Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ryanair seat issue. Another airline seat one...sorry

134 replies

thinkfast · 26/08/2023 23:07

Just returned from holiday today. We had booked and paid for tickets including reserved allocated seats in December. Me, Dd8 and DS11 in a row of 3 with DH over the aisle from us.

Board the plane to discover that the layout of the plane has changed and we have somehow ended up in the emergency rows. I ask one of the air stewardesses are we allowed to sit here and she says no...once everyone has boarded she will find someone to swap with us, as children aren't allowed in the emergency row. She finds 2 people to swap with DD and DS- 5 rows ahead of me. I explain she needs to ask a row of 3 adults to swap so I can sit with my children and she says no. I ask several different rows with 3 adults in will they please swap and explain why (and that they would get extra legroom) and they all look at me blankly. DD is crying. Air stewardess insists that I have to sit in my allocated seat and the kids have to be moved. Refused to ask any rows of three adults to swap. The third person in the row the kids have been moved to is an elderly lady so I can understand not asking her to swap, but there were plenty of rows with 3 adults nearby who could've been asked to move.

Previously, if I've ever sat in the emergency aisle I've been asked if I feel able to open the door in an emergency, and been instructed how to do it. None of that today. If they'd asked me I'd have said no. Currently suffering with a knee injury and reduced mobility so I don't think I should've been next to the emergency door anyway!

Luckily, just before take off very kind man across the aisle from where they have moved to eventually agrees to swap with DH.

Aibu that Ryanair shouldn't allow this to happen? Any chance do you think of getting back the extra we paid for allocated seating?

OP posts:
FrancescaSwan · 27/08/2023 12:55

I’m just saying because it’s happened to me. I paid the money for a seat I didn’t get. It was a different plane than the originally planned plane. I went through a loooong process and got nothing.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 27/08/2023 12:18

No, but when they changed the plane their data would have enabled them to see that there were children now sitting in the exit row, and effect a simple swap before boarding.

Exactly. This should have been picked up and rectified before boarding.

RoomOfRequirement · 27/08/2023 12:01

I'd ask for money back for the reserved seats but unless you told them your DCs were medically unable to sit alone, those ages are usually fine to be a few rows ahead of parents.

Naominumbers · 27/08/2023 11:57

If they were 4 and 5 I would see where you were coming from, but an 8 and 11 year old should be fine on a short ryanair flight without an adult beside them. I don't think it's a huge drama.

pinkyredrose · 27/08/2023 11:49

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 27/08/2023 08:22

The cabin crew was unreasonable not to try to get someone to swap with you. You could perhaps have spoken up about your knee injury It all sounds a bit disappointing and a little upsetting. But it’s not the biggest deal to be a few rows behind children of these ages.

I would not bother trying to claim back the seat allocation fee. You will only frustrate and upset yourself and will probably still get nowhere. Just try to consign it to history now. But don’t book with Ryanair again.

Disappointing and upsetting? How the fuck do some people get out of the house alone.

Diospyros · 27/08/2023 11:42

I don't know why you are getting such a hard time, OP. They breached their own seating policy and the CAA guidlines and it is a huge safety issue for both your DC and all the other passengers.

In the event of an emergency, children under the age of 12 need to be seated with or in the next row or across the aisle from their parents so their parents can assist them with oxygen masks or to evacuate.

I believe airline staff are supposed to check that anyone seated by the emergency exits are willing and able to help the crew in the event of an emergency evacuation. OP had reduced mobility due to an injury so she was not able and may have needed help herself to evacuate. Everyone who thinks she is unreasonable needs to ask themselves would they be willing to help with an evacuation or would they prioritise making sure their children are safe? The whole purpose of the guidelines are so parents aren't blocking evacuation by going in the opposite direction to everyone to get to their children. Even worse that the person responsible for opening the emergency door is the person is panicing and trying to force their way against the flow to get to their kids. Don't forget that in darkness or if there is smoke and with people crowding towards the exits, OP may not even be able to see her DC if they are 5 rows away.

There is a reason why you are told to put your own oxygen mask on first before helping children... you pass out. OP can't move to help her DC 5 rows away, may not be able to see if they need help, and can't physically get another passenger's attention to help the DC if she can't reach them while wearing a mask, which she could if they were seated nearby.

An 11 year old with SEN can't be responsible for themselves, and they certainly can't be responsible for an 8 year old in an emergency. Ryanair can't put responsibility on other passengers to take care of your DC.

However, it was resolved appropriately in the end but it should have been resolved by the airline staff without customers having to insist. You are entitled to a refund of the money you paid to be seated together but not any compensation as the issue was resolved. However, I do think you should complain to Ryanair that their staff breached their own seating guidelines and CAA guidelines putting both her DC and the general public at risk in an emergency. Their staff need to be reminded of the safety guidelines. If you aren't happy with Ryanair's response, you can also make a complaint to the CAA.

On a lighter hearted note, I once paid extra to be able to have an in cabin bag because I was carrying several laptops, iPads and other equipment that cannot go in the hold for safety reasons because they have non-removable batteries. The lockers were already full when I got to the gate so they were insisting that everyone put their luggage in the hold. They made me take everything out and struggle to walk a million miles then get on a bus to the plane carrying armfuls of electrical equipment while they checked in my empty case. And then, of course, they had to make someone else take their suitcase out of the lockers to be checked into the hold so I could stow the contents of my suitcase... I never got a refund nor compensation for the resulting cracked laptop screen.

electriclight · 27/08/2023 11:29

It's the 'don't give a shit' attitude that rankles most isn't it - I've just come back from holiday, having experienced something similar.

Their booking system created the error and yet suddenly your family, who have paid extra money to sit together, are not sitting together.

As a passenger I would have jumped at the chance to sit in seats with extra legroom. Why can't they do an announcement? Even if no takers, you'd feel like they cared enough to try.

bert3400 · 27/08/2023 11:22

Prescottdanni123 · 27/08/2023 08:29

Also, if you don't get money back, give them bad review. Won't do them any harm on its own, but if more and more people leave rubbish reviews, more and more people won't use them. There could come a time one day in the future when they are sat there thinking "Oh fuck. Maybe we should have treated people better,".

Give Ryan Air a bad review.😂😂..have you ever heard the CEO refer to his company...he doesn't care ...infact he will say they are shit but people will still fly with them because they have a monopoly for frequent cheap flights

Flippingflamingo · 27/08/2023 10:54

Brefugee · 27/08/2023 10:36

"huffing loudly"

what is wrong with you? they are not allowed to have children in that row. Get a grip

Nothing at all wrong with me, incredibly rude of you to imply there is!

The steward was very rude in the way she was speaking to people. She would have probably had more success had she asked politely if anyone was willing to move. Ryanair were at fault for allocating the emergency row to a family with children in the first place!

JudgeRudy · 27/08/2023 10:39

GuardiansPlayList · 26/08/2023 23:18

It would hardly be fair to expect the old lady to look after and entertain the kids. Planes are tiny and cramped so thinking that you can go up and chat with people is not realistic. You might be able to briefly go and say hello but not for any length of time.

I don't think anyone's expecting someone else to 'entertain' your children. At 8 and 11 they should be capable of sitting 'nicely' for a few hours.
I do think you should get your money back though and an apology for not making efforts to get a good resolution - it sounds like it wouldn't have taken much.
Going forward though my advice would be to nor let your anxiety rub off on your children. I suspect your alarm contributed to the crying. You were in the right though. Even if they weren't kids if 3 of you have paid to sit together that's what should happen. I mean if you pay for say extra leg room you don't get the air stewards measuring your legs n deciding if you need it.

Brefugee · 27/08/2023 10:36

Flippingflamingo · 27/08/2023 09:50

Similar thing happened to a family on our Ryanair flight last week.

A family with 2 children had been allocated the emergency exit row so needed to be moved. The air steward walked up and down the aisle huffing loudly that she needed 3 people to move seats and if no-one volunteered she would just be picking people and forcing them to move.

I had 2 children with me so couldn’t move but luckily eventually someone did agree to swap with the family.

"huffing loudly"

what is wrong with you? they are not allowed to have children in that row. Get a grip

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 10:29

No my 11 year old has SEN, not the 8 year old.

OP posts:
SoIinvictus · 27/08/2023 10:26

SisterWedge · 27/08/2023 10:03

Gobsmacked by people asking if the 8yo is SEN because they are scared to sit away from parent on a plane!

Flying is a big deal to a lot of people, SEN or no SEN.

Stories like this just confirm I never want to fly Ryanair.

Well, the OP has just told us that the child does, indeed have SN.

Perisoire · 27/08/2023 10:11

User287264 · 27/08/2023 09:59

We had a similar experience with Ryanair, last minute change of plane meant everyone's seat numbers were messed up. On one side was me with a 4 and 5 yr old, on the other a parent with maybe 9 and 11 yr olds. They swapped with the people who had originally booked the emergency exit seats. No-one would swap with us. No-one. It was awful. The pilot eventually made an announcement along the lines of "this family's seats have been messed up through no fault of their own. The plane cannot take off with this family in the emergency exit row. Please could someone grow up a bit and swap with them or we'll be here all night." Then someone swapped.

We didn't get any apology or compensation or refund. Just humiliation in front of everyone.

I still wonder if no-one had swapped if they would just have put us off the plane.

But Ryanair is cheap, especially since we didn't have any luggage. You get what you pay for I suppose. And we can visit family 5 times a year compared with the more expensive airlines.

Sounds like a horrible experience, glad pilot stuck up for you.

5 times a year? Do you not think that it’s a bit much given the state of our environment?

AvengedQuince · 27/08/2023 10:11

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 10:02

Have a 🥇for being a cool mum. All families are different, people have explained why their children at that age want to sit with their parents.

This is AIBU, no need for silly medals just because I have a different opinion. The OP says they fly every year so it sounds like they are very experienced flyers.

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 10:10

Oh and to clarify one more thing - the air stewardess never asked for volunteers to swap - the two people who swapped with the dcs were told that they were required to swap - they weren't given a choice. So, she could just have easily required 3 people to swap with us.

OP posts:
floribunda18 · 27/08/2023 10:07

JassyRadlett · 27/08/2023 10:05

No, but when they changed the plane their data would have enabled them to see that there were children now sitting in the exit row, and effect a simple swap before boarding.

A concern about the safety of who is sitting in an emergency exit row but not about the safety considerations of parents sitting a significant distance from their kids on the plane is an airline that only pays lip service to safety and is clearly trying to get away with as little as possible.

This.

floribunda18 · 27/08/2023 10:06

It's not like there is always a choice of airline to get to your destination either.

JassyRadlett · 27/08/2023 10:05

User287264 · 27/08/2023 10:01

This is what happened to us though. We'd booked, say, 24a 24b and 24c in a certain plane. They were not emergency exit rows. Then the physical plane that arrived was a different type with different row numbers so row 24 ended up being an emergency exit row.
So they didn't intentionally allow me to book an emergency exit seat for a 4 yr old.

(Am I actually defending Ryanair here? Shoot me now)

No, but when they changed the plane their data would have enabled them to see that there were children now sitting in the exit row, and effect a simple swap before boarding.

A concern about the safety of who is sitting in an emergency exit row but not about the safety considerations of parents sitting a significant distance from their kids on the plane is an airline that only pays lip service to safety and is clearly trying to get away with as little as possible.

floribunda18 · 27/08/2023 10:04

Also Ryanair isn't cheap in the summer holidays. As for people saying "You get what you pay for" well, this family didn't, that's the point. And if you paid slightly more to use BA, they have been cancelling loads of flights, so they may not have even got away on holiday.

However cheap the flight there should be basic standards.

SisterWedge · 27/08/2023 10:03

Gobsmacked by people asking if the 8yo is SEN because they are scared to sit away from parent on a plane!

Flying is a big deal to a lot of people, SEN or no SEN.

Stories like this just confirm I never want to fly Ryanair.

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 10:03

Both are very nervous flyers. We only fly once a year so it's a big thing for them. DS has mild SEN where he's well able to entertain himself for a couple of hours, but has anxiety about new situations and can't cope well with loud noises.

The woman they sat next to was apparently very kind and held their hands during landing and takeoff.

There was a lot of turbulence on the flight so not much opportunity for me to check they were ok, had DH not managed to get the seat across from them.

I'm annoyed that:

  • it's against Ryanair policy and CAA rules to seat children so far from parents - for safety reasons.
  • it would have been just as much effort for the air hostess to find a row of 3 adults to swap with all 3 of us as it was for her to select 2 people to swap with the 2 children.
  • no one checked if I was suitable to sit next to the exit and IMO I wasn't.
  • I paid to sit together and we didn't.
  • no-one was willing to help and swap with us, even for the extra legroom.
  • the Ryanair system allowed for us to be seated in unsuitable seats.
OP posts:
IHateWasps · 27/08/2023 10:03

I don't think it's relevant either that some people think her kids should be fine to sit alone because I suspect that she knows her children better than any of us and also she had the decency to do the right thing and pay for her family to be seated together instead of being one of those rude entitled parents on MN who refuses to pay and thinks that the other passengers, some of whom will have their own reason and needs for picking specific seats or sitting together with family members, should be moved to accommodate them even if they have paid.

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 10:02

AvengedQuince · 27/08/2023 09:59

I'd want my money back but wouldn't be concerned about two siblings those ages sitting five rows from a parent. My child flew 24 hours as an UM at a similar age.

Have a 🥇for being a cool mum. All families are different, people have explained why their children at that age want to sit with their parents.

User287264 · 27/08/2023 10:01

YetAnotherSpartacus · 27/08/2023 09:59

They majorly fucked up seating children in an exit row.

This is what happened to us though. We'd booked, say, 24a 24b and 24c in a certain plane. They were not emergency exit rows. Then the physical plane that arrived was a different type with different row numbers so row 24 ended up being an emergency exit row.
So they didn't intentionally allow me to book an emergency exit seat for a 4 yr old.

(Am I actually defending Ryanair here? Shoot me now)