Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - new build houses are AWFUL

262 replies

hooplahooper · 26/08/2023 19:36

I am currently living in a BRAND NEW Bellway home - renting while I renovate my childhood home. I was excited to live in something new enough to be zero maintenance while dealing with my own big Reno project...

But holy HELL it's been an awful eye opener for me. I've lived in 11 houses across three countries as an adult - 5 of which I have owned + sold - and I have never come across such bad build quality before. Some of the (many) entry level issues (which the landlord has repeatedly
flagged with the builder to no avail) include:

  • The walls aren't plastered, just painted plaster board - so zero internal sound insulation,
  • the tiling is wonky in all rooms
  • the windows don't seal,
  • half the doors don't catch on the hinges without considered effort.
  • the laminate kitchen counters aren't sealed at any joints
  • the front door hinges are loose
  • the electric car charge point doesn't turn on
  • The stair railings aren't secure
  • there is black mould everywhere from a leak (now stopped, but mould not attended to)

I'fe lived in new builds before overseas - I know there are always snags, but everything about this house feels like corners are cut + quality is compromised.

I'd let it go - I don't really care for me, I'm moving into my own home in 8 weeks - but I'm raging on behalf of my lovely + hard working neighbours here - who have got enormous mortgages on these poor quality structures.

I posted about it on my personal stories and have heard all sorts of even worse horror stories about new builds by Baratt Home, Persimmon + Taylor Wimpey as well. It seems universal that these huge developers are building low quality, parasitic dormitory towns on (often) greenbelt lane - and making astronomical profits from them (650m for Bellway last year..!)

With such gigantic profits - they could be building better quality homes if they wanted to. But they don't. And the government is clearly so caught up in meeting housing targets they are turning a blind eye.

I am RAGING. I am grateful I don't have to live here forever - and furious on behalf of the millions of people that deserve so much more.

YABU - let it go, they're not so bad you terrible snob. People are happy with their homes + can make their own judgements

YANBU - hard working people deserve more + there has to be a way of holding these big companies accountable for prioritising profit over quality homes

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Roselilly36 · 28/08/2023 07:42

I can’t stand new builds, would never consider buying one. Large estates, look like toy town. The quality is shocking. Over the top pricing. No chance to add any value. Professional snaggers are earning well out of them by finding all the faults.

Vettrianofan · 28/08/2023 07:33

"And the foreman here on the Bellway site admitted he would never move into one..."

Yep. That's not uncommon a response from employees of these companies. Most of the labour is subcontracted out.

Vettrianofan · 28/08/2023 07:30

DEX is an area where this post is very relevant. They have been going up at a ridiculous rate and of terrible quality. Tends to be half of Edinburgh situated in this development though.

One of my friends has a parent who works for one of the big five and he has warned all of his DC not to touch these houses with a bargepole.

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/08/2023 22:46

Spaghettine · 27/08/2023 21:40

It's easy to sneer at the boring new builds - but that's very much the kind of maths we were faced with when we were choosing what to buy as well.

True, balanced post. I don't think there's anything sneery about disliking new builds design at all however.

Lots of them are just thrown up with little thought. That's not a slight on the buyer, that's a slight on the developer. If we could build nice houses for workers 100 years ago, why can't we build (similar looking) houses that function 10x better now? we can. They simply don't care about how it looks because there's someone lined up to buy it

There are definitely some people who sneer at new builds - trust me I ran in to a lot of them! We moved from a period property in a conservation area so most of our acquantances were also in period properties. The amount of "ewww, new builds are ALL awful, why would anyone ever want a new build, they're cold, soulless, lego houses, teeny rooms, yuk yuk yuk" type comments we heard from people who hadn't even seen the house we were considering was insane. I swear some of the responses only just stopped short of fake vomit sounds!

It's one thing saying "I don't tend to like the design of new builds, I really like/prefer period features" or whatever. I'd actually agree, I adore nice period features. But many people do go way beyond that - you only have to look upthread! There's often a class element to the comments too.

I wasn't suggesting you personally were sneering (sorry if it sounded that way), it was more of a broad point.

hooplahooper · 27/08/2023 22:01

Badbadbunny · 27/08/2023 19:46

The big firms just engage any subbies they can find to do the work, at very low rates, so they'll never get proper experienced/able workers to build them and fit them out. Time served/qualified workmen can earn a lot more money doing "proper" work directly for customers and aren't interest in low paid subbie work.

All the trades I've dealt with on my Reno project have said similar things - they aren't paid enough or given enough time to care about the quality of the finish. Quality workers, especially finishing trades, can get more satisfying + better paid work elsewhere.

And the foreman here on the Bellway site admitted he would never move into one...

As many people say. Lots of smaller developments / local developers who do great work. But these huge estate style developments aren't being built by anyone who cares about creating quality homes or building community. This one sucks!

OP posts:
Spaghettine · 27/08/2023 21:40

It's easy to sneer at the boring new builds - but that's very much the kind of maths we were faced with when we were choosing what to buy as well.

True, balanced post. I don't think there's anything sneery about disliking new builds design at all however.

Lots of them are just thrown up with little thought. That's not a slight on the buyer, that's a slight on the developer. If we could build nice houses for workers 100 years ago, why can't we build (similar looking) houses that function 10x better now? we can. They simply don't care about how it looks because there's someone lined up to buy it

StatisticallyChallenged · 27/08/2023 21:12

Spaghettine · 27/08/2023 16:26

Have you ever seen a row of Edwardian terraces in a conservation area? They all look similar but they look stunning. Similar in itself isn't bad.

But all looking similar with no character or interesting features. No nature (lawn or fake turf with no trees), driveways with tarmac is the type of new builds people are referring to. Some look good but can't deny lots look so dreary

But the lovely conservation area Edwardian terraces probably aren't comparable properties to the very small new builds people are complaining about. Certainly they aren't around here - they would be comparable to larger/higher end newbuilds.

I've just looked at an area I know which has both - nice Edwardian period terraces, and a fairly recent (few years old) development. There's houses for sale of both varieties right now

  1. lovely edwardian house. Pros: Tonnes of period features (high ceilings, big bay windows, cornice, stained glass screen door. Slightly larger square footage -but it has the classic not terribly useful maids room over the utility arrangement (i.e. the extra space isn't in the main rooms really). Undeniably prettier with more kerb appeal. Nice but not very big back garden

Cons: needs a shitload doing to it: full new kitchen, bathrooms, windows are all single glazed, roof needs work, top to bottom redecoration.
It will cost a bucketload to run, home report estimates 5k per year utilities
Work such as windows will be very expensive as it's in a conservation area so it all has to be done in period style wood sash and case
Only has one bathroom, plus a WC tucked at the very back of the house.
On street parking only.

  1. second hand new build. Also terraced Pros: not hideous looking - small estate, houses not all identical. Modern, easy to live with layout (big kitchen diner for example) Everything still in excellent condition - any spend would be on optional decor as it's quite neutral just now, very blank canvas. Front garden does actually have plants as do neighbours (no plastic grass or tarmac) Has a separate garage so not only on street parking Extra bathroom, plus a more accessible WC Estimated annual utility bills about £1700

Cons: about 10% smaller sqaure footage wise.
Not as pretty, no beautiful period features
Back garden probably about the same size as the Edwardian but it is all paved (most of the neighbours aren't so don't think this was the developer).

In both properties the room sizes are fairly similar - they each have one small bedroom then 3 proper doubles.

These two are in the same area, same school catchments etc. So nothing in it area wise.

The edwardian is 5% more expensive list price, but realistically will probably need a large amount spent (£100k+ IME). By the time you factor in the renovation costs (which for most will end up on the mortgage via reduced deposit) then you're looking at the best part of an extra £1k a month on mortgage payments. Then you've got an extra roughly £300 on utilities per month.

It's easy to sneer at the boring new builds - but that's very much the kind of maths we were faced with when we were choosing what to buy as well.

Tahitiansummer · 27/08/2023 20:34

SomeCatFromJapan · 27/08/2023 15:42

@Tahitiansummer thanks again, some really interesting resources there. We've been toying with the idea of a possible future project in France but it's currently in the dreaming stage, so will be useful to get a clearer picture.

That sounds exciting. The planning stage is so much fun!

Elodie09 · 27/08/2023 20:01

Small /Regional builders are the ones I have heard good things about. Nationwide builders sub out work I believe, so it depends on the workmanship of the person/company they sub out to.
My friend's new build 5 bed house gave her so much grief and upset to get many things put right.
And that was 2 years before the pandemic !

ginghamstarfish · 27/08/2023 19:57

The 10 year NHBC warranty is for structural issues only.

ginghamstarfish · 27/08/2023 19:53

It's well known that the big developers are building crappy houses and pretty much getting away with it. And don't get me started on the issue of 'service charges' that goes with new builds. Tons of FB groups about all these developers.

boobot1 · 27/08/2023 19:52

hooplahooper · 26/08/2023 19:36

I am currently living in a BRAND NEW Bellway home - renting while I renovate my childhood home. I was excited to live in something new enough to be zero maintenance while dealing with my own big Reno project...

But holy HELL it's been an awful eye opener for me. I've lived in 11 houses across three countries as an adult - 5 of which I have owned + sold - and I have never come across such bad build quality before. Some of the (many) entry level issues (which the landlord has repeatedly
flagged with the builder to no avail) include:

  • The walls aren't plastered, just painted plaster board - so zero internal sound insulation,
  • the tiling is wonky in all rooms
  • the windows don't seal,
  • half the doors don't catch on the hinges without considered effort.
  • the laminate kitchen counters aren't sealed at any joints
  • the front door hinges are loose
  • the electric car charge point doesn't turn on
  • The stair railings aren't secure
  • there is black mould everywhere from a leak (now stopped, but mould not attended to)

I'fe lived in new builds before overseas - I know there are always snags, but everything about this house feels like corners are cut + quality is compromised.

I'd let it go - I don't really care for me, I'm moving into my own home in 8 weeks - but I'm raging on behalf of my lovely + hard working neighbours here - who have got enormous mortgages on these poor quality structures.

I posted about it on my personal stories and have heard all sorts of even worse horror stories about new builds by Baratt Home, Persimmon + Taylor Wimpey as well. It seems universal that these huge developers are building low quality, parasitic dormitory towns on (often) greenbelt lane - and making astronomical profits from them (650m for Bellway last year..!)

With such gigantic profits - they could be building better quality homes if they wanted to. But they don't. And the government is clearly so caught up in meeting housing targets they are turning a blind eye.

I am RAGING. I am grateful I don't have to live here forever - and furious on behalf of the millions of people that deserve so much more.

YABU - let it go, they're not so bad you terrible snob. People are happy with their homes + can make their own judgements

YANBU - hard working people deserve more + there has to be a way of holding these big companies accountable for prioritising profit over quality homes

There are new builds and there are new builds. Huge developers or bespoke builders. Like with everything they are not all the same.

Badbadbunny · 27/08/2023 19:46

The big firms just engage any subbies they can find to do the work, at very low rates, so they'll never get proper experienced/able workers to build them and fit them out. Time served/qualified workmen can earn a lot more money doing "proper" work directly for customers and aren't interest in low paid subbie work.

freetheunicorn1 · 27/08/2023 19:42

@Checkcurtains that's ok I will base my opinion on personal experience 🙄

Checkcurtains · 27/08/2023 19:39

freetheunicorn1 · 27/08/2023 18:54

@Checkcurtains according to people that have had need to contact NHBC...

Right, well your assertion based on 0 data or source is not very convincing

HennyPenny1234 · 27/08/2023 19:35

Not surprising when it only takes a couple of weeks to build one

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 27/08/2023 19:08

@greenacrylicpaint

You ask “where is the council/trading standards?”

building control was privatised under Thatcher. The major housebuilders employ their own in-house building control officers.

It doesn’t take a genius to realise that any who stuck their necks out and cost the firm money wouldn’t be employed for terribly long…

Its yet another case of the country going to the dogs because privatisation is a massive error when it comes to public services.

freetheunicorn1 · 27/08/2023 18:54

@Checkcurtains according to people that have had need to contact NHBC...

TheAOEAztec · 27/08/2023 18:44

Spaghettine · 27/08/2023 16:28

I have to also add: nobody is jealous of new builds. Anyone who wanted one would just buy one.

Yup. We looked at them. Ended up with ex council hous3. My 30s-40s semi had more m2 and even with updates costed less than new builds in the area. Considerably less

Checkcurtains · 27/08/2023 18:12

freetheunicorn1 · 27/08/2023 17:24

The 10 year thing is barely worth the paper it's written on!

According to whom?

JenniferBooth · 27/08/2023 17:46

Social housing tenants have had this kind of thing for decades.

THIS DOCUMENT. Myatts Field North refurb.

//www.geog.leeds.ac.uk/fileadmin/documents/research/pfisocialhousing/MFN_PFI_Refurb_Experiences_Report.pdf

Residents were told to remove their pets, but no compensation was offered to cover the
costs involved.
 No consideration was given to residents who worked night shifts.
 Workers used electricity paid for by of residents, without offering compensation.
 Doors were left open and residents were able to wander in unchallenged by workers
who did not know them.
 Quality alterations that residents had already made to their homes were ripped out to
make way for inferior alternatives.
 Supposedly completed electrical rewiring was found to be substandard and occasionally
dangerous.
 Supposedly completed pipe works and its housing were found to be substandard.
 In some homes, odd sized radiators and kitchen unit doors had been fitted.
 Flooding in one home had been caused by an unsupervised apprentice.
 Households were left overnight without running water or a toilet.
 At least one resident was left without electricity for a whole weekend.
 Some workers were found to be abusive, bullying and inconsiderate, especially towards
elderly or otherwise vulnerable residents.

peoplevspfi.org.uk/2017/07/21/myatts-field-north-regeneration-a-pfi-horror-show/

//www.theguardian.com/society/2017/jul/21/the-real-cost-of-regeneration-social-housing-private-developers-pfi?CMP=share_btn_fb

"Hodkinson carried out a qualitative survey of 14 homes refurbished by Rydon that had been the subject of a huge number of complaints. Showers were fitted next to electric fans. A toilet was installed so close to a wall that you could only sit on it sideways. Some households went for days without electricity and weeks without cooking facilities. Cupboards were fitted with wrongly size doors. Tenants who complained reported that they were treated dismissively. One remembered the site supervisor saying to him, “It ain’t Chelsea, mate.” Regenter’s out-of-hours emergency line linked to the wrong database, so callout engineers weren’t available. The striking thing was how long problems could drag out: one family’s flat was flooded in January 2014, and repairs weren’t even scheduled till September. Two years later, their flat still hadn’t been fully repaired and redecorated. Even at the most straightforward level, the work wasn’t done to a decent standard.

When approached for comment, Rydon said that since the complaints were made, three years ago, attempts have been made to remedy the problems. They said the comments were not reflective of most of the residents, and that there was a good level of satisfaction among the residents now.

For tenants with more complicated requirements, the situation was worse. The Cifuentes family, one of whom used a wheelchair, was left without ramps, hoists or any means of escape in a fire, and without a lock on the front door. Repairs were so slow and haphazard that, at one point, the family had to move out for over a month, and the disabled member could only have his needs met by going into a respite unit – whereupon they were threatened with losing their carer’s allowance, their disability allowance and their car."

The real cost of regeneration

The long read: When private developers move in, the first eviction is accountability – then tenants’ complaints procedures and safety. Zoe Williams reveals the truth about for-profit council estates

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/jul/21/the-real-cost-of-regeneration-social-housing-private-developers-pfi?CMP=share_btn_fb

freetheunicorn1 · 27/08/2023 17:24

Checkcurtains · 27/08/2023 16:10

Other than the leak all those snags are minor and I have to question how much your landlord has really tried to get them resolved?

I thought I'd never ever buy a new build due to everything you hear. I actually looked at a number of older, and modern-ish properties and they were in SO much worse condition than what you can get for your money on a new build.

You have a 10yr warranty. Anything that goes wrong in the first few years (esp when they are still building) gets fixed. No major expenses like a new roof, boiler etc.

Unless you're expecting a champagne house for lemonade money, they're actually pretty decent.

The 10 year thing is barely worth the paper it's written on!

JenniferBooth · 27/08/2023 17:22

There’s a load of new builds around the corner from my parents house. Before anyone could even move in they’re being torn down as no damp course was put in so they’re all covered in mould

Hmm Surprised they didnt rent them out as the culture in theUK is to blame any mould on tenants!!!!

Spaghettine · 27/08/2023 16:28

I have to also add: nobody is jealous of new builds. Anyone who wanted one would just buy one.