Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Threenow · 27/08/2023 20:52

MadeleineMummy · 27/08/2023 09:54

Because of vested interests and to give the semblance of democracy to the great unwashed.

Crazy. We ditched it here in NZ years ago, after a referendum to find what the public wanted.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 20:17

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 20:06

Perhaps all earned income, from the first pound, should be subject to tax.

Firstly no political party would ever get elected with such a policy and secondly even if it did exist then any Government wanting to increase spending through higher taxes would always want to levy those increases just on the wealthy and not proportionally across everyone.

FarEast · 27/08/2023 20:11

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

Well, John Stuart Mill argued in On Representative Government that one way of ensuring that liberal democracy was based on the votes of thoughtful rational people, was that university professors and judges and people in similar occupations should have 5 votes each, and the rest of the voting population should have votes apportioned on a a sliding scale according to education & profession, down to one vote for ordinary working people.

As I'm sure you know, from your extensive reading of political theory, Mill wasn't actually serious about this, however, but he wrote and thought a lot about the problem of British representative democracy was that an ignorant and careless person had the same voting power as a highly educated thinking person.

I'd get 5 votes, and going by the quality of your thought and writing in your OP@Thebestwaytoscareatory I'd say you're in the category of having only one vote.

Not so nice, is it?

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 20:06

Perhaps all earned income, from the first pound, should be subject to tax.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 19:57

As you say, not perfect, but probably not worse.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 19:56

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 19:26

Incorrect as a representative democracy is actually indirect

As far as I am concerned, we lost the right to be called "representative" when our craven parliament decided to abrogate it's role and give in to the mob.

And we won't be representative again until that is reversed.

And how exactly did "our craven parliament decided to abrogate it's role and give in to the mob"? 🤔

sequin2000 · 27/08/2023 19:49

The problem is that people generally vote for themselves, not for the whole of society and those in charge don't think beyond the term of office. I'd vote for a change to demarchy. Not perfect but could ensure long term strategies and less self interest participedia.net/method/194

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 19:47

@asterdaisy

"I assume you know we all pay a certain amount of tax. So what you really mean is poor people should not vote."

++++

But there has to be a balance, the 1% of wealthiest incomes pay 30% of all income tax whereas 48% pay no income tax because they don't earn enough.

When you are in the poorest 48% it is logical to vote for higher Government spending and higher taxes because the higher taxation won't impact you but you do benefit from higher Government spending on services.

Barbadossunset · 27/08/2023 19:44

So I like the poster who suggested that you have to sit a test, like passing your driving test, before being able to vote.

This was also suggested after Brexit and I think there’d rightly be uproar if it was suggested.

Anyway how would it work?
Would there be vast examination halls with invigilators with queues outside like for covid jabs?
Would the topics of the questions be known in advance so candidates could revise or would they have no idea what was coming so only those that really knew their stuff would pass?
What about for those who spoke poor or no English? Would tests be allowed in the language of their choice?
How many questions and what would the pass mark be?

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 19:41

Taxation explained in beer

Once a week, ten men go out for beer and the bill for all ten comes to £100.
If they paid their bill the way we pay our taxes, the first four men (the poorest) would pay nothing, the fifth would pay £1, the sixth would pay £3, the seventh would pay £7, the eighth would pay £12, the ninth would pay £18 and the tenth man (the richest) would pay £59
he group still wanted to pay their bill the way we pay our taxes. So the first four men were unaffected.
But how could they divide the £20 windfall so that everyone would get his fair share?
They realised £20 divided by six is £3.33 but if they subtracted that from everybody’s share then not only would the first four men still be drinking for free but the fifth and sixth man would each end up being paid to drink his beer.
But, once outside the bar, the men began to compare their savings. ‘I only got £1 out of the £20 saving,’ declared the sixth man. He pointed to the tenth man: ‘but he got £10.’
‘Yes, that’s right,” exclaimed the fifth man. ‘I only saved £1 too. It’s unfair that he got ten times more benefit than me.’
‘That’s true” shouted the seventh man. ‘Why should he get £10 back when I only got £2? The wealthy get all the breaks
‘Wait a minute,’ yelled the first four men in unison, ‘we didn’t get anything at all. This new tax system exploits the poor.’
The nine men surrounded the tenth and beat him up.
The next week the tenth man didn’t show up for drinks, so the nine sat down and had their beers without him but did not have enough money between all of them to pay for even half of the bill.
So Tax them too much, attack them for being wealthy and they just might not show up anymore.’

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 19:26

Incorrect as a representative democracy is actually indirect

As far as I am concerned, we lost the right to be called "representative" when our craven parliament decided to abrogate it's role and give in to the mob.

And we won't be representative again until that is reversed.

CauliflowerBalti · 27/08/2023 19:25

I don’t think democracy itself is the problem. It’s education and manipulation. So I like the poster who suggested that you have to sit a test, like passing your driving test, before being able to vote. They made a good point there. We don’t let people out on the road without the skills they need - it would cause chaos. Similar chaos ensues when uneducated voters, vote - and I mean, uneducated in politics and how government works, not anything more.

Second, if I were queen I’d make newspapers declare their political allegiances and print it at the beginning of every article. A free press is important. So is understanding the bias you are being exposed to.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 19:22

That's a brave mea culpa @Thebestwaytoscareatory . And a graceful one too.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 19:17

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 16:11

I’m surprised someone who is on the left is proposing it. It’s such a terrible idea

So nurses, plumbers, artists, social workers etc no say..

What a crazy aim. At least 86% say yabu

I do see why the majority think IABU. This is just something I've thought about on and off for a number of years and was reignited as I was rewatching Once Upon a Time in Iraq (Waleed Nesyif talks about how life was better under Saddam Hussain than it is now and it got me thinking about whether democracy is all that it's cracked up to be).

I also think that because I've spent a lot of time and energy in trying to engage with politics only to see everything going to shit with no apparent way of stopping it I'm just frustrated and disillusioned with democracy in general.

And in that frustration I laid the blame at the feet of voters for their apathy and unwillingness to see "the truth" or at least my truth anyway. But as I said, there's been plenty of good posts that show why that is unreasonable of me and that the fault isn't with democracy itself, rather in the people we elect to enact it.

Not really sure how that changes either, suppose I'll have to look at joining some campaigns that look to make politicians accountable.

OP posts:
EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 19:16

It works in countries with rural depopulation basically. There are huge areas of France and Spain (only chosen because those are the countries I know) where young people flee to cities to earn enough to have a family. I think Italy is fairly similar though.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 19:11

@StefanosHill , non lucrative visa programmes are for migrants who have provable income streams that do not require you to seek work from the local economy. You cannot work in the country where you live. In most of the EU it means roughly that a couple need to prove income of 55k pa in euros and ability to pay health insurance. Ours is derived from the rent on commercial properties, state pensions and a tiny occupational pension. Most of the EU countries have them, because they don't want to force out people who want to restore property in regions where there are no jobs. But they are happy for people to breathe life into those areas because it is much cheaper than government funding. If it works, then new incomers arrive and the economic advantage snowballs.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 18:47

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 18:32

There has to be a balance @StefanosHill . Otherwise the needy would vote en masse for more money and benefits, and anyone with money would scarper, removing the assets and income available to tax. I am already quite close to leaving for a/any country that has a non-lucrative visa programme. We earned every last penny we have, no inflation linked government pension and until May 2023, no inheritance, which wasn't a lifechanging amount. Taxes due all paid and in order. The people in situations like ours with options to choose thought about these questions 30 or 40 years ago, and saved what they could at the time.

That is an issue and not a road I want to go down, and it does concern me generally after next GE

But I’d still not take votes off people

I mean you can’t, it’s fundamental regardless of income or education

What’s a ‘non- lucrative’ visa programme btw?

Grantanow · 27/08/2023 18:44

I think democracy is the least worse option especially when set against Nazism, Fascism and Communism, not to mention some awful dictatorships around the world now. But the structure of democracy may need thinking about. Ancient Athens from where we mostly got the idea was a direct democracy where all citizens (excluding women, helots and foreigners) voted on all issues: there was no intermediate Parliament. It seemed to work for them but they executed Socrates. Our system is one in which we elect representatives to do our thinking and legislating for us but it is distorted by party political loyalty and subject to an unelected Lords. Moreover, a Party with a good working majority is unassailable even if incompetent until the next General Election. On the other hand, a system like the USA where the two Houses of Congress, President and Supreme Court can check each other can lead to gridlock. Many African countries inherited some form of Parliamentary democracy from the British complete with robes and wigs but now seem to have rejected it in some cases.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 18:44

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 18:12

we have a parliamentary democracy.

But not a representative democracy.

Incorrect as a representative democracy is actually indirect.

What we are not is a DIRECT democracy.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?
EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 18:36

Argentina is the political history you need to check out. It's flipflopped between being run for the rich and being run for the poor, and the last 30 years have been disastrous for most of the population.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 18:32

There has to be a balance @StefanosHill . Otherwise the needy would vote en masse for more money and benefits, and anyone with money would scarper, removing the assets and income available to tax. I am already quite close to leaving for a/any country that has a non-lucrative visa programme. We earned every last penny we have, no inflation linked government pension and until May 2023, no inheritance, which wasn't a lifechanging amount. Taxes due all paid and in order. The people in situations like ours with options to choose thought about these questions 30 or 40 years ago, and saved what they could at the time.

LoobyDop · 27/08/2023 18:18

You are terrifying, OP. You do realise that every dictator ever started out thinking that they were doing what was best for the people? Nobody sets out to be evil, they all just think they’re smarter than the people who shouldn’t be allowed a voice.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 18:14

Sparklesocks · 27/08/2023 18:12

Yes sounds fair, so the richer you are the bigger say you have in how things go….and if you’re a low earner, or disabled, or a carer etc…you’re not worthy of a say 😒

people don’t half come out with some shit on here..

Edited

It’s along the same lines as op’s idea of only Drs etc

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 18:13

<Tongue in cheek post> if you depend on being given everything, then your representation is at the kindness of others, who don't want to see your children starve.