Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 23:40

@FarEast Might that be because posters aren’t British? Or have had a short time here? There seems a lot of posturing but lack of understanding.

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 23:37

FarEast · 30/08/2023 22:25

It's just when people are giving the choice of voting on complex issues for parties in the General election, or e.g. Brexit but then they afterwards realise what a mistake it was, and then when you discuss with friends or people you know and they say oh newspaper x was saying y so I voted for that party, or we need our own trade deals, based on newspapers M,

So what? What if I said that you couldn't vote because of your "bad" opinions? (Such as not believing every voter has an equal vote).

Some of the ignorance and lack of thinking on this thread is downright scary. The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

First and foremost I'm not advocating only x people get to vote.

My point is when or if people vote on a whim, then why complain about e.g. Brexit ect when if you had studied the information in more detail you may have voted differently. Etc. Same for general elections.

FarEast · 30/08/2023 22:25

It's just when people are giving the choice of voting on complex issues for parties in the General election, or e.g. Brexit but then they afterwards realise what a mistake it was, and then when you discuss with friends or people you know and they say oh newspaper x was saying y so I voted for that party, or we need our own trade deals, based on newspapers M,

So what? What if I said that you couldn't vote because of your "bad" opinions? (Such as not believing every voter has an equal vote).

Some of the ignorance and lack of thinking on this thread is downright scary. The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 21:09

@serendipityjaneAre you thinking Chat gpt is going rogue?

The full Skynet ? Nah.

But as it advances it's going to produce results that can't be predicted. Precisely because it is being trained by the chaotic input of humans.

And if you are cornered by an AI bore at a party, just innocently ask for a definition of "intelligence" before you can consider the "artificial" bit of it.

user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 20:24

@GasPanic You are so right that politicians don't deal with issues that become worse over time. They avoid measures which will alienate their voters or the interests of business. But their judgement is skewed by consideration of their careers, their financial interests and by personal bias. Since AI has no emotion and no interest in money, it should be free of these flaws and able also to make accurate forecasts. I think a lot of failure to act is just human laziness as well, or inability - it's just too hard to solve problems on such a large scale. AI may well have ruled out Brexit as a logical action. It may even have calculated the sheer ridiculousness of asking the population to decide that one, when virtually none of us had the expertise to predict all the issues. I don't know quite how an AI PM would work, but I think it has potential.
@serendipityjane Are you thinking Chat gpt is going rogue? It's an interesting thought, I don't understand it enough to know if that's a possibility, but my nerdy friends seem to think it's not!

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 19:52

I’m so old! I prefer “human” as an adjective!!

However I agree short term election gains stop long term planning. Many areas of government are failing to plan for the future, eg social care, electricity supply when we try to replace fossil fuels, NHS services, and many many more.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 19:29

I don't think it's difficult for humans to know what the right thing to do is.

Some humans think the right thing to do is prevent pregnant women having abortions.

Some humans don't.

Some humans think homosexuality should be punished by death.

Some humans don't.

The human team behind ChatGPT are still working out how to communicate in a way users like, which is part of their business model I suppose.

It's starting to emerge that the team behind ChatGPT haven't yet realised what they are doing. Or more precisely what they have done. Which is odd, since they had the smarts to correctly call it a large language learning model.

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 18:25

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 16:22

But then you don't respect everyone's right to vote, because you can't possibly know why people vote. They could tell you they voted Tory because they looked at all the policies but really they just really like the colour blue. The ballot box is private. Your whole argument was that some people should not have the right to vote because they are too lazy/stupid.

Apologies I thought you were the OP

GasPanic · 30/08/2023 18:09

user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 17:47

@SerendipityJane The human team behind Chat gpt are still working out how to communicate in a way users like, which is part of their business model I suppose. It's not chat gpt asking, but the company trying to drive up engagement. AI is a huge field and I think has great potential for making complicated decisions in the future. I don't know much about it, but I think running a country well, being fair to all the conflicting interests and needs, is difficult for humans, whose vision is limited to the short term and incomplete knowledge.

I don't think it's difficult for humans to know what the right thing to do is. In fact I think they know pretty much all the time.

It's a lot more difficult for them to actually do it though.

Our short term popularity based election systems mean it is far easier to kick problems into the long grass for someone else to deal with than resolve them now. The net result is that those problems only become worse over time and are only dealt with as a last resort when there is no other option.

I don't see AI changing that.

I think with the coming of the internet and more information, our political outlook has become increasingly short term, as focus is put on political events on a short term basis, and any long term planning is effectively ignored.

user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 17:47

@SerendipityJane The human team behind Chat gpt are still working out how to communicate in a way users like, which is part of their business model I suppose. It's not chat gpt asking, but the company trying to drive up engagement. AI is a huge field and I think has great potential for making complicated decisions in the future. I don't know much about it, but I think running a country well, being fair to all the conflicting interests and needs, is difficult for humans, whose vision is limited to the short term and incomplete knowledge.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 17:12

user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 16:42

@SerendipityJane Sorry, I don't see the issue. Human politicians display the full range of flaws from corruption, to dictatorship to genocide. Are you thinking AI would be worse?

It certainly won't be any better. And notice how it's already asked you what answers you'd like.

Now as a nerdy type, forged in the fire of elemental particles, I am quite partial to the "right" answer. Not the one that could be broadcast before the watershed, or some other artificial constraint.

But now we are straying into the quagmire of universal truth.

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 16:52

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 16:43

I've just read all my responses and comments on this thread, I have never once said or commented on people actually having the option to vote.

Afaik all democracies have the option to vote without a test to prove knowledge of what constituents are voting for.

Much appreciated.
One of the things that has occurred in conversations with people is when some people vote for x party or brexit it's like did you study what you were voting for or was it more you voted on a whim then usually the ones that vote on the whim were the ones complaining about the outcome of it all,

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 16:43

I've just read all my responses and comments on this thread, I have never once said or commented on people actually having the option to vote.

Afaik all democracies have the option to vote without a test to prove knowledge of what constituents are voting for.

user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 16:42

@SerendipityJane Sorry, I don't see the issue. Human politicians display the full range of flaws from corruption, to dictatorship to genocide. Are you thinking AI would be worse?

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 16:38

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 16:22

But then you don't respect everyone's right to vote, because you can't possibly know why people vote. They could tell you they voted Tory because they looked at all the policies but really they just really like the colour blue. The ballot box is private. Your whole argument was that some people should not have the right to vote because they are too lazy/stupid.

I've just read all my responses and comments on this thread, I have never once said or commented on people actually having the option to vote.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 16:37

Yeah, lets all buy into the AI bullshit shall we. What could possibly go wrong ?

(I suspect the PP wasn't aware AI is now canvassing for opinions ....)

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?
user9630721458 · 30/08/2023 16:31

I think we need AI as prime minister. Tireless, unbiased and able to swiftly calculate every permutation, not motivated by money or ego. Would need careful programming and parameters, but likely to be far superior to any of our previous leaders.

Angrycat2768 · 30/08/2023 16:22

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 16:14

Which is understandable and for the record I respect everyone's right to vote etc.
It's just when people are giving the choice of voting on complex issues for parties in the General election, or e.g. Brexit but then they afterwards realise what a mistake it was, and then when you discuss with friends or people you know and they say oh newspaper x was saying y so I voted for that party, or we need our own trade deals, based on newspapers M,

But then you don't respect everyone's right to vote, because you can't possibly know why people vote. They could tell you they voted Tory because they looked at all the policies but really they just really like the colour blue. The ballot box is private. Your whole argument was that some people should not have the right to vote because they are too lazy/stupid.

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 16:14

FarEast · 30/08/2023 10:00

I am happy for anyone to vote for whatever their conscience, their brain, and their feelings prompts them to vote for. And I claim the same right.

Which is understandable and for the record I respect everyone's right to vote etc.
It's just when people are giving the choice of voting on complex issues for parties in the General election, or e.g. Brexit but then they afterwards realise what a mistake it was, and then when you discuss with friends or people you know and they say oh newspaper x was saying y so I voted for that party, or we need our own trade deals, based on newspapers M,

DownNative · 30/08/2023 13:23

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 13:04

Well done you for research but devolution and London don’t affect everyone. There have been city devolution votes too. However they are not policy affecting everyone. So a bit of a side issue for the majority.

The constitutional implications of them do, e.g. they invariably lead to greater calls for a referendum on other issues with the argument that "a, b & c have had their say in referendums but d hasn't!". Its an exorable process from the first one in 1973 to the most recent one in 2016.

Since 1973, UK Government has ceded some degree of Sovereignty and decision making to the people in part of OR whole of the UK.

At the end of the day, it is entirely democratic for the UK Government to give decision making over EU membership to the people.

And I voted Remain at the time.

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 13:04

Well done you for research but devolution and London don’t affect everyone. There have been city devolution votes too. However they are not policy affecting everyone. So a bit of a side issue for the majority.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 12:25

Oops, one more referendum in the UK was the Greater London Authority one in 1999!

Most referenda in the UK has been under the Labour Party. Most UK wide referenda has been under the Conservatives.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 11:26

TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 11:00

As most of us don’t vote in NI or Scotland, it’s slightly irrelevant to the majority of us. Thank God probably! It’s always divisive. Look at Scotland. Never ending arguments about Indy ref 2.

The Supreme Court settled the proroguing issue I recall. You can argue parliament must pass a referendum bill (or even do something illegal) but of course the majority party win that so it’s rubber stamping. It’s still poor governance. Brexit was too complicated for many to understand so exit was presented in three word slogans that were misleading but very easy to repeat and understand. Like advertising. As many were happy to sever ties with Europe because they believed they were the source of all our problems, it just needed a final nudge of persuasion. Cummings and Vote Leave found many gullible people without ever having to explain anything. They just built on, and rammed home, distrust of the EU and little England sentiments. Farage drove this for many years. He’s an arch disruptor but again, people are easily led. Never got elected but drove this ludicrous vote and policy.

How we get people to engage in possible outcomes is our problem. People cannot see the bigger picture. Cannot envisage any problems. So they vote in their bubble. Politicians don’t have vision. They lurch from crisis to crisis with few longer term policies. Vote with the whip. Don’t have enough talent to have sensible policies. All are driven by what they think their voters want via policy groups. So there’s no wider vision. That’s why I don’t want to vote for any of them.

Ah! Another three sets of referendums in the UK was 1979 and 1997 (both Scotland on devolution), Wales in 1997 (devolution) also.

The Welsh devolution result is even tighter than the 2016 EU referendum, but you don't generally see someone trying to argue it shouldn't have passed through anyway.

Northern Ireland and Scotland have had major constitutional implications for the entire UK Constitution. Whether or not some in England are politically aware enough of this.

The 2015 EU Referendum Act was NOT merely "rubber stamping"! It was an expression of Parliament's sovereignty! The numbers of MPs voting for it speaks for itself - 544. Conservative and Labour numbers very similar. Only SNP opposed.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?
TizerorFizz · 30/08/2023 11:00

As most of us don’t vote in NI or Scotland, it’s slightly irrelevant to the majority of us. Thank God probably! It’s always divisive. Look at Scotland. Never ending arguments about Indy ref 2.

The Supreme Court settled the proroguing issue I recall. You can argue parliament must pass a referendum bill (or even do something illegal) but of course the majority party win that so it’s rubber stamping. It’s still poor governance. Brexit was too complicated for many to understand so exit was presented in three word slogans that were misleading but very easy to repeat and understand. Like advertising. As many were happy to sever ties with Europe because they believed they were the source of all our problems, it just needed a final nudge of persuasion. Cummings and Vote Leave found many gullible people without ever having to explain anything. They just built on, and rammed home, distrust of the EU and little England sentiments. Farage drove this for many years. He’s an arch disruptor but again, people are easily led. Never got elected but drove this ludicrous vote and policy.

How we get people to engage in possible outcomes is our problem. People cannot see the bigger picture. Cannot envisage any problems. So they vote in their bubble. Politicians don’t have vision. They lurch from crisis to crisis with few longer term policies. Vote with the whip. Don’t have enough talent to have sensible policies. All are driven by what they think their voters want via policy groups. So there’s no wider vision. That’s why I don’t want to vote for any of them.

DownNative · 30/08/2023 10:17

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 09:35

You can't just brush that off.

A - if not the - key plank of the Leave campaign was an out and out lie. No ambiguity. No nuance. Just a bald lie.

Brexit was bought with a dud cheque. And just like a real dud cheque, every time you present it at the bank, it gets returned to drawer. And will keep on being returned to drawer.

Theresa May tried to buy the 2017 election with her dud cheque. And got nowhere.

Boris Johnson tried tippexing out the banks stamp and represented the same dud cheque in 2019.

Yes - Leave won. Christ knows we know they won. But what have they actually bought with their winnings ? And since their "winnings" came at the expense of the whole country being the stakes, I still fucking well want to know. Because frankly at this length of time, even Dusty Bin would have been a better prize than the literal flood of shit we are being washed in daily.

This is not a serious argument vis a vis Parliamentary Sovereignty!

Parliament showed its own Sovereignty by voting FOR the electorate to be able to vote on EU membership.

And AGAIN when Parliament voted to honour the result.

And AGAIN when Parliament was unconstitutionally prorogued!

Then you off on a tangent unrelated to the question of Parliamentary Sovereignty!

Jesus wept. 🤦‍♂️