Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded by friend's DP, how would you handle?

38 replies

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 20:58

I'm part of a close group of female friends.

We've all been friends for 15 years or so. There are 8 or 9 of us so naturally some are closer friends than others.

Those that are closer sometimes meet 1-2-1 but generally speaking, when we meet in a group everyone is invited.

Last weekend a few of us were out for dinner (the others couldn't make it).

Let's call one of the women who couldn't make the dinner Lucy. She has a partner who we'll call Dave. Lucy and Dave live together in Lucy's house (it's not jointly owned, it's very much Lucy's as Dave is a bit of a cocklodger but that's a whole different thread).

So, over dinner it came up in conversation that most of the group and their partners had been invited to spend that Sunday doing an activity to celebrate Dave's big birthday. Then they'd been invited back to Lucy & Dave's for a BBQ/chilled house party.

Me and my DH were not invited. Two other couples in the group also weren't invited (they tend to be less involved in the group generally through their own choice/priorities, not sure if this relevant).

Lucy had apparently brought up with Dave that the invite should be wider and had told the others she was feeling unhappy that Dave was dictating who she could have at her own house.

It feels quite hurtful to be purposefully excluded. I always thought that I got on fairly well with Dave, we've always had pleasant chats and never had a cross word of any kind.

So how would you handle this - I'm not proposing to make a big deal out of it but would you say or do anything differently in terms of Lucy and/or Dave?

I'd feel quite awkward going to Lucy's in the future, effectively knowing that her DP clearly dislikes me (or my husband, or both!).

Would you say anything next time you saw him or leave it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Atichen · 21/02/2024 10:23

Oops didn't notice how old this was ignore me

latetothefisting · 28/08/2023 12:51

No idea why others are being pedantic, OP, I completely agree with you. It would be different if he specifically got on well with 3 out of 9 of the male partners so just invited them to his birthday but not the other 6. Or if it was an activity with set numbers where you had to draw a line somewhere. But for a group of 7 of the 'closer' couples, to invite 6 and leave 1 out is rude. Particularly in a group that size (and I'm assuming he'd invite some of his own mates as well), he'd barely have to interact with you and your partner if he didn't want to. Even if he didn't particularly like you and your DP, unless he actively had a reason to dislike you, it wouldn't have killed him to have just added you on for Lucy's sake, given she was hosting the party for him and she's probably feeling awkward about you finding out you've been excluded.

I can only assume he doesn't like either you/your DP for some reason - perhaps he's realised you're not a fan of him (but hasn't realised the rest of the group feel the same way!). Or perhaps it's as random as you/dp supporting a rival sports team or whatever. either way, not sure what you can really 'do' about it - if he doesn't like you then leaving him out of future invites is hardly a punishment for him, but would be for Lucy.

ImNotReallySpartacus · 28/08/2023 12:33

Why would he invite someone who clearly does not like him to his own birthday party?

Aprilx · 28/08/2023 12:12

You called him a cocklodger in your first post and now you are wondering why he didn't invite you to his big birthday do! And I know you didn't call him that to his face, but he probably senses that you don't like him.

BigFatLiar · 28/08/2023 11:46

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 22:57

You don't know the whole story (I was clear that there is one but it just isn't relevant to this thread).

It's relevant in that you probably come across as someone who actively dislikes him so why would he want you at his birthday do.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 26/08/2023 23:17

BigFatLiar · 26/08/2023 22:43

it's not jointly owned, it's very much Lucy's as Dave is a bit of a cocklodger but that's a whole different thread).
He actively said Lucy couldn't invite us to the BBQ at her house.

I can see why he's a 'cocklodger' as it's 'her' house and he's still seen as a visitor rather than his home. With the attitude I can see why he wouldn't invite you. I wouldn't either.

OP said him being a cocklodger is a whole other thread and she hasn't given us the story about it so you can't possibly know why he wouldn't invite her. Are you his mum?

Fourecks · 26/08/2023 23:17

I would feel upset and excluded in this situation too. However, I don't think it's relevant in this situation where the party is, as long as Lucy is free to invite you over other times. But it sounds like you don't like Dave, so at least you're spared a night of having to be in his company.

I would organise something nice to do that evening, maybe with the others who weren't invited. And I certainly wouldn't send him a present as PP suggested. I think that would look a bit desperate. PP's situation is different as she was actually invited to the gathering, even if it was last minute.

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 22:57

BigFatLiar · 26/08/2023 22:43

it's not jointly owned, it's very much Lucy's as Dave is a bit of a cocklodger but that's a whole different thread).
He actively said Lucy couldn't invite us to the BBQ at her house.

I can see why he's a 'cocklodger' as it's 'her' house and he's still seen as a visitor rather than his home. With the attitude I can see why he wouldn't invite you. I wouldn't either.

You don't know the whole story (I was clear that there is one but it just isn't relevant to this thread).

OP posts:
socialdilemmawhattodo · 26/08/2023 22:55

This year I was actively excluded from a regular activity I go to with a fairly fixed group of individuals over many years. Plans were changed at the last minute and I was notified very late. The outcome was that I had to drive myself and take my own food (to a group activity). I decided that no-one was going to upset my perspective of the event - so I drove myself (in my sports car), took enough alcohol to drown a battleship (for sharing), took enough food to feed a country, carried the bags to the table and giggled and laughed all night. Part of the issue turned out to be that one of my friends had had to take over caring for one of their parents - sorting out care homes, move etc. The other - the other organiser really doesn't acknowledge me. He loved one item I took to the event - I gave it to him graciously with love and sent the rest I had later on by post. No-one that evening would have known how pissed off I was.

So for your friend's partner's "big" birthday I would send a lovely card, with suitable message and a decent present (if you can afford it and I don't mean £100's). But the message here to your friend and the rest of the group is that it's fine not be invited and you don't hold a grudge. That holds any gossip or bitchiness immediately. But now YOU know. And that is good information to have for going forward. I do agree with many of the other posters that of course not all partners will gell and this is his birthday celebration.

BigFatLiar · 26/08/2023 22:43

it's not jointly owned, it's very much Lucy's as Dave is a bit of a cocklodger but that's a whole different thread).
He actively said Lucy couldn't invite us to the BBQ at her house.

I can see why he's a 'cocklodger' as it's 'her' house and he's still seen as a visitor rather than his home. With the attitude I can see why he wouldn't invite you. I wouldn't either.

Nagado · 26/08/2023 22:37

We all consider him a cocklodger. A few things came out about things he's done or said at one of our days out earlier in the year and we all hold a very dim view of him since then I wonder whether the others are better at hiding it than you are and he realises that you see him for what he is? Or have you said something that could have got back to him via someone’s partner?

I don’t think I’d mention it or say anything about it to anyone and if Lucy mentions it, maybe just say that you were a little worried you’d said something to upset him, but it’s absolutely not a problem and you can see her another time. Then like fuck would I ever invite him to anything ever again & each time I saw him, he’d get icy politeness and excuses that you must go and say hello to your other friends.

billy1966 · 26/08/2023 22:32

I would be encouraging Lucy to be careful of this loser.

I wouldn't be the least bothered at not being invited and I would say it too to others.

pinkdelight · 26/08/2023 22:30

I am bothered that he invited most of our specific group (none of which he's any closer to, none of which are his mates) but excluded us.

Clearly he is closer to some than others, hence why he invited some not others. You can't be hurt by that as you don't like him and aren't bothered by not being invited in and of itself. It's Dave's big birthday not Lucy's friends party, so Dave should have who he wants there.

Canisaysomething · 26/08/2023 22:19

For a close friendship group of 8 or 9 women, to expect all the partners to also get along well with all the other women and partners is way too much to expect. It hurts as you are one of the couples excluded this time but your friend's DH isn't being unreasonable. I definitely can't name 9 friends where my DH likes all of their husbands! Let alone in one single friendship group.

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 22:04

I say the above as apparently Lucy had been saying how unhappy she was that "she couldn't even invite her own friends to her own house"

So it wasn't just a passive thing (I.e. he just invited people he liked the most and didn't think about the fact it might be a bit mean).

He actively said Lucy couldn't invite us to the BBQ at her house.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 21:58

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/08/2023 21:50

It seems very mean spirited to me to invite some people in a close group and not others.

But you’re a close group, you said in your OP, because of all the women friends. In these sorts of dynamics, the men often get drawn into the group by their partners, but wouldn’t actively choose to be friends with all of the other men in it of their own volition, and don’t consider the women in it their own friends at all. It’s unrealistic to expect whole group invitations to birthdays when you’re not actually the group of the person having the birthday.

I completely get that, but none of us are 'in the group of the person having the birthday' so why invite some and not others?

Especially if your DP is saying that she'd like everyone to come to the BBQ at her house (and it costs you no money)

OP posts:
Sickofchangingmyfuckingusername · 26/08/2023 21:50

I’d be fucked if he ever came to mine again, but I would invite my mate always on her own and expect her to come out of understanding and loyalty.

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/08/2023 21:50

It seems very mean spirited to me to invite some people in a close group and not others.

But you’re a close group, you said in your OP, because of all the women friends. In these sorts of dynamics, the men often get drawn into the group by their partners, but wouldn’t actively choose to be friends with all of the other men in it of their own volition, and don’t consider the women in it their own friends at all. It’s unrealistic to expect whole group invitations to birthdays when you’re not actually the group of the person having the birthday.

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 21:49

Personally if my DH said he wanted to invite some of my friendship group but not others, I would tell him that we needed to open it up to everyone or not invite anyone.

(I'm not saying Lucy didn't do that - I'm just saying it's this element I'm bothered about)

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 21:47

Sorry i obviously wasn't clear...

I'm not bothered about being invited in and of itself. If he'd just invited his mates and their partners to his birthday I wouldn't have been bothered at all.

I am bothered that he invited most of our specific group (none of which he's any closer to, none of which are his mates) but excluded us.

OP posts:
WunWun · 26/08/2023 21:45

I would drop him completely. Wouldn't say more than an unenthusiastic hello at group events. I would be the same as normal with Lucy as it seems he is controlling. I wouldn't go to their house though and I would explain to Lucy precisely why if she questioned it

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 21:44

FrippEnos · 26/08/2023 21:41

wheresmymojo

Its easy to see why he likes them more when you consider him to be a cocklodger.

We all consider him a cocklodger. A few things came out about things he's done or said at one of our days out earlier in the year and we all hold a very dim view of him since then.

OP posts:
HennyPenny1234 · 26/08/2023 21:44

You are bothered, you've started a thread about it

wheresmymojo · 26/08/2023 21:43

CClaire · 26/08/2023 21:33

But it’s his birthday. It doesn’t mean he doesn’t like you. You’re his partner’s friend, it’s not as if you’re in a couples friendship group. I’ve got a big birthday coming up and I didn’t want my husband’s friends outnumbering mine 😂 hopefully they’re not this sensitive!

To be clear I'm not bothered about not being invited per se and I wouldn't expect an invitation.

It's more that to invite most of the couple in our group but not us seems unnecessarily mean when he doesn't see the other people any more (it's not the case that he's closer with some of us).

There was no limit on numbers and no money impact either as everyone paid for themselves and in our group you take your own food/drink to BBQs.

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 26/08/2023 21:41

wheresmymojo

Its easy to see why he likes them more when you consider him to be a cocklodger.