Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TizerorFizz · 29/08/2023 10:10

I think that’s true in some constituencies because there are ingrained beliefs and traits. It’s floating voters in marginals that matter most. However marginal constituencies are possibly quite a few now. The 1997 election was won with 418 seats for Labour. 1983 saw 397 seats for the Conservatives. Boundary changes tend to make it more difficult for Labour but we do have many seats that will fluctuate. Usually over something they don’t like, eg stalling on Brexit, poor leadership of a party and economic reasons.

1dayatatime · 29/08/2023 08:57

110APiccadilly · 29/08/2023 07:48

The problem with voting for policies (well, one of them) is that you might well feel more strongly about one thing than another.

If I agree with party A on two issues, but don't really care that much about those issues, but agree with party B only on one issue, about which I feel very strongly, then it is not irrational for me to vote for B. Some people have one over-riding issue (the obvious example is Welsh/ Scottish independence) which they base their vote on. That is their right.

I think you are viewing voting behaviour to much in a rational and logical way.

Most voters base their decision on how they or their parents have always voted in the past. The majority of floating voters decide on voting for whoever is not currently in power each time on the basis of " well they can't be any worse than the current government " .

TizerorFizz · 29/08/2023 08:55

@CoffeeCantata Erskine May - Peers who sit in the House of Lords are disqualified from voting. A few other categories of person are disqualified too.

CoffeeCantata · 29/08/2023 08:36

OP - I'm the biggest elitist around and am snobbish about people who are wilfully ignorant, but even I know that everyone's views have to be taken into account, not just those you and I might agree with. Yes, that's the 'Problem of Democracy' as Plato foresaw!

As others have mentioned - Churchill put it brilliantly: it's far from perfect but better than any other system.

I think only prisoners and peers of the realm are barred from voting in this country (??).

110APiccadilly · 29/08/2023 07:48

The problem with voting for policies (well, one of them) is that you might well feel more strongly about one thing than another.

If I agree with party A on two issues, but don't really care that much about those issues, but agree with party B only on one issue, about which I feel very strongly, then it is not irrational for me to vote for B. Some people have one over-riding issue (the obvious example is Welsh/ Scottish independence) which they base their vote on. That is their right.

FarEast · 29/08/2023 06:55

Those of you advocating “elections” for written out policies have a pretty fundamental misunderstanding (ignorance actually) of the principles of British representative government and the British constitution. I recommend you read Bagehot and Mill.

Until you do, you are too ignorant of what you’re voting for to have a vote.

You see, that’s how it works, according to you. Grin

Hawkins0090 · 28/08/2023 23:41

Overall I guess is it any wonder why politicians usually do what they prefer considering that left to the public, some of the most monoliths of events eg, brexit are left to the public to vote upon.

To be honest I'd rather prefer the one world government.

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/08/2023 23:15

Maybe I'm not explaining this well. I am NOT suggesting that people get questions "right" that involve anything other than objective facts. Not opinions or views. Eg Who is the leader of the Labour Party? Is the Chancellor in charge of a) money b) war c) hospitals?
I teach RS. I spend every day explaining to teens the difference between fact and opinions and about how their exam answers get marked; not on the basis of if the do or don't believe in God, or abortion, or pacifism but on how much they KNOW that they can support their argument with. It's a crucial but simple difference.
I know zip about rugby. If I was given a vote on whether we should allow a certain kind of tackle, my vote would count but be utterly worthless in real terms as I might as well blindly pick. A short quiz on the basic rules of rugby and the likelihood of spinal damage in the case of said tackle would be ensure I have at least a modicum of understanding on which I have based my vote.

TizerorFizz · 28/08/2023 23:04

A series of questions on policies at an “election” is a referendum. Parties are a better solution. We need a system that represents people. Not a list of questions. Simply won’t work. We have MPs who will listen to anyone in their surgeries. They write letters and advocate for all citizens irrespective of how they vote.

Democracy is not all people being represented. It’s all people being asked for an opinion. What country truly has all views represented? Most have parties but many can form coalitions. At the moment we have an issue with extremes that would find it difficult to align . They might listen to the electorate but the outliers are the danger. As they are in other countries.

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 22:56

nothing is, but witnessing some of the idiotic comments made around Brexit by people.

If remain had won would you still want an exam to be passed before being allowed to vote?
What happens when candidates fail the test? Will they have to wait until the next election to have another go?

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/08/2023 22:46

Correct answers as in "who is the leader of X party" not "is it best to reduce taxes or raise them". Just factual to indicate that a person has the most basic understanding of the political landscape. As for different elections..no, I think realistically, a pass mark for each GE should qualify you to vote for any other election in the meantime. It wouldn't be perfect, nothing is, but witnessing some of the idiotic comments made around Brexit by people with a vote (including not being able to pronounce the word "referendum" let alone understand it) made me despair.

maddening · 28/08/2023 22:00

If you wish the idiots to consent to your leadership you need their vote. No vote, no consent.

What you are proposing is dangerous- look at the mess in the current world of academia - ideology has bled in to it and it has disappeared up its own arse and is churning out mindless twonks who have their heads up their arses with their eyes fixed entirely on their navals - you don't want these people deciding for us.

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 21:58

Also, will candidates have to informed about the policies of Count Binface and Monster Raving Loony Party?

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 21:57

Bibble Will these exams have to be taken to vote in by-elections as well as general elections?
What about council elections?

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 21:54

Nothing about right or wrong, just basic understanding of what you are voting for.

If you need an 80% pass mark then candidates will need to answer questions correctly. Therefore there obviously are right and wrong answers.

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/08/2023 21:51

. It's not about only people of a certain background or views being allowed to vote. You can vote for flat earth if you like, so long as you can show a basic understanding of what each theory comprises of. I proposed a simple online (or paper based available at libraries etc) multiple choice about really simple ideas that say an 80% pass mark would show at least some level of engagement..who are the leaders of each party?, Which part y has proposed policy X? And so on. Nothing about right or wrong, just basic understanding of what you are voting for. It can be available in any language on request and if you achieve the passmark you get a code which is scanned at the polling booth.

FarEast · 28/08/2023 21:50

Funny that @Barbadossunset

Tory bots?

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 21:19

And how will you test that?
Who will determine what the test is?
How will it be administered?
who are the people who will assess the tests

I’ve asked similar questions every time this undemocratic idea is proposed, but they are never answered.

FarEast · 28/08/2023 20:39

I do think that people shouldn't be allowed to vote if they do not know what they are voting for.

And how will you test that?
Who will determine what the test is?
How will it be administered?
who are the people who will assess the tests?

In Australia there’s a very famous case of a political dissident being denied his vote as a citizen. In the past in Australia you had to be able to speak the language of the British Idles. So they tested him in a Gaelic language ( I think it was Welsh).

In the south of the USA before the civil rights movement it was a regular thing to deny Black Americans their vote on the grounds that they could not write their names. The test? A biro on a piece of waxed paper.

I don’t think you’ve thought this through @MooseBreath

So I’m going to take your vote away because you don’t know what you’re voting for.

SENDYWENDY123 · 28/08/2023 20:31

Answer me, OP!

SENDYWENDY123 · 28/08/2023 19:08

Who decides whose views are moral and whose aren't, OP?

MooseBreath · 28/08/2023 19:01

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 17:54

I do think that people shouldn't be allowed to vote if they do not know what they are voting for.

MooseBreath by what means should people prove they do or do not know what they are voting for?

I already explained what I meant. A system where people vote blind for policies rather than a named party.

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 17:55

Funny we require immigrants to pass a test to have the privilege of being a UK citizen that we do not require of natural born citizens.

Seems a tad unfair.

Maybe we should require it of all citizens ? In fact it's hard to think of a cogent argument against that doesn't descend into low quality brain activity which it would be embarrassing to describe as "thinking".

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 17:54

I do think that people shouldn't be allowed to vote if they do not know what they are voting for.

MooseBreath by what means should people prove they do or do not know what they are voting for?

MooseBreath · 28/08/2023 17:46

FarEast · 28/08/2023 17:26

I can see how you are being unreasonable, but I don't entirely disagree.

@MooseBreath thats all very well, but what if one of your opinions- thought to be perfectly reasonable today - becomes “unreasonable “ in 10 years’ time. You’ll lose your vote. How would you feel about that?

There is NOTHING reasonable about the OP. NOTHING.

I do think that people shouldn't be allowed to vote if they do not know what they are voting for. Just because (for example) Mary's parents voted Labour and raised her with liberal values does not mean that the Labour party's manifesto aligns with Mary's views. Uninformed voting is worse than voting at all. That's not me saying that Mary shouldn't get a vote, just that she needs to have a clear understanding of her choice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread