Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope my dad would have been generous enough to help my sister

164 replies

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 14:26

My sister and I are close. We also have a close relationship with our parents who are now both in their early 80’s.

Dad is in good health physically and mentally but sadly our lovely mum has Alzheimer’s. She lives at home with dad. Both dsis and I live close by. I go and see/help them most days and my sister helps out a few times a week. She also cleans their house every week.

My parents are very comfortable financially. They live in a large house which is worth well over £600k and they have hundreds of thousands in their bank.

Since leaving home over 25 years ago I have never asked for money from my parents and don’t intend to or expect any, their money is theirs. As far as I am aware my sister has never asked for money either.

My sister works hard as a full time as a cleaner and runs a small business with a friend. Money has been quite tight for her at times as her partner is a minimal wage earner.

I am quite worried about my sister. In recent years she has not been well. She feels poorly most days but can not take time off because she is self employed and would also lose clients if she took too much time off.

About 2 years ago she developed a thyroid issue. She then experienced some heart symptoms and it was discovered she has very high calcium blood levels. This continues to be the case. After much faffing around by the NHS and lots of scans she was told earlier this year she has Parathyroid disease and the diseased gland will need to be removed.
However, due to the NHS being in the state it is and the recent strikes, her operation keeps being put back. Earlier this year we were told the op would be this summer (I went with her), now it’s more likely to be next year.
And as an incidental finding when having the CT Scans, it has been discovered she also has a large bronchogenic cyst, which is benign but due to its location and a possible risk of becoming malignant, it is advised she should also have this removed (god only knows when this op will be?).
She is becoming more and more poorly. Constantly shattered and sleeps as soon as she comes home from work, has palpitations frequently and feels very weary. The hospital and GP are next to useless. She is not one for pushing anything and is just waiting for appointments to come through. I worry about the long term leaching of her calcium levels as our mum is bent over with osteoporosis and this runs in the family as does heart disease.

Anyhow, long story short, our dad is fully aware of her health issues and how she is currently feeling but will not offer to help her go privately, I have asked him but he says it’s up to the NHS to help her.

If I had the money myself I would not hesitate to assist her to go privately.

Now, I appreciate dad and mum’s money is theirs and theirs to do with whatever they wish to but it’s upsetting that a) give money each month to various charities but can’t help his daughter out and b) dad now controls all the money (mum would have offered instantly) and the majority of their £££££’s in the bank is actually via mum’s inheritance from our grandad and he wouldn’t have hesitated to help my dsis as he was a very generous man and loved us immensely as we were his only grandchildren.

I just can not envisage being in a comfortable financial situation like my parents are and NOT helping my own dc if they needed it for health issues. Like I say this is my dad not my mum. If she had capacity she would not have hesitated to help.

I know they need to keep as much money saved as possible incase mum needs to go into care but even so……

AIBU to think my dad is being a little bit tight arsed?

OP posts:
Grendell · 26/08/2023 16:20

I'm in the states where trying to figure out how to pay for medical expenses is just a part of life.

Medical costs are a slippery slope and can lead otherwise financially sound people to bankruptcy. It is a HUGE ask to have family members - especially stingy older retired people - to pay for other people's medical. The expenses can accumulate quick as this procedure goes wrong, oh, but we need to do that procedure too, oh, but you need to see this other specialist, oh you really need to take this drug but it's new and very expensive...it just never ends. It's risky.

Other options are credit cards, travel to another country and get medical procedures for super cheap, or a gofund me page. Looking to your dad - who won't get a mold removed, which is inexpensive even as a cash patient - is just hitting your head against the wall.

angelikacpickles · 26/08/2023 16:19

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:14

And so the daughter thinks that to herself and gets on with it. You don’t stamp your feet and start name calling. That’s what kids do. Yes it’s disappointing and for your sister it’s upsetting. But that’s life!

Edited

Where was the OP calling her father names? Other than referring to him as tight arsed on this thread, which her father is unlikely to be reading?

Lucyboat · 26/08/2023 16:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:14

angelikacpickles · 26/08/2023 16:11

Nobody is "dictating" anything, on this thread or the other one. The OP's father can spend his money (or not spend it) on whatever he likes. But equally his daughters can think he's a miserly old so-and-so for choosing not to help his daughter when it's well within his means to do so.

And so the daughter thinks that to herself and gets on with it. You don’t stamp your feet and start name calling. That’s what kids do. Yes it’s disappointing and for your sister it’s upsetting. But that’s life!

DisforDarkChocolate · 26/08/2023 16:13

My MIL needs a hip op, I'd be straight there if I had the money. People like your father baffle me, she needs to step right back from them and get the rest she needs.

Also, sit down with her. Get details of how often it's been cancelled and complain to PALs. Copy in her Consultant.

angelikacpickles · 26/08/2023 16:11

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:08

You have to factor in elder abuse when you’re deciding to call eighty year olds names.

This is the second thread in a row of the children of parents trying to dictate what they do with their time/money. No wonder the government are terrified of okaying a Euthanasia bill!

Nobody is "dictating" anything, on this thread or the other one. The OP's father can spend his money (or not spend it) on whatever he likes. But equally his daughters can think he's a miserly old so-and-so for choosing not to help his daughter when it's well within his means to do so.

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:08

You have to factor in elder abuse when you’re deciding to call eighty year olds names.

This is the second thread in a row of the children of parents trying to dictate what they do with their time/money. No wonder the government are terrified of okaying a Euthanasia bill!

ScooterTricks · 26/08/2023 16:07

I’d tell him a few home truths. Then if he doesn’t change, I’d spend the hours that you’re helping him, on helping your sister instead. She needs to stop cleaning for him.

Lucyboat · 26/08/2023 16:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Namechangedforthis2244 · 26/08/2023 16:05

I think that you and your sister need to discuss this properly together and then be clear to him where the boundaries stand.

Either he is part of a family who pull together and help each other. In which case he needs to use some of the money which he has to fund your very poorly sister’s treatment.

Or he needs to be clear that he isn’t interested in all pulling together. In which case he needs to stop accepting your help.

Wallywobbles · 26/08/2023 16:04

Have you ever said to your dad that you'll never forgive them for not helping his daughter when she was so sick and for continuing to use her and making her sicker.

user8928928320 · 26/08/2023 16:04

£50 every 6 weeks? What an absolute cunt. (Is that £50 each, or between you?).

The only thing I have to add is, if anything he is doing (or refusing to pay for) is having an impact on your mum's wellbeing (e.g. refusing to pay for care that she needs) it's a massive red flag and you can raise it as a safeguarding concern with the GP or Social Services.

If I were your sister I'd cut contact. If I were you I'd be tempted but I suppose someone has to keep an eye on your mum.

I know quite a few elderly who refuse to pay for their own care as their savings pile up in the bank. I don't think I know any who wouldn't help out a relative though.

Fuckitydoodah · 26/08/2023 16:04

How sad. Does he not understand the seriousness of her bad health?

I'd do as someone else has suggested and write him a letter to read and digest in his own time.

I think his generation think the NHS should be used to sort stuff out, but it cannot be relied on like it used to.

NoTouch · 26/08/2023 16:02

It is his choice what he does with his money you can't change that and frustrating as it is should shift your focus to what you can do to help your sister that than what you think think other should do. Complaining about your dad is wasted effort and will just bring you down, it is what it is.

Why on earth is she choosing to continue to clean their house instead of letting them outsource it so she saves her energy for her paying clients that will keep a roof over her head? I would really help her explore her feelings why she does this.

Have you/she investigated how much is the operation is privately? Can you and/or your sister take out a bank loan to fund it.

Is she entitled to any benefits she is perhaps not claiming?

If she has kids can you childmind more to give her a break?

Can you batch cook bigger meals and save portions for her to help her out saving her cost and effort?

Thewizardbinbag · 26/08/2023 16:01

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:00

You cannot dictate what he does with his money. You can feel frustrated and exasperated. You can convince yourself it’s not his money to be miserly with. But at the end of the day legally it’s his to spend on what he will and he won’t be spending it on your sister’s health.

But she doesn’t have to take it quietly, not when her and her sister are providing such a level of support for her their mum, which will only need to increase and if the dad goes downhill too then he is going to need them.

No one can make him help, but they can damn well tell him what a selfish ass he is.

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:00

You cannot dictate what he does with his money. You can feel frustrated and exasperated. You can convince yourself it’s not his money to be miserly with. But at the end of the day legally it’s his to spend on what he will and he won’t be spending it on your sister’s health.

Sallyh87 · 26/08/2023 15:58

He sounds like a jerk. However, your sister needs to conserve her energy and stop cleaning for him.

Sleepimpossible · 26/08/2023 15:57

We are in a similar position with my mother in law, a very wealthy woman with unwell family members, who she refuses to help. It beggars belief.
I cannot imagine not doing everything I could to help my children in this situation. Your poor sister.
You are definitely not being unreasonable!

Thewizardbinbag · 26/08/2023 15:57

If you don’t ever expect to get an inheritance then you’ve nothing to lose. I’d rip him a new one (or have a “frank discussion”) pointing out how ill she is, whilst still doing everything she can to help them out. How long she has waited without complaint. And also remind him that your mum would have paid for it straight away, that your grandad would have paid for it straight away and he only has that money because of the 2 of them so he needs to stop being a tight, selfish, useless parent and step up for his sick kid. She might be an adult but she is still his child and she is in need.

I’d go both barrels blazing and wouldn’t give a shit if he didn’t like it.

PreferQuietlife · 26/08/2023 15:54

I'm wondering if you could write him a letter -- and lay it out like you have here - that you believe your mum would have offered, that her dad's/your grandad's money is in the bank, and that you think maybe he hasn't realized (a) how unwell your sister is, and (b) how bad the NHS is right now (the worse things have been in living memory). If he chooses to ignore or argue with it, then obviously carry on seeing your lovely mum but I'd stop talking or interacting with him, and tell him you'e just there to see your mum.

Can you borrow the money elsewhere to help your sister?

I know you've said you don't expect to inherit anything, but they are in their 80's and with over a million of assets in house and cash -- it seems to me to be more likely you will inherit in the end...

Hugs and good luck. You are a caring and thoughtful daughter and sister.

GalaApples · 26/08/2023 15:53

Oh OP this is awful Has your DF any idea at all of the current state of the NHS?
As your mother does not have capacity, does anyone have Power of Attorney for her? If not, could you get it, and then use some of your DM's inheritance from her parents to get treatment for your sister? If someone else other than your DF has PoA for your DFM, could they use your DM's money instead, given that she would want this?
Your poor sister needs to stop cleaning up after him. He sounds extremely selfish, and is more than "a bit tight-fisted". Its not even his money he is withholding. Does your DM have an account of her own?
I would read the riot act to him about your sister's bad health predicament and spell out the worst consequences to him to get him to change his mind. He is being a pig.
'

Enthusedeggplant · 26/08/2023 15:51

Get your sister to take out Bendendon. It will cover her pre existing conditions and is super cheap.

airforsharon · 26/08/2023 15:48

It doesn't matter what he thinks the NHS SHOULD be doing, the stark reality is it's NOT serving many people well. Is he genuinely aware of the the length of the wait for so many things, including cancer treatment? I'll have waited a year if I finally get to have my, so far cancelled twice, ENT consultation for my enlarged thyroid. Many people are waiting far longer, and end up seriously ill.

His daughter is really unwell, he could help her but he's choosing not to because 'but NHS'. I'd be having a strong word.

Totalwasteofpaper · 26/08/2023 15:44

This is really upsetting.
i could NOT let this drop with either of them.
I wpuld be bagging her to stop cleaning and i would be discussing it ever time i saw him and asking him how he think its okay to let his sick child scrub the floor when she has a tumour in her chest and he has the power to help her.

Just horrible stuff. I would be terrified in your sisters shoes... poor poor woman.

Do you have any spare cash - it might be possible to go private and see a consultant specialist then loop back into the nhs process

Redburnett · 26/08/2023 15:42

It is absolutely ridiculous that your parents can sit back and see your sister's poor health but will not offer to fund treatment privately. I think it is partly a generational thing but there is really no excuse for effectively making their adult children wait until the parents die before money is parted with. But you can take action: first your sister should stop cleaning for your parents as she is too unwell to do so. Your parents can hire an agency cleaner themselves. Second you should stop visiting and helping as much, and advise your parents to arrange private agency carers. They will no doubt hate parting with the money but the alternative is for them to use that money for your sister's treatment.
They will reap what they sow as the saying goes, they help with money and you help with care - or you withdraw much care and they have to pay for it from elsewhere.
If not already claiming it is likely that your mother is entitled to attendance allowance which is not means tested and which could go towards private care.
Dealing with elderly parents is always very difficult, you have my sympathy.