Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 18:12

we have a parliamentary democracy.

But not a representative democracy.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 18:12

Remember the poll tax

Sparklesocks · 27/08/2023 18:12

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 18:00

How about this as a criteria for voter eligibility.

On the basis that the whole American Revolution started over the principle of "no taxation without representation" then on the same principle how about moving to "no representation without x amount of taxation"?

Yes sounds fair, so the richer you are the bigger say you have in how things go….and if you’re a low earner, or disabled, or a carer etc…you’re not worthy of a say 😒

people don’t half come out with some shit on here..

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 18:12

Then there will be a violent revolution

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 18:11

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 18:07

I assume you know we all pay a certain amount of tax. So what you really mean is poor people should not vote.

Sounds like an idea ...

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 18:11

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:57

Wow. I can't believe some are seriously arguing that only those who own land should vote. Welcome back the 1900s when only rich men could vote.

But look how much better things were then.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 18:07

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 18:00

How about this as a criteria for voter eligibility.

On the basis that the whole American Revolution started over the principle of "no taxation without representation" then on the same principle how about moving to "no representation without x amount of taxation"?

I assume you know we all pay a certain amount of tax. So what you really mean is poor people should not vote.

continentallentil · 27/08/2023 18:05

So why do we pretend that the accountant's, joiner's, and doctor's opinion on the best way to run a country are all equally valid?

We don’t OP - we have a parliamentary democracy. We vote in politicians whose full time job it is to make decisions on good governance, and they get advised by specialised civil servants and specialist advisors so they can take the best decisions. Most of us don’t have the time or inclination to delve deeply into policy, which is why referendums are a terrible idea..

Admittedly, right now we have the most useless set of politicians in living memory, so the system isn’t working well, but we’d be better to address that than drop democracy, which is imperfect but the best option that exists. Anything else is a slippery slope to a totalitarian state.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 18:00

How about this as a criteria for voter eligibility.

On the basis that the whole American Revolution started over the principle of "no taxation without representation" then on the same principle how about moving to "no representation without x amount of taxation"?

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 17:57

Wow. I can't believe some are seriously arguing that only those who own land should vote. Welcome back the 1900s when only rich men could vote.

Angrycat2768 · 27/08/2023 17:56

I wonder if if would be better to have the Australian system where if is compulsory to vote. We would need a 'none of the above' but there may be people who knowing they have to get off their butt's and vote may do at least some cursory research into who they should vote for. It would also mean political parties would have to take an interest in all sections of society rather than just the people who vote ( over 60's)

1dayatatime · 27/08/2023 17:56

@SerendipityJane

"And having paid "a fucktonne" of tax these past 40 plus years, I'm not impressed that the state now needs to ask for even more"

+++

Well technically it's not the state asking for more, it's voters electing politicians who say they will ask for more in taxation from the "rich" - ie anyone on a higher income than most voters.

poetryandwine · 27/08/2023 17:28

@yourmotherknitssocksinhell the quotation you cite is from Winston Churchill and is the basis for the references to him here

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 17:13

BeyondMyWits · 27/08/2023 16:59

Intelligent people can be arseholes too...not mutually exclusive.

Giving everyone the right to vote kind of smooths out the extremes at each end of the spectrum.

My opinion is that we generally want the government we get... on average... otherwise we'd rise up against them and depose them... wouldn't we? They do only govern us because we let them, because they represent we-the-people in parliament.

Even though it's never explained to us in any meaningful way (and there is an argument that things you learn yourself have a greater authenticity than things you are taught) there is the notion of a social contract to life in any society.

We give up rights and powers (cf. a current thread about the breakdown of law and order) to the state in the vague understanding that in return we receive a better deal.

However this compact does need to be honoured to some degree or you will get heads on spikes.

And having paid "a fucktonne" of tax these past 40 plus years, I'm not impressed that the state now needs to ask for even more.

BeyondMyWits · 27/08/2023 16:59

Intelligent people can be arseholes too...not mutually exclusive.

Giving everyone the right to vote kind of smooths out the extremes at each end of the spectrum.

My opinion is that we generally want the government we get... on average... otherwise we'd rise up against them and depose them... wouldn't we? They do only govern us because we let them, because they represent we-the-people in parliament.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 16:59

The idea of limiting voting to those who have bought or earned a tangible stake (such as through owning land or military service etc.) isn't a bad one.

I agree that "bad" isn't the word I would use.

Incidentally, can anyone here put a value on a vote ? (a serious question that some may already suspect has a thrust ...)

Glowie · 27/08/2023 16:44

plehpleh · 27/08/2023 15:57

They used to do that. That's why womens couldn't vote...

They thought they were right. The example you've given is obviously right but there would be many cases that would be opinion, and might lead to serious social regression.

IIRC for all but a couple of years it wasn't a case of men or women, rather you had to own property in order to vote. I'm feel bad for the men who couldn't vote but were still shipped off to fight in wars.

The idea of limiting voting to those who have bought or earned a tangible stake (such as through owning land or military service etc.) isn't a bad one.

BarelyLiterate · 27/08/2023 16:44

Democracy is awful. It gives votes to the stupid, the ignorant, the bigoted, the uneducated, the criminal and the mentally ill. The UK’s particular flavour of democracy, featuring a ridiculous first past the post electoral system, an unelected House of Lords and an unelected, unaccountable head of state, is particularly bad.

The question is what would be better? Of course we could sack the monarchy and abolish the HOL & bring in proportional representation, but how could we decide on what to replace those things with. Referendums? Well, the last one was a disaster for the country as the aforementioned stupid, ignorant etc decided to leave the EU.
And if we decide that the stupid, ignorant etc shouldn’t vote, who decides where to draw the line? So, democracy is indeed awful. But, if not democracy, then what? And who decides?

CheeseCakeSunflowers · 27/08/2023 16:39

surely the whole thing about democracy is that everyone gets a say and the majority gets their choice. So although the racist or misogynist may have the same weight of vote, as long as they are in the minority their choice will not win.
With your system how would it be decided who is worthy of a vote and who is not? At the moment those serving prison sentences cannot vote after being tried and found guilty of a crime which is enough for me.

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:36

@EffortlessDesmond there used to be a culture in the civil service and to an extent all public services of public service. People regularly took jobs for way less money than they could get elsewhere. That culture has been deliberately eroded.
In return those staff got a fairly secure job and a good pension. That too has been eroded.
The idea people only take jobs for the salary is manifestly untrue after a certain level of salary.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 16:31

i meant to add: we like the policies we’ve voted for. Not ones of other parties. Coalitions are a hard sell.

TizerorFizz · 27/08/2023 16:30

@EffortlessDesmond I am personally ok with a coalition but you would find the general voting public doesn’t like delays. We are also used to adversarial politics and it’s getting worse.

We do have a poor method of selecting MPs. Too few are involved. Etonian’s are a minority though!

I noticed “sortition” was mentioned earlier. As this is a random selection of representatives , heaven help us frankly. What do we do if 50% are not up to the job? We need a better selection process for MPs but random isn’t it.

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 16:29

We should have has a coalition working towards a decent Brexit deal

The presupposes Brexit was meant to work. Which it wasn't.

I doubt this discussion would have the same character had Brexit not happened. It's the poster child for a total and utter failure of government at every possible turn.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/08/2023 16:28

On the point that government and governance mean different responsibilities, my opinion is that the Civil Service is well-intentioned but currently inadequate. Too few scientists, definitely non numerate enough and this is hard to fix: there's a UK job going to oversee and regulate AI being advertised at about £80k per annum, whereas in Silicon Valley the head of policy making for Google AI would command 10x that salary.... so which side of the fence does a person choose? The power to rule or the salary?

asterdaisy · 27/08/2023 16:22

I actually think shop steward to MP is less of a problem than Eton to MP. The traditional right wing route was Eton, lawyer, to MP. I think all MPs should have worked in other jobs before becoming MPs.