Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
FarEast · 30/08/2023 10:00

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:15

There's a vote on brexit ,one the one side, voters are basing their vote on newspaper headlines, another group has studied all the policies, and the whole debate of for and against brexit.

Which group would you prefer voted for brexit ?

I am happy for anyone to vote for whatever their conscience, their brain, and their feelings prompts them to vote for. And I claim the same right.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 09:35

DownNative · 30/08/2023 09:24

Parliament showed it was by the votes by MPs to honour the 2016 advisory referendum. 🤦‍♂️

And the Supreme Court has upheld the doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty since, including the Miller case as well as the two UKSC rulings that slapped down the SNP for acting ultra vires......

Next.

You can't just brush that off.

A - if not the - key plank of the Leave campaign was an out and out lie. No ambiguity. No nuance. Just a bald lie.

Brexit was bought with a dud cheque. And just like a real dud cheque, every time you present it at the bank, it gets returned to drawer. And will keep on being returned to drawer.

Theresa May tried to buy the 2017 election with her dud cheque. And got nowhere.

Boris Johnson tried tippexing out the banks stamp and represented the same dud cheque in 2019.

Yes - Leave won. Christ knows we know they won. But what have they actually bought with their winnings ? And since their "winnings" came at the expense of the whole country being the stakes, I still fucking well want to know. Because frankly at this length of time, even Dusty Bin would have been a better prize than the literal flood of shit we are being washed in daily.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 09:24

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 09:19

However, we have a doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty which means Parliament is the Supreme Legislator in the UK.

Except the entire leave campaign was predicated on telling us it wasn't.

Parliament showed it was by the votes by MPs to honour the 2016 advisory referendum. 🤦‍♂️

And the Supreme Court has upheld the doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty since, including the Miller case as well as the two UKSC rulings that slapped down the SNP for acting ultra vires......

Next.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 09:22

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 08:58

The UK government rarely uses referenda. 1975 EU, 2011 voting system change (did any of you vote for change?) and 2016 EU again. So three times in 50 years isn’t much. Parliament makes decisions and is better equipped to do it. Brexit was all about Cameron being rattled by UKIP and agitators in the Con Party who had been rattling the cage as far back as the 90s and fell out with the Major government.

I probably won’t vote in the next election. I don’t find either main party appealing and the same party gets in here anyway. I doubt I’m in a marginal seat! I strictly prefer middle ground policies but we lurch to extremes which I do not like. We are divided as a country in so many ways.

No government will ever vote for testing citizens pre voting. The more complex our problems and policies are, the less likely many people will understand what they are voting for. We are in the era, again, of three word slogans building on “Labour isn’t working” in the late 70s. This gets at the people who don’t think too much. 66% vote and this is surely affected by votes not mattering and disinterest in politics.

NI is very much missing Stormont. The oriole there have voted in these idiots though. NI needs a new party to represent modern collaborative views.

Three UK wide referendums since the 1970s, yes.

But UK referendum history actually began with the 1973 Northern Ireland one. Further referendums in the UK include 1998 (Northern Ireland) and 2014 (Scotland).

Northern Ireland's problems is more complex for this thread, but a significant issue is the fact the Belfast Agreement was amended in 2007 without the people voting via referendum. Under Belfast Agreement rules, DUP would still have taken the role of First Minister as largest designation gets it rather than party. Currently, it also prevents Alliance taking the FM role in future too.

However, Belgium has the record for longest span of time without a functioning government. Northern Ireland, in contrast, has a devolved form so Westminster is still sovereign (direct rule does not breach Belfast Agreement).

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 09:19

However, we have a doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty which means Parliament is the Supreme Legislator in the UK.

Except the entire leave campaign was predicated on telling us it wasn't.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 09:14

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 08:30

The issue of EU membership was far too complex to put to a referendum, and it affected far more people than just individuals. If you are voting for a local MP, you are voting for a person tp represent you in Parliament. The Brexit referendum has affected virtually every industry in the UK. Most of which no one had any clue about, like the Horizon programme. It was also not something you think @Oh Ive made a mistake, Ill vote differently next time. It should not have been allowed to be put to a referendum.

I would say direct your ire at Parliament.

However, we have a doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty which means Parliament is the Supreme Legislator in the UK. So, they have the power to allow referendums as we've seen in 1973 (Northern Ireland), 1975 (EEC), 2014 (Scotland) and 2016 (EU).

Indeed, referendums in the UK are advisory, but Parliament also has the power to put it through into action.

As I said, Parliament is the Supreme Legislator. You can check which parties voted to honour the 2016 result. IIRC, all did except for SNP who opposed it on the grounds in reality for it making IndyRef2 more difficult (not for reasons they stated publicly).

GrouchyKiwi · 30/08/2023 09:04

The best form of government is a benevolent dictatorship, but as actually benevolent dictators are rather hard to come by I'll stick with democracy, thanks.

Fightyouforthatpie · 30/08/2023 09:03

On a small point of pedantry 1975 was the EEC as the EU didn't exist.

I did vote in favour of PR in the 2011 referendum.

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 08:58

The UK government rarely uses referenda. 1975 EU, 2011 voting system change (did any of you vote for change?) and 2016 EU again. So three times in 50 years isn’t much. Parliament makes decisions and is better equipped to do it. Brexit was all about Cameron being rattled by UKIP and agitators in the Con Party who had been rattling the cage as far back as the 90s and fell out with the Major government.

I probably won’t vote in the next election. I don’t find either main party appealing and the same party gets in here anyway. I doubt I’m in a marginal seat! I strictly prefer middle ground policies but we lurch to extremes which I do not like. We are divided as a country in so many ways.

No government will ever vote for testing citizens pre voting. The more complex our problems and policies are, the less likely many people will understand what they are voting for. We are in the era, again, of three word slogans building on “Labour isn’t working” in the late 70s. This gets at the people who don’t think too much. 66% vote and this is surely affected by votes not mattering and disinterest in politics.

NI is very much missing Stormont. The oriole there have voted in these idiots though. NI needs a new party to represent modern collaborative views.

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 08:42

I think most of our problems come from too few people voting, not too many. I agree with the above and mentioned before that I am in favour of compulsory voting. We need to change the voting system to make it more representative and also to allow new voices to represent us. The current two parties are parties of a bygone era. They are coalitions, it seems to people with little in common who either hate each other or do whatever they can to undermine the other faction of the party. If we had PR then various parties would have to negotiate like grown ups and parties would not be able to hide within parties. People give the example of the Greens tail wagging the SNP dog but doesn't the ERG wag the Tory Party dog, even though UKIP have never ever been elected in any seat?

We also need to ensure that peoples votes are not being stolen by others. If we had minimum voting requirements it would be even easier for a husband to coerce a wife into saying she doesn't know what the chancellor does and deny her the vote. In many fundamentalist communities, this would certainly happen.
In any case, surely anywhere that has a voting system of any kind is some form of democracy, even a bad one. If the OP is arguing that democracy is not the best form of government, surely you should be arguing for the benefits of no one voting at all- so a one party state?

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 08:30

DownNative · 29/08/2023 22:55

When the elected representatives cannot make their minds up, they can, will and do put it to the people. That's not unusual at all.

Parliament voted to allow the electorate to vote on the question of EU membership. The Cameron Government clearly believed Remain would win and they campaigned for it.

However, when politicians take the voters fir granted, they end up with situations they didn't expect. Not just Brexit, e.g. Labour took voters for granted in Scotland and soon found themselves out of favour as well as replaced by the awful SNP.

The issue of EU membership was far too complex to put to a referendum, and it affected far more people than just individuals. If you are voting for a local MP, you are voting for a person tp represent you in Parliament. The Brexit referendum has affected virtually every industry in the UK. Most of which no one had any clue about, like the Horizon programme. It was also not something you think @Oh Ive made a mistake, Ill vote differently next time. It should not have been allowed to be put to a referendum.

Catsmere · 30/08/2023 08:20

labamba007 · 30/08/2023 07:30

More of a problem is not everyone voting. I forgot which country makes everyone 18+ vote, but I think this is a much better idea to get a true representation of our country.

21 countries had mandatory voting as at January this year, apparently. (I didn't know it was that many!)

BibbleandSqwauk · 30/08/2023 08:14

At the moment, as some posters have mentioned, (aside from rare referendums) we trust the MPs who have access to more info and whose job it is to learn about the issue before voting for it to do so . They defend their voting record based on info they gathered about X issue. We recognise that an informed opinion is valuable and useful when casting a vote. But we then are saying that that same principle doesn't matter when it comes to GE? That you can be as uninformed as you like, you just have to be 18 and not in prison. The basis for not giving under 18s the vote is that they are not likely to be knowledgeable enough to vote responsibly, but I don't think it's secret knowledge that vast numbers of over 18s aren't either..have zero knowledge of the most basic aspects. So yes, I do think bring able to name party leaders and that MPs vote at the HoC (in a multiple choice test) should be a basic requirement and access issues can be overcome with multiple tools..the illiterate can use the reader programmes or ask for assistance at the centre, ditto with language barriers. Those with learning disabilities, assuming they are able to function sufficiently to be aware of GE and want to vote, would also be entitled to assistance to access the test in whatever format they need. I simply don't agree that it's right that people with not the slightest clue about the most basic function of government should be able to participate. Again, NOT assessment of people's political views, just level 1 of the "citizenship" that PPS have mentioned should be taught in schools.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 08:01

labamba007 · 30/08/2023 07:30

More of a problem is not everyone voting. I forgot which country makes everyone 18+ vote, but I think this is a much better idea to get a true representation of our country.

Only if you put "none of the above" on the ballot and require 50% of the electorate to win. If no candidate gets over 50% you don't return a representative. That might focus some minds on compromises.

As we know from Northern Ireland, it's entirely possible to exist without the elected government.

(We'll come back to my suggestion for the second chamber ....)

EveSix · 30/08/2023 07:56

Democracy is absolutely fine.
The issue is with how elections work in the UK.
First past the post disenfranchises the electorate.
Having grown up in a country with proportional representation, I had to have FPTP explained to me so many times before I realised it actually was as ridiculous and cynical as it sounds.
The UK needs electoral reform and the introduction of a truly democratic proportional representation system. Voter engagement would rise overnight.

In addition, we need to ensure the national curriculum enshrines statutory opportunities for learning about models of governance and how politics works at different levels in the UK, and for this to be given considerable resources and priority. Citizenship education essentially. There's never been greater urgency.

And as for the press, as a previous poster suggested, political bias in in print, online and televised media needs to be further highlighted and made visible at a glance.

labamba007 · 30/08/2023 07:30

More of a problem is not everyone voting. I forgot which country makes everyone 18+ vote, but I think this is a much better idea to get a true representation of our country.

labamba007 · 30/08/2023 07:27

OlympicProcrastinator · 27/08/2023 02:45

Oh no no no. This is wrong on so many levels. You don’t realise how many experts in their field are also racist, homophobic bigots with hidden agendas. This reeks of classism. The fact that someone from Clacton called Sharon would be more likely to be a bigot than someone who got a few degrees is so short sighted and ignorant.

Who do you think upholds systems of oppression? I can tell you now it’s the people with the most, not the least power. Medical bias has killed hundreds of black people with ‘expert advice’ being steeped in incorrect racist assumptions. If you are interested in reading around this subject I suggest, “Hoberman, Black and Blue: The Origins and Consequences of Medical Racism.”

We already had the system described above in recent history in the UK where only educated males were allowed to vote. How do you think that worked out for the people?

You are suggesting an Orwellian future where some people ‘are more equal than others’ and want to live in a world where ‘expert’ opinion is taken as gospel without challenge from dissenting voices and the poor and uneducated are assumed to be morally bankrupt.

Telling people they have ‘wrong think’ is a slippery slope that never ends well. I want to live in a society where everyone has a voice, all views can be discussed and challenged out in the open and everyone gets a say.

This 100%

DownNative · 30/08/2023 07:22

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 07:07

If you asked all the people you know or people in shops etc , how much they know about the parties they voted for and why they voted , why would that be classed as rhetoric ?

Rhetoric = language intended to have a persuasive effect, but lacks meaningful content.

Asking people you know leads you to the Anecdotal Fallacy too. It's not evidence of anything.

Hence, you need a more robust data source of some credible kind.

Sweet Jesus....🙈

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 07:07

DownNative · 30/08/2023 06:45

Thought as much. You should've just said you had none instead of posting useless rhetoric! 🤦‍♂️

This thread is a joke. It's a SNat knowing their IndyRef2 train has come off the rails, so they're ranting about UK GE democracy whilst ignoring the democracy deficit in Scotland not having a second chamber to the point where Supreme Court has to slap them down!

It's quite clear the wannabe authoritarian posters really haven't thought their posts through either.

Jesus. 🙈

If you asked all the people you know or people in shops etc , how much they know about the parties they voted for and why they voted , why would that be classed as rhetoric ?

DownNative · 30/08/2023 06:45

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 23:07

For hard data, you only have to ask various members of the general public how or what influences their voting, and I'll bet a very small majority will say they have read the policies, manifesto, ect in detail,

Thought as much. You should've just said you had none instead of posting useless rhetoric! 🤦‍♂️

This thread is a joke. It's a SNat knowing their IndyRef2 train has come off the rails, so they're ranting about UK GE democracy whilst ignoring the democracy deficit in Scotland not having a second chamber to the point where Supreme Court has to slap them down!

It's quite clear the wannabe authoritarian posters really haven't thought their posts through either.

Jesus. 🙈

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 23:07

DownNative · 29/08/2023 22:45

This is a False Dilemma Fallacy since society is not made up of just these two groups and other permutations exist to balance extremes out.

Additionally, do you have any empirical data to support your hypothesis?

For hard data, you only have to ask various members of the general public how or what influences their voting, and I'll bet a very small majority will say they have read the policies, manifesto, ect in detail,

DownNative · 29/08/2023 22:55

Angrycat2768 · 29/08/2023 21:49

I would rather nobody was allowed to vote for Brexit. It was the start of this country going down the pan. We are a representative democracy. We vote for people who have access to all the facts to make decisions in our best interests. We are irretrievably divided as a country as a result of the referendum. But actually, it wasn't just racist dimwits moaning about immigration who voted for Brexit. It was degree educated intelligent people like James Dyson who voted for it because he didn't want to pay more corporation tax. And the far left who voted for it because they think the EU is a capitalist cabal. There were Black and Brown people who voted for Brexit. Just because people look into things and read up on it doesn't mean they can't disagree with other people who read.

Edited

When the elected representatives cannot make their minds up, they can, will and do put it to the people. That's not unusual at all.

Parliament voted to allow the electorate to vote on the question of EU membership. The Cameron Government clearly believed Remain would win and they campaigned for it.

However, when politicians take the voters fir granted, they end up with situations they didn't expect. Not just Brexit, e.g. Labour took voters for granted in Scotland and soon found themselves out of favour as well as replaced by the awful SNP.

DownNative · 29/08/2023 22:45

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:15

There's a vote on brexit ,one the one side, voters are basing their vote on newspaper headlines, another group has studied all the policies, and the whole debate of for and against brexit.

Which group would you prefer voted for brexit ?

This is a False Dilemma Fallacy since society is not made up of just these two groups and other permutations exist to balance extremes out.

Additionally, do you have any empirical data to support your hypothesis?

Angrycat2768 · 29/08/2023 21:49

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:15

There's a vote on brexit ,one the one side, voters are basing their vote on newspaper headlines, another group has studied all the policies, and the whole debate of for and against brexit.

Which group would you prefer voted for brexit ?

I would rather nobody was allowed to vote for Brexit. It was the start of this country going down the pan. We are a representative democracy. We vote for people who have access to all the facts to make decisions in our best interests. We are irretrievably divided as a country as a result of the referendum. But actually, it wasn't just racist dimwits moaning about immigration who voted for Brexit. It was degree educated intelligent people like James Dyson who voted for it because he didn't want to pay more corporation tax. And the far left who voted for it because they think the EU is a capitalist cabal. There were Black and Brown people who voted for Brexit. Just because people look into things and read up on it doesn't mean they can't disagree with other people who read.

Hawkins0090 · 29/08/2023 21:38

The other option, we let artificial intelligence choose the next political party to run the United kingdom.