Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 12:07

Sometimes just putting the brakes on and give something a chance before deciding it’s not working , might be a better thing to try.

I quite agree. I mean we never really gave slavery a chance did we ?

The most dangerous attitude in anything is "We've always done it this way". Mainly because it's the exact reason it can take generations to eliminate social evils.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 12:06

Hawkins009 · 27/08/2023 12:00

But if some people take the time to actually study the different policies etc and vote accordingly and the general mass that votes on a few newspaper headlines as an example.

How can that be for the greater good of the country if the majority just vote based on the newspaper headlines ?

The bigger the pool of people you deliberately disenfranchise based on intelligence, for example....the more unstable a State will become.

And the more likely political violence will follow.

Hence, the widening of the voting franchise from 1918 onwards.

Yoghurtpotsatdawn · 27/08/2023 12:05

I think getting less done is sometimes a good thing and can lead to stability. Different policies being introduced quickly and lurching from one idea to the next without those ideas being questioned is disastrous at times

I agree, within reason. When the government gets desperate, they introduce one ill-thought idea and policy after another. This leads to absolute chaos, with barely any time for civil servants and the public to get their heads round one thing, before that is kicked to the kerb, and something new is put in its place. Sometimes just putting the breaks on and give something a chance before deciding it’s not working , might be a better thing to try.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 12:03

Baconisdelicious · 27/08/2023 11:46

So what you really want is to exclude people who don’t think like you? Who says your views are the right ones?

In one.

OP is a Scottish Nationalist and, from their post, I would take it they want Unionists obstructed by such a policy. Especially as their common retort to them is along the lines of "Yooouuuu Tttttooooaaaarrrryyyyy!".

One rather suspects this given the SNP independence train has come off its rails in the last few months with the latest being SNP is almost a million quid in debt.

Democracy isn't going to go back to an exclusive pool of people in our lifetime, so that's a non-starter.

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 12:01

Threenow · 27/08/2023 04:25

And who is going to decide just who is "fit" to vote? Who is going to decide just who "the lowest common demoninator" is? Based on your OP I wouldn't think you fit to vote.

This. It is the main issue. Who decides who is suitable? 100 years ago men were thought to be the only suitable boters. Before that, only the Upper Class. Maybe we should have government by robot but even AI has biases based on previous biases. What would maybe work would be to have a decent voting system ( but that often means that the racists get representation that they don't under FPTP) but also send the entire House of Lords into the dustbin if history and start again with far fewer ( say 100 rather than 800) people who are experts in various areas of life to sit for 10-15 years.

Hawkins009 · 27/08/2023 12:00

Uterusbegone · 27/08/2023 11:41

I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic

Yeah, but that's no different to what people who believe in conspiracy theories say. Some people believe that watching TikTok and YouTube qualifies them as having learned about a topic, even if the videos are made by some complete random who has no actual idea what they are talking about

Besides your idea very much smacks of 'all animals are equal but some are more equal than others'. How long until 'the chosen voters' vote for things that only benefit themselves? It's human nature, very few people will take a purely altruistic stance and vote against their own best interests

Absolutely terrible idea OP, but then one look at your username shows us your agenda here

But if some people take the time to actually study the different policies etc and vote accordingly and the general mass that votes on a few newspaper headlines as an example.

How can that be for the greater good of the country if the majority just vote based on the newspaper headlines ?

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 11:57

Voters complain that all politicians are liars but it's the voters that deliberately choose to vote for the liars.

Let's take two candidates A and B.
A says they will increase Gov spending on health, education, pensions etc but not by putting up taxes because they will get the money from some promise of economic growth or cutting waste or closing loopholes etc.
B says that they will increase Government spending but only by putting up everyone's taxes.

Guess who gets to be elected and which one gets to be a politician. A becomes a politician then the economic growth doesn't happen or the savings from cutting waste or closing loopholes is insufficient to fund the promises they made.

Politicians have to lie in order to get elected by the electorate in order to become politicians.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 11:56

Ylvamoon · 27/08/2023 11:51

🤔 Long live the King! Anyone?

No system of government is entirely safe or able to keep the corrupt and power hungry at bay.

Sortition ?

KitchenSinkLlama · 27/08/2023 11:56

Of course democracy is the best form of governance. What we have in this country isn't truly democratic with FPTP. Proportional representation is fairer.

We also need to have more open and transparent selection of potential MP's, no second jobs for MP's, all parties to be funded by the state and donations banned, lying to parliament made a crime and immediate removal from office. We are governed by a party of self serving charlatans but we can't do anything about it until they call a GE. The speaker should be able to dissolve Parliament and call a GE if the party in power are so obviously corrupt (there would have to be certain stages to go through to achieve this obviously.)

Sadly none of this is likely to happen.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 11:55

rampagingrobot · 27/08/2023 09:17

There are many forms of democracy.
Our first-past-the-post parliamentary system with an appointed, unelected second chamber (house of lords) is a terrible system.

Most votes are irrelevant, so people are disengaged, and it greatly benefits the existing party that is already in power.

You don't need to replace democracy with an autocratic one party system like China, just fix our electoral system so every vote actually counts.

It's a better system than that which exists in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland since none of them have a second chamber to object to pieces of legislation.

This is most damaging in Scotland where a minority SNP administration propped up by the Greens (list vote) can push things through too easily. The Presiding Officer often doesn't do their job correctly, e.g. when SNP/Greens tabled legislation that is so unconstitutional the UK Supreme Court then has to be dragged into it.

A second debating chamber would deal with that.

I rather suspect the OP is objecting to democracy because the SNP independence project is in trouble. They'd rather Scottish Unionists weren't able to vote against their objective.

No, the system as it stands works. The saying is "Don't let perfect be the enemy of good". The Americans tried that and their constitution is so convoluted that it can result in gridlock where little gets done.

Not to mention the potential problems with the current campaigns for the Presidency in 2024.

Ours isn't perfect, but it works and Westminster remains the Supreme Legislator and Sovereign Power. Attempts to alter that will also breach the Belfast Agreement which we're told is sacrosanct despite the fact it was already amended in 2007. 🤦‍♂️

Under international law, the sovereign power is supreme.

Ascendant15 · 27/08/2023 11:55

daisychain01 · 27/08/2023 05:17

Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

Who's "we" in your system? Who'll do the choosing? Who gets to say what's acceptable and what's not valid?

you may not like democracy but don't throw the baby out with the bath water or we could end up being governed by the Taliban, a Communist regime or a Fascist Junta. Hmm not so clever huh?

A "Communist regime" is no more communist - politically speaking - than parliamentary "democracy" is the model for democracy. If you go to Marxist ideology, then the theory is "perfect democracy". What some people may make it is as representative as the UK or the US being representative of government "by the people for the people".

Yes, when you consider the amount of morons in the population, you're correct.

The best govt would be a panel of highly intelligent, highly educated experts in their respective fields who wouldn't have to worry about the vagaries of not being elected by Bazza and Sharon from Clacton.

Interesting that you (presumably not a moron) know nothing at all about Bazza and Sharon from Clacton, who happen to both be educated to PhD level. Bazza is a world-renowned physicist whose parents came to the UK as refugees from Yeman. Sharon was an engineer, but is now the MP for the area and is a rising star likely to become a minister one day - her main interests in poltics are healthcare, employment and training for disadvantaged communities, and improving facilities for reproductive rights. They'd both love to meet you but they don't mix with bigots....

Ylvamoon · 27/08/2023 11:51

🤔 Long live the King! Anyone?

No system of government is entirely safe or able to keep the corrupt and power hungry at bay.

poetryandwine · 27/08/2023 11:49

@PretzelKnot and more importantly Winston Churchill got it right.

But I share what I take to be your concerns OP, that too many are seduced by slogans and ready to cede their right and their duty to think when someone promises to look out for them. No matter how ridiculous the promise, or how harmful to the greater society. It is terrible and I am afraid.

kirbykirby · 27/08/2023 11:47

"Shazza" from Clacton, is far less dangerous than Theodore from Hampstead. Sounds just like a thinly veiled attack on the working classes. The really dangerous people are the upper and middle classes who like to think they know what is best for everyone else and want to impose it with force. As we can see from the past 20+ years when the country has been run by a conveyor belt of "elite" Oxbridge PPE graduates (representing all the main parties), they are far more dangerous than benign Shazza, but since she and her cohort have no real power, it's easy to make her the bogeymen/women.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 11:47

@Blossomtoes

"When did Reeves say Labour would “use the barge’? All she’s actually said is that the Labour economic model is predicated on growth, it’s nothing like Johnson’s policies and it’s completely disingenuous to say it is."

+++

Again this is lazy sound bite politics that appeals to all those that don't want to think it through.

Of course every politician says they want the economy to grow as a policy - what they fail to do is to detail how exactly they are going to do this without further increasing Government debt.

Any politician could make everyone feel better off simply by borrowing money and the handing it back out but this is not sustainable economic growth.

Baconisdelicious · 27/08/2023 11:46

So what you really want is to exclude people who don’t think like you? Who says your views are the right ones?

Begsthequestion · 27/08/2023 11:44

OlympicProcrastinator · 27/08/2023 02:45

Oh no no no. This is wrong on so many levels. You don’t realise how many experts in their field are also racist, homophobic bigots with hidden agendas. This reeks of classism. The fact that someone from Clacton called Sharon would be more likely to be a bigot than someone who got a few degrees is so short sighted and ignorant.

Who do you think upholds systems of oppression? I can tell you now it’s the people with the most, not the least power. Medical bias has killed hundreds of black people with ‘expert advice’ being steeped in incorrect racist assumptions. If you are interested in reading around this subject I suggest, “Hoberman, Black and Blue: The Origins and Consequences of Medical Racism.”

We already had the system described above in recent history in the UK where only educated males were allowed to vote. How do you think that worked out for the people?

You are suggesting an Orwellian future where some people ‘are more equal than others’ and want to live in a world where ‘expert’ opinion is taken as gospel without challenge from dissenting voices and the poor and uneducated are assumed to be morally bankrupt.

Telling people they have ‘wrong think’ is a slippery slope that never ends well. I want to live in a society where everyone has a voice, all views can be discussed and challenged out in the open and everyone gets a say.

Yes, this a thousand times.

Uterusbegone · 27/08/2023 11:41

I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic

Yeah, but that's no different to what people who believe in conspiracy theories say. Some people believe that watching TikTok and YouTube qualifies them as having learned about a topic, even if the videos are made by some complete random who has no actual idea what they are talking about

Besides your idea very much smacks of 'all animals are equal but some are more equal than others'. How long until 'the chosen voters' vote for things that only benefit themselves? It's human nature, very few people will take a purely altruistic stance and vote against their own best interests

Absolutely terrible idea OP, but then one look at your username shows us your agenda here

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 11:40

@SerendipityJane

Brilliant quote by Alexander Fraser Tytler

In fact we have seen and can start to see this occurring across the world.

Greece for example after its economic collapse was bailed out by the EU but with economic control ceded to the EU. At the time this was decried by many Greeks as authoritarian and un democratic.

In the UK we currently have the highest taxation in 70 years, the highest debt to GDP since WW2, low economic growth, low productivity Government spending at its highest yet public services that are falling apart. A change of Government will do nothing to fundamentally change this.

Cornettoninja · 27/08/2023 11:38

It’s clear we have a large number of people who don’t understand the economics of the country or lack capacity to understand complex issues

I don’t think many people lack capacity in terms of their intellectual abilities but I agree that many people lack the capacity to see beyond their own personal and immediate issues because those are often entangled with the their ability to function within society. They have very little left to lose and want to protect what they do have.

Cornettoninja · 27/08/2023 11:35

Democracy isn’t the problem, a massively unequal society is. societies with a thousand different priorities aren’t cohesive or able to envisage a bigger picture. Part of Blair’s success was being able to draw people to a larger vision for the country whilst encompassing a lot of individual goals. Basically giving people hope that there was something in it for them.

Frankly until we, as a globe, accept that economic growth can’t be infinite the foundations for any such societal movement now is unlikely.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 11:29

Our older people are more likely to vote so policies are skewed to them. That doesn’t make it right and they definitely voted for Brexit. Younger people didn’t turn out. If anything, that’s what we need to change.

I have mentioned in another thread about meeting some recent graduates. Now I thought I was cross. They are - in every mumsnet sense of the word - fuming.

It's looking like irony strikes again, and we are moving towards a society so politically disparate it will simply break the two party hegemony that has been allowed to ossify around us. We are already seeing that in the increasingly ludicrous series of reverse ferrets from the Tories and Labour as they react to the latest polling. If you didn't live here it would be funny.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 11:06

That would put many people off voting. We already have too few. One issue is first past the post. Some people are permanently disenfranchised. They live in constituencies that never change party.

It’s clear we have a large number of people who don’t understand the economics of the country or lack capacity to understand complex issues. This is borne out by the difficulties of explaining why we don’t have a bottomless purse for public sector pay and the outcomes of Brexit.

Three word slogans rule. Get Brexit Done and many others. It’s lazy politics. However Cummings discovered how to get messages across to the population who don’t want to think too deeply. It’s not going away and education won’t help. We have all ages of people who don’t make much effort to get informed. Our older people are more likely to vote so policies are skewed to them. That doesn’t make it right and they definitely voted for Brexit. Younger people didn’t turn out. If anything, that’s what we need to change.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 11:05

"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the majority discovers it can vote itself largess out of the public treasury. After that, the majority always votes for the candidate promising the most benefits with the result the democracy collapses because of the loose fiscal policy ensuing, always to be followed by a dictatorship, then a monarchy".

BIossomtoes · 27/08/2023 10:50

Boomboom22 · 27/08/2023 09:39

Democracy is short termist and does allow all to vote. But you do sound a bit like a tra, no debate you are right with no practicalities sorted. Which is often typical of the left, those on the right tend to be more pragmatic and willing to compromise for the longer term good, traditionally anyway maybe not now.
Interesting that Rachel reeves is going around saying Labour would keep most policies, not raise taxes, use the barge etc for migrants, so to win Labour have to basically meet Johnson type promises. He was very central one nation tory not right in the party by any means.

When did Reeves say Labour would “use the barge’? All she’s actually said is that the Labour economic model is predicated on growth, it’s nothing like Johnson’s policies and it’s completely disingenuous to say it is.