Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think being female and white is what meant Lucy Letby could continue her crimes?

267 replies

sociallyanxiouspartone · 27/08/2023 11:18

Let's face it, the reality is as women we are often disadvantaged but being a woman in this case is what meant Lucy went under the radar for so long and the fact she was white combined with this and looked like the 'girl next door' is what meant more babies lost their lives than needed to.

Just imagine, a male non white nurse was in the same position he would have been called out much much earlier

Let's hope this helps people think about how harmful stereotyping can actually be.

Sorry to all the families that lost babies in all of this 💐

OP posts:
LakeTiticaca · 27/08/2023 12:13

Oh here we go again

Pollyputhekettleon · 27/08/2023 12:13

sociallyanxiouspartone · 27/08/2023 11:18

Let's face it, the reality is as women we are often disadvantaged but being a woman in this case is what meant Lucy went under the radar for so long and the fact she was white combined with this and looked like the 'girl next door' is what meant more babies lost their lives than needed to.

Just imagine, a male non white nurse was in the same position he would have been called out much much earlier

Let's hope this helps people think about how harmful stereotyping can actually be.

Sorry to all the families that lost babies in all of this 💐

Ignoring the race-baiting, it's a simple fact that women are vastly less likely to murder someone else's babies than men are. And that's in circumstances where women make up most of those working with babies, so due to access alone they should be over-represented. And neonatal nurses are even less likely to than your average woman because of the type of personality that generally chooses such a job. Those aren't 'stereotypes' in the sense you mean the word. They're statistical probabilities. So in the absence of any other information it's absolutely rational to be more likely to suspect a man than a woman.

Anotherchristianmama · 27/08/2023 12:12

I think in this case the reason she wasn't caught quickly was because the hospital management were covering things up and not following procedure.

Flapjacker48 · 27/08/2023 12:11

Yes if she was a BAME and/or from overseas I think concerns would have been acted on earlier. I also think there would not have been a small but vocal minority on MN who "aren't convinced by the evidence" and less general hand wringing about "why"

quantumbutterfly · 27/08/2023 12:11

..and YABVU

GilbertMarkham · 27/08/2023 12:11

I agree, without getting into race or sex, the natural assumption is also that people don't do that ..so you'd look for other explanations.

Though with the Allit case relatively recent ish ... I don't know why the thought wouldn't occur to some extent.

CurlewKate · 27/08/2023 12:09

I agree. I don't think it was about "most people don't murder babies" at least at the beginning. The first whistle blowers were questioning her competence, not her intent.

GilbertMarkham · 27/08/2023 12:08

Usually you can see some psychopathy/sociopathy in the eyes and expression of murderers, I find.

(Beverly Allit didn't look cold or dead eyed per se, but she still had a look of inanity/stupidity about her in her photos).

Saschka · 27/08/2023 12:08

AIstolemylunch · 27/08/2023 11:23

I disagree with you. I think she was able to continue for so long because most people don't murder babies and normal people woukdnt suspect anyone of doing that. It's only when the evidence became overwhelming that they realised. I think this would have been the same for a male or non white nurse or doctor.

Agree. Nobody could believe it of Shipman either, and he was male. It’s because it isn’t very common.

quantumbutterfly · 27/08/2023 12:08

Identity politics is divisive, I agree with pp that we want to trust medical professionals whatever their background.

The erosion of trust in institutions we previously respected (medicine, law enforcement, education) is a worrying development.

GilbertMarkham · 27/08/2023 12:06

The implication being she doesn’t look like a murderer who in our heads is more likely to be male and/or black.

I don't think she doesn't look like a murderer because she not a black femal, a black male or a white male.

I don't think she looks like a murderer because it's very hard to see any of the typical dead eye coldness or craziness in her face, that I associate with murderers.

The before arrest photos look "normal", warm even.

The arrest photos looks miserable and sad.

I think her culpability is highly highly likely, yet I still have problems reconciling that to her face & demeanour.

(Obviously haven't seen her talk etc though).

Walkingtheplank · 27/08/2023 12:06

Comedycook · 27/08/2023 12:01

I didn't say she got away with it because she's a white woman. And she didn't get away with it as she's now in prison. However, I absolutely am open to the idea that her race/sex/looks meant she went undetected for longer than she otherwise might have been

I obviously meant that she got away for it for so long, as per the OP.

Stella123456 · 27/08/2023 12:03

SirVixofVixHall · 27/08/2023 12:00

I agree with most of this but I also think that her youth and general demeanour meant that she looked kind and “nice” .
Sadly people assume that people who do monstrous , unbelievable things look like monsters. I think we all naturally hope that a twisted mind is visible in someone’s face and general behaviour, as then we feel safer. It seems impossible that a smiley, totally normal looking young woman could be a mass murderer.

This is true too. We want evil people to be markedly different. We want to see evil so we can avoid it.

GCAcademic · 27/08/2023 12:01

Just imagine, a male non white nurse was in the same position he would have been called out much much earlier

Not in the healthcare setting, and no need to imagine as it actually happened, but West Yorkshire police resisted investigating grooming gangs for a long time because the perpetrators weren’t white.

Stella123456 · 27/08/2023 12:01

AIstolemylunch · 27/08/2023 11:23

I disagree with you. I think she was able to continue for so long because most people don't murder babies and normal people woukdnt suspect anyone of doing that. It's only when the evidence became overwhelming that they realised. I think this would have been the same for a male or non white nurse or doctor.

I agree with this. I don’t think it’s a race issue or even a gender issue. I think it’s that most nurses do not kill babies. It’s inconceivable to any normal person. So the evidence had to really pile up before they took action.

Comedycook · 27/08/2023 12:01

Walkingtheplank · 27/08/2023 11:57

I think it is racist/misogynist to say that LL got away with it because she was a white women.
I absolutely understand bias, I just don't think it was a factor in this case.

And you being a white woman too doesn't mean you can't be racist/misogynist against white women. It's called internalisation e.g. my mum is very sexist against women, despite being a woman. I have a gay friend who is against same-sex marriage and puts it down to his own internalised homophobia. It happens.

I didn't say she got away with it because she's a white woman. And she didn't get away with it as she's now in prison. However, I absolutely am open to the idea that her race/sex/looks meant she went undetected for longer than she otherwise might have been

SirVixofVixHall · 27/08/2023 12:00

AIstolemylunch · 27/08/2023 11:23

I disagree with you. I think she was able to continue for so long because most people don't murder babies and normal people woukdnt suspect anyone of doing that. It's only when the evidence became overwhelming that they realised. I think this would have been the same for a male or non white nurse or doctor.

I agree with most of this but I also think that her youth and general demeanour meant that she looked kind and “nice” .
Sadly people assume that people who do monstrous , unbelievable things look like monsters. I think we all naturally hope that a twisted mind is visible in someone’s face and general behaviour, as then we feel safer. It seems impossible that a smiley, totally normal looking young woman could be a mass murderer.

Optionyougot · 27/08/2023 11:59

LordEmsworth · 27/08/2023 11:53

Ummm, literally anything?

OK so for an imaginary or hypothetical scenario, how about... a "male non-white" nurse at a hospital in - hmm let's say Stockport, just at random - who contaminates saline with insulin; some of which patients die. But they're elderly patients not babies. A white female nurse is arrested - but the incidents keep happening. I can imagine that.

Oh sorry - remember, not imagine. I can remember a case where a "male non-white" nurse didn't get "called out" until after at least 22 incidents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Stepping_Hill_Hospital_poisoning_incident

You can't evidence or cite an imaginary scenario for God's sake 😁it sounds like you meant to say "OP I disagree because in this other, similar case this happened".

But instead you asked for evidence of a hypothetical. Fleshing out a hypothetical scenario also is not a citation or evidence.

You need to use your words correctly in order to avoid coming across as passive aggressive and unable to make a clear point.

TantalisingCantaloupe · 27/08/2023 11:59

I had never even heard of the Victorino Chua case! Looking about for cases, it seems much more common than I would have ever expected, the deliberate harm/death by meducal professionals. I imagine they get away with it because we are conditioned to believe these are people who would only help. I am sure bias comes into play, but, personally, I think the biggest bias is simply towards the idea that medics help, not hurt. It is clearly not always true, but we always believe it is until we witness deliberate pain and cruelty by a doctor or nurse.

I would never have believed I'd watch a woman scream as an inch deep chunk of arm is removed by scalpel with no pain relief at all, while a doctor explains 'your a junkie, get used to hurting', before I saw and heard it myself. All caring professions have vindictive, evil monsters in their ranks, we just struggle to believe it until it's impossible to disbelieve.

Walkingtheplank · 27/08/2023 11:57

Comedycook · 27/08/2023 11:52

What did I say that was racist or misogynistic?

I'm a white woman by the way.

It's not my fault you don't understand the concept of inherent bias.

I think it is racist/misogynist to say that LL got away with it because she was a white women.
I absolutely understand bias, I just don't think it was a factor in this case.

And you being a white woman too doesn't mean you can't be racist/misogynist against white women. It's called internalisation e.g. my mum is very sexist against women, despite being a woman. I have a gay friend who is against same-sex marriage and puts it down to his own internalised homophobia. It happens.

RoomOfRequirement · 27/08/2023 11:57

If she were a WOC, absolutely. Ridiculous and awful but true. Mmm

Being how society respects men more, and how the NHS promotes male nurses at a highe rate, I imagine if she were male it would have gone on even longer.

Comedycook · 27/08/2023 11:54

*unconscious bias I should have added

NutellaEllaElla · 27/08/2023 11:53

Harold Shipman got away with murdering patients for longer

LordEmsworth · 27/08/2023 11:53

Optionyougot · 27/08/2023 11:33

The OP said "just imagine". What kind of citation would you expect for an imaginary/hypothetical scenario?

Ummm, literally anything?

OK so for an imaginary or hypothetical scenario, how about... a "male non-white" nurse at a hospital in - hmm let's say Stockport, just at random - who contaminates saline with insulin; some of which patients die. But they're elderly patients not babies. A white female nurse is arrested - but the incidents keep happening. I can imagine that.

Oh sorry - remember, not imagine. I can remember a case where a "male non-white" nurse didn't get "called out" until after at least 22 incidents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Stepping_Hill_Hospital_poisoning_incident

2011 Stepping Hill Hospital poisoning incident - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Stepping_Hill_Hospital_poisoning_incident

Comedycook · 27/08/2023 11:52

Walkingtheplank · 27/08/2023 11:51

I'm in full possession of a grip.
I also don't appreciate your racist-misogyny.

What did I say that was racist or misogynistic?

I'm a white woman by the way.

It's not my fault you don't understand the concept of inherent bias.

Swipe left for the next trending thread