Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Marriage

103 replies

Mrsmcgeeh · 27/08/2023 05:16

I was single for a long time before meeting my partner. I have two DC and he has one. I currently earn 2.5 times his salary, and own my own home which I've reno'd split into two self contained flats and am renting out. I want my children to inherit this.

I also jointly own a rental property with my siblings. Myself and the children live with my grandmother who has dementia, so a familiar face (me) while she remembers us is with her all the time. She always told us not to put her in a nursing home and we promised. the children go to schools nearby and I work from home to stay with her, and she has carers through the week but not one full time, and sometimes she gets agitated because she doesn't recognise who they are. She is mortgage free, I pay bills.

My partner is renting a flat with his best friend and pays a lot with his ex for childcare for their under 5. I don't pay any childcare as my eldest is a teen and babysits my youngest should I need or my wider family help to care for my children as I am caring for our grandmother. I have savings, no debt except uni student loan. He has credit card debt.

Anyway my partner would like us to get married and move in together. He also wants another baby so we have one together. I'm not so sure. I do love him very much but not sure if it's practical financially to get married? Or am I being too harsh. He says I'm being too feircely independent. I'd love a wedding just the party but not the legal side. Is that a thing?!

OP posts:
Peony654 · 27/08/2023 07:56

I wouldn’t get married in your situation. And I’d really seriously consider whether another baby is right, especially if he’s struggling to provide child support for his other child. It doesn’t make your relationship less valid if you don’t have a child together. Focus on your existing children, and see how the relationship goes but no rush.

user1492757084 · 27/08/2023 07:54

Three questions ...
Are you happy with the arrangement as it stands now?
Do you want to marry or move in with a partner again?
Do you want another baby?

If you would prefer no live in partner and no baby then you need to break up with this man as he is looking for a wife and child.

If you want a live in partner, is this the man you want to live with - he wants a baby?

Would this man live with you without a baby?
Would he easily fit into your home with granny? He could live in part time and not change the arrangements he has in place for his 4 year old child.

MrsJamin · 27/08/2023 07:53

I think if you're using financial reasons not to marry then you can't really be ready to share your whole life with him, which is what marriage is. Your gut is saying "no"?

Rainbowqueeen · 27/08/2023 07:51

My view is that when you have DC still living at home then their needs come first. How would they feel about you having another baby and having your partner move in?

I would be focusing on that first. Your post is all about what he wants. Not even what you want. Just him

CoffeeCoffeeCoffeeMaybeATea · 27/08/2023 07:47

Also he wasn't fussy about being religious and 'doing it right this time round' when he wanted to move in with you in the early days.

sounds more like, he's throwing the marriage in there now to help sway you, so he can move in.

Thequeenofthetypis · 27/08/2023 07:41

User10932 · 27/08/2023 06:43

Call his bluff - explain you will be happy to do all those things, but it will mean you leaving your job to be a sahp and carer for your grandmother. He will have to financially support all of his brand new family - you, the kids, the new baby. See if he’s still as excited about it then 🤔. If he is, then you know it’s the real deal, just seek legal advice on your will first!

This is an excellent idea!
At the moment he is happy for you to do all the heavy lifting in theory. See how appealing it is to him when he has to financially support everyone.
Btw, he previously suggested moving in together ( he moving in with you?)
How early in the relationship was that suggested?
Is he very eager to get out of his flat share?

RantyAnty · 27/08/2023 07:32

Of course he wants to get married.
He's basically a grown man living like a student, no ambition, no savings, no property, and a pile of debt.

Does he have vices?

UndercoverCop · 27/08/2023 07:26

I am the higher earner always have been, I'm married.

However I think it's different for both sexes when we're talking about marriage later in life or second marriages where people already have lots of financial and other responsibilities. I chose to throw my assets into the pot and if all had gone wrong the only person to lose would've been me (DH had a job and no debt, but didn't own property). We'd also already lived together for several years and didn't have a family to blend. You haven't lived together and blending children can be very difficult. Even with all the best will in the world. You also have additional care responsibilities on top.

Now I have to put DS first, so if something happened to DH I don't think I'd marry again.

Sunflowergirl1 · 27/08/2023 07:20

Brown888 · 27/08/2023 05:31

Wow. Your partner definitely has more to gain financially from the marriage. If you do get married then I would recommend a water tight legal protection for your assets - maybe you could put it into a trust for your children?

No such thing as watertight. As for him wanting to get married..well I bet he does

SunRainStorm · 27/08/2023 07:18

Just saw he wants marriage because he's religious.

But has no issue with pre marital sex with you, and even having a child out of wedlock with his previous partner. So he wasn't in a rush to marry this other woman who has trouble paying childcare fees? Even though she was pregnant. But he's keen to marry you, a woman who owns three properties.

It sounds like he's picking and choosing his beliefs when it suits him.

notlucreziaborgia · 27/08/2023 07:16

No. You and your children have far too much to lose.

*and I would and have said that about men in the same position too.

Autieangel · 27/08/2023 07:16

You have a great set up and a lot to lose if you get married. You could do a pre nup to protect yourself but personally I'd be wary of legally tying myself to a man who isn't financially stable.

Then there's the living situation presumably you can't move him in to your grandmothers so you would have to make alternate arrangements for her. Which would be massively disruptive for her.

Do you want another baby? It sounds like it would mainly be you providing for it how would you feel about that?

I can see why he would want to change his living arrangements but not sure why you would want to change yours?

SunRainStorm · 27/08/2023 07:14

ZekeZeke · 27/08/2023 05:42

He says I'm being too feircely independent
that really struck a chord. How dare he!

What the fuck is wrong with being independent?

Are you sure he is right for you? The right man would respect that you have a full and self sufficient life.

And I agree, all very well offering babies when he is unlikely to pay much towards it. He should focus on clearing his debt and supporting the child he has.

Date him, have a commitment ceremony if you want a party, but you would be mad to compromise everything you've built by marrying him.

I wonder if he'd be rushing the alter if the shoe was on the other foot.

Cakecakecheese · 27/08/2023 07:04

Alwaysdecorating · 27/08/2023 06:46

Then I suspect she isn’t a high earner OR has a lot in assets.

You really need to ask the question, why didn’t he marry her. But now is saying it’s important he has a wife, now he is with someone who would make his life financially easier…….even though it would make that potential wife’s life harder.

This. It's a tad suspicious that he didn't marry his ex but suddenly wants to marry someone with assets and a good wage. Plus the 'fiercely independent ' thing feels like a red flag, if you were to get married would he expect you to be less independent and hand over all financial decision making to him? There was a thread on here recently where the wife was the breadwinner and the husband took it upon himself to fire the cleaner without consultation her leaving her with more on top of a already heavy load.

Curseofthenation · 27/08/2023 07:04

I only recommend that a woman should get married if she wants children with the man and it would protect her financially (as women are often the ones to go part-time etc). You obviously would not benefit in this situation. He can't be that religious if he's had a child out of wedlock. I'd leave the relationship before marrying him.

Dashel · 27/08/2023 07:00

For me the baby issue would be the hardest to resolve as there is no compromise. You either have a joint child or don’t and you don’t exactly sound keen. You need to talk through that and if he is desperate for a child and you aren’t then there is no point worrying about the money.

Assuming you do agree on that, I would see a solicitor for advice on the financial side. As others have said you could put the flats into a trust or find other ideas but if you are planning on staying with your DGM and don’t want a baby (and that’s perfectly ok, I don’t think I would want to start again if I had a teenager)

It also sounds like he is the one driving this relationship and whilst I can see his suggestions are in his best interests, I’m not sure they are in yours so make sure you take things at your speed and put yourself and your DC first

rand0mstuff · 27/08/2023 06:54

Leaving the points others have already raised aside, as a very first step, I would want to move together. Without living together for a good amount of time, I wouldn't consider marriage in any case.

tuvamoodyson · 27/08/2023 06:52

Aprilx · 27/08/2023 06:13

No I have seen it hundreds of times. It is always the same. Women better off, don’t get married, man better off, you must get married.

Exactly. Women being advised to get married because ‘that way your entitled to half’

Devonshirelass · 27/08/2023 06:51

Aprilx · 27/08/2023 06:05

I don’t really like the double standards on mumsnet with regard to you must get married for financial security but as soon as the women is in a better position, it is definitely don’t get married. But that said, it doesn’t sound like you want to get married, or have a baby, so don’t!

But no, you can’t have a “wedding party” and not bother with the actual wedding. That is not a thing

Of course you can! You can have your own commitment ceremony/ party but not get legally married.

I would not get married OP or have a baby.

As others said, you have nothing to gain and a lot to lose.

You have made the decisions you have for very sensible reasons and have built the financial security you wanted for yourself and your children. It is obvious this is important to you . These are clearly your core values. Don’t let him let him emotionally pressure you into undermining your own values and throwing all that security away.

CoffeeCoffeeCoffeeMaybeATea · 27/08/2023 06:49

Mrsmcgeeh · 27/08/2023 06:30

Thank you all, I'm going to raise with him the things raised here and think about a commitment ceremony. I'm not sure what his ex's financial situation is except that they find childcare fees a real strain on the two of them.

how much childcare is it costing? because if you've been with him for 3 years the dc are definitely over 3 more like 4 - 5 up? (or did he leave in the first year? and move straight on to you)

So if 4 + should be in school so looking at wrap around care which is significantly less then full time private nursery fees.

Alwaysdecorating · 27/08/2023 06:46

Mrsmcgeeh · 27/08/2023 06:30

Thank you all, I'm going to raise with him the things raised here and think about a commitment ceremony. I'm not sure what his ex's financial situation is except that they find childcare fees a real strain on the two of them.

Then I suspect she isn’t a high earner OR has a lot in assets.

You really need to ask the question, why didn’t he marry her. But now is saying it’s important he has a wife, now he is with someone who would make his life financially easier…….even though it would make that potential wife’s life harder.

ZekeZeke · 27/08/2023 06:44

Again OP what exactly will YOU gain by marrying this man?

User10932 · 27/08/2023 06:43

Call his bluff - explain you will be happy to do all those things, but it will mean you leaving your job to be a sahp and carer for your grandmother. He will have to financially support all of his brand new family - you, the kids, the new baby. See if he’s still as excited about it then 🤔. If he is, then you know it’s the real deal, just seek legal advice on your will first!

HungryandIknowit · 27/08/2023 06:37

I wouldn't. If you really want to I would wait, then live with him for 5 years +, then consider it. I'd also look at what legal steps I could take (pre-nup, wills etc.) to protect my assets, knowing some of these may be of limited effect. I also wouldn't appreciate being told that I'm too fiercely independent. Seems patronising and paternalistic imo.

Sally2791 · 27/08/2023 06:33

Marriage is a legal contract. Sounds like a bad idea for you and yours, and all to gain for him. I wouldn’t touch it with a barge pole.