Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
DownNative · 27/08/2023 14:59

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 14:14

I wasn't arguing that there shouldn't be a second chamber, but how many of the 800 Peers in the Lords are actually working peers, scrutinising legislation and how many are sitting around getting an attendance fee while they pop in on their way to lunch? We need a massively slimmed down second chamber. The Supreme Court is an important check on government, but that's not what was mentioned. The Monarch was. We also have a press that launches attacks on the Supreme Court at every opportunity with little sanction. It is not democracy that is the problem, or people called Sharon having the vote but our system. The ideas of the OP and people on both the hard Left and Hard Right that other people are too stupid to know what's good for them is what leads to dictatorship. And that has never ended well.

The OP is a strong Scottish Nationalist, so that explains their view. Especially in recent months when the SNP IndyRef2 train has come off the rails. Hence their focus on attacking the UK wide system.

However, they appear to be silent on the fact Scottish politics has NO second chamber and the Greens tail can wag the SNP dog very well. The Greens aren't directly elected, but they get in through the backdoor aka list.

The West has freedom of the press which has no real effect on the role of the Uk Supreme Court which is to interpret UK Constitutional Law. It does this job very well and so it undermines ANY argument about the Monarch being unable to provide a check on Government. Anyone who argues for/against that clearly doesn't understand the terms of the restoration of the Monarchy in addition to the supremacy of Parliament.

Our system of democracy works well enough and is flexible enough to cope with rapid global changes which is in contrast to States with a codified written constitution. If we'd had an inflexible, codified written constitution the Windsor Framework would have been easily unconstitutional.

We have an uncodified written constitution instead.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 14:54

No party will succeed with infighting. This goes back decades and both main parties have had this issue. Kinnock and then Blair tackled it, as an example in the labour party. The corrosive side of the Conservatives has been present for decades. It’s not gone away. It’s difficult to see how the disruptors can be dealt with unless deselected. They won’t be.

I don’t think we have a corrupt government. Most MPs are decent human beings. Undoubtedly some will end up with minor conflicts of interest. Same with the Lords. Procurement policies should deal with this and declarations of interest.

We are all lucky we have an impartial judiciary. Unlike the USA, our Supreme Court are not political appointees. They are a check on extremes which are illegal. The HofL needs culling. Maybe attendance should be required for x number of days each year. They do have committees overseeing legislation but there are far too many political appointments. We need knowledge and it is not a reward system (Nadine please note). About 500 would suffice.

I also think we need higher calibre MPs . Many candidates are political fodder. Yes people. No ideas. No original thought. It’s poorly paid for most high calibre people to want to swap into it. Plus the hate aimed at women. Far better to keep the well paid job where no one wishes you dead and might even carry it out.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 14:51

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/08/2023 14:17

tescocreditcard · Today 03:45
I think democracy is the least bad option.

Would you rather a junta? Or autocracy?”

Do we actually have a democracy, without PR?

Yes, we do have democracy without PR as that is simply one form of it in the same way FPTP is another form of democracy.

FPTP doesn't mean there's an absence of democracy.

itsgettingweird · 27/08/2023 14:37

I'm not convinced as a country we are really far right.

I think actually we have a very centric voting population but there are issues that can be homes in on and groups that can be targeted to swing the vote to either main party.

I also don't think you need to be the better party to win the GE either.

Right now Labour are so far ahead in the polls because Starmer is much more centric and the Tory's are making a hash of things with their infighting.
They assumed Brexit vote was the country saying it wanted to be far right. It wasn't. Polls have shown immigration is low on people's priorities. Many voted brexit because they thought economically it would benefit the country.

The story's won a lot of labours votes on levelling up and the fact that Corbyn was too far left for many Labour supporters.

As long as we have have 2 main parties that swing from centre to far left and right we'll always have a change of governments every decade or so. And as long as we have a very strong and vocal (actually very partisan) media well have the false narratives out there all the time and people that do stick to particular media outlet will always buy into what they're told.

BlueMoe · 27/08/2023 14:35

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 11:40

@SerendipityJane

Brilliant quote by Alexander Fraser Tytler

In fact we have seen and can start to see this occurring across the world.

Greece for example after its economic collapse was bailed out by the EU but with economic control ceded to the EU. At the time this was decried by many Greeks as authoritarian and un democratic.

In the UK we currently have the highest taxation in 70 years, the highest debt to GDP since WW2, low economic growth, low productivity Government spending at its highest yet public services that are falling apart. A change of Government will do nothing to fundamentally change this.

I am neither German nor Greek, but know and work with several Greeks and many Germans.

Economically, Greece was living in cloud cuckoo land. They thought they should retire at 55, paid for by the EU (in practice, Germans) who were working until 68.
You have to have some brass neck to think that’s going to fly.

Germans got the blame for wanting to hold the clean end of the stick Greeks had swirled around in the septic tank.
It was completely a mess of their own (Greek) making.

JaneyGee · 27/08/2023 14:21

mdinbc · 27/08/2023 05:20

I think this is why education is so important.

You run down a slippery slope when deciding who is fit to make decisions about leadership. If not democracy, then what do you suggest; back to monarchy assisted by well-educated, land owning lords?

Just because someone holds liberal-left views doesn't mean they're wise or good. Some of vilest, stupidest, most ignorant people I've ever met have been on the liberal-left. Who should be allowed to vote then? Only people who can mindlessly regurgitate the liberal-left view on every issue? If there is one person who isn't fit to vote it's a ghastly woke fascist who spends his life yelling "you can't say that, you can't say that," yet has no genuine empathy.

In general, I find moderate conservatives the most intelligent. Show me a skeptical, pragmatic, mildly pessimistic centrist and I'll show you a thoughtful, intelligent individual. Both socialists and Thatcherites are ideologues. Thatcher and Corbyn are two sides of the same coin. They've stopped thinking. They already have all the answers. Intelligent people are adaptable. They change their mind. They hold right-wing opinions on some issues, liberal or left-wing opinions on others. It's called thinking for yourself.

Squirrelsnut · 27/08/2023 14:21

Who decides who gets to vote?
Which opinions disqualify a person from voting?

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/08/2023 14:17

tescocreditcard · Today 03:45
I think democracy is the least bad option.

Would you rather a junta? Or autocracy?”

Do we actually have a democracy, without PR?

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 14:14

DownNative · 27/08/2023 12:24

The proroguing of Parliament showed the power of the UK Supreme Court to curtail and reverse Government advice to the Monarch.

An important check and balance we have.

Lords has proven to be an effective check on Government, e.g. reversed a Bill that had negative consequences for the rights of disabled people.

I wasn't arguing that there shouldn't be a second chamber, but how many of the 800 Peers in the Lords are actually working peers, scrutinising legislation and how many are sitting around getting an attendance fee while they pop in on their way to lunch? We need a massively slimmed down second chamber. The Supreme Court is an important check on government, but that's not what was mentioned. The Monarch was. We also have a press that launches attacks on the Supreme Court at every opportunity with little sanction. It is not democracy that is the problem, or people called Sharon having the vote but our system. The ideas of the OP and people on both the hard Left and Hard Right that other people are too stupid to know what's good for them is what leads to dictatorship. And that has never ended well.

Glowie · 27/08/2023 14:06

Well put @Pollyputhekettleon, I quite agree with you there. I was trying to limit my scope as it's difficult enough to successfully get the notion of inequality across.

Pollyputhekettleon · 27/08/2023 13:45

Glowie · 27/08/2023 13:38

This is a very interesting thread!

Here's the problem with democracy - it hinges on the notion that all people are equal when they quite clearly are not. How can they be? I am not even equal to myself from 5 years ago.
To argue against the full franchise is to acknowledge this, and the question then becomes in which way do you separate people.

Relying on 'experts' is also a terrible idea. For one, there's nothing to say that they are correct or even honest. For another, would you really be happy with their decisions?

For example, if someone could produce concrete evidence and multiple peer reviewed studies with perfect replication etc. that all browns were rapists, and that women should be in the home, would you accept that?

Personally, I would advocate for either a Starship Troopers method, or a return to Monarchy.

There's a lot more than democracy that falls apart once you acknowledge that people aren't equal. It's one of the foundations of post-Enlightenment western civilizations, of the left, of liberalism, and particularly of the post-WW2 order. No society has ever maintained democracy permanently anyway and we're not going to be the first. Nor will we get to choose what replaces it. Caesarism follows it, whether anyone advocates for it or not. See Trump. I'd prefer monarchy, at least it's less orange.

Glowie · 27/08/2023 13:38

This is a very interesting thread!

Here's the problem with democracy - it hinges on the notion that all people are equal when they quite clearly are not. How can they be? I am not even equal to myself from 5 years ago.
To argue against the full franchise is to acknowledge this, and the question then becomes in which way do you separate people.

Relying on 'experts' is also a terrible idea. For one, there's nothing to say that they are correct or even honest. For another, would you really be happy with their decisions?

For example, if someone could produce concrete evidence and multiple peer reviewed studies with perfect replication etc. that all browns were rapists, and that women should be in the home, would you accept that?

Personally, I would advocate for either a Starship Troopers method, or a return to Monarchy.

poetryandwine · 27/08/2023 13:27

Your last paragraph above is bang on, OP.

If we could hold politicians and their cronies properly accountable I would feel much less afraid.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 12:57

Besides your idea very much smacks of 'all animals are equal but some are more equal than others'

Well yes, that was the general point. You wouldn't ask an accountant what type of wood is best to build a table and you wouldn't ask a joiner what type of surgery should be undertaken to remove a tumour.

So why do we pretend that the accountant's, joiner's, and doctor's opinion on the best way to run a country are all equally valid?

Someone asked earlier how I would feel if I was the one to be disenfranchised by a move away from democracy but, tbh that's exactly how I feel already.

In the almost two decades that I've been able to vote I've joined groups, marches and protests. I've attended debates, participated in campaigns, and written letters to all levels of government. I've even retrained and changed career to work in an area that I hope(d) would help bring about some meaningful changes for normal people and continue to advocate for the things I believe in as much as I can.

Yet, despite this I've never had my views represented properly in a government and come election day my X is worth no more than the X of someone who's sole understanding of politics comes from the memes they see online. It just seems a bit shit and pointless.

Even more so now when you look at the outright corruption in our government (how many conflicts of interest has Rishi ignored now?) that is being ignored simply because they've managed to create a great big distraction about immigration.

But there's been some excellent posts on here to counter my view/feeling and they've certainly given me lots of food for thought.

Maybe it's not the concept of democracy that's the root of the issue, rather the way we administer it.

Perhaps if we had stronger systems in place that held politicians accountable for their failures, lies, and corruption; that tried to shift focus from what will get them re-elected next term to the long-term best interests of the country; that worked to improved representation in government, it wouldn't feel quite so hopeless.

OP posts:
Pollyputhekettleon · 27/08/2023 12:55

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/08/2023 12:47

I think people should take a theory test like we do to drive a car. Just to make sure they know the basics, like: if the UK, under a Conservative government, stopped taking in immigrants do you think the money saved would be spent on the health service, council houses and infrastructure? Because this is such a serious misconception it drives me to distraction. There are so many people who are brainwashed by the red tops I could cry. It might be an idea to put politics on the curriculum for secondary and high schools as a mandatory subject.

The reason we shouldn't introduce a test is because people like you would, apparently unsarcastically, want to include in it 'questions' like the above. A sane society would keep people like you as far from the levers of power as humanly possible.

MrsSlocombesCat · 27/08/2023 12:47

I think people should take a theory test like we do to drive a car. Just to make sure they know the basics, like: if the UK, under a Conservative government, stopped taking in immigrants do you think the money saved would be spent on the health service, council houses and infrastructure? Because this is such a serious misconception it drives me to distraction. There are so many people who are brainwashed by the red tops I could cry. It might be an idea to put politics on the curriculum for secondary and high schools as a mandatory subject.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 12:37

A typical voter position seems to be as follows:

Voter: "I think the Government should spend more on [insert area where voter's selfish interest is - for example the retired want higher pensions, young families want more on education and everyone wants more on the NHS]
Question: OK how are we going to pay for it?
Voter : By increasing taxes on the rich
and cutting spending in other areas
Question: OK so who are the rich ?
Voter : Basically anyone earning about 30% more than me but most definitely not me.
Question: what areas would you cut spending on?
Voter: Basically any area that I don't benefit from for example the retired wouldn't spend any more on education and young families wouldn't spend anymore on the retired.

DownNative · 27/08/2023 12:24

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 12:17

But this could be the House of Lords. The issue isn't necessarily with all of the people in it but the sheer size of it and that its stuffed with political appointees. Just because you abolish the HoL doesn't mean you just leave us with no second chamber. And the Monarchy has no power to do anything about corruption politicians. The whole proroguing of Parliament fiasco showed that. It didn't really matter what Jacob Rees Mogg said to The Queen. She had to accept it and do what he said. All they do is rubber stamp ( unless they want to get out of doing things like abiding by equality laws, or tax laws or environmental laws, in which case they negotiate an opt out for themselves before rubber stamping it)

Edited

The proroguing of Parliament showed the power of the UK Supreme Court to curtail and reverse Government advice to the Monarch.

An important check and balance we have.

Lords has proven to be an effective check on Government, e.g. reversed a Bill that had negative consequences for the rights of disabled people.

LlynTegid · 27/08/2023 12:22

I agree with Winston Churchill. I'd like better democracy to find out.

Pollyputhekettleon · 27/08/2023 12:20

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

The fact that your 'education' has resulted in a 'belief' that others believe all brown people are rapists and all woman are nothing more than broodmares is exactly why democracy is necessary. Allowing the illiterate the same vote as you is an unfortunate, and unfortunately weak, but necessary, corrective to the unique stupidity and arrogance of the 'educated' human being. Above all in 21st century western societies.

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 12:17

guzzleandstuff · 27/08/2023 09:11

@sashagabadon I agree although it's not fashionable to agree. If you abolish the monarchy and the HoLords decisions are only made by the MPs. And our PM becomes our Head of State with all the associated power and status. I'd actually like to see a third set of representatives in Parliament along the lines of what someone mentioned upthread - like jury service - with people selected for five years only and representing small businesses, Trades Unions, Teachers, Doctors, Farmers, Council Tenants, Mothers, Pensioners, Students, Apprentices, retailers, etc etc. People who didn't have to pander to voters as they would never be re-elected but who would give another insight and level of power to decision making. And a much more sold, less corrupt Local Council system.

But this could be the House of Lords. The issue isn't necessarily with all of the people in it but the sheer size of it and that its stuffed with political appointees. Just because you abolish the HoL doesn't mean you just leave us with no second chamber. And the Monarchy has no power to do anything about corruption politicians. The whole proroguing of Parliament fiasco showed that. It didn't really matter what Jacob Rees Mogg said to The Queen. She had to accept it and do what he said. All they do is rubber stamp ( unless they want to get out of doing things like abiding by equality laws, or tax laws or environmental laws, in which case they negotiate an opt out for themselves before rubber stamping it)

DownNative · 27/08/2023 12:15

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 12:09

The bigger the pool of people you deliberately disenfranchise based on intelligence, for example....the more unstable a State will become.

How about the UK system which "accidentally" disenfranchises millions ?

That's nothing like what the OP is proposing! You suggesting so is an example of the Non-sequitur Fallacy = It Doesn't Follow.

People are free to vote for any party they choose from the list. It just so happens that the biggest vote shares goes to the two biggest parties.

Or just one in the case of Scotland.

Those who vote for smaller parties still have the choice of voting for the most popular ones.

Exclude people on the basis of intelligence as OP is suggesting and you will end up with an unstable State where the biggest pool of people may well advocate political violence. The State agencies could not cope with this en masse.

HippoStraw · 27/08/2023 12:12

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 12:07

Sometimes just putting the brakes on and give something a chance before deciding it’s not working , might be a better thing to try.

I quite agree. I mean we never really gave slavery a chance did we ?

The most dangerous attitude in anything is "We've always done it this way". Mainly because it's the exact reason it can take generations to eliminate social evils.

That’s not what is meant. I’m thinking especially of things like education, where it is one change after another, often introduced without proper consideration, because of short termism.

Snittle · 27/08/2023 12:10

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 27/08/2023 07:01

I don't like this idea, but I did wonder if a system similar to jury service would work. No elected MPs, instead every adult is eligible to be called up to serve as a member of parliament representing the area they live in for a period of, say, five years.

Your job or business would be protected whilst you serve, and you're paid a basic, modest salary and provided accommodation whilst away from home. You can defer, if it's really bad timing, or have yourself declared exempt if there's a very good reason why you can never serve; but otherwise, off you go and serve your country.

Once you've served, you can be called up again, and you go back to your normal life afterwards - so the decisions you've helped make whilst you serve are ones you personally will have to live with the consequences of.

I do wonder if that might be a better system.

My family would literally go bankrupt if my salary was replaced with a modest salary for 5 years. We rely on my earnings to pay the mortgage and meet the costs of the lifestyle we can afford. Any costs would need to be commensurate with your average salary over the 3 years before being called up - which on average might not be much different to the average MP’s wage given the majority of the population would be on less than an MP’s salary.

But I think there is a consensus that democracy is the least worst solution, rather than a “good” solution. It gets very difficult when you say Racist Gary doesn’t get a vote, but what about Gender Critical Deborah - are her views also too extreme? Who decides which views are extreme? Does pro-choice make the cut? What about euthanasia?

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 12:09

The bigger the pool of people you deliberately disenfranchise based on intelligence, for example....the more unstable a State will become.

How about the UK system which "accidentally" disenfranchises millions ?