Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ryanair seat issue. Another airline seat one...sorry

134 replies

thinkfast · 26/08/2023 23:07

Just returned from holiday today. We had booked and paid for tickets including reserved allocated seats in December. Me, Dd8 and DS11 in a row of 3 with DH over the aisle from us.

Board the plane to discover that the layout of the plane has changed and we have somehow ended up in the emergency rows. I ask one of the air stewardesses are we allowed to sit here and she says no...once everyone has boarded she will find someone to swap with us, as children aren't allowed in the emergency row. She finds 2 people to swap with DD and DS- 5 rows ahead of me. I explain she needs to ask a row of 3 adults to swap so I can sit with my children and she says no. I ask several different rows with 3 adults in will they please swap and explain why (and that they would get extra legroom) and they all look at me blankly. DD is crying. Air stewardess insists that I have to sit in my allocated seat and the kids have to be moved. Refused to ask any rows of three adults to swap. The third person in the row the kids have been moved to is an elderly lady so I can understand not asking her to swap, but there were plenty of rows with 3 adults nearby who could've been asked to move.

Previously, if I've ever sat in the emergency aisle I've been asked if I feel able to open the door in an emergency, and been instructed how to do it. None of that today. If they'd asked me I'd have said no. Currently suffering with a knee injury and reduced mobility so I don't think I should've been next to the emergency door anyway!

Luckily, just before take off very kind man across the aisle from where they have moved to eventually agrees to swap with DH.

Aibu that Ryanair shouldn't allow this to happen? Any chance do you think of getting back the extra we paid for allocated seating?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cinnamonfrenchtoast · 27/08/2023 15:44

Viviennemary · 27/08/2023 15:32

That's really cheeky of the airline. I would never fly with those budget type airlines. They always seem to be ripping people off.

Having to change aircraft at the last minute is hardly unique to budget airlines.

It once happened to us flying to Australia with Singapore Airlines. We were meant to switch planes in Singapore but our ongoing plane had a fault, so they had to fly a replacement in from Melbourne. The only one available was a slightly different configuration so people had to move seats.

There was no other option.

TheWeeDonkeyFella · 27/08/2023 15:41

Viviennemary · 27/08/2023 15:32

That's really cheeky of the airline. I would never fly with those budget type airlines. They always seem to be ripping people off.

It's not just budget airlines adding in extra charges, I'm flying long haul with BA in November and had to pay an extra £180 to book a preferred seat in advance.

TheWeeDonkeyFella · 27/08/2023 15:38

It's not just a Ryanair thing, aircraft can change fairly late in the day, I've experienced it with BA and KLM.

I think you should definitely persue a refund for not getting the seats you booked together and also flag up that no exit row safety checks were undertaken.

But on the point of just telling other passengers to move, as someone who often flies solo I do get fed up of being the one asked. I always pay the extra in advance to book the seat I want in the area I prefer but it's often assumed solos are fair game to move about like chess pieces (admittedly usually by couples or families who wouldn't pay a small amount to sit together when booking which I appreciate isn't you in this case). As well as moving from where a passenger may have booked for their own preference or needs, it's also usually difficult to move cabin baggage again once boarded so you end up separated, sometimes causing even more problems when disembarking if it's further back.

I really sympathise with the issue you experienced but another passenger choosing not to move for you does not make them 'unkind' or 'cant be bothered', they may just have their own requirements too.

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 15:37

gogomoto · 27/08/2023 15:14

Unfortunately I suspect the cabin crew have issues with parents deliberately booking the exit row, whether they realise kids can't sit there or not, also every day parents are trying to get others to move (who haven't booked seats and it gets tedious.

I personally would swop for the extra room myself to help you but I hate not having my bad in front of me (I travel with only an under seat bag as I dislike the overhead lockers and pay for checked luggage) but I can see why people can't be bothered to move seats once they have got comfortable

It’s not possible to reserve seats in the exit row for children.

Viviennemary · 27/08/2023 15:32

That's really cheeky of the airline. I would never fly with those budget type airlines. They always seem to be ripping people off.

Snittle · 27/08/2023 15:32

LoveThisUsername · 27/08/2023 05:24

If I was that bad, I doubt they'd be on a plane.

Resilience was what was needed here, not compensation.

What?! If you pay for a service then don’t receive it, compensation should absolutely be in order. Maybe also resilience but this is a textbook example of when monetary compensation would be appropriate.

RampantIvy · 27/08/2023 15:27

Why do threads like this always bring out the smug parents of perfectly behaved, confident DC, who no doubt become completely responsible and independent adults ready to leave home the minute they turn 18?

It isn't helpful or supportive.

Not everyone is the same. Even adults get anxious about flying.

The idea of throwing a child in at the deep end to sink or swim does not "build resilience". The term is sink or swim for a reason. Not everyone can swim.

gogomoto · 27/08/2023 15:14

Unfortunately I suspect the cabin crew have issues with parents deliberately booking the exit row, whether they realise kids can't sit there or not, also every day parents are trying to get others to move (who haven't booked seats and it gets tedious.

I personally would swop for the extra room myself to help you but I hate not having my bad in front of me (I travel with only an under seat bag as I dislike the overhead lockers and pay for checked luggage) but I can see why people can't be bothered to move seats once they have got comfortable

Saoirse82 · 27/08/2023 15:07

curaçao · 27/08/2023 04:14

They are 8 and 11! They need to learn to be a bit braver and more self sufficient

Oh give over! 🙄

Some adults are anxious flyers! An 8 year old child doesn't need to be braver or more self sufficient if they are scared and want to sit by their mum!

Oblomov23 · 27/08/2023 15:06

Blimey User, maybe start a thread in legal for advice. Can you email and threaten small claims?

pizzaHeart · 27/08/2023 14:55

Theroom · 26/08/2023 23:44

I think it's beside the point that they're children. You paid to be seated together. The airline didn't honour that. Therefore I think you would be right to complain and ask for your money back.

This^ you ended up sitting near emergency exit because of them, it wasn’t on you.
and plus you were with children and one of them was upset and crying.
She should have asked a whole row to move . Complain.

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 14:54

OldandTired66 · 27/08/2023 14:51

Why couldn't dh swap with one child so he sat on the emergency row and mum and other child move?

Because DH was on the corresponding emergency row across the aisle from our original seats (until kind man swapped with him).

OP posts:
OldandTired66 · 27/08/2023 14:51

Why couldn't dh swap with one child so he sat on the emergency row and mum and other child move?

user1471500928 · 27/08/2023 14:49

As a matter of interest - has anyone ever got any compensation from Ryanair?
We had a flight to Funchal on May 8th which couldn’t land and we got dumped in Lisbon instead. Somehow we had to get to Funchal where we had accommodation booked so we had to get a flight with another airline. Ryanair had no seats to get us there. We incurred costs of £1,222 but Ryanair are not responding to our communications is any way. The online form doesn’t work; you phone them and they tell you to use the online form (!) and then ring off; we posted all the evidence to their Dublin address on June 14th and they haven’t even acknowledged it. My job for today is to contact the Press. I refuse to give in!

londonmummy1966 · 27/08/2023 14:43

Turnthelightoff · 27/08/2023 14:23

Did you book on your credit card? Could you apply for a refund through them for the service you paid for having not been provided?

Genius....

OP I think that there was a serious safety issue with that stewardess as she breached 3 safety points - sitting under 12s away from their parent, not checking that you were able to open the emergency exit and not telling you how to open it. That is a really serious problem and she needs retraining. I'd tweet Simon Calder (wel known travel journalist) about this (as well as the not getting the seats together you'd paid for) and suggest that there was a stewardess on flight number x on day y who needed retraining.

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 14:36

Turnthelightoff · 27/08/2023 14:23

Did you book on your credit card? Could you apply for a refund through them for the service you paid for having not been provided?

Great suggestion! Yes I did!

OP posts:
Turnthelightoff · 27/08/2023 14:23

Did you book on your credit card? Could you apply for a refund through them for the service you paid for having not been provided?

Minfilia · 27/08/2023 14:13

RausageSoul · 27/08/2023 13:31

The unwritten rule is only ask someone tp swap if your seat is better than theirs! So an exit row legroom seat would be considered prime real estate and I'm rather baffled why nobody wanted if?

I had the same scenario yesterday, I was asked to move to an exit row as a disabled person was sitting there and had to move!

I said no. 1) because I’d rather sit with my DD, who wouldn’t have cared either way but we’d paid to sit together. 2) you can’t have your bag on an exit row seat on take off and the pilot had already announced the skies were likely to be turbulent so I’d have been stuck without my bag for over an hour. I need my snacks and entertainment 😂 3) I’d have been sat in a window seat and I hate asking people to move out or the way.

And I also couldn’t really be arsed to move!

CherryMaDeara · 27/08/2023 14:06

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 13:49

I don't want compensation, or really even a refund for the extra we paid for allocated seats. My children are perfectly capable of sitting nicely by themselves for a couple of hours. If we'd been on a train this would be a non issue. However they are nervous on planes and this ended up being a very turbulent journey.

They would not be capable of putting on oxygen masks or dealing with any kind of emergency by themselves. Would they be able to adopt the brace position, or would they have been turning round to try to see their parents? The woman sitting next to them was very nice and friendly, held their hands when they were scared etc, but was really quite elderly and I expect she wouldn't have been any help to them in an emergency. She may well have needed assistance herself.

The air steward had a bad attitude and acted like the whole thing was my fault. It really wasn't my fault as I had pre-booked seats that were perfectly suitable at the time I booked them. Had she had one iota of common sense she would have asked / insisted one of the nearby groups of 3 adults swap with the 3 of us. She also had a bad attitude. I heard her saying to another passenger they'd run out of seat belt extenders as there were too many obese passengers on the plane. She laughed and shrugged her shoulders.

To the poster who said my anxiety rubbed off on the children - I really don't think it did. It didn't occur to me that we would be separated until the last minute, as there were several groups of 3 adults seated nearby, so I assumed she would ask one of those groups to swap with us.

I'm sure emergencies on planes are really rare, but are you all saying that if there had been an emergency you would've opened the emergency door and jumped down the slide, leaving your children to fend for themselves? If DH hadn't managed to get a seat nearby surely at the very least I would've hesitated / caused an obstruction inadvertently while I considered the dilemma of whether to go out the exit or try to get to my children?

I'm also fairly sure they are supposed to tell you how to open the door in an emergency in case it's needed - but she didn't do that.

But if you don’t complain and ask for a refund then nothing changes. Do you have her name by any chance?

EarthlyNightshade · 27/08/2023 14:01

curaçao · 27/08/2023 04:40

You would have 2 choices- get off the plane or get over it!

Why only two choices?
Would you not ever complain if you didn't get the service you paid for?
I ordered some clothes recently from M&S. Only two of the three items turned up. I complained and they refunded me.
Should I have let that go as well?

thinkfast · 27/08/2023 13:54

RausageSoul · 27/08/2023 13:31

The unwritten rule is only ask someone tp swap if your seat is better than theirs! So an exit row legroom seat would be considered prime real estate and I'm rather baffled why nobody wanted if?

So am I! Ryanair normally charge extra for these seats as they have extra legroom. I think I had about 6 feet in front of me!
I think once people have done their seatbelts up, they just can't be bothered to move!

OP posts:
thinkfast · 27/08/2023 13:49

I don't want compensation, or really even a refund for the extra we paid for allocated seats. My children are perfectly capable of sitting nicely by themselves for a couple of hours. If we'd been on a train this would be a non issue. However they are nervous on planes and this ended up being a very turbulent journey.

They would not be capable of putting on oxygen masks or dealing with any kind of emergency by themselves. Would they be able to adopt the brace position, or would they have been turning round to try to see their parents? The woman sitting next to them was very nice and friendly, held their hands when they were scared etc, but was really quite elderly and I expect she wouldn't have been any help to them in an emergency. She may well have needed assistance herself.

The air steward had a bad attitude and acted like the whole thing was my fault. It really wasn't my fault as I had pre-booked seats that were perfectly suitable at the time I booked them. Had she had one iota of common sense she would have asked / insisted one of the nearby groups of 3 adults swap with the 3 of us. She also had a bad attitude. I heard her saying to another passenger they'd run out of seat belt extenders as there were too many obese passengers on the plane. She laughed and shrugged her shoulders.

To the poster who said my anxiety rubbed off on the children - I really don't think it did. It didn't occur to me that we would be separated until the last minute, as there were several groups of 3 adults seated nearby, so I assumed she would ask one of those groups to swap with us.

I'm sure emergencies on planes are really rare, but are you all saying that if there had been an emergency you would've opened the emergency door and jumped down the slide, leaving your children to fend for themselves? If DH hadn't managed to get a seat nearby surely at the very least I would've hesitated / caused an obstruction inadvertently while I considered the dilemma of whether to go out the exit or try to get to my children?

I'm also fairly sure they are supposed to tell you how to open the door in an emergency in case it's needed - but she didn't do that.

OP posts:
Prescottdanni123 · 27/08/2023 13:33

@bert3400

I've seen several massive companies who thought they were untouchable go bust - and no one was surprised because their customer service was shite.

RausageSoul · 27/08/2023 13:31

The unwritten rule is only ask someone tp swap if your seat is better than theirs! So an exit row legroom seat would be considered prime real estate and I'm rather baffled why nobody wanted if?

electriclight · 27/08/2023 13:06

Naominumbers · 27/08/2023 11:57

If they were 4 and 5 I would see where you were coming from, but an 8 and 11 year old should be fine on a short ryanair flight without an adult beside them. I don't think it's a huge drama.

Sure, they'd be ok, they'd get there safely. But when you've paid to sit together, why shouldn't you? I teach kids of a similar age and not every 8 year old would be able to cope with this. Of course it's upsetting, if you're looking forward to chatting together or playing a game. It was also presented at the last minute, so no time to discuss, explain, amend plans. It's not awful and it's not the end of the world but it's really fucking annoying when you've paid to avoid it happening but it does anyway, and it's not your fault, and nobody cares, and better solutions aren't even attempted.