Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 08:27

I get the feeling the OP thinks that the only ones who should be allowed to vote are the people that agree with her views on everything. smdh

I think you’re right. If Labour win the next election I wonder if there will still be posts on here requiring a passed test before candidates can vote.

PriOn1 · 02/09/2023 05:19

I think our current “democratic” system is partly failing because of capitalism and the fact that money is generally needed and used to buy power.

It’s bad enough in the UK, but look particularly at the US leadership competitions. What are the genuine chances that a small group of the same families have all the best leaders, for example? Two Bushes? Two Clintons?

Democracy is the least worst we’ve seen. Some means of completely random selection, as others have outlined, might be better, but it’s a huge change. Equally, doing away with political parties and making all candidates independent might improve things, though the only way to find out would be to try. You’d still probably end up with men hugely over represented though, and various minorities underrepresented, so some problems would continue.

But I suspect the main problem with our current version of democracy is that those who seek power and have the money to do so are not necessarily those who are best suited to have it and they are certainly not representative of everyone.

Nanaof1 · 02/09/2023 05:04

BibbleandSqwauk · 27/08/2023 06:56

I get where the OP is coming from...the ignorance of many adults around some basic facts of economics and even what each party really stands for is shocking. Maybe at some absolutely basic level prior to a GE there should be some form of mandatory online quiz with a pass mark before you can participate (could also be done on paper at local libraries etc to facilitate inclusion). We don't let people drive a car if they can't read road signs and master the controls... but we just assume that an 18yo has certain understanding of political issues. I teach them ..many don't have a clue. 😳

So, if "those people" are not smart enough to pass the quiz and vote, then they should also be exempt from paying any taxes or fees. Only the voters pay for everything, the rest get a free pass. Because, if they don't get to have a choice, they shouldn't be responsible to pay for other's choices.

I get the feeling the OP thinks that the only ones who should be allowed to vote are the people that agree with her views on everything. smdh

1dayatatime · 01/09/2023 22:51

Many Chinese not only don’t believe that democracy is necessary for economic success but do believe that their form of government is legitimate and effective
In addition China views Western democracies as in decay and are happily supporting authoritarian regimes around the world.

Reading through some of these posts I think they may have a point.

1dayatatime · 01/09/2023 22:45

@Barbadossunset

We do have an issue that manifestos are not followed when a party is in government.

Thats a good point. To all those posters advocating reading up on the plans of each party before the election - what if you like the idea of what they are proposing and then they don’t do it?
How are people to know which manifesto promises will happen and which won’t?"

+++
But to be fair politicians have to lie in manifestos or at least make the promises so vague ("improve education" "fix the NHS" etc ) to be measured, in order to become politicians in the first place.

Look if there two candidates A and B.
Candidate A promises to spend more on education and the NHS but it will mean tax rises.
Candidate B promises to spend more on education and the NHS but will get the money from "growing the economy" / "cutting waste" / "closing tax loopholes" etc etc.

Which one do you think will get elected? So when B does get elected and finds they can't get the money needed they then fail to deliver on their manifesto promises.

So the reason politicians lie is that democracy means they have to in order to get elected.

Albioncreed · 01/09/2023 22:15

110APiccadilly · 27/08/2023 07:04

I've long thought something like this might be a good replacement for the House of Lords.

This would be a fantastic replacement for the house of lords

SerendipityJane · 01/09/2023 21:24

Thing is, you can't expect people to be interested enough in all that stuff to bother trying to learn a bit. It's just not realistic.

So the next best thing is to trust those that are interested in all that stuff and accept their knowledge.

The fundamental problem here is the lack of trust. And that's not an accidental situation. It's deliberately engineered to allow demagoguery to triumph.

EffortlessDesmond · 01/09/2023 21:21

It's called polarisation @Kendodd . And it is getting worse, not healing over. Mea culpa, I did not foresee the endless rancour that would follow the 2016 referendum. I used to think that the inventiveness ( and imho, we are really good at inventive) of Britain would be freed to do better.

The UK was a seriously important member of the EU. The UK was more open to new ideas. We wrote and developed many of the basic protocols; Europol is completely based on Interpol, created by the UK between the two wold wars. The basic food hygiene technology and and handling rules. Massive amounts of the health and safety code originated in the UK. Maternity rights. The UK's NMW and living wage rates are at the top of the European league, even since leaving, because the rest have not kept up. The UK has been shockingly bad at claiming all the credit it should be due.

Kendodd · 01/09/2023 20:37

SerendipityJane · 31/08/2023 07:30

The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

It very much is a reflection of real life though. If it were limited to politics it would be worrying. Luckily it extends across science, medicine, technology, arithmetic and statistics.

Thing is, you can't expect people to be interested enough in all that stuff to bother trying to learn a bit. It's just not realistic. What really gets me is complete know nothings, spouting bollocks and dismissing the knowledge of experts as if somehow they know better about economics and world trade that Pascal Lamy. I remember, during the EU referendum, the views of experts dismissed with a wave of the hand because 'they're all remainers' hmm... why would that be I wonder?

TizerorFizz · 31/08/2023 23:36

@Blossomtoes
I meant in a historical sense. Stalin and others. Intolerance of others on a grand scale usually means numerous deaths within the dissident population.

BIossomtoes · 31/08/2023 22:08

It’s never OK. Obviously. 🙄

Barbadossunset · 31/08/2023 22:07

We do agree that it’s intolerance and fascism by another name.

What about intolerance and communism, or is that ok?

PlipPlopChoo · 31/08/2023 22:06

Yes, when you consider the amount of morons in the population, you're correct

Yes this first comment nails it.

BIossomtoes · 31/08/2023 21:32

Barbadossunset · 31/08/2023 21:27

Maybe Tizer means voters with wrong views.

They don’t stand a chance when highly respected politicians are thrown overboard. We do agree that it’s intolerance and fascism by another name.

Barbadossunset · 31/08/2023 21:27

BIossomtoes · 31/08/2023 21:25

Isn’t that what Johnson did in 2019? The casualties included Churchill’s grandson and a former chancellor.

Maybe Tizer means voters with wrong views.

BIossomtoes · 31/08/2023 21:25

TizerorFizz · 31/08/2023 20:12

Next step is usually to get rid of the people with the “wrong” views.

Isn’t that what Johnson did in 2019? The casualties included Churchill’s grandson and a former chancellor.

TizerorFizz · 31/08/2023 20:12

Next step is usually to get rid of the people with the “wrong” views.

Barbadossunset · 31/08/2023 17:07

It’s intolerance and fascism by another name.

Of course it is, but maybe that’s acceptable to some when the wrong politicians are voted in by people with wrong views.

FarEast · 31/08/2023 16:45

SerendipityJane · 31/08/2023 07:30

The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

It very much is a reflection of real life though. If it were limited to politics it would be worrying. Luckily it extends across science, medicine, technology, arithmetic and statistics.

Sadly, yes @SerendipityJane The great Victorian reformers who revolutionised public education (particularly in the 1870 Education Act) might be quite disappointed to see that the precious resource of education offered to everyone is so debased by most citizens.

But still no reason to allow people like me (very highly educated and widely read) to determine who should be allowed to vote. It’s intolerance and fascism by another name.

TizerorFizz · 31/08/2023 16:44

@Barbadossunset They don’t. That’s why we get voters not voting for a party because they don’t like or like the leader, just respond to 3 word slogans (Get Brexit Done) and various other likes and dislikes which might or might not be linked to policies. Most people pick a few reasons to vote for a party and rarely it’s the quality of the potential MP who will represent them. We have moved, by stealth, to a presidential election where the leader means everything. The Conservatives realised this and foisted Johnson on us.

Even now, less than exciting Starmer could struggle. Too many people want a big personality for PM. Hopefully more want a safer pair of hands but it’s difficult to read voting instincts at times.

Barbadossunset · 31/08/2023 11:36

We do have an issue that manifestos are not followed when a party is in government.

Thats a good point. To all those posters advocating reading up on the plans of each party before the election - what if you like the idea of what they are proposing and then they don’t do it?
How are people to know which manifesto promises will happen and which won’t?

TizerorFizz · 31/08/2023 11:28

We do have an issue that manifestos are not followed when a party is in government. There’s not enough money, unforeseen issues arise, it was a poor policy in the first place, world events take over, we have an immediate crisis etc. So voters don’t always trust any party. It’s naive to think any party can do everything they say. It’s why many people vote with a few policies in mind. Or general gut persuasion because of generational beliefs. So knowing policies is pretty rare and often discounted.

The argument for staying in the EU was complex. It could not beat the simplistic reaction: too many Europeans here, too much interference and too costly. Some voters saw “sovereignty” as more important than trading ease. They didn’t understand trade and it was discussed in a fog of rhetoric. So hard to explain.

Angrycat2768 · 31/08/2023 08:56

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 23:40

"Representative democracy is a form of democracy in which people vote for representatives who then vote on policy initiatives; as opposed to direct democracy, a form of democracy in which people vote on policy initiatives directly."

surely a representative democracy functions best if all members vote for x candidate or party based on detailed understanding of what that party stands for, rather than oh I voted x party but didn't realise they advocate x.

Of course it does. But the problem is how you enforce it. In an ideal world, yes, everyone who votes will have an interest in who they are voting for. But all you do by putting a test in place is exclude people. Probably those lacking education in general, who will tend to be the poorest and most vulnerable in society.
We can see already that those who vote ( the elderly) have the most power. We have governments who are willing to let the young suffer in the future for the sake of short term electoral gain. It is clear that all that will happen is that the 'tests' ( set by whom? ) will weed out the most expensive- people with low educational attainment are more likely to need benefits, have low paying jobs, be in need of health and social care, be long term unemployed- and cater for those who are interested in politics. It is far better to change the voting system to make it more representative and have compulsory voting than exclude more people. Compulsory voting may force people to do a bit of research. They will be forced to get off their butts and go to the polling booth under threat of a fine, so a few may decide they may as well have a look at who to vote for.

SerendipityJane · 31/08/2023 07:30

The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

It very much is a reflection of real life though. If it were limited to politics it would be worrying. Luckily it extends across science, medicine, technology, arithmetic and statistics.

Hawkins0090 · 30/08/2023 23:40

FarEast · 30/08/2023 22:25

It's just when people are giving the choice of voting on complex issues for parties in the General election, or e.g. Brexit but then they afterwards realise what a mistake it was, and then when you discuss with friends or people you know and they say oh newspaper x was saying y so I voted for that party, or we need our own trade deals, based on newspapers M,

So what? What if I said that you couldn't vote because of your "bad" opinions? (Such as not believing every voter has an equal vote).

Some of the ignorance and lack of thinking on this thread is downright scary. The lack of understanding of the history & theory of British representative democracy is depressing.

"Representative democracy is a form of democracy in which people vote for representatives who then vote on policy initiatives; as opposed to direct democracy, a form of democracy in which people vote on policy initiatives directly."

surely a representative democracy functions best if all members vote for x candidate or party based on detailed understanding of what that party stands for, rather than oh I voted x party but didn't realise they advocate x.

Swipe left for the next trending thread