Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that shoplifting should be taken seriously by the police and public?

169 replies

ScarySpinster · 26/08/2023 12:04

I used to work in retail. The police would rarely come out for a shoplifter, even if it was £1000s of pounds.

My local village shop may have to close because of teenagers regularly shoplifting. It's just not profitable for them to stay open with the losses they have.

Looking at the bigger picture, shoplifting raids are taking place regularly in London, and all the big cities, with the people involved rarely being prosecuted.

I think that we need to take this crime much more seriously. I don't want to live in a world where there are no repercussions for bad behavior. Because where will this stop? Will burgarly and mugging start to become okay next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
FindingMeno · 29/08/2023 07:33

Quite honestly I find it hard to get worked up about shoplifting from big chain stores with our appalling conviction rate for rape.

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 07:25

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 00:54

SerendipityJane
Seems our glorious Home Secretary is a Mumsnetter.

And she also appears to have no clue about reality

The two are most certainly not mutually exclusive.

RhymesWithOrange · 29/08/2023 06:54

@Felix125 those procedures you describe sound massively outdated and inefficient. Which, talking to my friends in the police, is part of the problem. But if the problem is so bad I can't get my head around the fact that teams of police were sent to arrest / give words of advice to people like Kate Scottow, Caroline Farrow, Graham Linehan, Sarah Philimore, Posie Parker, Marion Millar, Harry Miller, the sticker lady from Wales who's name escapes me and dozens of others who are saying pretty mild (criminally speaking) on the internet. That, along with the police's rainbow paraphernalia, the support for pride, the LBGTQIA++++ police SM accounts, all signals that the police are spending too much time on virtue signalling and not enough time on stopping crime.

Yes, like all public services the police are under pressure, underfunded and in need of investment but as a comparison, I'm equally in despair of the NHS spending time on removing gendered language in maternity services instead of working out how to bring treatment waiting lists down. It's the wrong focus at the wrong time.

jcyclops · 29/08/2023 01:16

I saw an interesting opinion article that blaming police and/or government is aiming at the wrong target. Shops should carry most of the blame. Allowing crimes to take place then maybe catching and prosecuting criminals is nowhere near as good as preventing the crime in the first place.

Would you leave your car keys in the car with the doors unlocked or on a hook outside your front door and expect your car not to be stolen? No - you try and protect what is yours. Shops, however, give everyone free access to their goods and don't try and prevent them being stolen. Surely it is not beyond them to change and tighten up their operations to reduce or prevent theft, without returning to the historic method of everything behind a counter, although Argos, Screwfix and others have retained this procedure and I bet their losses to theft are very low. The one thing introduced in recent years that practically eliminates theft is online shopping.

At some petrol stations you have to insert a credit/debit card at the pump BEFORE it will dispense fuel. Hotels operate in the same way, as do many companies where you hire something such as a car. As well as ensuring payment it is also a way to get a customer's ID.

Northernsouloldies · 29/08/2023 01:03

A gang of masked up teen thugs steaming a shop is an act of violence and not the same as a kid sneaking a Mars bar into a pocket.

shitt · 29/08/2023 01:02

Also the shop in your example is partially to blame for this problem. Firstly shrinkage should be built into every business model, you can’t 100% stop shoplifting. Shoplifting shouldn’t come as a surprise in costing. Secondly, why haven’t they put changes in place to deter shoplifters such as security tags, security cabinets, CCTV, placing high risk items behind the till or in a lockable container, not repurchasing high risk items, banning people etc? If the same people keep stealing the same items, the shop has to change its business model. That’s not the public’s responsibility.

shitt · 29/08/2023 00:58

Nah, I can’t get worked up over this and I used to work in retail. I literally witnessed people stealing and using me as a mug, and the police refusing to attend. I still don’t think shoplifting is a priority when police don’t even attend for crimes against the person. In fact, I think I’d be annoyed if the same police force that’s too busy to investigate violent offences suddenly had time to investigate teenagers stealing small value items from a shop.

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 00:54

SerendipityJane
Seems our glorious Home Secretary is a Mumsnetter.

And she also appears to have no clue about reality

Northernsouloldies · 29/08/2023 00:51

It's concerning on how much anti social behaviour is derived from tik tok, yet the same platform isn't available in China.

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 00:42

RhymesWithOrange
I agree - we should attend every burglary, shop theft etc. but we don't have the resources to do so - so something is going to give. If I attend a burglary, theft etc - in theory I should close that as a crime scene and await SOCO and remain whilst SOCO complete their investigation. Then obtain statements from the victims & witnesses. So that could take me the entire shift to complete this one job.

Which things don't we attend in the mean time - DV's, breach of non-mols, breach of DVPO/DVPN, missing people, mental health, sudden deaths, RTA's, cannabis farms, drug dealing etc....?

We have more jobs on our queue than officers to attend them. Our shift has about 25 cops on it on a good day - but the job queue runs at about 100+. Then you have the new jobs coming in all the time.

So your thefts from garden sheds where an old lawn mower has been taken or a theft of sweets from a corner shop will not have an officer attend - we just don't have the resources to do so.

Even burglaries, if we talk to the victim on the phone and from what they are describing we can assess if SOCO are needed and if there is any solvabilty factors.

manontroppo ·
The police shouldn’t be dealing with the mental health scenarios that @Felix125 is describing. And they certainly shouldn’t be dealing with them just because no one else will.

Who is going to attend them though - someone standing on a bridge threatening to jump?

And the missing children who just run off again when they are returned to their care home?

DdraigGoch · 28/08/2023 23:51

Another thing to consider is that criminals such as burglars are much more forensically aware now. They know how the system works (or their solicitor does) and can always give cast tight alibis all the time.

Which is why the courts (and the sentencing guidelines they follow) need to impose much stiffer sentences for such crimes. So that when someone does slip up and get caught they go away for a decent amount of time, a partial reflection of the dozens of crimes that the average burglar never got caught for.

RhymesWithOrange · 28/08/2023 14:11

@crumblylancs you agree with my policeman friend. I agree with my policeman friend. The police are not spending their time on the right things. We all agree ☺️

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 10:53

anniegun · 28/08/2023 10:50

Its bollocks. It is her government's policies and financial decisions that has stopped the police investigating crime

You may think that. But that's not what you are going to hear (obviously).

anniegun · 28/08/2023 10:50

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 10:46

Seems our glorious Home Secretary is a Mumsnetter.

I'll leave others to find her account - but it's here 😉.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66636347

Its bollocks. It is her government's policies and financial decisions that has stopped the police investigating crime

anniegun · 28/08/2023 10:48

We have a government that has crippled the social justice system so trials take years to get to court. The Tories just don't care about crime despite their "tough" rhetoric

crumblylancs · 28/08/2023 10:33

RhymesWithOrange · 27/08/2023 20:08

So @crumblylancs you're saying that you actually agree with me! When I talk about "the police" I'm not distinguishing between the rank and file and the leads. They are all in the same organisation to me. The outcome is the same.

I don't know how you've come to the co cousin that I agree with you, I agreed with your friend and I gave my reasons why and they certainly were not the shit you've pulled out.

Lazyusername · 28/08/2023 09:27

@Unexpectedlysinglemum Thanks for the reply. My business isn't a small village shop - we are right in the centre of a large city and have hundreds of people coming through; this is why I have so much awareness of how bad shoplifting is now. Most days as I pass Greggs I see people just walking in, picking up drinks and walking off. Same at the self-serve in Sainsbury's. My premises has CCTV, security tagging and every other precaution. The problem is there is no deterrent any more to just, "having a go". Just try to get out with the item and if you are stopped it's no big deal as you are then just let go. I also understand there are now many Tiktok videos giving tips and advice on stealing.

My concern also is that this is part of a whole couldn't care less attitude which is causing crime to escalate in other areas and to involve people who wouldn't normally have thought of committing crimes. Imagine you are a kid from a disadvantaged area and another kid in your street keeps coming round showing you all of the computer games, clothing etc. they have nicked. No consequences; they do it every week while you have nothing. So you tag along and begin stealing and over the following weeks some of your friends come too. Then you have an idea; why don't we all get our mates and invade JD Sports and ransack it - it will be fun. Why not? You have seen there are no consequences. You can even post videos to show off about it afterwards. This is what we have seen beginning to happen in London recently with many police officers called out to deal with it. And this is going to escalate and spread. Why wouldn't it? If the initial kids had been stopped though then none of it would have happened. The police end up having to come out to deal with a major problem which only escalated because it wasn't nipped in the bud - I question how this is saving the police work.

It's as if we have officially given up on morality in this country. As I said before, if we are bringing our kids up to think it's normal to see people just helping themselves from shops and we should all just passively stand there while it happens then we are storing up problems for the future.

Rocknrollstar · 28/08/2023 09:09

Our local branch of Boots no longer stocks cosmetics because they have all been stolen. I read that shops in the West End are keeping their doors locked and you have to ring a bell.

RhymesWithOrange · 28/08/2023 08:35

@manontroppo as I understand it, where there is a threat to life the police are bound to attend. They are being used as an overflow from emergency health services.

A few years ago the police in my area told the health services they would no longer routinely lock up mentally ill people in cells (to keep them safe from harm) on the weekends when there were no other services to help them. This often included children. It was shocking.

manontroppo · 28/08/2023 08:21

The police shouldn’t be dealing with the mental health scenarios that @Felix125 is describing. And they certainly shouldn’t be dealing with them just because no one else will.

There is a place for police involvement in missing vulnerable people (children and so on) but for adults who “just” have mental health problems? Not the police’s role.

RhymesWithOrange · 28/08/2023 07:17

@Felix125 but if the police don't even attend a scene of shoplifting or housebreaking then how do they know if they have the evidence?

And in cases where stolen goods like bicycles are being offered back to the owner on Facebook still the police won't do anything.

Of course crime takes police resources to handle, it now seems though that criminals can safely bet on the police to be too busy to investigate their crime. You see it all the time, people being advised to not even call the police because they won't bother.

About 20 years ago I was burgled, they actually took nothing because my house alarm scared them away. But I had officers, forensics etc. dusting for fingerprints. Now if someone is burgled they get a crime number for their insurance claim over the phone.

In the meantime there are dozens and dozens of women (and men) who are having their perfectly legal speech investigated by forces all over the country. I can't help but think that has to do with both being captured by Stonewall and it's easier to tackle a middle aged woman in front of her children rather than an actual criminal.

Lonicerax · 28/08/2023 03:01

Part of the problem is that you cannot use physical force on anyone without being criminalised yourself. How is anyone supposed to do anything about anything. A man walked through and out of the self service area when I was checking stuff out the other day, with a couple of carrier bags full. So one thing the supermarket could do is stop self checkout and make it harder to leave the shop.

Felix125 · 28/08/2023 01:26

manontroppo
Mental health calls should not be the Police’s problem to deal with until a crime is in progress.

But who is going to deal with it? A suicidal person who is stood on a bridge threatening to jump?

And then, not only do you need a cop to talk/negotiate with them. You need one cop at each end of the bridge to stop people walking past, and a load of cops to close the road and feeder roads underneath. And it could take hours to sort out.

Ditto with missing from homes.

And these incidents are happening every shift now. We always have 4-5 missing from homes all the time. As soon as you find them, they go again.

So the non-urgent incidents tend to drop down the queue to be dealt with as and when. So this will include your shop thefts, hurt feeling jobs etc etc

Even if you had a set aside unit to deal with retail theft - after a few thefts, the unit will be tied up with those jobs to deal with (arrest, statements, CCTV reviews, interviews, CPS, case files) so who will be able to attend the next shop theft that comes in?

RhymesWithOrange
Crimes are never 'too tricky' to deal with - you either have the evidence there or you don't. Rapes & sexual assaults are difficult to prove at the best of times as they often come down to one word against another and you have to prove beyond reasonable doubt. From our force's point of view, every rape is taken seriously, but consider the cops now tied up with rape scenes, cell watches and victim management off the back of each rape report. So there is another 5 or so cops written off that day who can't go to the shop thefts.

Another thing to consider is that criminals such as burglars are much more forensically aware now. They know how the system works (or their solicitor does) and can always give cast tight alibis all the time.

DdraigGoch · 27/08/2023 22:59

I don't believe that a Labour government will bring any improvement. The current rot set in long before the present rabble. David Blunkett was a reasonable Home Secretary, but we haven't had a properly tough one since Michael Howard. Otherwise they've all seemed keen to make life easier for criminals - particularly Theresa May.

Swipe left for the next trending thread