Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with ppl trying to convince me Atkins/keto only way

91 replies

rainawf · 26/08/2023 18:41

I tried it and when younger did work but now tried it again recently and I can’t stand it. I’m going back to old fashioned calorie counting next week and everyone keeps saying how bad it is and only keto/low carb is sure way to lose weight. What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
12bms34katd · 26/08/2023 21:39

I lost a lot of weight with just calorie counting, using the my fitness pal app and measuring food religiously at the beginninf to get an understanding of proper portion sizes etc.

Keto did not work for me and made me feel awful.

AnIntrovert · 26/08/2023 21:35

You wouldn't be a good lowcarber with your username @YouCantBeSadHoldingACupcake 😁

YouCantBeSadHoldingACupcake · 26/08/2023 21:30

I have lost 53lb since March with calorie counting. It works for me as I don't have to cut out the food I like, just eat smaller portions. Honestly though, the only diet that will work is the one you can stick to, whether it's calorie counting, keto, intermittent fasting, weight watchers, whatever, they all work as long as you stick to them.

TakeBackTheCity · 26/08/2023 21:21

I lost 6 stone by eating a healthy diet and exercising.

When I lost the weight initially I had a lot of people asking how I did it - their faces always fell when I said a healthy lifestyle.

It may not be a quick fix or a fad but it works...

Bacon88 · 26/08/2023 21:18

@ShellySarah

Why is that a bad thing?? It's more sustainable than cutting food groups out for a few months then putting it all back on after. If you can find the balance between reducing calories and still have a normal eating habit then why not have chocolate as part of a balance diet??

I have choclate, takeaway, alcohol, coffee etc. And I am 8st by calorie counting (I am short so healthy BMI before someone calls me anorexic)

I am also really healthy as I have been checked by my midwife so no concerns about the eat what you want but calorie counting diet I have been following for the 10 years before I got pregnant.

Indiacalling · 26/08/2023 21:13

I did very low carb/keto several years ago and lost about two stone. But it messed with my digestion, my hair started to fall out, and it was not sustainable for me.
Now I make sure to have enough fibre from whole grains, eat lots of salad and veg, not much sugar or fatty foods, and lean meats or fish. I love coffee so I do have a plant milk based latte every day as I have a milk allergy.
I would not do very low carb again, but low-ish carb and generally healthy eating - along with plenty of gym time - works for me. I don’t drink so maybe that helps as well. I don’t have the motivation to calorie count but I do need to take care to make healthy choices consistently and that seems to be okay.

2oreosandmilk · 26/08/2023 21:09

Atkins gave me an eating disorder. There is a reason dieticians recommend we don’t cut food groups. Carbs have a purpose

ShellySarah · 26/08/2023 21:07

The caveat with calorie counting is you can eat unhealthily & have chocolate bars as long as it doesn't take you over your calories

Bacon88 · 26/08/2023 21:03

I calorie count and weigh myself weekly. If I gain weight I cut down. People think I am natural thin but it is bs. I do not really exercise but I just count calories.

Calorie counting is the best in my opinion as you can have all the nice things just eat less other stuff. I have cake for breakfast as an example. (Not every day)

AnIntrovert · 26/08/2023 20:58

I have no issues with Low Carb as a way of reducing the processed food people eat and cooking from scratch. It is when they preach the bullshit of the insulin model and the " you have been lied to " that it gets really annoying.

You can reduce what you eat (calories) in many ways. By counting them, reducing a group of them (Low carb, low fat), by reducing the time you allow yourself to eat (IF), but in the end, it is just eating less , one way or the other.

Lose weight in any way and your metabolic health will improve.

AllyCart · 26/08/2023 20:38

The reason people recommend keto/Atkins is because it is (or should be) a way of reducing calories without being hungry and without having to religiously count calories.

Personally I would never do Atkins as I love vegetables and I'm not keen on fatty meats, etc. And Keto is pretty tricky to do properly.

Low carbing is pretty simple and for me is the easiest and most reliable for a long term diet. You quickly get used to it and it's a sustainable way of reducing calories without being hungry.

Rainbowsandrainclouds1 · 26/08/2023 20:30

Keto can work well for some but not for others.

The ones that tend to be evangical tend to be the ones doing 'dirty keto' which is really not healthy long term - as PP said, butter in coffee, double cream etc, net carbs under 25. But, if you do Keto as it was intended, as treatment for epilepsy, you can have a much more sustainable and balanced diet.

Just tell them to butt out of your diet.

MrsB2603 · 26/08/2023 20:24

Being in a calorie deficit is the sure fire way to lose weight / fat - you don’t need fancy diets to achieve this, burn off more than you eat, it’s very simple - not to sound patronising, I just don’t think it needs to be over complicated. Count your calories on an app and be accountable and you’ll be fine

StorminanDcup · 26/08/2023 19:27

You don’t have to do keto or atkins to reduce your carb intake.

There is a vast body of evidence about the benefit of protein and how eating more in a diet will help weight loss and help maintain it too.

If you want to calorie count and it works for you then go for it, but I’ll bet you £100 now that if you take your normal “diet” calorie level and you swap out say 200/300 of those cals you’d use on carbs and replace it with 300 cals of protein instead you’ll feel less hungry and will lose weight quicker (all other things being equal).

People talk a lot about keto because it is proven to be one of the only diets which reverses pre diabetes and helps those with diabetes to adequately control it. It is not perfect but it is a proven way to improve metabolic disease.

MeinKraft · 26/08/2023 19:21

I have tried every single diet going. Calorie counting does work, atkins is torture. The most effective 'diet' was when I had gestational diabetes so had to cut out sugary stuff and reduce carbs. I ate a lot more fresh foods and obviously couldn't eat crisps or sweets or cakes. I lost 3 stone in the last 6 months of pregnancy without trying (well I was trying to manage my diet but certainly not trying to lose weight)

Pabbit · 26/08/2023 19:19

Keto isn't for me either, I find calorie counting sustainable and I lost 7 stone this way and have kept it off for several years now. A natural outcome of more awareness of calories has been incorporating more veg and other low calorie high density foods for me and I like not having restrictions beyond that. It works for others though I'm sure.

Sagedragon · 26/08/2023 19:16

For me, calorie counting is the easiest to keep up for a prolonged period as nothing is bad/forbidden as long as I have the calories left. I've lost 6st over 2 years so far, with another 2 to go.

KajsaKavat · 26/08/2023 19:11

I’ve never done Atkins or Leto but I cut out carbs (yes fruit too) for 10 years and it helped super fast and super well so I do tell people all the time, I think people are often confused about what healthy means. Many think that a punnet of grapes is ok but the sugar content is insane, same with bananas, so if your dieting and getting nowhere peooole will want to help.

Oysterbabe · 26/08/2023 19:10

ImTheBakerLiteGirl · 26/08/2023 18:58

The only people I know who follow it are overweight.

And the award for stating the ruddy obvious.... 😂

The point being that slim people seem to have no issue with evil carbs, almost like carbs aren't the problem...
The only weight loss approach worth considering is one you can sustain forever. If you can't then the weight will just go back on.

Moonshine5 · 26/08/2023 19:08

@AlphaRomeoSierraEcho I know you weren't joking but your comments made me laugh because they're spot on for so many people I know

RitzyMcFitzy · 26/08/2023 19:08

bellac11 · 26/08/2023 18:48

I suppose if you're mentioning/moaning about being overweight or wanting to lose weight, then people will give their opinion on what worked for them

that's what I was going to say. If you're initiating a conversation about weight loss methods people will obviously refer to whatever it is that's worked for them. If you're feeling fed up then stop having these chats and just get on with whatever it is you've decided upon.

AlphaRomeoSierraEcho · 26/08/2023 19:04

My thoughts, from the people I see who are low carb/keto, is that it’s a diet they don’t do properly. I rarely see one without sky high cholesterol because they compensate lowering carbs by eating loads of butter, cream, cheese, belly pork, skin off the chicken, fat edged steaks etc.
The highest cholesterol I’ve seen is over 13, it triggered a consultant consultation. Total waste of NHS resources because some idiot was adding butter to their black coffee each day, another one was practically drinking cream and eating blocks of cheese to fill themselves up, but they all tell me they are eating as much full fat low carb stuff as they can so they don’t feel hungry.

Squirrelsnut · 26/08/2023 19:04

I believe it works very well for many people, but I don't enjoy meat and I do enjoy fruit and vegetables, so I couldn't do it.
I tried it once and lost 6 lbs in a week (I wasn't even officially overweight) but couldn't bear it.

cardibach · 26/08/2023 19:02

RadishAndTwiglet · 26/08/2023 19:00

YANBU if it's not for you. I am evangelical about keto/Atkins, because not only does it make you lose weight like nothing else, but it's cured all sorts of ailments I had and makes me feel alive, sharp brained and full of energy.

But I don't really give a stuff if other people want to do things the harder/slower way. I don't waste my time trying to convert anyone else, I just get annoyed with people who still try to warn me about what a terrible, unbalanced 'fad' diet it is, and how I'll die of a heart attack on it.

I’m glad it works for you. But don’t assume others who don’t do it ‘want to do it the harder way’. It doesn’t work for me. I feel like utter shit - stomach ache, headache, brain fog - and I don’t lose weight. My body needs carbs. Calorie counting works for me.

RadishAndTwiglet · 26/08/2023 19:00

YANBU if it's not for you. I am evangelical about keto/Atkins, because not only does it make you lose weight like nothing else, but it's cured all sorts of ailments I had and makes me feel alive, sharp brained and full of energy.

But I don't really give a stuff if other people want to do things the harder/slower way. I don't waste my time trying to convert anyone else, I just get annoyed with people who still try to warn me about what a terrible, unbalanced 'fad' diet it is, and how I'll die of a heart attack on it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread