Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope my dad would have been generous enough to help my sister

164 replies

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 14:26

My sister and I are close. We also have a close relationship with our parents who are now both in their early 80’s.

Dad is in good health physically and mentally but sadly our lovely mum has Alzheimer’s. She lives at home with dad. Both dsis and I live close by. I go and see/help them most days and my sister helps out a few times a week. She also cleans their house every week.

My parents are very comfortable financially. They live in a large house which is worth well over £600k and they have hundreds of thousands in their bank.

Since leaving home over 25 years ago I have never asked for money from my parents and don’t intend to or expect any, their money is theirs. As far as I am aware my sister has never asked for money either.

My sister works hard as a full time as a cleaner and runs a small business with a friend. Money has been quite tight for her at times as her partner is a minimal wage earner.

I am quite worried about my sister. In recent years she has not been well. She feels poorly most days but can not take time off because she is self employed and would also lose clients if she took too much time off.

About 2 years ago she developed a thyroid issue. She then experienced some heart symptoms and it was discovered she has very high calcium blood levels. This continues to be the case. After much faffing around by the NHS and lots of scans she was told earlier this year she has Parathyroid disease and the diseased gland will need to be removed.
However, due to the NHS being in the state it is and the recent strikes, her operation keeps being put back. Earlier this year we were told the op would be this summer (I went with her), now it’s more likely to be next year.
And as an incidental finding when having the CT Scans, it has been discovered she also has a large bronchogenic cyst, which is benign but due to its location and a possible risk of becoming malignant, it is advised she should also have this removed (god only knows when this op will be?).
She is becoming more and more poorly. Constantly shattered and sleeps as soon as she comes home from work, has palpitations frequently and feels very weary. The hospital and GP are next to useless. She is not one for pushing anything and is just waiting for appointments to come through. I worry about the long term leaching of her calcium levels as our mum is bent over with osteoporosis and this runs in the family as does heart disease.

Anyhow, long story short, our dad is fully aware of her health issues and how she is currently feeling but will not offer to help her go privately, I have asked him but he says it’s up to the NHS to help her.

If I had the money myself I would not hesitate to assist her to go privately.

Now, I appreciate dad and mum’s money is theirs and theirs to do with whatever they wish to but it’s upsetting that a) give money each month to various charities but can’t help his daughter out and b) dad now controls all the money (mum would have offered instantly) and the majority of their £££££’s in the bank is actually via mum’s inheritance from our grandad and he wouldn’t have hesitated to help my dsis as he was a very generous man and loved us immensely as we were his only grandchildren.

I just can not envisage being in a comfortable financial situation like my parents are and NOT helping my own dc if they needed it for health issues. Like I say this is my dad not my mum. If she had capacity she would not have hesitated to help.

I know they need to keep as much money saved as possible incase mum needs to go into care but even so……

AIBU to think my dad is being a little bit tight arsed?

OP posts:
BreadInCaptivity · 26/08/2023 18:54

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:46

BreadInCaptivity JojoMcK, I believe, and he has voiced this several times, that he fears if they have little or no money they will have no choice in which care homes mum or he (if he needed to go in one) would go into. He feels the more money squirrelled away the better the care. We have had SS in and had a care assessment etc and the OT said that due to a wide spread lack of council run care homes nowadays most residents regardless if they are government funded or private funded often end up in the same care homes, receiving the exact same care.

The issue here is all about proportion.

If your sister needed £100k he might have a point.

But £6k - it would make no difference at all.

Premium care homes can cost £2k per week.

That's 3 weeks of care and would have zero impact on his choices.

Even if they spent everything (including the house equity) the LA have to pay for care when their assets dip to circa £23k.

Honestly I appreciate it's difficult and you want to protect your mum but I think you need a tough conversation with him (and your sister).

He needs to understand how dire your sisters condition is and he's not going to "get" that while she is still cleaning for him.

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:54

PoshHorseyBird I have tried explaining but it truly falls onto deaf ears, sadly.
SmudgeButt DH has taken the same approach. He used to get on well with my dad (we have been together 30+ years and they had a great relationship) but since all this has been going on he’s withdrawn more and more as he sees the stress it brings me and does like it. Then when we go to see FIL he’s shaking his head and tutting regarding what he sees as complete ‘tightwadded’ behaviour. It puts me in an awkward position.

OP posts:
Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:46

BreadInCaptivity JojoMcK, I believe, and he has voiced this several times, that he fears if they have little or no money they will have no choice in which care homes mum or he (if he needed to go in one) would go into. He feels the more money squirrelled away the better the care. We have had SS in and had a care assessment etc and the OT said that due to a wide spread lack of council run care homes nowadays most residents regardless if they are government funded or private funded often end up in the same care homes, receiving the exact same care.

OP posts:
BreadInCaptivity · 26/08/2023 18:45

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:38

JojoMcK he is aware of the £3k allowance, his financial advisor mentions this every time he sees him but he has said he doesn’t want to spend it on anything or ‘anyone’.

Well he won't want to spend it on cleaners then will he?

I really think you and your sister need to toughen up and present a united front.

If he had paid her to clean for the last 2 years she'd have enough money to fund the operation - that's the reality.

Equally if she took on a paying client rather than clean for him she could put that to a savings post for the operation.

Get a quote for commercial cleaning services. Tell him your sister can't do it any more until she's had her operation.

You need to make this about him. Don't appeal to his better nature (he clearly doesn't have one) but rather the most financially beneficial outcome for him.

SmudgeButt · 26/08/2023 18:40

No help whatsoever but it sounds a lot like my mom. We needed money which my mom had, and even chatted with me about it "oh dear, what shall I do with all of this?? Oh my, I guess I'm lucky I don't actually need it!!" Thanks mom for ignoring me. If she had explained why I might be better able to cope with this but apparently it was something she should talk to my brother about and not me. It's only because my brother has been open about it that I'm aware now what her concerns were. Net result though is now my DH won't talk to my family at all because they wouldn't help when we were in a desperate situation. And so to make things worse I'm left having to try and defend behaviour I myself don't like.

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:38

JojoMcK he is aware of the £3k allowance, his financial advisor mentions this every time he sees him but he has said he doesn’t want to spend it on anything or ‘anyone’.

OP posts:
PoshHorseyBird · 26/08/2023 18:37

I know you've spoken to your dad but is it worth sitting him down and really spelling it out for him? Something like "Dad I know you think the NHS should be the one to help dsis but surely you can appreciate what a mess the NHS is in right now? She wont get any help for months probably years the way things are going. Would you not even consider helping her by paying for her to go private? She can pay you back via all the current free cleaning she does for you." If he says no then you need to persuade your sister to drop their cleaning why on earth should she add extra to her load to help an utterly selfish father? I couldn't even imagine not helping my child especially when it comes to their health, and with having that much money too! It's really awful. I know your poor mum has dementia but its worrying that your dad now has control of all the money, especially as he seems happy enough to pay out for his own comfort..buying himself a new mattress but not his wife is unreal.

BreadInCaptivity · 26/08/2023 18:36

JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 18:30

Agreed, BreadInCaptivity. I did ponder if he’d use it as a get out. He wasn’t shamed when the OP’s FiL offered, was he? Nor is he embarrassed about the mattress, his obvious miserliness and selfishness.
I’m struggling to comprehend how someone can care so much about money when he’s alive but not give a shit about it when he’s dead. Most people care about both scenarios.
I’m with you all the way with your ideas.
👍

Edited

I think you started the good idea re: the tax!

My guess re: why he doesn't worry about the money post death is simply just part of his selfishness.

If it's not being used to benefit him in some way then so what?

JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 18:36

No, it’s not DOA - £6K is within this year and last year’s tax-free allowance.
OP, temporarily withdraw assistance which might force him into considering respite care. Then he’d realise how far £6K goes as BreadInCaptivity suggests.

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 18:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

I’m so sorry. That should have been for RudsyFarmer. My apologies 😳

OP posts:
JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 18:30

Agreed, BreadInCaptivity. I did ponder if he’d use it as a get out. He wasn’t shamed when the OP’s FiL offered, was he? Nor is he embarrassed about the mattress, his obvious miserliness and selfishness.
I’m struggling to comprehend how someone can care so much about money when he’s alive but not give a shit about it when he’s dead. Most people care about both scenarios.
I’m with you all the way with your ideas.
👍

BreadInCaptivity · 26/08/2023 18:22

Just another thing. He may be concerned about deprivation of assets.

The reality is that given his wealth and what the money would be spent on, there's no way a LA would be able to make a case for DOA's in the future.

It's such a small percentage of his wealth and spent on a good cause that it's clearly not an attempt to circumvent paying for future care.

Essentially if you look at care home fees, you could burn through £6k in a month.

Again it might provide some context for your father. A month of care vs your sister getting her life back.

BreadInCaptivity · 26/08/2023 18:09

JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 17:57

Actually if your sister’s operation costs £6K, he can use the tax-free allowance from this year and last year to pay for it.
Point out that if left in the estate, IHT will take 40% of this. Does he want to gift it to the tax man rather than his daughter?
Suggest one of her clients has offered to pay and shame him into it?
Get him to talk to a wealth manager. He’ll be persuaded how to use his money wisely before he dies.

I wouldn't suggest a client has offered to pay.

That just gives him more reason to say no.

But the idea of using the tax allowance and highlighting 40% to the inland revenue is a good idea.

I would also calculate how much your sister has saved him year on year doing a weekly clean (I would estimate at least 3k per year) and point out if she is too poorly to do it any more then in 2 years he'll spend more on cleaning than her operation.

Combined with the tax it starts to look like a good investment for him.

It's sad you have to put it in these teens though.

The mattress tale was absolutely awful. He should be ashamed of himself.

Frankly if the time comes and your mum needs residential care if I were you and your sister I'd wash my hands of him. Leave him to fester with his bank balance to keep him company.

MsRosley · 26/08/2023 18:01

No useful advice to give, but you and your sister sound lovely, and I'm sorry things are so difficult and your dad is such a selfish arse.

JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 17:57

Actually if your sister’s operation costs £6K, he can use the tax-free allowance from this year and last year to pay for it.
Point out that if left in the estate, IHT will take 40% of this. Does he want to gift it to the tax man rather than his daughter?
Suggest one of her clients has offered to pay and shame him into it?
Get him to talk to a wealth manager. He’ll be persuaded how to use his money wisely before he dies.

ihadamarveloustime · 26/08/2023 17:51

Friggingfrog · 26/08/2023 14:29

Yanbu. Sister needs to stop cleaning their house every week and explain to your dad she can’t anymore as she is too unwell. Maybe he’ll be inclined to help if it directly impacts him. It’s a shame he doesn’t want to help when he’s able to- does he realise how bad the nhs is these days?

100%

I'd be pulling back my assistance, too. They can pay for it.

Anothershitusername · 26/08/2023 17:42

You mum needs to go in to a nursing home
get social services into assess her ,tell them he won’t buy her a mattress,
there are some lovely homes ,your mum would be well cared for ,
then you can cut your dad off ,and leave him to wallow in his own thoughts

JojoMcK · 26/08/2023 17:41

I wonder if he sees his and your mother’s finances as a buffer, as security and therefore overlooks them. Money is safely away from anyone who could “rip him off”. As this is his focus, concentrating on this angle might galvanise him into action.
He cannot assume he will spend some or all of their finances before they both die. Is he aware how much inheritance tax is payable on their estate, regardless of who inherits - how much the tax man will take (rip him off)? In the last few weeks the sum of money gained by the government in the last year from IHT has been published. Refer to it. Do some calculations about your parents’ situation before this exchange. State the amount of money raised from the house and savings which would be taken by the tax man. It’s eye watering. He might see this as a “rip off”.
Still focusing on money, ask him to consider the seven year rule. If he were to pay for your sister’s private treatment now (assuming it’s in excess of £3K), each year before your parents die less tax has to be paid by her upon the sum given. At the end of seven years the tax which can be levied is nil. Be ahead of the tax man, dad, and pay for it now. (Of course, your sister needs it now but he’s not rising to this.)
If you convince your father to release some money, run the implications by a wealth manager before proceeding. That’s really, really important.
Judging from your updates, appealing to him by emphasising the severity of your sister’s health (even if you suggested she might have to raise the money herself which would have a detrimental effect upon her own circumstances) wouldn’t work.

Lucyboat · 26/08/2023 17:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Lucyboat · 26/08/2023 17:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 17:31

user8928928320 · 26/08/2023 17:26

Yeah the mattress refusal plus the taking ages to agree to get a carer to
wash your mum are what I was getting at - he is putting his desire/need to hang onto money over his wife's wellbeing.

How was he persuaded to get the carer in, in the end?

Because he was struggling getting mum showered every morning and I could not help as my own health issues are worse in the mornings. Luckily a friend of a friend is a carer so I had her come and have a chat. She has been an absolute Godsend tbh.

OP posts:
Thomasthe · 26/08/2023 17:29

Being mean with money shows so much about a persons character.

You & your sister sound like lovely daughters. After reading about the mattress on top of this- he sounds incredibly selfish. I think in your position I’d have to say something OP.

Picklemeyellow · 26/08/2023 17:29

ohbygolly · 26/08/2023 17:22

Parathyroid disease is horrific. I've had it before, and have it again. Excess calcium takes a huge unseen toll on your body. You lose the calcium from your bones, which in itself is painful (persistent aches in your wrists and forearms), and the the calcium is deposited throughout your body, particularly impacting your heart and kidneys, leading to high blood pressure, increasing your risk of heart attack, and kidney stones.

But that's the more obvious stuff. Less obvious are the psychological changes - your memory goes, you lose the ability to focus. Your emotional state is hugely impacted - mood swings, depression, anger, irrationality are all part of this condition, as well as the fact you spend most of your time feeling like you could just burst into tears.

Insomnia is awful and you spend hours awake even though you are truly exhausted. Some people find they gain weight rapidly, others lose it. You end up absolutely drained. But the brain itch is awful. No matter how tired you feel, you can't rest, and all the other symptoms pile in on top. You're tired, but you can't sleep, so you get irritable, and angry that this is what you're dealing with. You feel yourself slipping into the brain fog, and so you grasp on to those things you can control (it could well be why your sister still cleans). It's an illness that invisibly erodes you and you disappear into the condition. It is horrible.

But the weirdest thing about this illness is that you have an operation and literally in minutes your body starts to return to normal. Your body recovers and rebuilds, and all the previous damage is reversed. Your bones rebuild, your brain settles. You have a small scar on your neck, but you get yourself back.

I'm not in the UK, so not at the mercy of the NHS. I have health insurance and that covers what I need. But I could never imagine being in a position of feeling as awful as this condition can make you feel and knowing someone could help me and they won't. My heart goes out to your sister.

My sister has literally everything you have described. I had never heard of parathydisease before this and had no idea on the impact on the body. I honestly don’t know how she gets up every day and drags herself to work. She can not sleep at night at all and has put on so much weight which is leaving her feeling so unhappy and depressed. I can not believe the hospital has left her so long. We have a patient service within our NHS, I will help her to write an email to them. I do hope you can get your issues sorted soon. Best of luck to you.

OP posts:
MrsRachelDanvers · 26/08/2023 17:29

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 16:22

If the OP didn’t one of the subsequent posters certainly did.

I’m also reading posters talking about straight talking with the father and telling them some home truths. Alternatively you could have some respect and accept it’s not your money to lay claim to. Elder abuse happens daily but seems to be acceptable to many on here.

Yes I called him a nasty old man. And that I’d tell him some home truths. Of course it’s his money-in which case he needs to be told that as he doesn’t believe in caring for his family in difficult times, he can use the money to pay for home help instead of abusing his sick daughter.

user8928928320 · 26/08/2023 17:26

Yeah the mattress refusal plus the taking ages to agree to get a carer to
wash your mum are what I was getting at - he is putting his desire/need to hang onto money over his wife's wellbeing.

How was he persuaded to get the carer in, in the end?

Swipe left for the next trending thread