Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 21:24

@SerendipityJane75,000 voters sounds far too few.

It's very easy.

List constituencies by their margin. Smallest to highest.

Now sum all the margins in the seats that made up the majority to the winning party. In the 2019 election that's the first 49 seats. Annoyingly my dataset seems suspect with some null results (thank you HMG) but I get c. 88,000 votes that decided what government we got. Admittedly as an artificial cohort. But certainly not a number even a mediocre TikTokker would be impressed by.

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:15

FarEast · 29/08/2023 18:04

This thread is actually quite scary in the way that authoritarian posters (I'm trying not to use the word 'fascist' but it's quite apt) are presenting their cases for stopping others voting, as if any of these ideas is reasonable. Trying to argue for banning other people voting.

There's a vote on brexit ,one the one side, voters are basing their vote on newspaper headlines, another group has studied all the policies, and the whole debate of for and against brexit.

Which group would you prefer voted for brexit ?

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:11

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 18:09

I think part of the issue is if people start voting with oh I liked his hair ect rather than what's better for the country overall.

Hawkins so are you in favour of this test? Also, even if the voter passes the test there’s still nothing stopping them from voting because they like the candidate’s hair. Do you think candidates from Count Binface, Monster Raving Loony Party should be banned?

I don't have enough analysis to offer a qualified answer

TizerorFizz · 29/08/2023 18:41

@CheeseCakeSunflowers Ive been in the former Speakers constituency too. The one that voted Labour and elected the con Robert Maxwell as the MP.

@SerendipityJane 75,000 voters sounds far too few. If you look at Blair’s majority and Thatchers, far more people switched than 75,000. However there are clearly swing seats. There’s a huge list of those now. Although 1 vote in each could swing it either way.

Ofcourseshecan · 29/08/2023 18:10

OlympicProcrastinator · 27/08/2023 02:45

Oh no no no. This is wrong on so many levels. You don’t realise how many experts in their field are also racist, homophobic bigots with hidden agendas. This reeks of classism. The fact that someone from Clacton called Sharon would be more likely to be a bigot than someone who got a few degrees is so short sighted and ignorant.

Who do you think upholds systems of oppression? I can tell you now it’s the people with the most, not the least power. Medical bias has killed hundreds of black people with ‘expert advice’ being steeped in incorrect racist assumptions. If you are interested in reading around this subject I suggest, “Hoberman, Black and Blue: The Origins and Consequences of Medical Racism.”

We already had the system described above in recent history in the UK where only educated males were allowed to vote. How do you think that worked out for the people?

You are suggesting an Orwellian future where some people ‘are more equal than others’ and want to live in a world where ‘expert’ opinion is taken as gospel without challenge from dissenting voices and the poor and uneducated are assumed to be morally bankrupt.

Telling people they have ‘wrong think’ is a slippery slope that never ends well. I want to live in a society where everyone has a voice, all views can be discussed and challenged out in the open and everyone gets a say.

This, 100%. I hope the OP and posters such as TrishM80 are just winding us up. Democracy has its flaws (and the ‘first past the post’ voting system is rubbish), but it is pretty much essential.

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 18:09

I think part of the issue is if people start voting with oh I liked his hair ect rather than what's better for the country overall.

Hawkins so are you in favour of this test? Also, even if the voter passes the test there’s still nothing stopping them from voting because they like the candidate’s hair. Do you think candidates from Count Binface, Monster Raving Loony Party should be banned?

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 18:06

are presenting their cases for stopping others voting, as if any of these ideas is reasonable.

Yes. Also a number of the posters who regularly comment on political threads are silent on this issue.

FarEast · 29/08/2023 18:04

This thread is actually quite scary in the way that authoritarian posters (I'm trying not to use the word 'fascist' but it's quite apt) are presenting their cases for stopping others voting, as if any of these ideas is reasonable. Trying to argue for banning other people voting.

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 18:04

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 17:56

This happens with the current system of voting. If you are in some way intellectually incapable of organising registering to the electoral roll, attending the polling station or organising a postal vote then unless support is specifically requested it’s unlikely to be offered ime.

So why add to these problems with a test? Even fewer people would be able to vote.

I think part of the issue is if people start voting with oh I liked his hair ect rather than what's better for the country overall.

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 17:56

This happens with the current system of voting. If you are in some way intellectually incapable of organising registering to the electoral roll, attending the polling station or organising a postal vote then unless support is specifically requested it’s unlikely to be offered ime.

So why add to these problems with a test? Even fewer people would be able to vote.

Cornettoninja · 29/08/2023 17:26

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 17:10

What about adults with learning disabilities? People with short term memory loss? Prople who are functionally illiterate? They are massively vulnerable and dependent on the government providing them with the services they need. Do you think people with learning disabilities shouldn't be allowed to vote?

I think those in favour of pass a test before you vote didn’t want these people voting. This test would rule them out.

This happens with the current system of voting. If you are in some way intellectually incapable of organising registering to the electoral roll, attending the polling station or organising a postal vote then unless support is specifically requested it’s unlikely to be offered ime.

Barbadossunset · 29/08/2023 17:10

What about adults with learning disabilities? People with short term memory loss? Prople who are functionally illiterate? They are massively vulnerable and dependent on the government providing them with the services they need. Do you think people with learning disabilities shouldn't be allowed to vote?

I think those in favour of pass a test before you vote didn’t want these people voting. This test would rule them out.

DownNative · 29/08/2023 16:42

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 15:38

Well if you can't navigate the new identity requirements you are effectively disenfranchised anyway.

Given that help and assistance is provided for groups such as these, they are not disenfranchised.

The Electoral Commission holds Northern Ireland ID requirements up as a successful model. The GB model is based on this.

ID requirement to vote is normal right across Europe. What is NOT normal is to exclude people on the basis of intelligence via tests. The aforementioned groups would concretely and absolutely be excluded under those.

No, that's a non-starter. 🤦‍♂️

Angrycat2768 · 29/08/2023 15:55

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 15:38

Well if you can't navigate the new identity requirements you are effectively disenfranchised anyway.

Well, quite. But people with learning difficulties will have a PA or parent or someone caring for them who will be able to help them access ID. I presume they won't be allowed to help them to do a test where they have to name the leader of the Liberal Democrats if they want to vote!

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 15:38

Angrycat2768 · 29/08/2023 15:28

What about adults with learning disabilities? People with short term memory loss? Prople who are functionally illiterate? They are massively vulnerable and dependent on the government providing them with the services they need. Do you think people with learning disabilities shouldn't be allowed to vote?

Well if you can't navigate the new identity requirements you are effectively disenfranchised anyway.

Angrycat2768 · 29/08/2023 15:28

Barbadossunset · 28/08/2023 21:54

Nothing about right or wrong, just basic understanding of what you are voting for.

If you need an 80% pass mark then candidates will need to answer questions correctly. Therefore there obviously are right and wrong answers.

What about adults with learning disabilities? People with short term memory loss? Prople who are functionally illiterate? They are massively vulnerable and dependent on the government providing them with the services they need. Do you think people with learning disabilities shouldn't be allowed to vote?

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 12:58

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 12:51

Look at the way the Tories have shafted perma-Tory voters these past few years.
Indeed and look at the way they say "please please shaft us some more" any time there's any political debate by wanging on about Corbyn. Twats.

This is why we get cycles in governments. It's no coincidence that the Tories were evicted after 18 years of rule.

Q: What drives the uptake of new ideas* ?
A: Old people die.

As true now as it was when I wasn't old 😀

*Except email.

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 12:51

Look at the way the Tories have shafted perma-Tory voters these past few years.
Indeed and look at the way they say "please please shaft us some more" any time there's any political debate by wanging on about Corbyn. Twats.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 29/08/2023 11:38

Yes, @PretzelKnot , Churchill summed it up.

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 11:17

Oh, just for perspective, if you are illegally denied your vote - for whatever reason - it's exact value has been set as "fuck all".

Yes - your vote actually is worthless.

Something I bear in mind if people want to lecture on democracy,

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 29/08/2023 11:13

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 10:20

yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.
OP if you are studying this you must be aware that in the UK general election system, votes are very from of equal value. In many places your vote will count for nothing if you don't vote for a candidate from the incumbent party as the area is a safe seat.

Also if you live in the constituency that the speaker represents you do not get a chance to vote for any of the main three parties as Conservatives, Labour and Liberals do not put a candidate up against the speaker. In the general elections of 2010, 2015 and 2017 I along with everyone else in my constituency only had the choice of voting for one of the minor parties, independent or speaker, that did not feel democratic at all.

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 11:04

TizerorFizz · 29/08/2023 10:10

I think that’s true in some constituencies because there are ingrained beliefs and traits. It’s floating voters in marginals that matter most. However marginal constituencies are possibly quite a few now. The 1997 election was won with 418 seats for Labour. 1983 saw 397 seats for the Conservatives. Boundary changes tend to make it more difficult for Labour but we do have many seats that will fluctuate. Usually over something they don’t like, eg stalling on Brexit, poor leadership of a party and economic reasons.

If you knew how few the number of people it takes to decide who is in government, you'd be worried. It's shockingly low. Less than 75,000.

That's 75,000 people whose votes decided who won the 2019 election. Now imagine if you could find those voters and offer them £10,000 a piece to vote how you instruct.

You, my data totin' friend have just bought an election.

Obviously that wouldn't be possible without FPTP. Which is probably reason enough to dump it.

Also, if you "always vote <party>" then don't be surprised when <party> does fuck all for you. Why would they ? You've already voted for them. They are much more likely to promise a floating or switch voter a better policy. Look at the way the Tories have shafted perma-Tory voters these past few years.

newnamethanks · 29/08/2023 10:28

I take it that you're still studying OP? Keep it up until you reach a more reasoned conclusion.

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 10:25

BibbleandSqwauk · 28/08/2023 23:15

Maybe I'm not explaining this well. I am NOT suggesting that people get questions "right" that involve anything other than objective facts. Not opinions or views. Eg Who is the leader of the Labour Party? Is the Chancellor in charge of a) money b) war c) hospitals?
I teach RS. I spend every day explaining to teens the difference between fact and opinions and about how their exam answers get marked; not on the basis of if the do or don't believe in God, or abortion, or pacifism but on how much they KNOW that they can support their argument with. It's a crucial but simple difference.
I know zip about rugby. If I was given a vote on whether we should allow a certain kind of tackle, my vote would count but be utterly worthless in real terms as I might as well blindly pick. A short quiz on the basic rules of rugby and the likelihood of spinal damage in the case of said tackle would be ensure I have at least a modicum of understanding on which I have based my vote.

Most people agree on what the problems we want to solve are (with a liittle tinkering around edge causes).
The problem is that all political idealogies claim to have the solutions. There aren't "objective facts" about the efficacy of 99% of political policies as their proponents will always cite additional reasons why they didn't work out as promised - that is politics.

Fightyouforthatpie · 29/08/2023 10:20

yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.
OP if you are studying this you must be aware that in the UK general election system, votes are very from of equal value. In many places your vote will count for nothing if you don't vote for a candidate from the incumbent party as the area is a safe seat.