Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“You are so lucky”

137 replies

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 11:04

Does anyone else hate this phrase when actually, luck has nothing to do with the situation?

We have recently bought our forever home. I’m not being modest when I say it’s nothing spectacular - it’s a standard sized three bed semi. It was recently done up before we bought it - not to a high spec or anything (eg you can tell the kitchen is not of high quality, cheap appliances, etc) - but basically nothing needs immediate attention but we will need to upgrade some things within the next 5 or so years.

Our previous home was smaller and needed quite a bit of work; we stuck it out for a long time, allowing us to save enough to afford this house.

We have had zero financial help from anyone to get this house; and we have made a lot of sacrifices for many years to be able to afford it. We both work full time, we have worked hard to get “decent” jobs (we are not wealthy by a long shot) and we have a fairly large mortgage which we will be paying until retirement (unless our financial position changes of course)

AIBU to hate it when other family and friends constantly tell us how “lucky” we are - especially friends who earn the same as us and have chose to prioritise travel/social life for the past 10+ years whilst we have stayed in almost every weekend and maybe spent a few nights away in the UK every second year, whilst our friends have been to Bali/the Maldives/cruises etc?

Now I understand that some of this is luck, for example we have been healthy enough to work, we have had healthy children who don’t need extensive care etc, but the friends who are making these comments have been similarly fortunate, and actually have had family helping them financially with deposits/with free childcare, so actually are probably more “lucky” than us.

AIBU to hate people assigning “luck” to situations which are nothing to do with luck, and actually a lot to do with hard work and sacrifice?

OP posts:
SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:07

Marynotsocontrary · 26/08/2023 12:06

The people in question earn roughly the same as us; they just enjoyed looking down on us previously and now that we have “come up in the world” they are uncomfortable that we now have something to show for our money whereas before we didn’t (since it was all tied up in savings which they didn’t necessarily know about)

You sound like you have quite a large chip on your shoulder. Forget about what other people do or think - you might well be wrong in your (over)analysis anyway.
As a pp said, most people use lucky simply to mean how lovely.

So walking round someone’s new house repeating “I hope you realise how lucky you are” whilst comparing their belongings to your own is them saying “how lovely”

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 26/08/2023 12:07

It sounds like you're taking it the wrong way. 'You're so lucky' doesn't usually mean this all fell on your lap, it just means 'I'm happy for you', that's certainly how I would take it anyway.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:06

Teaandbiscuits60 · 26/08/2023 12:03

Someone said it was okay for me after 2 strokes because I’m recovering well!!! It’s not okay because to have 2 strokes is not okay for anyone. Everything I’ve done has been very very hard. It’s not okay because it’s not ok for anyone. You’re not lucky, you worked hard and saved hard to make it happen . That’s the truth .

Exactly.

I see the same with my children. It’s okay that we lost 5 babies, both fallopian tubes and needed IVF (self funded) because we have two children.
Somehow being “okay now” is lucky?
it invalidates the journey that it took to get there.
Im happy that you are recovering well after your strokes but I’m sorry that happened to you; strokes are truly devastating ❤️

OP posts:
Marynotsocontrary · 26/08/2023 12:06

The people in question earn roughly the same as us; they just enjoyed looking down on us previously and now that we have “come up in the world” they are uncomfortable that we now have something to show for our money whereas before we didn’t (since it was all tied up in savings which they didn’t necessarily know about)

You sound like you have quite a large chip on your shoulder. Forget about what other people do or think - you might well be wrong in your (over)analysis anyway.
As a pp said, most people use lucky simply to mean how lovely.

rand0mstuff · 26/08/2023 12:05

As someone with 2 disabled children and zero earning potential, I think YABU. You are lucky. Being healthy and having healthy children are jackpot! And often pure luck. How are you possibly not lucky???🤔

Inmybirthdaysuit · 26/08/2023 12:04

I think it's not that deep. Saying 'your so lucky' or whatever is just a way of saying what a lovely thing for you.

readbooksdrinktea · 26/08/2023 12:04

HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 11:34

Just enjoy it. And remove the word 'luck' if it annoys you.

Replace it with fortunate.

You are fortunate in the sense you don't have disabilities. You're fortunate you were able to access education that worked for you. You were fortunate you got jobs you applied for. You were fortunate you were approved for a mortgage. You're fortunate you found someone to build a life with and buy a house with when many single people would not be able to no matter how hard they worked. You're fortunate your kids have no additional needs. You're fortunate DP hasn't left you in the lurch. You're fortunate that you didn't lose your incomes during a pandemic.

It is not the case anymore that working hard equals and making certain certain lifestyle choices equals being a home owner. Many people do the same and won't be able to be home-owners.

I agree the word 'luck' may be annoying but I guarantee you had some advantages that don't apply to everyone and were out of your control.

Don't get pissy or feel superior to anyone else, feel 'fortunate' because that's what they mean.

So much this. Absolutely agree.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:04

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 11:56

This. " Lucky you" because they are pleased for you.

And you are right to acknowledge that whilst you can give yourself credit for the hard work and the determination, there is is a big element of luck.

I worked hard, saved hard, went without, to buy and keep a house as a single mum. Now live in a very nice house, with well paid and flexible job. Lots of that was hard work and planning and tenacity but so much of it was good fortune too- good fortune to have a stable home life and a strong academic brain, good luck to have decent employers who supported me when I was ill, and when I was homeless with small children (after leaving abusive ex), good luck to have spotted the job advert that has given me such a satisfying and well remunerated but flexible career- I literally spotted it the day applications closed and typed my application up furiously with a small child crawling at my feet, tenacity yes, but also good fortune to have spotted it.

So yeah, despite all the hard work, I mainly feel very lucky

Agree it is frustrating to see people not realise they could buy if they reprioritised, and they may well eventually realise and regret their decisions. But I think you can also accept your good fortune that you have been able to buy the home you wanted.

Sorry if it wasn’t clear - these people also own a home.
They come from more affluent backgrounds than us and therefore have family help (financial) with things like deposits and free childcare.
Maybe they genuinely don’t realise that we don’t have all that - I don’t know. Although it would beg the question where we put our money in the past if it wasn’t paying for childcare and savings for our house!

OP posts:
Teaandbiscuits60 · 26/08/2023 12:03

Someone said it was okay for me after 2 strokes because I’m recovering well!!! It’s not okay because to have 2 strokes is not okay for anyone. Everything I’ve done has been very very hard. It’s not okay because it’s not ok for anyone. You’re not lucky, you worked hard and saved hard to make it happen . That’s the truth .

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 12:03

Bananaramad · 26/08/2023 12:00

Funny the harder I work the more I save the luckier I get 😉

I've worked damn hard my whole life and just been diagnosed with a rare, disabling, and incurable condition. Maybe I should have worked even harder 🤷‍♀️

Hard work can help create better "luck", agreed, but there's a huge element of chance in life too

WaltzingWaters · 26/08/2023 12:03

I used to get the same (but the opposite way around) when I travelled. “You’re so lucky you get to travel for so long at a time”. - no, I just saved money, and prioritised travelling over buying a house/having a family in my 20’s etc.

I just used to say “save some money, quit your job, rent your house out and you can do the same” and they’d usually shut up.

LardoBurrows · 26/08/2023 12:03

I would be inclined to challenge their comment and their viewpoint by saying something like "I'm not sure luck had much to do with it, I think it was going without holidays abroad, spending evenings at home and saving like crazy that had more to do with it."

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2023 12:02

I don’t know. I think I’d accept the comment to be honest as we are lucky to be living in a democracy. We are lucky to be gainfully employed. We are lucky to have food to eat. I feel exceptionally lucky to have met my OH who has made it possible for me to have my kids and my home.

So why not he gracious and nod along and say ‘yes, we are exceptionally lucky to have created the life we have’ and that pretty much says everything you need to say.

HarlanPepper · 26/08/2023 12:02

Though clearly, from your other posts. you don't seem to like your friends very much.

HarlanPepper · 26/08/2023 12:01

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 11:53

Where did I say I’m a better person than them? 😂

The people in question earn roughly the same as us; they just enjoyed looking down on us previously and now that we have “come up in the world” they are uncomfortable that we now have something to show for our money whereas before we didn’t (since it was all tied up in savings which they didn’t necessarily know about)

You didn't? You were just dissatisfied with the compliment because it didn't acknowledge your dedication, hard work and sacrifice. So I asked you what compliment you would prefer. Or would it be better if they said nothing?

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 12:00

WandaWonder · 26/08/2023 11:58

I take like like 'did you have a nice weekend/holiday/did your operation go ok/how was your Christmas or mother's day'

The answer they want is 'yes thanks' not endless details

So saying 'aren't you lucky' or whatever is just 'yes' really

There is not meant to me some indepth analysis over it

Agreed, it's just a bland easy comment. Doesn't mean much.

Bananaramad · 26/08/2023 12:00

Funny the harder I work the more I save the luckier I get 😉

WandaWonder · 26/08/2023 11:58

I take like like 'did you have a nice weekend/holiday/did your operation go ok/how was your Christmas or mother's day'

The answer they want is 'yes thanks' not endless details

So saying 'aren't you lucky' or whatever is just 'yes' really

There is not meant to me some indepth analysis over it

CorylusAgain · 26/08/2023 11:58

The people in question earn roughly the same as us; they just enjoyed looking down on us previously and now that we have “come up in the world” they are uncomfortable that we now have something to show for our money

Your friendship group sound competitive, mean-spirited and rude. That's the issue.
I've genuinely never come across this with the people I care about.

Desecratedcoconut · 26/08/2023 11:57

Bad luck can make a mockery of hard work and savings as quickly as you can click your fingers.

GrumpyOldCrone · 26/08/2023 11:56

I’m just wondering how people would acknowledge the fact that you worked hard for your house. “Lovely house, you’ve worked so hard for this.” Somehow it doesn’t sound quite right to me.

But I don’t think I’d say you were lucky either. I think it’s a bit odd. I’d probably just admire the house and any particular features (beautiful fireplace etc) and maybe ask about how you’re settling into the area. The friend doing the comparisons is out of order!

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 11:56

Matchinglipsandfingertips · 26/08/2023 11:45

We have just moved and we have had requests to visit by people not seen for years! Cheeky sods. I wait for the 'I'd love to see the house', not me then?
Lots of how much is your mortgage etc. We were in rented for years and they suspect the money came from unusual sources. It didn't. I had a massive bonus from a company I brought in £4m of new business in 7 months. It was my last chance to get back on the property ladder. I think there are a lot of competitive people out there. We also buy our cars and drive them for 10 years +

Yes!

It’s the same when my eldest was born - people crawling out the woodwork to “see the baby” then vanishing, only to reappear when we move house.

Ironically nobody gave two stuffs when the second baby was born.

I posted a photo of the new keys on Facebook (no indication of where the new house was/what the house looked like/whether we owned or rented) and someone I worked with a decade ago messaged asking when the housewarming was 🙃

Its next Saturday, and you aren’t invited Susan.

OP posts:
Littlemissalone · 26/08/2023 11:56

I think you need a breezy comment to say back, something along the lines of "oh no haha we saved hard for this" or "haha nope not luck, just hard work and lots of saving".

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 11:56

Shinyandnew1 · 26/08/2023 11:16

People say, ‘lucky you’ to mean ‘how lovely for you’ I think. So if someone says they’re off to Spain for the week, they might get a ‘lucky you!’ in the same way. It’s nothing to do with luck-just means something nice is happening.

If you want to reply, you could say, ‘more years of saving, than luck, but we are happy!’

This. " Lucky you" because they are pleased for you.

And you are right to acknowledge that whilst you can give yourself credit for the hard work and the determination, there is is a big element of luck.

I worked hard, saved hard, went without, to buy and keep a house as a single mum. Now live in a very nice house, with well paid and flexible job. Lots of that was hard work and planning and tenacity but so much of it was good fortune too- good fortune to have a stable home life and a strong academic brain, good luck to have decent employers who supported me when I was ill, and when I was homeless with small children (after leaving abusive ex), good luck to have spotted the job advert that has given me such a satisfying and well remunerated but flexible career- I literally spotted it the day applications closed and typed my application up furiously with a small child crawling at my feet, tenacity yes, but also good fortune to have spotted it.

So yeah, despite all the hard work, I mainly feel very lucky

Agree it is frustrating to see people not realise they could buy if they reprioritised, and they may well eventually realise and regret their decisions. But I think you can also accept your good fortune that you have been able to buy the home you wanted.

Curseofthenation · 26/08/2023 11:54

I probably would just reply with something along the lines of 'Yes, moving here has made all of the uneventful weekends and lack of holidays feel very worthwhile! I'm so glad we saved as hard as we did.'

I don't mean in a sassy or sarcastic way, but with a friendly, warm smile. I'm sure it is likely how you feel. Well done.