Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: Elderly parents do not care about their impact on the environment

481 replies

Scientistathome · 27/08/2023 08:07

My elderly parents acknowledge (in passing) that the human impact on the planet is destructive and that their family's future could be jeopardized.
However, they refuse to do anything about it. They burn gas and electricity in summer to keep warm (extra jumper? Nooo!), Will not Install solar panels (they can afford it), take unnecessary flights, ... the list goes on.
They flaty refuse to change any habits despite that they know they should and could.
I get quite mad with them!
AIBU?
I know it is their choice, not mine but it affects all of us (their grandchildren are quite disgusted with them).
Are other people's parents like this?
(I know that some parents cannot afford eco-friendly choices like solar panels)

OP posts:
Justcallmebebes · 27/08/2023 11:20

Nanny0gg · 27/08/2023 09:48

It does NOT have excellent public transport if you live rurally

Many villages have no bus service at all, not even one day a week.

This!! I don't know where you live to have "excellent public transport". There's zero public transport to the city I work in. Our buses run until 7pm and there's none on a Sunday or Bank Holiday and it's unreliable

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 11:20

As an aside there’s a special place in hell for parents who raise their kids as Eco Twats. As in, they tell them their special little cause trumps the feelings of humans. There’s a girl in DD’s class (whose hippy parents support JSO) who stages protests at lunch time about not cutting down trees (who the fuck is she protesting to?! They haven’t felled a bloody tree at the school for years). On a few occasions she sat in tress and refused to move and encourages other kids to do it too. Very disruptive for the other kids and one day the class missed swimming because by the time they got the ‘eco warriors’ out the trees it was too late to set off. Parents support darling little eco warrior’s cause of course. And then the same child badgered the Head to impose a ‘no meat Monday’s’ at the school. And eventually succeeded - despite the fact that some parents told the head their fussy eater wouldn’t eat a thing of meat wasn’t available, and it would affect others with allergies too. But no, Precious had to have her no meat Mondays. She’s not a vegan BTW she’s a vegetarian because being a vegan is ‘too hard’ 🙄 so it’s alright for her fussiness to be pandered to but not other children.

No meat Mondays lasted 2 weeks BTW because of the wasted food

Kendodd · 27/08/2023 11:20

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 11:05

Personally, I expect less from younger generations as they have less money to pay for lifestyle changes

Skint people are the perfect people to make changes!

  • Public transport is cheaper than a car
  • UK holidays rather than foreign
  • Less to spend on bills
So this comment doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t cost money to be eco-friendly. In fact, at my local independent school some people drive 40 miles round to drop off their 4 kids in their MASSIVE cars and I’d say the onus is more on THEM to do better

Disagree with two of your three points.

I would argue that using public transport is more expensive than having a car (it certainly would be for me).
And, that holidays in the UK are not cheaper than going abroad.

The environmentally friendly option should be cheaper but very often its both more effort and more cost, in the immediate terms at least. Longer term, climate change is going to cost us an absolute fortune.

CoffeeWithCheese · 27/08/2023 11:19

My mum didn't learn to drive until she was nearly 50 (and she had to because she had a chronically ill child and my father buggered off). She's as low waste as you can get in terms of food.

I wish she'd put the heating on more - she sat freezing under blankets last winter because the media had scared her so much about utility bills; and I don't begrudge her going off on holidays a lot one iota because I'm just glad she's having some joy in her life to improve her mental health and stop her sitting in the house, cold and in pain.

And I don't want fucking solar panels either - they're ugly as shit, I don't think we fully calculate the environmental cost of their production and if you started preaching at me like you have on here - I'd be telling you to fuck off.

SoosanCarter · 27/08/2023 11:17

Occasionalsnaccident · 27/08/2023 10:47

If it helps, consider that their destructive impact on the environment will have scaled up very gradually, so their lifetime impact will still be lower than most moderately careful people you know!

Most sensible post in this thread

WibblyWobblyTimeyWimeyStuff · 27/08/2023 11:17

TGGreen · 27/08/2023 10:55

I'd put money on that your lifelong carbon footprint is greater than theirs. They had children when no one knew bugger all. What's your excuse?

I would put money on the OP and her children already having a much bigger carbon footprint than her elderly parents have ever had, or will ever have. As a number of people have said, including me - the parents would have come from a generation where they recycle bottles, they didn't have any plastic packaging, they bought fresh food, meat, veg, eggs, and fruit etc from the local shop or farm, and they reused everything til it fell apart. Which would have been several decades in those days. I still wear a cardigan I bought in 1988!

Many of our elderly relatives would have cycled and walked everywhere and probably got public transport if it was too far to walk or cycle, and they had VERY little electric gadgets. Just a TV and a hi fi... or a radio. And an iron and washing machine/twin tub that they only used a couple of times a week. Oh and a fridge and possibly a freezer. Possibly 7 electrical items!

No mobile phones, MP3 players/ipods, DVD players, Alexa, blu-ray players, sound bars, electric alarm clocks, fancy coffee machines, microwaves, toasters, tumble dryers, laptops, playstations, X-boxes, snack sandwich makers, desktop computers, electric kettles, cable TV/satellite TV boxes, internet modems, fans, and multiple Televisions (4 or 5 in some homes!) And thing like dehumidifiers, and white noise machines, and something 'on charge' half of the daylight hours! This is all in addition to the 7 items I mentioned! Some 20-odd EXTRA items that most of our elderly relatives would not have had!

Also, they didn't have any central heating. I remember the days of frost patterns on the inside of the windows as well as we didn't have any central heating. My parents and grandparents were very, very frugal. We didn't have even have a landline or a car until the early 1970s. Dad's job was 10 minutes walk away, mom didn't work - she was a SAHM...

My mom and my grandmother couldn't even drive - and neither could my aunties - all born before the mid 1940s. We had hardly any cars in the family and most people walked/cycled to work. The older generation born before 1950 have got an almost non-existent carbon footprint ... As has been pointed out people born 1980s and 1990s and after have probably already got a much bigger carbon footprint than the older people have ever had or WILL have and yet the older generation (75+) are constantly attacked. So nasty!

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 27/08/2023 11:16

When you are old let’s see how you like being cold to the bone. It’s not like me and you being cold. It’s painful and deeply uncomfortable, can lead to health issues and a jumper won’t cut it

When I bought my flat it didn't have central heating and that first winter was miserable despite having heaters. And I was in my 30s. Now in my late 60s and have no intention of being cold in winter ever again.

EveSix · 27/08/2023 11:14

Nala, you are conflating 'what we do on an individual level' with the presumption of being the only one doing, or ceasing to do, a particular thing. If many people in the UK decided to halve the number of flights they take, of course there would be a reduction in flights departing. "The planes will take off anyway, whether I'm on it or not," is one of the saddest misconceptions frequently raised in this conversation.
As an individual you do have power: with your consumer choices, whether to engage in different kinds of activism, from signing petitions and writing letters, through to financially supporting the work of organisations or participating in organised mass civil disobedience, and by keeping the conversation current.

WongWifi · 27/08/2023 11:14

Bloody well leave them alone! You sound like a nightmare How dare you show this amount of disrespect to your own parents. Oh, and grow up!

Wafflesandcrepes · 27/08/2023 11:12

My parents are the opposite. Never been on a plane, always lived in town so walked to work, only bought very few clothes, very careful with their water consumption etc….

Emeraldrings · 27/08/2023 11:08

So if your parents get solar panels, turn off the heating and don't fly the world will be saved?
They are elderly, if you can't relax and not worry too much after retirement age then when can you? They aren't going to be around to see what happens anyway.
Make your kids eco friendly and maybe teach them to be nice to their grandparents too. They won't live forever.

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 11:08

OP describes himself as ‘someone with a Y chromosome’ rather than just saying ‘man’ so I’m not sure we should be taking the advice of someone so dense

Berlinlover · 27/08/2023 11:08

I’m 47 and similar to your parents. What on earth is an unnecessary flight?

Mammyloveswine · 27/08/2023 11:06

IAmAnIdiot123 · 27/08/2023 08:42

DS has had same phone for many years!

We thank him for his sacrifice.

GrinGrinGrin

Prelapsarianhag · 27/08/2023 11:06

Blaming and shaming will not change anything.

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 11:05

Personally, I expect less from younger generations as they have less money to pay for lifestyle changes

Skint people are the perfect people to make changes!

  • Public transport is cheaper than a car
  • UK holidays rather than foreign
  • Less to spend on bills
So this comment doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t cost money to be eco-friendly. In fact, at my local independent school some people drive 40 miles round to drop off their 4 kids in their MASSIVE cars and I’d say the onus is more on THEM to do better
meemawwww · 27/08/2023 11:05

meemawwww · 27/08/2023 11:00

My DD has a scar on her face from a minpin that was our own pet. He wasn't mistreated or badly trained. If the dog is that badly behaved the owner needs to be held accountable. Ring the dog warden

Oops wrong thread 🤣

Oblomov23 · 27/08/2023 11:04

Your expectations are totally unreasonable. What exactly other than solar panels are you expecting them to do. Specifically? I put rubbish in black bin. Recycling in blue. I expect it all gets shipped to landfill and 2/3 sent to some poor country Turkey and Sri Lanka etc. disgusting. And they had s world conference up in Scotland 2 years ago which achieved practically nothing? Yet you are very scornful of parents?

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 11:02

Your children is disgusted with their grandchildren? Well, I'm a little disgusted that you managed to raise children who are so ill-informed about the process of getting older

This in spates!! I’d rather be raising kind sweet children than little obnoxious nasties who think they’re better than the elderly

Cotswoldbee · 27/08/2023 11:00

Scientistathome · 27/08/2023 08:36

Thanks everyone for your messages; on average, it seems that I am living in an 'eco-bubble' and not in step with Mumsnet users. And I am being unreasonable!

For the record, we did install solar panels, we try to reduce footprint (lower thermostat, less plastic use, take public transport, only 1 car, etc)

Personally, I expect less from younger generations as they have less money to pay for lifestyle changes (DS has had same phone for many years!). I feel that the burden of change should fall on older generations (including myself) as they often have more resources with which to do it.

Some have asked.
Do you or have you flown on holiday?

meemawwww · 27/08/2023 11:00

My DD has a scar on her face from a minpin that was our own pet. He wasn't mistreated or badly trained. If the dog is that badly behaved the owner needs to be held accountable. Ring the dog warden

WestwardHo1 · 27/08/2023 10:59

Scientistathome · 27/08/2023 08:07

My elderly parents acknowledge (in passing) that the human impact on the planet is destructive and that their family's future could be jeopardized.
However, they refuse to do anything about it. They burn gas and electricity in summer to keep warm (extra jumper? Nooo!), Will not Install solar panels (they can afford it), take unnecessary flights, ... the list goes on.
They flaty refuse to change any habits despite that they know they should and could.
I get quite mad with them!
AIBU?
I know it is their choice, not mine but it affects all of us (their grandchildren are quite disgusted with them).
Are other people's parents like this?
(I know that some parents cannot afford eco-friendly choices like solar panels)

In my experience a huge number of older people are like this. They say they love their grandchildren, but in practice just don't give a shit

JohnnyYenSetHimselfOnFireAgain · 27/08/2023 10:59

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 27/08/2023 10:00

On MN? over 50.

😂😂

WeetabixTowels · 27/08/2023 10:59

You’re angry at the wrong people.

When you are old let’s see how you like being cold to the bone. It’s not like me and you being cold. It’s painful and deeply uncomfortable, can lead to health issues and a jumper won’t cut it.

Leave them alone and target the big corps that are actually making a difference to the planet being destroyed.

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 27/08/2023 10:58

OP, you are expecting too much from your parents. Let me explain.

Some years ago I decided to go back to school to get my IGCSEs (I'm currently at university.) In school I was subjected to massive information about climate change from some splendid teachers, not only info but reasons why it happened. I hadn't had that kind of education when I first studied, and it changed my mindset, not only on climate change but also on environmental refugees. In the media all I read until then was one side (woke) screaming at people about the environment, and another side (right-leaning) screaming about being woke. That didn't exactly inspire me to recycle or put up solar panels, and your parents get the same limited information from the media or from you.

Your children and you have the same vast knowledge due to schooling, so it's easy to forget that not "everyone knows this." Your parents haven't been taught about climate changes by professionals. When you, a daughter who doesn't sound very kind, try to explain it to your parents, you preach and give them the impression that you find them selfish or egotistical, and that is not the way to inspire anyone. Please stop expecting your parents to act like you or your children and instead be supportive. Please stop demanding they change.

Your children is disgusted with their grandchildren? Well, I'm a little disgusted that you managed to raise children who are so ill-informed about the process of getting older. How confusing it is to see the world change around you, and how cruel it is to experience your body and mind decaying. The older you get, the less stress you can handle and being met with scorn/disapproval from someone you love and trust is extremely hurtful. Being told to change by someone who is disgusted with you? Yes, I wonder why your parents aren't willing to change.