Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that shoplifting should be taken seriously by the police and public?

169 replies

ScarySpinster · 26/08/2023 12:04

I used to work in retail. The police would rarely come out for a shoplifter, even if it was £1000s of pounds.

My local village shop may have to close because of teenagers regularly shoplifting. It's just not profitable for them to stay open with the losses they have.

Looking at the bigger picture, shoplifting raids are taking place regularly in London, and all the big cities, with the people involved rarely being prosecuted.

I think that we need to take this crime much more seriously. I don't want to live in a world where there are no repercussions for bad behavior. Because where will this stop? Will burgarly and mugging start to become okay next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 27/08/2023 22:40

Lazyusername · 27/08/2023 22:16

@Unexpectedlysinglemum Because I have a retail business and have worked in retail for 30 years? I am talking about my business if you look at my previous post. I am not talking about stealing to eat. The people who steal on my premises are stealing luxury non-essentials just because they want them. And yes they are mainly teens and there is no deterrent whatsoever. This is setting kids off to a bad start in life; they need to be shown that criminality is wrong.

Oh I’m so sorry it’s your business being damaged by this :-(

do you have cctv? Can you put photos of them on the door as ‘banned customers’ for all in the village to see? A rule about how many school kids can come into shop at once? Or school kids need to show you their ID (eg bus pass) before they start browsing? Can you report them to the school if they are in uniform? Remind all of them they are on cctv as they come in? Not to victim blame but don’t want you losing your business without a good fight and these things might scare then off?

DdraigGoch · 27/08/2023 22:39

Brightandshining · 27/08/2023 21:10

I'm more concerned that people can barely afford to live.
I'm doing OK myself right now, i have absolutely no need to steal, but if I saw some kid shoplifting in these times I'd completely ignore it. Sorry not sorry.

You realise that most shoplifters aren't stealing bread and milk because they're on the bones of their arse?

DdraigGoch · 27/08/2023 22:26

SerendipityJane · 27/08/2023 17:53

Where else would someone who identifies as a police do go ?

Do they bite shoplifters? If not, they're of no use.

Lazyusername · 27/08/2023 22:23

@PumpkinPie2016 Some employees in shops may not care. It's not their business. Believe me the owners of small to medium businesses care very much as they have paid for every item that is stolen. But they also know that there is nothing they can do. The police won't come.
So if you just shrug and say there aren't the resources to do anything about it I guess you are saying it may as well be legal. Just go through life taking whatever you want. It's sad this country has come to this attitude; it certainly isn't the attitude everywhere.

Lazyusername · 27/08/2023 22:16

@Unexpectedlysinglemum Because I have a retail business and have worked in retail for 30 years? I am talking about my business if you look at my previous post. I am not talking about stealing to eat. The people who steal on my premises are stealing luxury non-essentials just because they want them. And yes they are mainly teens and there is no deterrent whatsoever. This is setting kids off to a bad start in life; they need to be shown that criminality is wrong.

PumpkinPie2016 · 27/08/2023 22:12

I do think the general public care.

I also think the police do care, but resources are so limited these days that they have to prioritise the more serious crime e.g. serious assault.

I've probably mentioned this before on mumsnet, but people don't realise just how stretched they are. To give an example, my dad is a retired police officer who worked in our medium sized town.
In the late 80s/early to mid 90s, he was at divisional HQ and the shift paraded on with 18 officers. On top of that, there were smaller, sub stations around the town - 3 that I can think of. They used to parade on with 4 per station. So, on a shift, you had 30 officers to go out and about.
Now, substations have closed and HQ parade on with 9 officers. 9, for the whole town!! It's madness!

Back to shoplifting though, some shops seem not to care. I once witnessed a man going round a co op store, filling two carrier bags with goods. Walked out without paying. Several staff saw him but not one batted an eyelid!
I also saw, in the cafe of a large city centre hospital, a man, in full view, take a bottle of juice, cake and bag of crisps and breeze out, past the security guard, without a care in the world. I actually pointed out to the security guard and the lady behind the counter that he had stolen. Their response- 'oh people do it all the time', like it was totally normal.

In a nutshell, people should care, some do. It's obviously wrong to shop lift, but there aren't the resources to go chasing every shoplifter.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 27/08/2023 21:59

How do you know it's teens?
I was recently offered 'half price' random goods from a rucksack by a 40+ man behind a mall that I'm guessing he must have just shoplifted - I think the COL crisis is hitting families hard- encouraging parents to shop lift for themselves and also to sell items on to families who can't afford to pay full price. I also wonder if he was an asylum seeker desperate and not able to make ends meet as can't work.

Lazyusername · 27/08/2023 21:23

@Lonicerax Some of them know it. But a lot of them don't. They are thick. That's why they are out stealing. And they don't like being interviewed by the police or the threat of their parents being informed (a lot of the parents actually do care from my experience when the police did used to call them).
In my opinion, having a society where people are going around openly committing crimes without any sanction whatsoever is harmful to every single member of that society. It's openly demonstrating that crime does pay and that there is no point being a good person as the criminals come out better off. I believe this lackadaisical attitude is partly responsible for the toxic environment we all have to live in nowadays.

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 21:14

heir details in a notebook and saying they would be prosecuted if they ever stole again. It took the police minimal time and was a great deterrent.

But surely if they are under age they’re not going to be prosecuted and they know it.

Brightandshining · 27/08/2023 21:10

I'm more concerned that people can barely afford to live.
I'm doing OK myself right now, i have absolutely no need to steal, but if I saw some kid shoplifting in these times I'd completely ignore it. Sorry not sorry.

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 20:53

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 20:33

people's lives and livelihoods, and instead do stupid stuff around hurty feelz on the internet.

Our MPs make the laws. And I imagine the home office directs what needs prioritised.
And the put upon minority groups led on forcing a stop on giving them hurtzy feels - if more people had contacted their MPs to criticise the phobic comments legislation but everyone did nothing. Now it’s here and the law is what it is. I can’t imagine anyone joining the police expected to be spending their time on hurtzy comments.

Actually, the College of Policing, a private organisation, drew up the guidelines on responding to and recording non-crime hate incidents, which have taken up so much police time, and which is now being pushed back against. They over-reached, a lot.

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 20:50

1 shoplifting crime would take hours and hours to investigate then court time then what punishment could you give them

This is such a defeatist attitude. As a PP said, bicycle theft is rife. There are examples of bike owners seeing their own bikes on sale on Facebook, meaning they have the name and address of the thief. And the police still won't do anything. There are examples of the same people raiding the same shops at the same time every day and the police still don't do anything.

I don't blame any small retailer for just shutting up shop in the face of such lack of support.

Lazyusername · 27/08/2023 20:48

I own a retail business which has been going some 30 years. Back in the day you could call the police and they would come out for shoplifting incidents. In my business we have mainly teenagers stealing. It's not because of the economy; there is no valid excuse for it. Previously, there would be a couple of PCSO's or officers walking around the city centre. They would attend a theft and then frighten the life out of the teen by writing their details in a notebook and saying they would be prosecuted if they ever stole again. It took the police minimal time and was a great deterrent. Now everyone knows you can go ahead and steal with no consequences so unsurprisingly shoplifting is rife. I don't understand how the police can't see it is not a waste of time to get out there on the streets deterring people and hence stopping all of those kids from going on to commit more and more crimes.

My other comment is that in my experience different forces are vastly different and one I have had interactions with is corrupt and will falsify the facts to suit themselves. They refuse to issue crime numbers and I have also actually identified shoplifters by name and had clear footage of the crime and they have refused to do anything at all about it. In another area the police would engage with us small businesses and try to help. So it varies by area.

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 20:33

people's lives and livelihoods, and instead do stupid stuff around hurty feelz on the internet.

Our MPs make the laws. And I imagine the home office directs what needs prioritised.
And the put upon minority groups led on forcing a stop on giving them hurtzy feels - if more people had contacted their MPs to criticise the phobic comments legislation but everyone did nothing. Now it’s here and the law is what it is. I can’t imagine anyone joining the police expected to be spending their time on hurtzy comments.

user1477391263 · 27/08/2023 20:28

Totally agree, OP. Shoplifting is not a victimless crime. It pushes up prices for everyone, it drives shops to do things like putting items in cases or behind counters, it creates an unsafe atmosphere when observed and makes the shop feel like a threatening environment.

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 20:24

Look people !
Exactly what should happen to these thieves?
Because despite hours of police work, witness statements, checking video, arresting etc -what should happen - no one will get jail, maybe some community work - ooh yes, that’ll sort it -not.
Thieves will either disappear/ have some sob story/ plead mental I’ll health etc etc
Were an enlightened western country where the human rights apply to baddies as well as goodies.
We could go back to shops having counters where the assistant hands you what you want and takes your money. And actual doors you have to open to get in and out.

rwalker · 27/08/2023 20:23

I used to work in retail
Let’s be honest at best you’d have some shitty cctv image of someone with a hood and a mask they’ll be off before police arrive
The evidence they’ll have to go off will be practically none existent

staff quite shouldn’t tackle them it’s not being dramatic to say they are at risk of being stabbed or seriously assaulted

I think for some retailers will be going down the click and collect route

1 shoplifting crime would take hours and hours to investigate then court time then what punishment could you give them

I think retailers are going to have to change the way we shop back to the old days were everything was out of public reach and assistant got it which is now click and collect

manontroppo · 27/08/2023 20:13

Mental health calls should not be the Police’s problem to deal with until a crime is in progress.

Bicycle theft in Cambridge has been massively reduced by one Facebook group, when the police did bog all.

My personal interactions with the police give me no faith that they will provide a response to a crime in my area. The news regarding corruption in the Met, and overreaction to social media spats also give me little faith in the police.

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 20:08

So @crumblylancs you're saying that you actually agree with me! When I talk about "the police" I'm not distinguishing between the rank and file and the leads. They are all in the same organisation to me. The outcome is the same.

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 20:05

But the point of this thread is that many people are of the impression that police are choosing not to investigate crime that really affects people's lives and livelihoods, and instead do stupid stuff around hurty feelz on the internet.

Cyber crime, shop lifting, house breaking, stalking, harassment, all seem to come under the category of "too trivial/tricky" and serious crimes such as rape and sexual assault are committed with near impunity. In the meantime Suffolk police are threatening a woman with arrest for reading an online magazine written by women.

crumblylancs · 27/08/2023 19:55

Felix125 · 27/08/2023 19:23

RhymesWithOrange
So that was one job - and each job has to be taken on its own merits. And it will have been investigated by one cop. And each cop on a shift will have a dozen jobs on their crime queue which they just tick over when they can (common assaults, thefts etc etc).

If there was threats or something similar which suggested a crime (harassment or malicious communication) then it needs to be investigated. And what isn't harassment to you - maybe to someone else.

It gets to the stage of saying - do the police just ignore all harassment & mal comms over social media? What if its and ex-partner doing this and its causing the victim's life to be a complete misery. May be trivial to some people, but to the victim its not.

It's also been passed through a gate which has resulted in a charge by CPS, so there must have been some sort of evidence there to suggest a crime.

👏🏼👏🏼

crumblylancs · 27/08/2023 19:54

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 18:56

So no one is allowed to have an opinion unless they're actually in the police? How ridiculous. The police themselves have described the forces as having major problems. My good friend in Police Scotland is in despair at what his superiors are telling him to spend his time on.

If you can't stand up to public scrutiny you have no business being in public service.

No you don't have to be in the police to have an opinion but before you start spouting absolute shit that you know nothing about, you might want to actually look a bit deeper than the media.

Public scrutiny is one thing but what its based upon isn't always a full story (there are obviously examples where it is, I certainly would not be condoning the likes of Wayne Couzins)

I'd also agree with your friend in police Scotland, I despair at what we spend our time on! I honestly think you would struggle to find a regular cop who doesn't agree with that- the time spent to investigate crime reports (regardless of what they are) is taken over by relentless mental health jobs and others which have been previously mentioned.

Felix125 · 27/08/2023 19:23

RhymesWithOrange
So that was one job - and each job has to be taken on its own merits. And it will have been investigated by one cop. And each cop on a shift will have a dozen jobs on their crime queue which they just tick over when they can (common assaults, thefts etc etc).

If there was threats or something similar which suggested a crime (harassment or malicious communication) then it needs to be investigated. And what isn't harassment to you - maybe to someone else.

It gets to the stage of saying - do the police just ignore all harassment & mal comms over social media? What if its and ex-partner doing this and its causing the victim's life to be a complete misery. May be trivial to some people, but to the victim its not.

It's also been passed through a gate which has resulted in a charge by CPS, so there must have been some sort of evidence there to suggest a crime.