Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
guzzleandstuff · 27/08/2023 09:02

So the natural inference of that is that the public know the tories are self interested and immoral. But continue to want them to govern regardless. Therefore it’s the public who actually seem to want corruption, right wing politics and a government who uses the power for their own gain

OR - the natural inference is that despite people paying lip service to "we want equality for all", or whatever, what they actually vote for is what works best for them or what they really think will keep society strong and safe. (I'm not saying they are right/ wrong I'm just saying people don't always vote for what they say they will)

MadeleineMummy · 27/08/2023 08:57

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

What we need are a panel of experts such as Boris Johnson, Farridge, Gove, Rees-Mogg and Dorries (a good mix of public school and old school self-serving working class Tories who want to kick the ladder from beneath them) as our rulers. They should form a dictatorship and tell the little people what to do. It would be good to have a biased media and an uneducated electorate that votes every 4 years based on vague slogans or better still never votes at all, which gives the semblance of democracy but really allows the establishment to ride roughshod over the populace. Then have an offshore billionaire media that sucks up to them or better still diverts issues of poor governance towards the most vulnerable in society such as benefit claimants, single-mothers, feckless youth and asylum seekers.

seems such an ideal system.

Jamtartforme · 27/08/2023 08:53

It's those voted in by democratic process then using that power for their own gain and not the good of the electorate that are the issue.

This makes no sense at all.

The conservative government have showed who they are time and time again, and yet they continue to be voted in by the public - Boris Johnson got a huge majority.

So the natural inference of that is that the public know the tories are self interested and immoral. But continue to want them to govern regardless. Therefore it’s the public who actually seem to want corruption, right wing politics and a government who uses the power for their own gain.

It’s fashionable to make out the government are like Skynet, that they just came out of nowhere to impose their regime on us, so we should ‘get angry with the government not each other’. But it’s ‘each other’ who put them there.

KnickerlessParsons · 27/08/2023 08:44

Sparklesocks · 27/08/2023 05:08

Surely it’s a slippery slope to categorise which members of society should or shouldn’t be allowed to vote? As vile as racism/sexism/homophobia etc is, it’s not necessarily easy to weed out which viewpoints should bar you from voting.

White male property owners over the age of 35 surely?
(Joke, before people pile in).

Hawkins009 · 27/08/2023 08:43

It's a mix of perspectives

sashagabadon · 27/08/2023 08:41

We actually have an excellent system of governance here in U.K. imo. A democratically elected chamber representing the whole U.K. with an official opposition meant to challenge the government of the day. ( currently the Labour Party)
an unelected House of Lords in theory at least made up of experts in their fields or others that have served the country well and a constitutional monarchy as head of state plus an agressive ( often too aggressive imo and too partisan) media.
and it mostly works.
it failed somewhat during covid I think as all these groups did not challenge lockdowns enough ( media in particular) and went along with the status quo in-fact the official opposition wanted more lockdown but that’s an argument for another day!

Poppysmom22 · 27/08/2023 08:32

So people who don't fit with your ideology should not get a vote. Hmmmmmm where have we seen that before?

MorePressureMoreRelease · 27/08/2023 08:26

If we want a society where the most effective long term decisions are made, which will benefit that society for generations to come then the democracy that we have is not the best model. It doesn't allow for long term planning and is dependent on the vagaries of a largely uneducated on the issues population.

If we want a society that reflects they way humanity is and operates generally (ie short term, knee jerk & emotional) then it's pretty good.

Some sort of benevolent dictatorship would probably be best for us all. Just need to find a non despotic dictator candidate....

Ibetthatyoulookgoodon · 27/08/2023 07:58

PretzelKnot · 27/08/2023 03:48

Like Winston Churchill said, “democracy is the worst form of government – except for all the others that have been tried.”

Came here to say this!

yeah, you can pick holes in it but it doesn’t need to be perfect to be the best option we have.

itsgettingweird · 27/08/2023 07:52

Democracy isn't the issue.

It's those voted in by democratic process then using that power for their own gain and not the good of the electorate that are the issue.

It's the fact that the electorate don't fight against those bad decisions enough.

Currently we have a government that have removed our rights to protest and limited right to strike and I'm totally against that as being democratic. If the country is being run by people for the people then protest and strike wouldn't be the norm.

I think a big issue of proportional representation. It doesn't honestly represent the will of the electorate and means that limited areas get improvements during election time to sway the votes and other areas always lose out because their vote won't really swing a GE.

We need democracy. But we need a better democratic process.

Raquelos · 27/08/2023 07:52

I wouldn't mind a system where a minimum level of knowledge was required to vote. After all democracy works best when the electorate is well informed and engaged. That's why the ownership of the press by those with specific interests and misinformation peddled on the Internet is so damaging.

Hecate01 · 27/08/2023 07:22

You lost me at "yet my vote counts as much as someone". YABVU and seem to have a high opinion of yourself.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 07:17

I’m with majority yabu

I’d be more concerned about people who think their view should carry more weight in a vote

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 07:15

I think it’s more our combative style where left and right take opposing positions. So extreme!

However I heard Ken Clarke saying this was the best method as one holds the other to account -and as I’m in Scotland and see what a mess a one party dominated Gov can make I think I agree.

Apparently a coalition Gov can just argue and nothing gets done.

CurlewKate · 27/08/2023 07:12

Democracy is the worst form of government-apart from all the others, as someone said.

110APiccadilly · 27/08/2023 07:08

The thing is, OP, I bet you also hold at least one view that many people would disqualify you for. Your system simply doesn't work, because whoever gets to choose the electors is also a fallible human, with biases and prejudices. And if you yourself think you are above bias and prejudice, all you are is not very self aware. No one is free from these things entirely.

110APiccadilly · 27/08/2023 07:04

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 27/08/2023 07:01

I don't like this idea, but I did wonder if a system similar to jury service would work. No elected MPs, instead every adult is eligible to be called up to serve as a member of parliament representing the area they live in for a period of, say, five years.

Your job or business would be protected whilst you serve, and you're paid a basic, modest salary and provided accommodation whilst away from home. You can defer, if it's really bad timing, or have yourself declared exempt if there's a very good reason why you can never serve; but otherwise, off you go and serve your country.

Once you've served, you can be called up again, and you go back to your normal life afterwards - so the decisions you've helped make whilst you serve are ones you personally will have to live with the consequences of.

I do wonder if that might be a better system.

I've long thought something like this might be a good replacement for the House of Lords.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 27/08/2023 07:03

This should read: once you've served, you can never be called up again."

Why don't we get the edit function on the app?!

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 27/08/2023 07:01

TrishM80 · 27/08/2023 01:48

Yes, when you consider the amount of morons in the population, you're correct.

The best govt would be a panel of highly intelligent, highly educated experts in their respective fields who wouldn't have to worry about the vagaries of not being elected by Bazza and Sharon from Clacton.

I don't like this idea, but I did wonder if a system similar to jury service would work. No elected MPs, instead every adult is eligible to be called up to serve as a member of parliament representing the area they live in for a period of, say, five years.

Your job or business would be protected whilst you serve, and you're paid a basic, modest salary and provided accommodation whilst away from home. You can defer, if it's really bad timing, or have yourself declared exempt if there's a very good reason why you can never serve; but otherwise, off you go and serve your country.

Once you've served, you can be called up again, and you go back to your normal life afterwards - so the decisions you've helped make whilst you serve are ones you personally will have to live with the consequences of.

I do wonder if that might be a better system.

BibbleandSqwauk · 27/08/2023 06:56

I get where the OP is coming from...the ignorance of many adults around some basic facts of economics and even what each party really stands for is shocking. Maybe at some absolutely basic level prior to a GE there should be some form of mandatory online quiz with a pass mark before you can participate (could also be done on paper at local libraries etc to facilitate inclusion). We don't let people drive a car if they can't read road signs and master the controls... but we just assume that an 18yo has certain understanding of political issues. I teach them ..many don't have a clue. 😳

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 27/08/2023 06:47

You need a free and independent press too - in Danish the press is called the watchdog of democracy.

Newrumpus · 27/08/2023 06:35

YAB totally U.

Breezycheesetrees · 27/08/2023 05:55

I do kind of agree with you OP. I think the other side of democracy needs to be an engaged, literate, well-educated populace, and maybe you don't "deserve" to participate unless you're going to uphold your end of the deal. It also needs a genuinely free media though, which is not able to be exploited by those in power to achieve their own agendas. Without those things (engaged electorate, free press) you get a shit-show like Brexit.

Unfortunately though, as others have pointed out, any system which regulated democratic participation based on competence would be undemocratic and open to abuse.

curaçao · 27/08/2023 05:47

Who gets to choose which opinion s are more valid .You seem to be assuming you would be one of those judged as fit to vote.What if you weren't? Would you still support your system?