Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fed up with ppl trying to convince me Atkins/keto only way

91 replies

rainawf · 26/08/2023 18:41

I tried it and when younger did work but now tried it again recently and I can’t stand it. I’m going back to old fashioned calorie counting next week and everyone keeps saying how bad it is and only keto/low carb is sure way to lose weight. What are your thoughts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnIntrovert · 30/08/2023 21:00

RadishAndTwiglet · 30/08/2023 09:41

In French there isn't a word nor verb for snack.

There is, actually. A gouter, an after school snack for children, before their evening meal. But I take your point about the French way of eating in general.

Food and diet are complicated.

Margaritawithlime · 30/08/2023 10:21

If you’re interested in research I’d recommend Ben Carpenter’s book
fat loss the definitive guide
Highly, highly researched and full of citations.Fat Loss: The Definitive No Bullsh*t Guide Here

montysma1 · 30/08/2023 10:02

Calorie count, in that you eat less and don't over eat.
But within that, try to limit carbs to the level that you find sustainable. This will help keep calories down and make you feel full longer as you won't be spiking .

RadishAndTwiglet · 30/08/2023 09:41

In French there isn't a word nor verb for snack.

There is, actually. A gouter, an after school snack for children, before their evening meal. But I take your point about the French way of eating in general.

Cormoran · 30/08/2023 03:13

People can have healthy low carb and healthy low fat diet, or the opposite for both extremes.
Most didn't get fat eating lentils or rice stuffed capsicum, so blaming the "carbs" is a bit quick.
The point of this discussion however is the zealots who preach one diet being superior to others, usually thanks to new data, new discoveries you have been lied to, or whatnot nonsense that goes on the fringe of dangerous, such as high cholesterol is not bad for you, eat as many saturated fats as you want.

Any diet that restrict somehow calories intake will work. The one you can stick with is the best for you. You can restrict calories in many ways, reducing a macro (carb) is one of them. When calories and proteins are matched, there isn't much difference between low carb or low fat.

My mother has no idea what a carb is. Happily eats croissant every weekend and baguette every day and is still as slim as she was on her wedding day 50 years ago. You will never however see her taking a bite or drink whilst walking, in a car, on the beach, at the park, anywhere. She doesn't carry food in her bag. She doesn't have a junk drawer. She eats 3 times a day, always seated at a perfectly put table. My kids are never allowed any snacks when visiting. You don't eat between meals is a big mantra in French culture. You eat good food, fresh food, and avoid the cochonneries . In French there isn't a word nor verb for snack. There are a few words with similar sense, but you will never hear a child say I want an " en-cas. ".

One of my son's friend called us " an ingredient family" because we didn't have any ready-to-eat food. Everything required mixing ingredients. There wasn't anything to grab and eat.
When you restrict a macro, you have to become an ingredient household, and maybe this is where the dietary success comes from. Unless you start buying keto bread, keto ice-cream, keto crisps . Or the low-fat equivalent . Grab and eat.

Food quality matters, whatever diet you are on. It is what ends up in your mouth that matters, not what you avoid.

Crikeyalmighty · 29/08/2023 11:19

@LadyBird1973 I feel like that about the fact I now have to eat gluten free- it's easy to reach for the pasty , sandwich, or biscuits or sausage roll- especially if out. It's much harder to 'snack' or eat easily grabbable crap so I tend to make better choices. I eat more eggs, hummus, tinned fish etc , so I naturally eat less carbs anyway (around 65- 85g on average a day)

BIWI · 29/08/2023 10:20

There's a lot to be said for personalisation of medicine (including diet), and Tim Spector's work on Zoe is exploring just this. I definitely think it's true that some diets suit some people better than others. Even on low carb, it's very clear from all the Bootcamps I've run that some people can tolerate more carbs on a daily basis than others.

Back in the day, I was a 100% card-carrying calorie counter. It's actually much easier to follow a low calorie diet because so much of our foods are based around that promise - even if not explicitly about calorie reduction, lower/no fat foods are so widely available, which helps to keep the calories down. And, of course, there's the whole 'Lite' business - cup-a-soup and Muller Lites are the backbone of many a low calorie diet! Which, of course, takes us straight into UPF territority.

LadyBird1973 · 29/08/2023 10:13

And o also think there's a lot we are only just starting to understand about how our bodies process different foods. In the 70s/80s I remember my mum's diets and her view that you could eat whatever you wanted just as long as you stuck to 1,000 calories . She said it could be 1,000 calories of dairy milk and you'd still lose weight, which might technically be true but would cause sugar spikes and cravings. Having read the Chris van Tulleken book on UPF I think there is something in the view that low fat, artificial sugar heavy diets might not be the best way to go , even if you do lose weight on it. Of course, you can do low calorie and cook properly but I think that most people will use the 'cheat' foods if they are available and allowed on a specific diet. I kind of like that most of this is off limits to me now so I don't think about them as much.

hermioneee · 29/08/2023 10:10

ItsNotRocketSalad · 29/08/2023 09:54

So so many studies consistently show that any diet works as long as you stick to it.

They also consistently show that only a tiny proportion of people can/do stick to it. Because food and eating is hugely complex.

There is also evidence that yo-yo dieting is worse for you than being consistently fat.

Yes agreed, which is why what works for one will not necessarily work for another one. The best diets are one where you actually know you'll enjoy the food/ experience enough that you can stick to it long enough.
Going really low carb isn't going to work if you're craving chips all the time. Good ol calorie restriction might though.

LadyBird1973 · 29/08/2023 10:03

I do still eat a sandwich but I buy low carb bread. Obviously it's not as lovely as a sourdough or tiger bread, but it's a good replacement for a supermarket sliced loaf.
I think to stick to it long term, you have to find shortcuts that you can incorporate into your normal life. I don't think I do low carb quite as strictly as bootcamp rules say is optimal, but I'm certainly eating a better diet than before (am a total carb fiend and could live off jacket spurs and cake).

BIWI · 29/08/2023 09:56

Speakerbox · 29/08/2023 09:18

I get that we’re all different but unless you have intolerances, any diet that is super restrictive with food groups is a big no-no for me.

This is often said, as a criticism of a low carb diet.

But as I said before, a low carb diet doesn't cut out a whole food group - you're getting your carbs from veg, salad and (some) fruit.

... and funnily enough, those espousing a low fat diet never say that about their diet, when they're out and about buying 0% fat yoghurts and the like!

The three macronutrients (carbohydrate, protein and fat) are all important in our diets, it's the proportion of them that a low carb diet changes. So instead of being carbs/protein/fat, it becomes fat/protein/carbs.

ItsNotRocketSalad · 29/08/2023 09:54

So so many studies consistently show that any diet works as long as you stick to it.

They also consistently show that only a tiny proportion of people can/do stick to it. Because food and eating is hugely complex.

There is also evidence that yo-yo dieting is worse for you than being consistently fat.

Abhannmor · 29/08/2023 09:48

My sil has tried every diet known to human kind and they all worked at first and then failed.

About 5 years ago she announced , proudly, that she'd lost 60+ pounds. How? ' I eat whatever tf I like - just less of it!'

Sounds good to me.

TheYadaYada · 29/08/2023 09:45

I like the strictness of Keto and the fact you’re never hungry. I also think it’s really healthy. I monitor my blood sugar and it’s always perfect if I’m in a Keto phase.

But if calorie counting suits people, it’s no-one else’s business.

riotlady · 29/08/2023 09:42

YANBU, low carb makes me feel foggy and constipated

MagpiePi · 29/08/2023 09:24

AnIntrovert · 26/08/2023 20:58

I have no issues with Low Carb as a way of reducing the processed food people eat and cooking from scratch. It is when they preach the bullshit of the insulin model and the " you have been lied to " that it gets really annoying.

You can reduce what you eat (calories) in many ways. By counting them, reducing a group of them (Low carb, low fat), by reducing the time you allow yourself to eat (IF), but in the end, it is just eating less , one way or the other.

Lose weight in any way and your metabolic health will improve.

I would agree.

I thought the keto dirt that reversed diabetes was very strict, something like 800 calories a day for 12 weeks and is nothing like what people call keto which does seem to be eating a lot of meat and fat.

Speakerbox · 29/08/2023 09:18

I get that we’re all different but unless you have intolerances, any diet that is super restrictive with food groups is a big no-no for me.

hermioneee · 29/08/2023 09:09

So so many studies consistently show that any diet works as long as you stick to it.
Keto/ Atkins works to help you restrict calories because you feel fuller for longer. It usually encourages you to eat more energy dense foods which is a good thing.

All calories are not created equal, however the general rule applies that if you consume less energy than you use day to day; you will lose weight.

HollieHobbie · 29/08/2023 09:03

I'm currently on a calorie controlled diet and I've lost a stone since early July. It's coming off easier than I thought, the calories are easy to keep track of on the app I use. Im not looking for a quick fix but one that I can maintain my weight on once I hit target weight (another stone to go) plus I've started going to the gym to tone up as I lose. I've tried Atkins in the past unsuccessfully so was loath to try that again.

RadishAndTwiglet · 29/08/2023 08:59

I've tried low carb a few times over the decades, I have never made it past lunchtime. I'd rather carry some extra pounds than not eat a sandwich.

If a few extra pounds were all most of us were dealing with then I'm sure we'd all rather have the sandwich. When it's several stones you need to shift, I'll happily lose the bread and the cakes to be thinner, healthier, have more energy and fewer aches, pains and ailments.

MorrisZapp · 29/08/2023 08:56

I've tried low carb a few times over the decades, I have never made it past lunchtime. I'd rather carry some extra pounds than not eat a sandwich.

IamnotSethRogan · 29/08/2023 08:49

I just think different diets work for different people. I personally lost a lot of weight on Keto after trying a few different diets a few years ago and kept it off. Intermittent Fasting and calorie counting did not work for me at all but that doesn't mean they don't work for other people. I think people who have success on keto like it so much because they can eat whenever they want as long as it isn't particular food groups.

LadyBird1973 · 29/08/2023 08:41

On the low carb bootcamp @BIWI says to drink a lot of water, to flush out ketones and if you are following the instructions (so still eating vegetables, just not the high starch ones) you won't detect high levels of ketones in urine because you will be flushing them out. But your body will be making them in order to burn fat as fuel (since you won't be consuming lots of sugar).
I think. Biwi explains it better.
I just know it seems to work and I'm eating more 'proper' food than not. I do cheat a bit with some dark chocolate and some low sugar ginger beer.

bellac11 · 29/08/2023 07:13

staryellow · 28/08/2023 14:20

The thing about low carbing is everyone says you have to go really low/keto to get into ketosis and lose weight. But I do a 'lower carb' version, so about 50-70g per day, not that I spend too long agonising over it, and I take a kind of 2 steps forward, one step forward approach - e.g. at a family outing the other day, I had an ice cream 😮I also eat pulses and too many peanuts when I want to. And any veg I like. Basically, what I've cut out is bread, pasta, spuds and rice. And for the most part sugar.

AND I still lose weight. I've been doing it about 3 months now and though it's not always been going down, overall I've come down about 2kgs. I had gestational diabetes (which is basically a diagnosis of pre-existing insulin resistance), so I see this as a way of life now, rather than a diet. Hence the moderate approach; I need to know I can stick on it, that there's leeway here and there, that it's realistic. I'm in for the long haul. ... I've tried before and this is the only way it's ever seemed doable.

So though i know this is borderline religious for some people, I know for a fact that my body steadily loses weight on a 'lower carb' diet though it's unlikely because I'm going into ketosis.

The Caldesi cookbooks have helped me, because the recipes actually taste nice. Some low carb diets you read online sounds awful to me.

I know everyone's different, just sharing my long winded tuppence worth in case the extreme low carbing stuff might be putting some people off who might benefit ... I feel way better and more energetic these days

Yes this is me. And I think unless you're talking to someone who's fairly balanced, you always get one of two things, either someone getting very upset that 'low carbing' means you're cutting out food groups and as you say low carb does not mean no carb

Or you get the other end saying that 'low carbing' is not doing it right because you should be in ketosis. I dont want to be in ketosis, ketosis as far as I understand it is a medical condition!

So like you, Im around that figure of carbs, it means I incorporate pulses, some grains, fruit and veg without worrying that it needs to be the 'right' veg but I dont get the cravings caused by having too many starchy carbs (still eat mash from time to time, in fact I have mash for lunch today)

Scarfweather · 28/08/2023 23:22

Why are there posters here saying that keto involves UPF and no veg? That’s just not true.
Been on keto for 4 years with one or two breaks of a month each year at Christmas or on holiday so I can eat regular food with friend and family and top my body up with anything it has been missing like sausage rolls.
It’s so easy, just stick to under 20g carbs a day. No weighing etc….
Lost the stone and a half, back to size 8-10, rid myself of pre-diabetes (had gestational diabetes) and feel healthier and sharper than ever.
I’m not ‘evangelical’, but as a lifestyle change I recommend it, especially if nothing else has worked. People are recommending it to you because in most cases, it works.

Swipe left for the next trending thread