Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
bellac11 · 27/08/2023 09:49

mdinbc · 27/08/2023 05:20

I think this is why education is so important.

You run down a slippery slope when deciding who is fit to make decisions about leadership. If not democracy, then what do you suggest; back to monarchy assisted by well-educated, land owning lords?

Doesnt that depend on who's doing the educating?

MadeleineMummy · 27/08/2023 09:48

milkandbread · 27/08/2023 09:04

We do have a good form of government however (yes, that old chestnut) what I think is that; to qualify to vote, you need to be a net taxpayer. So, not all taxpayers have the vote - just those who pay in more than they receive from the government/local council at that point in time.

If the country is like one big household, only those who currently contribute to the household income get to vote on total household policy reflected in spend allocation, when votes are needed.

It also doesn't exclude anyone from voting (unless at no point in your life you contribute to the household income.)

If you are a dependant you can give your opinion but (just like in personal households) you can't have a say in how the household money is spent.

There are millions in this (country) household, so individual opinions and wishes are taken into account but the most practical decisions are made, taking into account the needs of the vulnerable, young and old as much as possible.

It's what we as parents do, every month and every year - as head of our own households - balancing the books and trying to do the best for the long term security of the family as a whole, even if it means disappointing a family member from time to time on specific wishes or interests.

So students who will come into the workforce at some point in the future should not have a stake in how policy that will impact them in the future?

so people who are made redundant should not have a say in government?

what about all the undesirables such as recent arrival, the simple minded, the old, the young, the secret cabal of internationalists who want a world government and control society from the shadows, the disabled, the long term sick and all the other subhumans who should only be dictated to rather than have a say in how things are run? Why not go back to a society where only the landowners can vote and women who just do simple things and don’t really work but just do the housework and bring up children should try and persuade their husbands as to which government they should vote for but really should not worry their pretty little heads with the complicated notions of politics, economics and the gold standard and leave that to their betters who really pay the bills. After all women are just leeches and live on their husband’s income so they should be treated like children and not really have a say in how the government affects them.

No dear, society is not like a household.

KimberleyClark · 27/08/2023 09:45

Democracy is the best form of government, but FPTP is probably the worst way of electing one.

Boomboom22 · 27/08/2023 09:39

Democracy is short termist and does allow all to vote. But you do sound a bit like a tra, no debate you are right with no practicalities sorted. Which is often typical of the left, those on the right tend to be more pragmatic and willing to compromise for the longer term good, traditionally anyway maybe not now.
Interesting that Rachel reeves is going around saying Labour would keep most policies, not raise taxes, use the barge etc for migrants, so to win Labour have to basically meet Johnson type promises. He was very central one nation tory not right in the party by any means.

Spendonsend · 27/08/2023 09:36

Isnt the saying thats its the best of all the alternatives.

I think the issue with uk democracy is we dont have the best system of seperatung powers between houses and judicuary and we have an indirectly elected pm who energes from a party with most votes, plus a hereditary head of state. With first past the post on constituencies. It always fascinates me how the governing party can have 30 odd percent of the votes.

Not sure what Id go for though. Lots of different structures of democracy and voting systems out there.

Malarandras · 27/08/2023 09:30

And who decides what opinions are correct?

Also governance is about decision making processes and frameworks and how to govern an organisation. It is not about government. The two are different things.

Natsku · 27/08/2023 09:29

Benevolent dictatorship would be best, but no dictator is going to stay benevolent for long with all that corrupting power, so it would only ever be good for a little while.

Jamtartforme · 27/08/2023 09:28

itsgettingweird · 27/08/2023 09:07

See I disagree with this.

The current government (as an example) are not governing off a mandate or elected PM.

That was Johnson. His manifesto was about levelling up, green policies etc.

These have been scrapped and the latest is the India deal gives a who,e host of cash to Sunak wife's family company for the visas.

Ok, Johnson was a self serving lying disaster. But he was what was voted in. Not Truss or Sunak. And the fact the polls have swung since partygate and these leaders show that the voting system does work in some way. As in they voted Johnson and not the Tory's as a whole.

Yes, you'll get people who will always be completely partisan to a particular party but I know so many people - like me - who are centric and swing voters.

What happened for Tory's to get in was a promise of levelling up in areas (which they never then did) that got them a big vote because of the first past the post system.

I doubt the public could explain the intricacies of Johnson’s policies versus Sunak’s.

I think they simply wanted Brexit and right wing politics, and see Labour as the party of immigrants and the work shy.

This whole ‘they want us to be arguing with each other so we don’t focus on them’ is a bit cringey and makes no sense for that reason. If you want a change of government you have to persuade voters, not the government, so ‘arguing with each other’ is the best thing to happen really

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/08/2023 09:24

sheworemellowyellow · 27/08/2023 03:49

Is that you, Jacob (Rees-Mogg)?

You fundamentally misunderstand what government is. It’s a representation of the society you live in, all of it.

The views and examples would argue that OP is very far from ‘right wing’ .

TLDRfuckers · 27/08/2023 09:24

Many people who voted for “brexit” feel the government didn’t deliver the brexit they voted for so that is a poor example to use.

Saying that people are voting for the “right wing” tories is another poor example as many people feel the Tory party is not in fact a right wing party.

like everything it’s all subjective and one person’s idea of the “lowest common denominator” will differ from yours OP.

TaniaBania · 27/08/2023 09:23

Couldn’t disagree more, OP, and find your position a bit scary. “My opinion should count for more because I’m right” is both illogical and the first step towards autocracy. Despots throughout the ages have justified tyranny on the basis that they know what’s best for the people they rule.

There are lots of problems with democracy, certainly. One protection against them is the modern human rights regime which seeks to treat some rights as so fundamental as to be outside the vagaries of democracy, by making them matters of international agreement and (in some jurisdictions, not the UK) entrenching them constitutionally. This is a much better solution than arguing that people with the “right” views get more of a say (although a critic might argue that it’s effectively the same thing).

RedToothBrush · 27/08/2023 09:22

The counter argument to this is always:

So what system do you think is better?

In truth no system is better. Democracy is the least flawed.

Other options are worse. Much worse.

And not all democracies are equal - there are lots of different forms and different levels of corruption going on.

Justcallmebebes · 27/08/2023 09:21

Threenow · 27/08/2023 04:25

And who is going to decide just who is "fit" to vote? Who is going to decide just who "the lowest common demoninator" is? Based on your OP I wouldn't think you fit to vote.

This. Who decides? Based on your post OP, you're a classist bigot, so that's you struck off for a start

queenMab99 · 27/08/2023 09:20

All forms of government seem to become corrupt in the end, even if the original motives are good, so democracy is the least harmful. However the power is always unbalanced, and tends to swing too far one way and then the other, with our first past the post method, but proportional voting seems to lead to stagnation.

Threenow · 27/08/2023 09:18

I agree that first-past-the-post is a terrible system and can't understand why the UK clings to it.

guzzleandstuff · 27/08/2023 09:18

@rampagingrobot - this is completely true

rampagingrobot · 27/08/2023 09:17

There are many forms of democracy.
Our first-past-the-post parliamentary system with an appointed, unelected second chamber (house of lords) is a terrible system.

Most votes are irrelevant, so people are disengaged, and it greatly benefits the existing party that is already in power.

You don't need to replace democracy with an autocratic one party system like China, just fix our electoral system so every vote actually counts.

guzzleandstuff · 27/08/2023 09:12

No system is perfect though

guzzleandstuff · 27/08/2023 09:11

sashagabadon · 27/08/2023 08:41

We actually have an excellent system of governance here in U.K. imo. A democratically elected chamber representing the whole U.K. with an official opposition meant to challenge the government of the day. ( currently the Labour Party)
an unelected House of Lords in theory at least made up of experts in their fields or others that have served the country well and a constitutional monarchy as head of state plus an agressive ( often too aggressive imo and too partisan) media.
and it mostly works.
it failed somewhat during covid I think as all these groups did not challenge lockdowns enough ( media in particular) and went along with the status quo in-fact the official opposition wanted more lockdown but that’s an argument for another day!

@sashagabadon I agree although it's not fashionable to agree. If you abolish the monarchy and the HoLords decisions are only made by the MPs. And our PM becomes our Head of State with all the associated power and status. I'd actually like to see a third set of representatives in Parliament along the lines of what someone mentioned upthread - like jury service - with people selected for five years only and representing small businesses, Trades Unions, Teachers, Doctors, Farmers, Council Tenants, Mothers, Pensioners, Students, Apprentices, retailers, etc etc. People who didn't have to pander to voters as they would never be re-elected but who would give another insight and level of power to decision making. And a much more sold, less corrupt Local Council system.

LovelyQuiche · 27/08/2023 09:10

If the “lowest common denominator” isn’t represented then does that mean they should get out of paying tax?

madroid · 27/08/2023 09:07

@milkandbread
I'm glad I'm not your dependent

Oh and before anyone suggests abolishing the H of Lords, you might reflect on the fact that they are the only people holding this govt's appalling legislative record to any kind of account or standard. The Lords are the only people insisting that law should actually be workable and not just politicising sloganeering put into a legal language.

itsgettingweird · 27/08/2023 09:07

Jamtartforme · 27/08/2023 08:53

It's those voted in by democratic process then using that power for their own gain and not the good of the electorate that are the issue.

This makes no sense at all.

The conservative government have showed who they are time and time again, and yet they continue to be voted in by the public - Boris Johnson got a huge majority.

So the natural inference of that is that the public know the tories are self interested and immoral. But continue to want them to govern regardless. Therefore it’s the public who actually seem to want corruption, right wing politics and a government who uses the power for their own gain.

It’s fashionable to make out the government are like Skynet, that they just came out of nowhere to impose their regime on us, so we should ‘get angry with the government not each other’. But it’s ‘each other’ who put them there.

See I disagree with this.

The current government (as an example) are not governing off a mandate or elected PM.

That was Johnson. His manifesto was about levelling up, green policies etc.

These have been scrapped and the latest is the India deal gives a who,e host of cash to Sunak wife's family company for the visas.

Ok, Johnson was a self serving lying disaster. But he was what was voted in. Not Truss or Sunak. And the fact the polls have swung since partygate and these leaders show that the voting system does work in some way. As in they voted Johnson and not the Tory's as a whole.

Yes, you'll get people who will always be completely partisan to a particular party but I know so many people - like me - who are centric and swing voters.

What happened for Tory's to get in was a promise of levelling up in areas (which they never then did) that got them a big vote because of the first past the post system.

PurpleChrayne · 27/08/2023 09:06

I lived in a communist dictatorship for a decade and people seemed a lot happier, to be honest. It was only the encroachment of western democratic ideals that started to tarnish it.

milkandbread · 27/08/2023 09:04

We do have a good form of government however (yes, that old chestnut) what I think is that; to qualify to vote, you need to be a net taxpayer. So, not all taxpayers have the vote - just those who pay in more than they receive from the government/local council at that point in time.

If the country is like one big household, only those who currently contribute to the household income get to vote on total household policy reflected in spend allocation, when votes are needed.

It also doesn't exclude anyone from voting (unless at no point in your life you contribute to the household income.)

If you are a dependant you can give your opinion but (just like in personal households) you can't have a say in how the household money is spent.

There are millions in this (country) household, so individual opinions and wishes are taken into account but the most practical decisions are made, taking into account the needs of the vulnerable, young and old as much as possible.

It's what we as parents do, every month and every year - as head of our own households - balancing the books and trying to do the best for the long term security of the family as a whole, even if it means disappointing a family member from time to time on specific wishes or interests.

madroid · 27/08/2023 09:02

If not democracy, then what do you suggest; back to monarchy assisted by well-educated, land owning lords?

I'm not so sure that we're are really that far away from this even though we have a universal franchise.

While there's a monarchy we will never have a true meritocracy. Power and wealth will remain concentrated in the hands of the privately educated, landed gentry and titled. They may be more subtle about it now, but it's still there. Very few challenge it.