Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 16:21

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:49

@SerendipityJane FPTP does represent the people who voted for that candidate. That can even be over 50%.Obviously not always. As I said, my views have never been represented. Won’t ever be I suspect.

You cannot get away from weighing up the difficulties with FPTP against coalition difficulties when MPs cannot work together. Could you ever have imagined Corbyn’s Labour working with the Cons? Are we ok with the prospect of this turmoil?

But is the reason they can't work together FPTP? Other counties manage it. We managed it during the war. We should have has a coalition working towards a decent Brexit deal ( although I agree it was too complex an issue to put to the electorate) and we should have had a government of national unity to deal with COVID but instead we had what we had because we had a buffoon in charge surrounded by ideologues on both sides.. Corbyn wouldn't have worked with the Tories and didn't, to everybody's detriment during the referendum campaign because he is a 6th form ideologue. We need a better calibre of politicians than this.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 16:16

Probably one of the most interesting MN threads for a while.

My two cents worth: government is not governance.

Democracy is probably the least worst of all the systems that have been tried.

I'm not wedded to the notion of FPTP, and actually I think broad centrist coalitions are preferable, because slower to legislate and more open to reaching consensus.

The existence of a focused political class is a problem. Eton or shop steward to researcher and on to MP is too narrow a route to political power.

I approve of a bicameral legislature, such as a Senate or HoL, but I don't think anyone joining or appointed to it should sit for longer than one 10 year term.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 16:11

Barbadossunset · 27/08/2023 16:09

Very few voters are truly ideologues. Whilst I cannot put into words how much I despise the Tories, it's not a Netflix and Chill for the Labour Party.

SerendipityJane so who do you want?

I'll know it when I see it.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 16:11

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:06

The expertise issue is nonsense. We don't ask people to vote on details of economic policy usually. It's why Brexit should never have been put to a referendum.
Elections are about what policies are important to people.. why should a group of well off professionals decide the cost of living crisis is not a priority to tackle? Or that there is no need for better laws to protect tenants?
We desperately need democracy. But we also need a decent political class who are not corrupt. The political class is the real issue.

I’m surprised someone who is on the left is proposing it. It’s such a terrible idea

So nurses, plumbers, artists, social workers etc no say..

What a crazy aim. At least 86% say yabu

Barbadossunset · 27/08/2023 16:09

Very few voters are truly ideologues. Whilst I cannot put into words how much I despise the Tories, it's not a Netflix and Chill for the Labour Party.

SerendipityJane so who do you want?

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:06

The expertise issue is nonsense. We don't ask people to vote on details of economic policy usually. It's why Brexit should never have been put to a referendum.
Elections are about what policies are important to people.. why should a group of well off professionals decide the cost of living crisis is not a priority to tackle? Or that there is no need for better laws to protect tenants?
We desperately need democracy. But we also need a decent political class who are not corrupt. The political class is the real issue.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 16:02

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 15:56

I haven’t heard the money one but for claims of education I’d say it’s a failure of education to believe you can strip votes from people due to a perceived superiority

Hmmm

plehpleh · 27/08/2023 15:57

They used to do that. That's why womens couldn't vote...

They thought they were right. The example you've given is obviously right but there would be many cases that would be opinion, and might lead to serious social regression.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 15:56

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 15:51

The idea of someone thinking they can remove votes from other people is more concerning to me than a person with a couple of GCSE getting a vote

There are people - who walk among us - that believe if you earn more money you should have more votes.

All of this discussion needs to bear in mind that that actual turnout for any UK election rarely exceeds 70% and vert often is less than 30%.

I haven’t heard the money one but for claims of education I’d say it’s a failure of education to believe you can strip votes from people due to a perceived superiority

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 15:56

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:49

@SerendipityJane FPTP does represent the people who voted for that candidate. That can even be over 50%.Obviously not always. As I said, my views have never been represented. Won’t ever be I suspect.

You cannot get away from weighing up the difficulties with FPTP against coalition difficulties when MPs cannot work together. Could you ever have imagined Corbyn’s Labour working with the Cons? Are we ok with the prospect of this turmoil?

Do you know something ?

If something works, I give not a flying fuck what colour carton it came in. I'd happily have a fully funded and working NHS under a Tory flag as a Labour flag.

The problem is I am up against people who would much rather have a shit service under their flag, than a better under someone elses.

Very few voters are truly ideologues. Whilst I cannot put into words how much I despise the Tories, it's not a Netflix and Chill for the Labour party. Who can be equally ghastly and no doubt will need removing after so many years in power corrupt them as much as they have corrupted the Tories.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 15:51

The idea of someone thinking they can remove votes from other people is more concerning to me than a person with a couple of GCSE getting a vote

There are people - who walk among us - that believe if you earn more money you should have more votes.

All of this discussion needs to bear in mind that that actual turnout for any UK election rarely exceeds 70% and vert often is less than 30%.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:49

@SerendipityJane FPTP does represent the people who voted for that candidate. That can even be over 50%.Obviously not always. As I said, my views have never been represented. Won’t ever be I suspect.

You cannot get away from weighing up the difficulties with FPTP against coalition difficulties when MPs cannot work together. Could you ever have imagined Corbyn’s Labour working with the Cons? Are we ok with the prospect of this turmoil?

Nevermind31 · 27/08/2023 15:46

That’s right OP. Let’s decide whose vote should count. Surely women’s votes don’t, because they can be hysteric. Definitely not gay people, they don’t have morals. And not people of other religions- they are all terrorists. Brown people don’t really know much about what is best for our culture (and and are probably terrorists). And poor people should know their place in life. Autistic people and their ilk really shouldn’t vote of course, and neither should physically disabled people. Non-religious people are the same category as other religions.
Really, only rich, white, religious, educated men should vote, they know best!

DownNative · 27/08/2023 15:44

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 12:57

Besides your idea very much smacks of 'all animals are equal but some are more equal than others'

Well yes, that was the general point. You wouldn't ask an accountant what type of wood is best to build a table and you wouldn't ask a joiner what type of surgery should be undertaken to remove a tumour.

So why do we pretend that the accountant's, joiner's, and doctor's opinion on the best way to run a country are all equally valid?

Someone asked earlier how I would feel if I was the one to be disenfranchised by a move away from democracy but, tbh that's exactly how I feel already.

In the almost two decades that I've been able to vote I've joined groups, marches and protests. I've attended debates, participated in campaigns, and written letters to all levels of government. I've even retrained and changed career to work in an area that I hope(d) would help bring about some meaningful changes for normal people and continue to advocate for the things I believe in as much as I can.

Yet, despite this I've never had my views represented properly in a government and come election day my X is worth no more than the X of someone who's sole understanding of politics comes from the memes they see online. It just seems a bit shit and pointless.

Even more so now when you look at the outright corruption in our government (how many conflicts of interest has Rishi ignored now?) that is being ignored simply because they've managed to create a great big distraction about immigration.

But there's been some excellent posts on here to counter my view/feeling and they've certainly given me lots of food for thought.

Maybe it's not the concept of democracy that's the root of the issue, rather the way we administer it.

Perhaps if we had stronger systems in place that held politicians accountable for their failures, lies, and corruption; that tried to shift focus from what will get them re-elected next term to the long-term best interests of the country; that worked to improved representation in government, it wouldn't feel quite so hopeless.

A society is a collection of individuals living in am ordered community though and, given the interlocking parts, there is no one expert on it.

Society is not a specialised subject or occupation, but a constantly evolving group of people living in an ordered community.

Your analogy about accountants, doctors and joiners fails as it is reliant on the false equivalence fallacy.

Society is not equivalent to specialised jobs. Those jobs are one of many parts of a society, but NOT the only part of it.

Society is dependent upon large groups of people agreeing on the ordered rules for it to work. Barring people from voting for the kind of government they want on the basis of intelligence is a fast track route towards the collapse of society.

Never had your views represented in government?!

The SNP has represented you for more than a decade now!

And we're seeing the SNP leaders being held "accountable for their failures, lies, and corruption; that tried to shift focus from what will get them re-elected next term to the long-term best interests of the country;"....aren't we?

But, of course, you'd prefer only the sovereign UK Government was mentioned....right?

Even though you didn't once restrict scope of the thread to it.

Reality is, Government in the UK is multi-layered. Sovereign power is in Westminster and with UK Government. Devolved power is restricted to local issues, subject to the sovereign power as well as UK Supreme Court. And there is the UK Supreme Court which hasn't gone the way of Scottish Separatists the last few years.

And, finally, you have ZERO empirical data show that "come election day my X is worth no more than the X of someone who's sole understanding of politics comes from the memes they see online"! This just seems more like a variation of SNat exceptionalism than anything else.

Why exactly should YOUR vote be worth more than someone else's?!

Your idea of basing it on intelligence begs more questions than answers and is a Slippery Slope Fallacy too. It's pretty discriminatory, especially against those with some degree of learning challenges.

But it still takes us back to why should YOUR vote be worth more than someone else's? 🤷‍♂️

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:43

In my view, no multi seat constituency (eg London) should be FPTP. STV is much better. All should be elected at one election. Not staggered ones. I was really referring to a GE with one election date and one candidate per party in each constituency.

StefanosHill · 27/08/2023 15:41

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 12:57

Besides your idea very much smacks of 'all animals are equal but some are more equal than others'

Well yes, that was the general point. You wouldn't ask an accountant what type of wood is best to build a table and you wouldn't ask a joiner what type of surgery should be undertaken to remove a tumour.

So why do we pretend that the accountant's, joiner's, and doctor's opinion on the best way to run a country are all equally valid?

Someone asked earlier how I would feel if I was the one to be disenfranchised by a move away from democracy but, tbh that's exactly how I feel already.

In the almost two decades that I've been able to vote I've joined groups, marches and protests. I've attended debates, participated in campaigns, and written letters to all levels of government. I've even retrained and changed career to work in an area that I hope(d) would help bring about some meaningful changes for normal people and continue to advocate for the things I believe in as much as I can.

Yet, despite this I've never had my views represented properly in a government and come election day my X is worth no more than the X of someone who's sole understanding of politics comes from the memes they see online. It just seems a bit shit and pointless.

Even more so now when you look at the outright corruption in our government (how many conflicts of interest has Rishi ignored now?) that is being ignored simply because they've managed to create a great big distraction about immigration.

But there's been some excellent posts on here to counter my view/feeling and they've certainly given me lots of food for thought.

Maybe it's not the concept of democracy that's the root of the issue, rather the way we administer it.

Perhaps if we had stronger systems in place that held politicians accountable for their failures, lies, and corruption; that tried to shift focus from what will get them re-elected next term to the long-term best interests of the country; that worked to improved representation in government, it wouldn't feel quite so hopeless.

The idea of someone thinking they can remove votes from other people is more concerning to me than a person with a couple of GCSE getting a vote

Of course they should. I’m not sure where this high self value comes from that the op would keep the vote and others not.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 15:35

Generally first past the post delivers certainty and clarity.

The absence of the word representative is noted

MereDintofPandiculation · 27/08/2023 15:33

Generally first past the post delivers certainty and clarity. It doesn’t cover all views and, in my life of nearly 70 years, no MP from any party other than Conservative. No system truly gives us everything. I live in a Council Ward which is roughly 60% Conservative, 40% Labour. We have three Councillors, one elected each year. FPTP ensures all three are Conservative. This is not fulfilling the basic aim of a representational system, that the representatives should mirror the population and not just one part ofit.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 15:32

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:24

@MrsSkylerWhite So please discuss which system you think is better? With examples of other countries using it. Don’t just say PR. That’s not a system.

Sortition was mentioned previously. it speaks volumes in a discussion about people being unwilling to consider change that no one picked up on it.

MereDintofPandiculation · 27/08/2023 15:28

but we just assume that an 18yo has certain understanding of political issues. I teach them ..many don't have a clue. Nor do many older people.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:24

@MrsSkylerWhite So please discuss which system you think is better? With examples of other countries using it. Don’t just say PR. That’s not a system.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 15:22

@Isitsixoclockalready So which voting system would you prefer? It’s easy to say you don’t like what we have, but which is better?

Im not against parties forming coalitions, (often needed after a form of PR voting) but they can take months to reach an agreement. Cameron and Clegg were actually quick. Did it lead to better governance? Not sure. It lead to the lib dems committing suicide by having to agree to tuition fee increases at uni. So many people want the policies they voted for. Not someone else’s. As a society we are not mature enough for give and take it appears.

Generally first past the post delivers certainty and clarity. It doesn’t cover all views and, in my life of nearly 70 years, no MP from any party other than Conservative. No system truly gives us everything.

We make a lot of having a local mp who advocates for us. We end up with great people in that job but often have little original thought. Many will never be government material. They also end up as voting fodder. It’s clear the potential pool of ministers is poor as being an mp does not attract the best candidates. Decent candidates who might offer solutions and think the unthinkable simply don’t want the job. The parties are straightjackets. They exist to get re-elected. They are largely poor because they dare not upset their voters.

yourmotherknitssocksinhell · 27/08/2023 15:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Previously banned poster.

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/08/2023 15:10

“The biggest issue at the moment IMO is the antiquated First Past the Post system, which is so unrepresentative and wastes votes”

👏👏👏👏

Isitsixoclockalready · 27/08/2023 15:02

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

The biggest issue at the moment IMO is the antiquated First Past the Post system, which is so unrepresentative and wastes votes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread