Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with ppl trying to convince me Atkins/keto only way

91 replies

rainawf · 26/08/2023 18:41

I tried it and when younger did work but now tried it again recently and I can’t stand it. I’m going back to old fashioned calorie counting next week and everyone keeps saying how bad it is and only keto/low carb is sure way to lose weight. What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 28/08/2023 23:11

@staryellow I had a cake (rare for me) which was gluten free and made with ground almond and it was fab

staryellow · 28/08/2023 23:01

@Crikeyalmighty @TotalOverhaul I really think its the only way to make it doable long-term and when you do it that way you get loads of veg into you and as someone said it's naturally anti-inflammatory. ...win win. I'll check out the bbc goodfood recipes, thanks.

I have adapted a cake recipe I found in a recipe book:
3 eggs
2 tablespoons of coconut oil
1 tsp vanilla essence
2 grated apples
1.5 tsp baking powder
150g ground almonds

Blitz and bake in an oven lined small cake tin at 150c until a knife comes out dry. lovely with coffee for breakfast.

or with cream and raspberries and melted 70% chocolate as a dessert ...

TotalOverhaul · 28/08/2023 22:06

@staryellow - that's the way I want to go too. Small amounts of wholewheat carbs, naturally occurring sugar in veg and fruits. Occasional treats.
I recommend the BBC Good Eats low carb recipes. I made one the other day - chicken with mushrooms, peas and parsley. It tasted so good. I'd made enough for my lunch too but DS demolished it.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/08/2023 15:29

@staryellow that's how I do it- have lost 2stone 3lb in 9 months - only 3 stone to go to be at a level I am ok with. I eat cauliflower rice, small amounts of wholewheat pasta, very very few cakes or biscuits and not much bread (I'm gluten free anyway, so that bits easier) - I did try keto but couldn't get rid of headaches and found it quite hard to make it massively varied

TotalOverhaul · 28/08/2023 14:39

I agree that calorie counting is the best way if done in combination with a focus on healthy eating, because it is the closest to long term maintenance. You can have birthday cake or wine when celebrating. You can eat fries if you really crave them, and still lose weight, but overall, focus on lean proteins and lots of veg with a few complex carbs.That's just sensible long term eating for anyone.

I have a friend who swears by keto, absolutely religiously. She can shrink to a size 10 on keto, and look great but then can't maintain and ends up piling on more than she lost. Every time. I've tried to suggest she just focuses on healthy eating as a long term plan, with a deficit until she is at her goal weight. but because keto gives a quick loss she thinks it's great even though she can't see that she is yoyo dieting and gaining more than she loses, year on year.

There are advantages to keto/low carb, I tried it last week as a fast short term thing and lost 3-4lbs. I almost never felt hungry and didn't have to focus on calorie counting or portion size. But this week I've decided I'd rather lose 1lb a week and occasionally have wholemeal toast or pasta with veggie sauce.

staryellow · 28/08/2023 14:20

The thing about low carbing is everyone says you have to go really low/keto to get into ketosis and lose weight. But I do a 'lower carb' version, so about 50-70g per day, not that I spend too long agonising over it, and I take a kind of 2 steps forward, one step forward approach - e.g. at a family outing the other day, I had an ice cream 😮I also eat pulses and too many peanuts when I want to. And any veg I like. Basically, what I've cut out is bread, pasta, spuds and rice. And for the most part sugar.

AND I still lose weight. I've been doing it about 3 months now and though it's not always been going down, overall I've come down about 2kgs. I had gestational diabetes (which is basically a diagnosis of pre-existing insulin resistance), so I see this as a way of life now, rather than a diet. Hence the moderate approach; I need to know I can stick on it, that there's leeway here and there, that it's realistic. I'm in for the long haul. ... I've tried before and this is the only way it's ever seemed doable.

So though i know this is borderline religious for some people, I know for a fact that my body steadily loses weight on a 'lower carb' diet though it's unlikely because I'm going into ketosis.

The Caldesi cookbooks have helped me, because the recipes actually taste nice. Some low carb diets you read online sounds awful to me.

I know everyone's different, just sharing my long winded tuppence worth in case the extreme low carbing stuff might be putting some people off who might benefit ... I feel way better and more energetic these days

Crikeyalmighty · 28/08/2023 14:17

@RadishAndTwiglet 4 weeks! It's not something I could do long term either as I don't actually much like the diet . I do find I am fine at around 60-90 grams and that's made a big difference.

RadishAndTwiglet · 28/08/2023 14:01

I don't do keto as I get bad headaches on it

How long did you stick with it for? Lots of the low carb, keto style diets suggest you give up caffeine, which I never have. I it makes no difference to my weight loss and if I have to do a caffeine withdrawal I will have a headache. Also the first three or four days or low carbing are tough. You will feel low in energy, lethargic and headachey just coming off a constant supply of carbs. But it doesn't last. If you are doing it properly you'll be rewarded with a burst of energy and a clearer head feel than usual because your insulin levels won't be peaking and dipping all over the shop.

I know so many people who have given up on low carbing at the first hurdle because they've assumed that feeling tired in the first 48 hours means it can't possibly be good for you. They are completely failing to understand what a diet consisting of constantly replenished processed carbs does to you, and what is involved initially in withdrawing from that.

LegendsBeyond · 28/08/2023 10:59

My consultant recommended a very low carb diet for me & it’s changed my life. I’m no longer pre-diabetic & have lost a lot of weight. I’ve maintained as well, as I’ve adapted to a whole new way of eating. I don’t really care what other people do though & never preach about low carb to anyone.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/08/2023 10:39

I definitely can lose weight on a combo of 1400 calories and lowish carb (under 85 a day) but I don't do keto as I get bad headaches on it

SisterwifesofAUB · 28/08/2023 10:16

If it's an unsustainable way of eating for you, it's unsustainable.

I think most if not all of the studies say it's excellent for initial rapid weight loss but not so much long-term so you do whatever you think is most sustainable for you in the long term.

5128gap · 28/08/2023 10:12

Calories in calories out is the only thing that works for me. Any diet that's been successful has just been a novel way of achieving a calorie deficit. When ive cut carbs it just takes out a lot of the foods I'd over eat on so works from that angle.
I lost two stone in 2020 and have kept all but 7lb off (deliberately gained as I was a little too thin) by changing my diet to vegan whole foods. There's nothing magical about what these foods are doing in my body for weight loss. The restrictive nature simply makes it harder to consume excess calories. No opportunist treats. If I want a cake or ice cream I have to go to some effort to find one for example.
I eat all the carbs, no meat and minimal fat and I'm maintaining my weight at post menopause at 8' 10" at 5' 4". If I go above 1700 calories or reduce my walks I gain.

FirstTimeNameChanger · 28/08/2023 09:56

Is it to do with how much weight you have to lose? Not being rude, but the extreme diets - keto etc - always seem recommended by people who have so much excess weight that their health is really suffering. Maybe when your health is so out of whack more moderate diets don't work anymore?

BashfulClam · 27/08/2023 23:54

I’ve lost 31lbssince June. Calorie counting. Carbs are part of my first as are all food groups. Have a look on Facebook instagram at Sean Casey, James Smith and Ben Carpenter - Non bullshit advice.

Objectrelations · 27/08/2023 22:22

If I do low carb I end up feeling completely depressed.

LadyBird1973 · 27/08/2023 22:08

I think studies show that both will make you lose weight, assuming there's a calorie deficit. And for people who eat healthily and cook properly , I think either would be okay. For me , the main advantage of low carb is that it reduces the amount of crap food I can eat - I pretty much have to eat eggs, veg, fish , meat, some cheese/cream/butter, which are real foods. On a calorie controlled diet I could get away with eating a lot of UPF and junk, so I was still hungry and not eating particularly well.
I think it's pretty good to cut down on sugar and artificial sweeteners and reduce dependence on sweet food.

Not all carbs are the same - you can low carb and still eat vegetables and some fruit, you just can't have cake and rubbish carbs.

So I guess the best diet is the one which compels you to eat real food, not one where you can 'cheat' and eat crap with no nutritional value

Crikeyalmighty · 27/08/2023 21:27

I needed to lose weight quickly to get my pre diabetes of44 reversed back to ideally under40 - did this in 4 months with far less carb (under 80g a day) far less sugar ( cakes, biscuits etc) and gluten free - one reason I would struggle with keto is I like porridge ideally with 1/2 a banana for breakfast most days. I'm not massively keen on salads either, so it starts to get restricting. I did try it and I had enormous headaches for days on end (at one point for almost 2 weeks)

bellac11 · 27/08/2023 21:08

TakeBackTheCity · 26/08/2023 21:21

I lost 6 stone by eating a healthy diet and exercising.

When I lost the weight initially I had a lot of people asking how I did it - their faces always fell when I said a healthy lifestyle.

It may not be a quick fix or a fad but it works...

So in other words your calories in was less than your calories out and currently in order to maintain your weight, your calories in equals your calories out

Thats what you've achieved

Squirrelsnut · 27/08/2023 20:55

I did strict Keto back in the 90s. There was no fruit and almost no veg allowed. Just couldn't do it.

BIWI · 27/08/2023 11:31

Squirrelsnut · 26/08/2023 19:04

I believe it works very well for many people, but I don't enjoy meat and I do enjoy fruit and vegetables, so I couldn't do it.
I tried it once and lost 6 lbs in a week (I wasn't even officially overweight) but couldn't bear it.

I need to point out here that a (good) low carb diet doesn't exclude vegetables or fruit (although some fruits will need to be included only very occasionally, e.g. bananas, as they have a very high carb - aka sugar - content).

Also, a low carb diet is just that - low carb. Not no carb. Vegetables and fruits are carbs.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 26/08/2023 22:33

I eat a little healthy carbs, a little protein, a little healthy fat and lots of fruit and vegetables. Seems to work.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 26/08/2023 22:17

'UPFs' are taking over as the current fad so keto will be out of fashion soon. I wonder what will be next.

bluegreenandcoral · 26/08/2023 22:11

I can’t do either low carb or intermittent fasting, both make me feel unwell so I can’t stick with them long enough to even see if I lose weight! Calorie counting has always been the best approach for me and it seems to work so 🤷‍♀️

4timesthefun · 26/08/2023 21:47

YANBU - I had severe insulin resistance, and tried everything including Keto and IF (separately and together). Neither helped me lose any weight, although after the initial headaches etc from giving up carbs/sugar, I did feel good within myself. I needed medication to combat the insulin resistance, and then I could lose weight with a much more balanced approach.