Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think her her need for respect doesn’t trump mine?

243 replies

Tonightsthenight91 · 27/08/2023 10:11

Prefacing this by saying I know this isn’t the end of the world and it’s not a war but it’s just really getting on my tits if I’m honest.

I have a family member (let’s call her H) who is very very religious, married an equally religious man, and is raising equally religious kids. Fine, I respect that - our beliefs are different but that’s more than ok, I am actually deeply interested in other peoples religions and cultures and find it makes for interesting conversations 95% of the time.

however, I feel like my whole family feel like everyone should dance to her tune just because of her beliefs.

example: a family holiday has been proposed. H won’t be happy for me (an adult and a mother) to drink/get drunk, wear anything revealing such as a tie string bikini, swear, listen to non-secular music within her ear shot, watch your average TV with her in the room etc. and the rest of my family will expect me to tow the line “because I have to respect H”

H doesn’t respect or listen to my beliefs (which I don’t try and force on anyone or even bring up, it’s only if it comes up in conversation). Says my beliefs are witchcraft and a sin.

other examples are:

  • won’t come to family parties as she doesn’t want to be around alcohol
  • Has opinions on everyone’s clothing (her kids have been known in the past to say people should be ashamed for their short skirts)
  • censors photographs of teenagers in our family with emojis (e.g if they’re wearing a tight T-shirt she’ll put a big flower emoji over the chest area on her social media)
  • tells me she’ll pray for me and actively prays for me to “see the light” and open my heart. I don’t feel comfortable with this.
  • wont allow me to stay over with my partner as we’re not married but we’ve been together 12 years and have 2 kids (which is absolutely her right as it’s her home, but it kind of sets the undertone for other settings)
  • Thinks being gay is absolutely wrong and sinful and there’s no two ways about it. Despite us having gay people in the family whom she also prays for.
  • has very blatantly spoke about other religions in a less than acceptable way

Whilst I do respect her and her beliefs, AIBU to think she should let me be too? Why should I have to change how I behave just because her religion disapproves? Aside from religion, H as a person is funny, sporty, interesting and outgoing. I know none of what she says is through malice but I’m just feeling really irked at the thought of being censored on this holiday

OP posts:
Yoghurtpotsatdawn · 27/08/2023 11:55

A holiday is the one time you get to do what you want, when you want, how you want. As opposed to the rest of the year when you have to do things a certain way and be around people you wouldn’t choose to be around.

No way would I be going on holiday with H. Absolutely she can live how she wants but she shouldn’t be allowed to expect the rest of the family to be living up to her exacting standards. She would be better going away with a faith based group , so everyone is happy with the same rules. You can’t inflict that on family. It’s selfish and completely out of order.

WandaWonder · 27/08/2023 11:52

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 27/08/2023 11:28

I think we should all try and make allowances for each other but it’s not fair to just make allowances for one person/one family.

I would think the majority rules and it’s up to her to chose whether to join in or not.

It seems a shame to miss out on your family holiday so I would try and compromise somehow and perhaps book accommodation separate from them (or just do what you want and tell her to shut TF up when she starts judging you).

How is wearing revealing clothing, drinking, listening to non religious music erc. Actually got anything to need to make allowance for?

The op is not making the person do this but just wants to be able to do it themselves

ladeluge · 27/08/2023 11:51

I may be out of step with others, but despite having a loving and close family I would never go on holidays en masse with any of them! The feeling is mutual too. We all like different things and when you are at close quarters on a holiday you are not in your own environment and see and hear things about others (and yourself) that you would not ordinarily experience. It can lead to disagreements, and let's face it holidays are not cheap so I get the most out of my travels on my own terms.

So in your shoes I would not go on a family gathering holiday to save my life. Better off doing your own thing, and seeing family as you normally do (or don't!) at other times, when there is a sunset clause on the visit and you can escape!

Fundays12 · 27/08/2023 11:50

I wouldn't be going on holiday with her as it would be awful and I wouldn't allow my children around someone who is a bigot and homophobic either which she sounds like. She is entitled to her own religious views but she is not entitled to impose them in you and your family.

Cosmosforbreakfast · 27/08/2023 11:50

You can respect someone's beliefs without changing your own lifestyle for them. What she's doing is forcing her own beliefs on everyone else around her. She can dress demurely, avoid alcohol etc, no one else is obliged to pander to her self enforced rules at all. Ignore her and carry on as you are, if she doesn't like it tough and if anyone objects on her behalf tell them she is being disrespectful of your beliefs and trying to force her lifestyle down your throat.

JenWillsiam · 27/08/2023 11:49

Tonightsthenight91 · 27/08/2023 10:28

I agree, it is bigotry. We’ve clashed a couple of times about it over dinner when she’s sat saying how much she fears for our gay relative and how sad it is and how she will just continue to pray for his repentance or whatever it’s called

She is a bigot with deeply offensive views using religion as an excuse. She shouldn’t be anywhere near your children. Ever.

Saschka · 27/08/2023 11:49

I wouldn’t go - sounds like neither of you would enjoy the holiday. Tell you DM that H’s constant sniping and criticism are exhausting, and you want to go on holiday to enjoy yourself, not to be constantly told you are dressing like a slut.

FedUpMumof10YO · 27/08/2023 11:48

H is a fun sponge.

Hell no (like that ?!) would I be going.

PonyPatter44 · 27/08/2023 11:47

I would go, but I'm generally quite strong-minded and outspoken, so would not have a problem telling H to shut up from time to time.

sandalsinthebin · 27/08/2023 11:44

Aren't Christians supposed to be kind and tolerant?

user1471556818 · 27/08/2023 11:43

Save your holiday leave ,your sanity and don't waste either going on holiday with this person.Just say no

zingally · 27/08/2023 11:42

I'd stop pandering to her nonsense forthwith.

If it's mentioned, say "I thought Jesus taught us to love our neighbour?" Or "doesn't Jesus love a sinner?"
Or my own personal favourite, "It's important to sin a little bit, otherwise Jesus died for nothing."

I also have some extreme god-botherers in my extended family, so I feel your pain OP!
My mums sister married a god-botherer, became one herself, and so now their kids, and THEIR kids are god-botherers as well.

My mum goes to stay with her sister maybe once a year. They do things like say grace every meal, and my mum will "just sit there and smirk at them."
They are preachy in the extreme, but none of them bother to live out any of the christian values. They have umpteen holidays a year, that they like to brag about in their Christmas letter every year. They've never once given a single penny to charity, they do no volunteer work apart from "helping run their church" (which I hardly think counts).

Mirabai · 27/08/2023 11:41

You could go to separate villas and meet up? i wouldn’t even bother doing that.

CrackedChina · 27/08/2023 11:40

It's worrying that your family are so determined to 'respect' homophobia and misogyny. Those kind of views shouldn't be tolerated, even if someone is trying to disguise them as a religion.

Truemilk · 27/08/2023 11:39

I'd go and just do/wear what I wanted and enjoy myself.

If H's holiday is spoiled as result that's her own fault for trying too hard to control other people

Hibiscrubbed · 27/08/2023 11:39

Nah, fuck her. Respect goes both ways and she’s not bothering to respect anyone else.

CurlewKate · 27/08/2023 11:38

You absolutely don't have to "respect" her beliefs. You carry on with your life the way you want to.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 27/08/2023 11:35

So no drinking, dress demure at all times, no TV, no vulgar language. Sounds vaguely familiar, apostolic Christian by any chance?

You know that despite all the family and favourite location you won't enjoy it so don't go.

ElFupacabra · 27/08/2023 11:32

Go on the holiday but constantly be in a state of undress, with a cocktail in hand and playing heavy metal on your phone. It’ll ward her off like garlic and vampires from the sounds of it.

Seriously though, if she can’t respect your beliefs but expects you to respect hers there’s no happy holiday here. Don’t go, be very very straight as to why and then go low / no content. She sounds like a toxic person to have around anyway

LegalAdviceNeededPlease123 · 27/08/2023 11:32

Would your mum be upset at you not going on the holiday? If so, point out that it her lack of respect to you as much as your sister's (I'm guessing) which is making you make this decision. Your mother can pander to her as much as she likes but not to your detriment. Ask her why she is blatantly favouring your relation over you, and does she realise this could destroy your relationship (as happened to me)?

crumpet · 27/08/2023 11:30

Can you go but stay separately? Eg in another villa/another hotel? Meet up from time to time but otherwise each group can enjoy themselves as they wish?

Cheeesus · 27/08/2023 11:30

Gosh. It sounds like something extreme like Plymouth Brethren or Amish, with the objecting to (presume you mean) secular music.
Would it work for them to have a room to withdraw to if someone does something that offends, like (shock) putting the radio on.

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 27/08/2023 11:28

I think we should all try and make allowances for each other but it’s not fair to just make allowances for one person/one family.

I would think the majority rules and it’s up to her to chose whether to join in or not.

It seems a shame to miss out on your family holiday so I would try and compromise somehow and perhaps book accommodation separate from them (or just do what you want and tell her to shut TF up when she starts judging you).

WickedSerious · 27/08/2023 11:27

One of my uncles married a woman like H.Given a choice of cleaning toilets with my tongue or going on holiday with her I'd get licking.

FlamingoQueen · 27/08/2023 11:26

If you go, you’ll be posting on here about your controlling member and wishing you’d never gone!!
Some people just don’t have mutual respect and it sounds very much like she’ll be in charge.
Don't go!

Swipe left for the next trending thread