Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that democracy isn't necessarily the best form of government?

413 replies

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2023 01:36

For example, I'm interested in politics and governance and have spent time learning about the topic, yet my vote counts exactly as much as someone who thinks all brown people are rapists or that all women are nothing more than broodmares.

This doesn't sit right with me. Surely we should acknowledge that some opinions are not as valid as others and take steps to ensure that the lowest common denominator isn't represented equally at elections?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
user9630721458 · 04/09/2023 22:20

EffortlessDesmond · 02/09/2023 21:20

I'm losing track of the content of the threads I am currently reading, so please, ignore this if it's the wrong thread.

On democracy and the "best" versions of government, Singapore is an interesting mini state to consider. Lee Kwan Yu is (AFAIK) the only benevolent dictator to have created the conditions for a prosperous democratic city state, with a 21st century infrastructure, and a really good education system.

However, it is a really good system because it is unashamedly elitist. There are no remunerative options for Tim Nice but Dim.

It seems Lee Kwan Yu was highly motivated to escape the colonial rule of the British and the Englishman's 'assumptions of superiority', and not to be pushed around by Japan either. The whole island must have had really powerful motivations to make it as self governing. They had to unite a multi ethnic/multi cultural society as well Although it could be called elitist, the meritocracy of society is closely entwined with preserving collective identity in a multi ethnic society. With a diversity of ethnicity, languages, religion and culture, it's probably important to insist that success is based on merit rather than ethnic identities. Otherwise their society would be divided. I don't know how Singaporeans feel about Lee Kwan Yu's rule, but he seemed to do a good job of uniting disparate groups and freeing Singapore from colonialism.

TizerorFizz · 04/09/2023 17:29

It’s still nothing like the uk.

EffortlessDesmond · 04/09/2023 09:28

It's a representative democracy now, but its early years - after seceding from Malaysia - were dominated by Lee Kuan Yew... who was pretty close to benevolent dictator.

TizerorFizz · 03/09/2023 20:02

The problem with comparing Singapore with the uk is size. It has 5.6m population and is only 270 square miles. It’s tiny. It has a highly developed economy and is a representative democracy.

Barbadossunset · 03/09/2023 16:53

There were no visibly homeless addicts, as in San Francisco, though.

The huge homeless encampments in SF are so sad and depressing. Grim for everyone, those that are living in them, those who have to try to run businesses in the vicinity, those who have been attacked.
What will happen? Will they just get bigger and bigger with no state intervention while anyone who can moves away?

EffortlessDesmond · 03/09/2023 16:37

That's a reasonable objection @Angrycat2768 . To the best of my knowledge, no one I have met in Singapore is gay so I don't have that insight. It's not usually the first thing that I have to evaluate on going to a new town. There were no visibly homeless addicts, as in San Francisco, though.

Angrycat2768 · 03/09/2023 13:27

EffortlessDesmond · 03/09/2023 12:29

I think that's a bit of a harsh judgement @TizerorFizz . There's actually strong social provision in Singapore, but it's only a small place. That it's so Chinese ethnically and has a fairly entrepreneurial culture is visible in the constant change. I don't know it well, but a cousin is married into a Singapore family and loves it.

My friend at University was from Singapore. She was also Gay, and had a different view on living there. This was 20 years ago, so maybe it's different now. So maybe great for some but not do great if you don't conform to the norm.

EffortlessDesmond · 03/09/2023 12:29

I think that's a bit of a harsh judgement @TizerorFizz . There's actually strong social provision in Singapore, but it's only a small place. That it's so Chinese ethnically and has a fairly entrepreneurial culture is visible in the constant change. I don't know it well, but a cousin is married into a Singapore family and loves it.

1dayatatime · 03/09/2023 09:20

@SerendipityJane

inews.co.uk/news/world/ashamed-brexit-voter-holidays-affected-2581261

+++++

Actually in defence of this Brexit voter at least he recognises and admits that his vote has adversely affected him and he regrets his decision.

Many others in his position would simply blame it on the wrong type of Brexit.

TizerorFizz · 02/09/2023 21:49

@EffortlessDesmond So presumably a lot of stress for them! Sounds unpleasant to me. Everyone can find a role here regardless of characteristic or parental wealth.

EffortlessDesmond · 02/09/2023 21:20

I'm losing track of the content of the threads I am currently reading, so please, ignore this if it's the wrong thread.

On democracy and the "best" versions of government, Singapore is an interesting mini state to consider. Lee Kwan Yu is (AFAIK) the only benevolent dictator to have created the conditions for a prosperous democratic city state, with a 21st century infrastructure, and a really good education system.

However, it is a really good system because it is unashamedly elitist. There are no remunerative options for Tim Nice but Dim.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 18:28

Incidentally it may be a stopped clock moment, but just a record that - on the face of it - I can't find much to disagree with in Suella Bravermans latest polemic about police political posturing - even though I can't put into words how much I detest her and her cruel inhuman and murderous policies.

TizerorFizz · 02/09/2023 16:59

@SerendipityJane Not understanding issues, and possible problems with a pretty unalterable decision (Brexit) is a big issue and is certainly one we need to guard against. Of course it’s bad if few understand the issues but can vote directly for a policy that affects everyone. If it’s one of 20 policies in a manifesto, it’s less of an issue.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 14:38

I've no issue with views that oppose mine providing they are informed and the holder is willing to engage on them

Indeed. But you can't force people to engage, not should you.

However, if someone only parrots a soundbite. and won't - or can't - explain why they agree with it (and that is assuming they actually understand it in the first place) then I don't see I need to really have much time or respect for that person.

Here's someone who clearly hadn't a fucking clue as to what he was busy supporting. Not a single fucking clue. The clue train stopped at every station, but nobody got one. He managed to fall out of the clue tree without hitting a single branch on the way down. The squandered their resistance for a pocketful of mumbles such are promises.

I bet they were also telling anyone who suggested they might want to actually think about their position to go fuck themselves as enemies of the people, we won, get over it etc etc .

https://inews.co.uk/news/world/ashamed-brexit-voter-holidays-affected-2581261

‘I’m ashamed to be a Brexit voter - it never occurred to me that my holidays would be affected'

A gardener from Hertfordshire with a £43,000 farm in Umbria says he is hoping to leave England for good

https://inews.co.uk/news/world/ashamed-brexit-voter-holidays-affected-2581261

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 02/09/2023 14:00

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 08:27

I get the feeling the OP thinks that the only ones who should be allowed to vote are the people that agree with her views on everything. smdh

I think you’re right. If Labour win the next election I wonder if there will still be posts on here requiring a passed test before candidates can vote.

Not at all, I've no issue with views that oppose mine providing they are informed and the holder is willing to engage on them. Ultimately I would want my views to be the prevalent one's in society, who wouldn't?

But as I said, since starting the thread I have released my main issue isn't about everyone having an equal vote. It's about the way in which democracy is administered in the UK, specifically around the lack of standards our elected officials are held too and the lack of mechanisms in place to challenge them of make them accountable.

Just look at how complaints against them are handled by the parliamentary standards commission. Almost all complaints that result in them finding an MP in breach of the standards are dismissed as being "inadvertant" or "on the lesser end of the scale" and no further action is taken.

Revent examples include our current PM, the guy running the country, the ex-chancellor and supposed financial guru, who was apparently so "confused" by the concept or registering conflicts of interest (that directly benefited his wife's investments) that the PCS found the rule breach to be "inadvertent" with no further action taken.

Or how about Barbara Keeley; who was accused of failing to register 3 conflicts of interest within the specified deadline only for it to be found during the investigation that there were 8 more breaches. But she apologies so that was the end of that. 11 breaches and no action taken!

It seems that MPs can breach rules, lie, fail to turn up to work for a year, abuse their position and there's nothing anyone can do about it until an election is called.

I've also never voted Labour in my life and I'm sure there are just as many corrupt Labour mps abusing their position as tory ones.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 13:57

We seem incapable of seeing issues in any depth.

You say that like it's a bad thing.

TizerorFizz · 02/09/2023 13:55

@1dayatatime
I think that’s inevitable. Brexit isn’t what people were sold snd could not be. Remain mostly haven’t changed and still see the obvious negatives. I guess some people will laud our trade deals, our lack of EU workers and increased border checks for goods but it doesn’t take much to see we have diminished influence in the world and very much with the US who are more aligned to dealing with the EU.

Referendums in this country are largely a mistake. Look at the voting system one. Hardly anyone knew what the options were let alone understand them. We see time and time again knee jerk reactions. Look at forcing the convicted to come to court to face the sentence. It’s assuming prisoners feel remorse and will go if the law says so. What about if they become violent? Upset the victims even more? What about injuries to those doing the forcing? We seem incapable of seeing issues in any depth.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 13:49

So on that basis no one will ever be happy with the outcome whether they voted Leave or Remain.

I know. Great isn't it ? The next century can be spent wasting political bandwidth on the colour of a totally unnecessary Brexit, rather than holding those in power to account.

Cui bono ?

1dayatatime · 02/09/2023 13:35

@TizerorFizz

"In many ways it was a protest vote but voters never get what’s promised. They mostly get a shadow of it."

++++

What Brexit would actually look like was never defined other than "Brexit means Brexit " or " Brexit is red white and blue ".

So on that basis no one will ever be happy with the outcome whether they voted Leave or Remain.

TizerorFizz · 02/09/2023 12:00

More importantly, who starts the wars?

I gave a fairly detailed account of why governments find it difficult to implement a manifesto some pages ago.

Also the Brexit mess was largely the making of politicians in the Conservative party and Farage. They drummed up public opinion. The gullible read a bit in the newspapers but the argument for staying in was too complex. Once you have the easy to understand ideals of Brexit pumped you day after day, it’s really difficult for many who voted to see the downsides. They believed everything Farage and others said about finance, sovereignty, trade deals, limiting immigration etc and it was simple to get across on slogans. The detail and possible problems were labelled as “project fear”. This again taps into mistrust and lies.

In many ways it was a protest vote but voters never get what’s promised. They mostly get a shadow of it.

Angrycat2768 · 02/09/2023 11:40

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 09:59

So yes, in that sense, dictatorship is better than democracy- easier to plan ahead!

I think history suggests that dictatorships tend to be quite vulnerable to outside attack. Dictators that weren't offed by their own side were defeated when a neighbouring country had enough.

The problem with dictatorships (I use as my example the Nazi regime, but you are free to find your own) is that eventually you end up with the craven, not the competent. People whose qualities begin - and end - with how quickly they can say "Yes, Mein Fuhrer". And with Hitlers "trick" of deliberately giving vague instructions to many people and letting them fight it out, you eventually end up with the crap of the crop.

There is a true scene in "The Death of Stalin" where the survivors state that because of Stalins repeated purges, there weren't any doctors that could have treated him around. They had all been sent to the Gulags.

Mentioning China ... look how much they are buying into the Big Man theory. Making Xi leader for life, etc, etc.

Have two democracies ever been to war ?

Hmm interesting question! Can't think of many! However some democracies do have a habit of playing war games with various dictators and dictatorships.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 09:59

So yes, in that sense, dictatorship is better than democracy- easier to plan ahead!

I think history suggests that dictatorships tend to be quite vulnerable to outside attack. Dictators that weren't offed by their own side were defeated when a neighbouring country had enough.

The problem with dictatorships (I use as my example the Nazi regime, but you are free to find your own) is that eventually you end up with the craven, not the competent. People whose qualities begin - and end - with how quickly they can say "Yes, Mein Fuhrer". And with Hitlers "trick" of deliberately giving vague instructions to many people and letting them fight it out, you eventually end up with the crap of the crop.

There is a true scene in "The Death of Stalin" where the survivors state that because of Stalins repeated purges, there weren't any doctors that could have treated him around. They had all been sent to the Gulags.

Mentioning China ... look how much they are buying into the Big Man theory. Making Xi leader for life, etc, etc.

Have two democracies ever been to war ?

StefanosHill · 02/09/2023 09:57

Angrycat2768 · 02/09/2023 09:50

The Chinese success story is more or less built on it not being a democracy. One party who is never going to be out of power can make long-term decisions and implement a long-term strategy for growth. Of course they can also force people to work in areas they want to grow, knowing they don't have to rely on some idiot voting for them. So yes, in that sense, dictatorship is better than democracy- easier to plan ahead! Maybe OP thinks she will be one of the governing party rather than one of the worker drones?

Edited

Tbf western democracies have had a good go over history even with democracy which some feel is too short term

And yes not many would prefer the lower freedoms

Angrycat2768 · 02/09/2023 09:54

EffortlessDesmond · 01/09/2023 21:21

It's called polarisation @Kendodd . And it is getting worse, not healing over. Mea culpa, I did not foresee the endless rancour that would follow the 2016 referendum. I used to think that the inventiveness ( and imho, we are really good at inventive) of Britain would be freed to do better.

The UK was a seriously important member of the EU. The UK was more open to new ideas. We wrote and developed many of the basic protocols; Europol is completely based on Interpol, created by the UK between the two wold wars. The basic food hygiene technology and and handling rules. Massive amounts of the health and safety code originated in the UK. Maternity rights. The UK's NMW and living wage rates are at the top of the European league, even since leaving, because the rest have not kept up. The UK has been shockingly bad at claiming all the credit it should be due.

This is the ironic thing. All the 'elf n safety' regulations in the EU were all proposed by us. We were the red tape masters of Europe, yet our governments ( successive) and Brexit supporting newspaper barons pretended this was all imposed on us. We were a big fish in a big pond, but outside the EU, we are a tiny fish in a pond of sharks who can all smell blood.

Angrycat2768 · 02/09/2023 09:50

1dayatatime · 01/09/2023 22:51

Many Chinese not only don’t believe that democracy is necessary for economic success but do believe that their form of government is legitimate and effective
In addition China views Western democracies as in decay and are happily supporting authoritarian regimes around the world.

Reading through some of these posts I think they may have a point.

The Chinese success story is more or less built on it not being a democracy. One party who is never going to be out of power can make long-term decisions and implement a long-term strategy for growth. Of course they can also force people to work in areas they want to grow, knowing they don't have to rely on some idiot voting for them. So yes, in that sense, dictatorship is better than democracy- easier to plan ahead! Maybe OP thinks she will be one of the governing party rather than one of the worker drones?