Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think her her need for respect doesn’t trump mine?

243 replies

Tonightsthenight91 · 27/08/2023 10:11

Prefacing this by saying I know this isn’t the end of the world and it’s not a war but it’s just really getting on my tits if I’m honest.

I have a family member (let’s call her H) who is very very religious, married an equally religious man, and is raising equally religious kids. Fine, I respect that - our beliefs are different but that’s more than ok, I am actually deeply interested in other peoples religions and cultures and find it makes for interesting conversations 95% of the time.

however, I feel like my whole family feel like everyone should dance to her tune just because of her beliefs.

example: a family holiday has been proposed. H won’t be happy for me (an adult and a mother) to drink/get drunk, wear anything revealing such as a tie string bikini, swear, listen to non-secular music within her ear shot, watch your average TV with her in the room etc. and the rest of my family will expect me to tow the line “because I have to respect H”

H doesn’t respect or listen to my beliefs (which I don’t try and force on anyone or even bring up, it’s only if it comes up in conversation). Says my beliefs are witchcraft and a sin.

other examples are:

  • won’t come to family parties as she doesn’t want to be around alcohol
  • Has opinions on everyone’s clothing (her kids have been known in the past to say people should be ashamed for their short skirts)
  • censors photographs of teenagers in our family with emojis (e.g if they’re wearing a tight T-shirt she’ll put a big flower emoji over the chest area on her social media)
  • tells me she’ll pray for me and actively prays for me to “see the light” and open my heart. I don’t feel comfortable with this.
  • wont allow me to stay over with my partner as we’re not married but we’ve been together 12 years and have 2 kids (which is absolutely her right as it’s her home, but it kind of sets the undertone for other settings)
  • Thinks being gay is absolutely wrong and sinful and there’s no two ways about it. Despite us having gay people in the family whom she also prays for.
  • has very blatantly spoke about other religions in a less than acceptable way

Whilst I do respect her and her beliefs, AIBU to think she should let me be too? Why should I have to change how I behave just because her religion disapproves? Aside from religion, H as a person is funny, sporty, interesting and outgoing. I know none of what she says is through malice but I’m just feeling really irked at the thought of being censored on this holiday

OP posts:
itspiefortea · 27/08/2023 12:36

"Do whatever floats your boat, as long as you don't sink mine"

She's totally sinking your boat 🫤 Not someone I'd want to spend time around - I'm fortunate that my strongly religious relative only brings it up when it fits the discussion, as you said you do. Much more comfortable for those around them.

pikkumyy77 · 27/08/2023 12:33

You can’t win, OP, because the entire family has cast you as the potential villain and her as the frail heroine. Just don’t go and be honest about it: Its no holiday to spend time with this aggressive bigot.

RandomMess · 27/08/2023 12:31

You could have daily memes about why Jesus said, there are some very funny and true FB groups out there.

He hated religion, called his followers just to look at him and love all others without criticism or judgement.

paulhollywoodshairgel · 27/08/2023 12:28

I can't stand people who hide hatred and bigotry behind religion. I'm a catholic and I believe in a god that loves all people. Don't go.. it won't end well and you'll have wasted money on a holiday that you'll hate!

LlynTegid · 27/08/2023 12:28

Respecting someone's views when you go to their house is something reasonable.

Very different to going on holiday with them and you should politely decline.

BrightGreenMoonBuggy · 27/08/2023 12:25

It’s a holiday for everyone, not an extended residential religious sermon with her at the pulpit. Take out the religious element and you are left with someone judgemental, intolerant, selfish, controlling and didactic. Really, the religion is just an excuse / justification for her to behave in these ways towards other people. Ask yourself if you want to go on holiday with someone who is going to control the music, clothes, television and language of other adults. Nope.

Duchessofspace · 27/08/2023 12:24

MrsDBaddiel · 27/08/2023 10:13

Sorry but she sounds like a complete bigot, I wouldn’t be pandering to her nonsense.

This she might be family but you can call her views out and her views do not trump yours. You don’t have to go on holiday with someone that body shamed, is homophobic, misogynist and is actively bullying anyone and you can be offended by someone praying for you and object to it too.

Perisoire · 27/08/2023 12:23

I’m pretty religious and conservative and I wouldn’t go.

For me religion is personal and private and I don’t want to impose it or be imposed on.

I can understand her not wanting to be around alcohol, I get so sick of colleagues who can only seem to talking about alcohol and their favourite watering holes. In our society, you are expected to take part in alcohol based activities or you are seem as a loser, wallflower etc.

But the answer isn’t to impose tee-totality on others, it’s to take yourself out of the equation.

RandomMess · 27/08/2023 12:20

Can you not let her know beforehand that you will be wearing what you want, drinking etc and if she can't keep he judgement to herself perhaps she shouldn't go?

I would also do a crash course in the bible and counter act what she says. It doesn't say anything much on homosexuality etc.

Tonightsthenight91 · 27/08/2023 12:20

I wish I’d have done a name change for this as there’s so many details I could give about the specific church (pretty certain that it’s not known as being extreme?) and more specific examples that I could give about particular beliefs/things that have been said but to be honest they’d likely get me banned for trolling they’re that incomprehensible!

with regards to fragility of religion and being the golden child. She’s definitely not that but there is a bit of a backstory with her past which would be incredibly outing so I’ll just say going to church was the making of her in my families eyes (which I do agree with to an extent)

OP posts:
ImABox · 27/08/2023 12:14

Fuck no would I go on holiday with her.

BustyDin · 27/08/2023 12:13

Cheeesus · 27/08/2023 11:30

Gosh. It sounds like something extreme like Plymouth Brethren or Amish, with the objecting to (presume you mean) secular music.
Would it work for them to have a room to withdraw to if someone does something that offends, like (shock) putting the radio on.

I was thinking Plymouth Brethren, and I wouldn't be going on holiday with anyone who belongs to that "faith".

pikkumyy77 · 27/08/2023 12:13

Is H “the golden child” who can do no wrong? Or is it that your mother thinks that there is some magical power to H religiosity as it has enabled her to clean up her act and become wealthier than other family members? Why do they treat her like her religious status is so fragile that she can’t handle the existence of other life choices? Is the problem that she will throw a strop or that she will get sad/whiny?

8misskitty8 · 27/08/2023 12:10

I wouldn’t go on the holiday. Holidays are for relaxing and you wouldn’t be able too.

I would also be very wary of letting your children spend time with these people, particularly girls.
The wanting woman to cover up, not drink or swear and basically toe the line are not people I would want to associate with.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 27/08/2023 12:09

My mum is the biggest drinker of us all and swears like a trooper! Understandably, it annoys me doubly that she has these opinions 😂

Next family gathering get your mum drunk and start singing drinking songs.

Don't go on the holiday.

hot2trotter · 27/08/2023 12:06

Why would you even consider going, stop pandering to her.

DrDaedalus · 27/08/2023 12:05

Respect one way is contempt.

Your choices are wider than go or not go. You could go and stay elsewhere. Why doesn't they stay somewhere else?

Cowlover89 · 27/08/2023 12:05

She sounds delightful.

electriclight · 27/08/2023 12:01

I would not let her stop me from going to a favourite place with the rest of my family.

If they can endure her, then so can I.

I would be willing to capitulate on some things - I wouldn't mind not swearing for example, and could bear to say Grace I suppose - but not on others.

I would drink wine, watch tv and wear what I usually wore but do it in such a way that she looked unreasonable for raising it.

HowToSaveAWife · 27/08/2023 12:00

If you have to demand respect, you won't get it.

Personally if I went I'd repeat "that's you're choice and this is my choice" ad nauseam.

But for an easy life I wouldn't go, I wouldn't mix with her and I wouldn't allow my children around her. You can have your beliefs and still have kindness and tolerance. H has neither and these extremely religious nuts wrap it up in faux concern, when it's disrespect and condenscion.

Tonightsthenight91 · 27/08/2023 12:00

Thanks for all the responses. I agree it is bigotry.

I suppose it’s a difficult dynamic because she’s the only one in the family to follow “religion”. So similarly in not wanting to offend minorities, everyone just says this is the life H lives and we all must respect that and not poke the bear for want of a better word.

Whilst I would undoubtedly continue my holiday as I would if they weren’t there, I know I’d get aggro from the rest of my family for doing so and be seen as being goady. Also, I don’t doubt she would remove herself and her children from the setting if I were for example to be drunk or swearing during the night (which is absolutely her right to as she can decide what she wants her children to be around). I just know for fact that I would then be getting told I’m ruining everyone’s holiday by making H have to leave and it’s upsetting everyone.

I am generally quite outspoken and a bit of a free-love kind of person. I understand how crass I’m portraying myself to be, I must sound like some drunken lout that shouts profanity over dinner but I promise that’s not the case 😂

I think I’ll just have to not go, which is a shame!

OP posts:
NatashaDancing · 27/08/2023 11:59

Holidaystress11 · 27/08/2023 11:56

Op we are a 'religious' family and I also wouldn't go with her. I couldn't give a flying lonkeys what other people did or wore and if my beliefs made others uncomfortable then I'm the problem. She can practice without judging and offending and stopping others. No religion I know if allows that type of behaviour. But people do do it! And it's not right. If anything she shouldn't be going on the holiday as it doesn't fit her lifestyle. I would find a nice holiday for you and your DP and explain why! Others might follow suit in your family and it might put a stop to her behaviour

You sound lovely and clearly understand what "respect" means.

ActDottie · 27/08/2023 11:57

She sounds very narrow minded and personally I just wouldn’t be going on holiday with her

NatashaDancing · 27/08/2023 11:57

tensmum1964 · 27/08/2023 11:26

You can respect her right to practice her religion but you don't have to respect the religion itself. Nor do you have to respect the way she imposes her values on others. Why do people think they have a right to respect, it's not a given. Personally I would respectively say, thank you but no thank you. I don't want to spend my time being restricted and curtailed on my holiday. I hope you all have a lovely time but I would rather go on an alternative holiday.
If they criticise you in any way just simply say, please respect my decision as you do hers.

I don't think any one should have a right to demand respect for their religious beliefs. In the UK there is a right to be able to hold , and provided it doesn't contravene, secular criminal law, to practice your religion.

If "respect" means the latter , fine. If it means no one is allowed to criticise your beliefs, not fine.

Holidaystress11 · 27/08/2023 11:56

Op we are a 'religious' family and I also wouldn't go with her. I couldn't give a flying lonkeys what other people did or wore and if my beliefs made others uncomfortable then I'm the problem. She can practice without judging and offending and stopping others. No religion I know if allows that type of behaviour. But people do do it! And it's not right. If anything she shouldn't be going on the holiday as it doesn't fit her lifestyle. I would find a nice holiday for you and your DP and explain why! Others might follow suit in your family and it might put a stop to her behaviour