few weeks. Yes, you'd think he'd love that - which he does on the day - but he doesn't seem to factor it in to his overall trip advisor rating.

I'm not upset because he's not settled quick enough. I'm upset because he's wasted the whole honeymoon period by walking around with a face like thunder saying everything is "rubbish" and harking back to years with his ex as his happiest.

Which I think is quite fucked up to be honest. I have thought so many times that if he liked it so much, and was so happy, then he should have just stayed.

He says he can't imagine any life that isn't the both of us together, but I see no point in that at all.

The main thing being - he built a life of value with his ex. He got a nice house, job he liked, hobbies, a friend group and so on; but he is not even trying to build a life of value with me.

That makes me very sad and depressed because I'd actually quite like to have a life my OH enjoyed. We make £109k between us and there's no reason we can't have a nice life and enjoy lots of things.

We have four days off right now, in a beautiful air B&B with two of our kids here with us. He's spent most of it alone in the bedroom working. Which he'll do for the remaining days.

I suggested we go and get pissed. He doesn't want to (the old version of him would have loved that) and it's raining so I suggested we all watch a movie or play a game. He's too busy working.

I am trying here.

I genuinely feel like he'd be fucking happier if he left us and I'm really tired of feeling like this. Yes, I know it's not working, but he doesn't want to accept that.

I do think he really loves me, but he's just spoiling our life.

OP posts:
C152 · 27/08/2023 15:49

It doesn't sound like he preferred life without you, OP. It sounds like he wants both you and to be living in his home country.

I think you are being unreasonable to expect him to slip into life easily here. 14 months isn't actually a long time to get used to the massive culture shock of moving to the UK. And the alternatives you are suggesting to his issues, aren't comparable at all - surely if you've lived elsewhere, you must see that?

Perhaps you both imagined it would be easier than it is and he's disappointed and angry about the situation here and all he's given up and you're disappointed and angry about his attitude. To me, his suggestion that you both move to another country shows how desperately unhappy he is and one day he will leave. If you've had enough, by all means, accept that the move hasn't worked and ask him to leave. You don't have to wait for him to make a decision. Could he move back home and you both continue to have a long distance relationship?

In the iterim, rather than trying to argue him out of his points of view, just accept they are valid and ask, other than moving countries, what he suggests would make things a little better.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 27/08/2023 15:48

He's looking back with rose tinted glasses on
Fair enough he needs time to adjust, but it's not fair he's making no effort to make a happy life with you
In my head, I'd set a time limit and if if no change I'd tell him to leave
Simply if he loved you, he'd want you to be happy

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/08/2023 15:40

He sounds like hard bloody work.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 15:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 15:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 15:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

JudgeRudy · 27/08/2023 15:20

You're not being unreasonable to be hurt. He's not being unreasonable to think his former life was better. Yes, he could take action to improve his lot but will it really make it better. You're asking him to give up so much to be with you yet you aren't even prepared to try giving up stuff for him and moving. I can't think of any reason why you couldn't go. Let's say eg you care for your mum, she could have carers or go into a care home. If you are diabetic with high BP and COPD you might feel healthcare was too expensive but could he pay. I think you could move if you really wanted but you don't.
He gave it a go, it didn't work. If you want to give it a go then follow him home. If not the relationship is over.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 27/08/2023 14:52

Also, when you're in a less than ideal situation it is easy to look back and romanticise how things were before.... I doubt his life was that bloody perfect.

TheAOEAztec · 27/08/2023 14:52

Don't understand the comment upthread about hiking not being as good here as abroad - there is some beautiful countryside in Britain, but he has to make the effort to go and see it!

Freedom to roam makes it completely different game to england. I think scotland has it too. Prices of getting to that places are ridiculous. Most of my friends on mainland take cheaply train to next door country or other aide of country making nature and travel accessible to quite a lots of people.
Example Vienna to Bratislava just under 13eur, similar distance manchester to york 34eur. But the freedom to roam is just major thing. I spent youth roaming countryside. Hours and hours in forest criss cross picking mushrooms, no stick to foothpaths, wild camping wherever suitable, swimming in rivers and lakes. Very few fences.

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 27/08/2023 14:50

Firstly, I think he's being v insensitive.

Secondly, he made a choice and unless he is going to move back, he needs to own that choice. This involves trying to improve things for himself where he can. He has to try... And stop moaning.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 14:47

I'd tell him to bugger off back home then.

aloris · 27/08/2023 14:47

I think you are being really hard on him. I've moved several times, work related. To different areas in the same country. The quality of individual aspects was the same (i.e we weren't moving up or down an income bracket), it was just that the things themselves (and I) were in a different place than before. The first year, I was on the verge of tears all the time. The reality is that moving just really sucks. The weather is different, the geography is different, the culture is different, you don't know who you can trust, people don't know you so they don't necessarily trust you, etc.

Yes, you can make new friends, but, come on, these are superficial friends, for at least a few years, if not longer. They are people you might be able to have a barbeque with, but they aren't going to go out of their way to help you the way your childhood friends would. In all the places I've moved, I've made what seemed to be really good friends, very close. The day I told them I was moving to a new place for work, they all stopped calling me or inviting me to meetups. (this has happened enough times that I've learned not to tell people I'm moving until the house is on the market). My "best friend" from my last place before this, we were friends for 7 years. I haven't talked to her in 5 years now.

I've been in my "new" place almost a decade now. I have new friends. I've visited lots of the attractions in the area. I've been very intentional about integrating myself into the local community and finding the best ways to make new friends. But it still doesn't feel like home. Again, that's staying in the same country. Now imagine doing that in a whole a$$ different country.

This man gave up his whole lifestyle to be with you and you're annoyed he's not instantly happy.

piercedears · 27/08/2023 14:43

I understand him. He has to try and work out if it's the specific place you live in now, or if he feels it's the UK, culturally as a whole.
If he feels more comfortable and at ease in a different culture, and can't recreate that somewhat by moving nearer to this expat community in the uk, then he should seriously consider moving back to where he was before.

LadyBird1973 · 27/08/2023 14:41

Oh and you are totally right to maintain a family home for your children. Uni aged kids are not really adult and especially if you have one who has struggled mentally

LadyBird1973 · 27/08/2023 14:39

This would piss me off - life in Britain is not terrible for a lot of people. I know plenty who are going out for nice meals, on holidays and mini breaks, perusing hobbies. It's not all skint and depressed! The truth is that very often life is what you make it - if he hates his job, there's nothing stopping him from finding another one. It's possible to move house etc.
You said he's half British and has a child here - is there no part of him that's happy to be in the same country as his child?

Don't understand the comment upthread about hiking not being as good here as abroad - there is some beautiful countryside in Britain, but he has to make the effort to go and see it!

He's never going to be happy if he constantly complains yet does nothing to improve things.

RadishAndTwiglet · 27/08/2023 14:28

Is that what he is really saying, or just how you are choosing to interpret it?

'He literally says his life is better by every metric constantly. He says his house was better, job, friends, social life, hobbies: literally ALL those things he did with his ex.'

Yes but it's not about his ex is it? That was my point. She was there in the background, yes, but it's the other things in his old life that he misses. I think you are choosing to focus on his ex being in the equation, but that's not what be means. Not that that helps, necessarily, if he's still dissastified with absolutely everything about his life except you.

topnoddy · 27/08/2023 14:25

Sounds to me like he needs to return to where he used to live and his old life

TheAOEAztec · 27/08/2023 14:20

It's not about the ex tho.

Gerrataere · 27/08/2023 14:20

I’m guessing he’s from Australia (no need to say op I’m just venturing from what you’ve said). I’m not sure what he was expecting, Britain is not for those who’ve lived the sunshine, laid back life, it can affect you in every which way. I can imagine it’s quite a culture shock being suddenly submerged in Britishness wherever you’re from.

Personally I’m not sure how it’s go to work longterm. I know one couple where one moved from similar circumstances and they’re miserable. They thought they could move after a few years but their spouse became very ill. They keep saying ‘once they’ve passed I’m on the first plane home’, just seems a very depressing situation to get to.

dottiedodah · 27/08/2023 14:16

I think he seems unhappy wherever TBH. If life was so great with his ex, why did he leave her?Quite honestly I would think about ending things ,he is making you unhappy as well! Sometimes it doesnt work out due to circumstances and this is one of those times .

Viviennemary · 27/08/2023 14:12

It's clear from your post he is unhappy and doesn't like life in this country. I don't agree he is just a natural miserable grump wherever he lives. A lot of people find it hard to adjust to a new country or even a new area and some folk never settle.

GentlemanJay · 27/08/2023 14:10

It's not going to work in England. I think you need to accept that.