Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that shoplifting should be taken seriously by the police and public?

169 replies

ScarySpinster · 26/08/2023 12:04

I used to work in retail. The police would rarely come out for a shoplifter, even if it was £1000s of pounds.

My local village shop may have to close because of teenagers regularly shoplifting. It's just not profitable for them to stay open with the losses they have.

Looking at the bigger picture, shoplifting raids are taking place regularly in London, and all the big cities, with the people involved rarely being prosecuted.

I think that we need to take this crime much more seriously. I don't want to live in a world where there are no repercussions for bad behavior. Because where will this stop? Will burgarly and mugging start to become okay next?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Lonicerax · 05/09/2023 07:24

I'm sure I've just heard on the radio that Scottish police are going to concentrate on major crimes - so a free ticket to shop lifters.
Why would you puclicise this unless trying to prove they are so different from the UK Gov Suella Braverman (who also comes up with stupid ideas).

Wowzerdowzer · 05/09/2023 07:00

'But aren't you concerned about the domino effect that ignoring shoplifting might have on a criminal?

You start with shoplifting. Next you try burgarly. Then it's mugging randomers. After that, ?'
*

Wow that's very ignorant. *

Northernsouloldies · 05/09/2023 06:57

Should try living in Scotland, police Scotland are to trial a scheme in Ne Scotland that not all crimes will be looked at and thus enabling officers to get back to members of the public as to why they are doing fuck all about what you reported. Oooo that's a good idea. Snp turns everything they touch to shit.

verdantverdure · 04/09/2023 19:00

I was told some old ladies recently stopped a store security guard from chasing a woman with a baby who'd shoplifted a box of nappies a tub of margarine and a block of cheese.

OneTC · 04/09/2023 18:21

anyoneanyoneanyone · 02/09/2023 17:13

Poverty as an excuse is crap. No one is stealing basic foodstuffs.

Yes they are!!!!!!!

In our shop generally people don't steal basic foodstuff. It's not that we don't catch people stealing it, it's just that very little of it goes missing. People steal household stuff like laundry pods and detergent to sell for drug money, they steal booze because they're multi dependent drug and alcohol abusers, they steal meat and cheese but to sell in pubs. They steal anything you can knock out for 2-5 quid

There was one woman who used to buy a basket of shopping most days but she'd also have been putting about another basket worth into a shopping bag she had next to the basket. She'd been coming in for years. When my colleague clocked her the shopping bag had plenty of luxury items that weren't from our shop, so I'd struggle to define this as stealing basics.

Occasionally a homeless person comes in and tries to steal sandwiches or snacks and we often give them food.

Stealing basics does happen I'm sure but our own experience is that it's rarely about hunger and 99% about drug money

anyoneanyoneanyone · 02/09/2023 17:13

Poverty as an excuse is crap. No one is stealing basic foodstuffs.

Yes they are!!!!!!!

SerendipityJane · 01/09/2023 09:10

58HappilyRetired · 01/09/2023 05:31

Having retired from a career in criminal justice, one of the reasons people dislike the police is because too many of them tell far lies in court. That certainly was my conclusion after listening to 40 years of police evidence on oath.

But as for shoplifting it is usually a non-violent, acquisitive crime of modest value. It should not be a priority for our cash public strapped services. I am all in favour of raising taxation to improve public service, but policing shop-lifting is way down the list of my priorities.

Clearly not a broken windows fan then ?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory#

Keen students will have noted that - like all initiatives - the broken window premise leads to the situation when landowners have to spend money as a class on their stock.

And it was at that point that capitalism lost interest.

(People sneer about individuals who "live off the state" which rather blinds them to entire industries which are on the taxpayer tit, as USians colorfully say).

Broken windows theory - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broken_windows_theory#

LadyMuckingabout · 01/09/2023 08:53

Good job you are retired, then, @58HappilyRetired , as you seem concerningly ambivalent about crime Hmm “Acquisitive” indeed!

58HappilyRetired · 01/09/2023 05:31

Having retired from a career in criminal justice, one of the reasons people dislike the police is because too many of them tell far lies in court. That certainly was my conclusion after listening to 40 years of police evidence on oath.

But as for shoplifting it is usually a non-violent, acquisitive crime of modest value. It should not be a priority for our cash public strapped services. I am all in favour of raising taxation to improve public service, but policing shop-lifting is way down the list of my priorities.

Felix125 · 01/09/2023 01:35

Another thing to consider is that some of the large retailers have really strict rules about passing over their CCTV.

In the past, shops would hand it over there and then. So the investigation could be done really quickly.

Now, some stores need to send a message to their head office. Head office then send a password to a specific manger to access the CCTV. The password only lasts 24 hours, so if the manager was busy or not at work that day - they have to re-apply for it. Or sometimes head officer don't send it or send the wrong password for the wrong store. They won't allow any other staff member to access it. And if this scenario goes beyond the 31 days, it's overwritten.

So without it, the police have to bail the suspect and often it gets no further auctioned due to lack of the CCTV footage and hence lack of evidence.

jcyclops · 30/08/2023 23:15

Don't let any facts get in the way of your "Tory cuts" dogma.

  • the current police officer headcount in England and Wales (149,572 officers) as at 31 March 2023, is the highest number of police officers on record since comparable records began
  • the current headcount is 3,542 (2.4%) greater than the previous peak of 146,030 officers in post as at 31 March 2010
  • of the 43 territorial police forces in England and Wales, 42 have met or exceeded their force’s allocation of additional officers

source:

Police officer uplift, England and Wales, quarterly update to 31 March 2023

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-officer-uplift-quarterly-update-to-march-2023/police-officer-uplift-england-and-wales-quarterly-update-to-31-march-2023

LadyMuckingabout · 29/08/2023 21:24

If we all just shrug our shoulders and say that nothing can be done, before too long we’ll be living in a South Africa situation in which even the modestly off live in armed gated communities. In fact I can’t see a future where we all walk round freely like today. I think criminality will rise and cities/town centres will be no go areas. Very sad.

TrishM80 · 29/08/2023 21:09

Stompythedinosaur · 26/08/2023 12:22

I'm far more fussed about violent crimes, gangs, knife crime and criminal exploitation tbh. Police time is limited, and I'm happy that it's focused on on most serious areas.

I can absolutely guarantee you that those gangs of shoplifting teenagers are also involved in the other criminal activities you've mentioned.

UsingChangeofName · 29/08/2023 21:06

Whereas Google tells me that, in WMP, there were 8715 officers in 2010 and 7579 officers in 2022, which does sound like a drop in numbers to me...... approx 15% at a quick estimate.

manontroppo · 29/08/2023 21:01

Actually, reading through the Nextbase info, it’s curious that the evidence is reviewed by a police officer before a decision is made. I would have thought that this would be an ideal scenario where triaging could be done by non officers.

manontroppo · 29/08/2023 20:55

superplumb · 29/08/2023 19:34

Ahh another anti police thread. Instead of moaning about the police why don't you main about this shitty gov who have cut numbers so much the police have to choose between crimes with greater threat harm and risk or theft. Police can't do all. Shoplifters don't all turn to burglary because theft from shop doesn't result in prison whereas burglary ( normally) does so it isn't in their interests to risk it

Certainly in London, the number of officers has risen since 2003 and been broadly the same since 2010, so this argument doesn’t stack up.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/864928/officer-numbers-of-the-metropolitan-police/

And to Felix125’s point - police should not be the “grown ups of last resort” in society. It appears that this message is beginning to get through, with the Met no longer planning on responding to routine mental health calls.

People get frustrated when they have good, solid evidence (see previous posts on bicycle theft for example, often captured on either city centre CCTV or on mobile phone footage) and it’s ignored. It would be great to roll out Nextbase, which makes it easy to upload dash cam footage to your local police force, as a similar concept for petty theft, for example.

Number of police officers in London 2022 | Statista

There were 34,868 police officers in London in 2022, an increase of 1,065 officers when compared with previous year.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/864928/officer-numbers-of-the-metropolitan-police/

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 19:41

Instead of moaning about the police why don't you main about this shitty gov who have cut numbers so much the police have to choose between crimes with greater threat harm and risk or theft.

I can assure you that people do. Loudly and vociferously. Obviously they keep on voting for them though - isn't that how it's supposed to work ?

superplumb · 29/08/2023 19:34

Ahh another anti police thread. Instead of moaning about the police why don't you main about this shitty gov who have cut numbers so much the police have to choose between crimes with greater threat harm and risk or theft. Police can't do all. Shoplifters don't all turn to burglary because theft from shop doesn't result in prison whereas burglary ( normally) does so it isn't in their interests to risk it

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 18:50

RhymesWithOrange
Things aren't outdated - they just take time to complete and often there is no other way around it. For example, you have to secure a scene for SOCO to attend - otherwise the scene is spoilt, anything you get from the scene in not admissible court. And a SOCO examination can take ages.

Sending teams to arrest people - what usually happens in these 'non urgent' jobs have to be dealt with as and when. So for example, the Caroline Farrow job is likely to be a 'non urgent' enquiry which is sat on some officers job queue to deal with. So they will try and find time to progress it - often you never get chance due to demand, which is why these enquiries drag on. If they get an opportunity to try an arrest attempt, you shout up to see if someone can give you a hand. You my find a unit is close by on another enquiriy, and will pull away from that to help you for a 10 minute arrest attempt. If you need a method of entry officer to force entry, you will have to find that unit who can hopefully pull away from what ever they are doing.

Its not as though there are big teams of cops just sat in the police station waiting to attend then next arrest.

If someone has phoned a job in and it has been classed as a crime (harassment or malicious communications) it has to be investigated. Its not an urgent job, so it just drops onto an officers crime queue to be dealt with as & when. We all have about 10-15 of these type jobs at any one time. Some days/weeks you just never have time to touch them.

PCSO's don't have warranted powers to deal with shop thefts. They can not arrest, summons, seize CCTV, search for stolen property - so they can not help unfortunately.

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 18:32

manontroppo
But someone is going to have to attend the person standing on the bridge threatening to jump. Someone is going to have to close the roads. Someone is going to have to close the bridge. Social services can't/won't do this.

Missing children are often medium to high risk - as they are vulnerable to exploitation or sexual crime or becoming involved in other crime etc. Social services don't have any powers to search for them (searching houses etc). And each occasion has to be risk assessed which takes about an hour of form completing to do. So every time you return them and they go missing 15 minutes later - you have to start again.

SOCO for shoplifting - if you're going to deal with the theft properly you need to consider this. Even if it has been captured on CCTV, all the suspect has to say in interview is 'that's not me' or 'no reply'. You will then have to prove they were in the shop.

Handing things to the back office staff - If you're the OIC, its down to you to investigate the crime and put the case file together. The back office staff will not know the ins & outs of the case to put such an investigation or case file together. Even if you tried to do it, the OIC would have to document everything in a 'handover' to the back office staff - so the OIC may as well complete the file. For example - redacting all the BWV - the back office staff will not know what needs to be redacted out or not as they have not been part of the enquiries.

Also - we don't have back office staff set aside to help police like this. You may have someone on you're shift who is office bound (injured, pregnant etc) but you can't rely on this happening all the time.

LadyMuckingabout · 29/08/2023 15:54

There are some bizarre and unfortunate views on here. Saying the shops are to blame?! By that logic women are responsible for any attack on them as they shouldn’t have been out after dark, tempting men who can’t help themselves.

I guess one problem is that many people and particularly kids simply do not care about breaking the law. And when there is little regard for authority and scant chance of being caught or punished then it becomes a free for all.

Poverty as an excuse is crap. No one is stealing basic foodstuffs. It’s attitude. I always wonder if thieves are bothered if someone robs them…

RhymesWithOrange · 29/08/2023 09:50

Yes, and PCSOs were supposed to deal with minor stuff and support police officers. Surely they could deal with shoplifting?

manontroppo · 29/08/2023 09:10

Felix125 · 29/08/2023 00:42

RhymesWithOrange
I agree - we should attend every burglary, shop theft etc. but we don't have the resources to do so - so something is going to give. If I attend a burglary, theft etc - in theory I should close that as a crime scene and await SOCO and remain whilst SOCO complete their investigation. Then obtain statements from the victims & witnesses. So that could take me the entire shift to complete this one job.

Which things don't we attend in the mean time - DV's, breach of non-mols, breach of DVPO/DVPN, missing people, mental health, sudden deaths, RTA's, cannabis farms, drug dealing etc....?

We have more jobs on our queue than officers to attend them. Our shift has about 25 cops on it on a good day - but the job queue runs at about 100+. Then you have the new jobs coming in all the time.

So your thefts from garden sheds where an old lawn mower has been taken or a theft of sweets from a corner shop will not have an officer attend - we just don't have the resources to do so.

Even burglaries, if we talk to the victim on the phone and from what they are describing we can assess if SOCO are needed and if there is any solvabilty factors.

manontroppo ·
The police shouldn’t be dealing with the mental health scenarios that @Felix125 is describing. And they certainly shouldn’t be dealing with them just because no one else will.

Who is going to attend them though - someone standing on a bridge threatening to jump?

And the missing children who just run off again when they are returned to their care home?

Frankly I don’t think the police should be doing either of those things and I would far rather they were dealing with the kinds of “low level” crimes detailed on this thread. Both of the cases you mention are social work issues - why should the police be repeatedly called out for a missing child? They aren’t solving the issue and there’s nothing to stop other people looking.

Also, why do you need a full SOCO work up for shoplifting that’s been captured repeatedly on CCTV?

There was a thread on here recently where people were suggesting more efficient ways of doing things (such as handing things over to back office staff) and a police officer was insisting that it was completely impossible to do things any other way. That went a long way to explaining people’s dissatisfaction with local policing….

TodayInahurry · 29/08/2023 08:07

In London there have been films on twitter of teenagers rampaging around looting shops. Shops will not be prepared to take losses and will close stores, this is happening in the US already. There will be areas with no food shops, staff will lose their jobs and people will be forced to travel to get goods.

Our local small village shop which struggles at the best of times now has a CCTV because of teenagers shoplifting. It will be very sad for us if it shuts as we use it every day to try to stop it closing

SerendipityJane · 29/08/2023 07:38

I saw an interesting opinion article that blaming police and/or government is aiming at the wrong target. Shops should carry most of the blame. Allowing crimes to take place then maybe catching and prosecuting criminals is nowhere near as good as preventing the crime in the first place.

So victims need to take their share of the blame ?

Righty ho.