Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“You are so lucky”

137 replies

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 11:04

Does anyone else hate this phrase when actually, luck has nothing to do with the situation?

We have recently bought our forever home. I’m not being modest when I say it’s nothing spectacular - it’s a standard sized three bed semi. It was recently done up before we bought it - not to a high spec or anything (eg you can tell the kitchen is not of high quality, cheap appliances, etc) - but basically nothing needs immediate attention but we will need to upgrade some things within the next 5 or so years.

Our previous home was smaller and needed quite a bit of work; we stuck it out for a long time, allowing us to save enough to afford this house.

We have had zero financial help from anyone to get this house; and we have made a lot of sacrifices for many years to be able to afford it. We both work full time, we have worked hard to get “decent” jobs (we are not wealthy by a long shot) and we have a fairly large mortgage which we will be paying until retirement (unless our financial position changes of course)

AIBU to hate it when other family and friends constantly tell us how “lucky” we are - especially friends who earn the same as us and have chose to prioritise travel/social life for the past 10+ years whilst we have stayed in almost every weekend and maybe spent a few nights away in the UK every second year, whilst our friends have been to Bali/the Maldives/cruises etc?

Now I understand that some of this is luck, for example we have been healthy enough to work, we have had healthy children who don’t need extensive care etc, but the friends who are making these comments have been similarly fortunate, and actually have had family helping them financially with deposits/with free childcare, so actually are probably more “lucky” than us.

AIBU to hate people assigning “luck” to situations which are nothing to do with luck, and actually a lot to do with hard work and sacrifice?

OP posts:
BookwormDadUK · 26/08/2023 12:28

I think two things can be true at the same time: you've made good choices that have involved hard work and sacrifice; and you've been fortunate to have had some of those choices.

We bought our house with no help, but I was fortunate to have had opportunities at work that enabled me to earn enough to save in the first place. We lost 3 babies and self funded 2 unsuccessful rounds of IVF before the blessing of falling pregnant naturally.

Counting your blessings doesn't negate your own contribution. No matter our struggles, there are people worse off who would kill for a house or job or family of their own, and see no route to them.

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 12:28

What would you want people to say?

rand0mstuff · 26/08/2023 12:27

Even if we had been very lucky; we still wouldn’t have got to where we are today without a lot of hard work too.

I think this is the point you are missing. Hard work enabled you to buy a house and different things. Some people (such as unpaid carers) work all hours under the sun and will never be able to achieve any of that. Hard work doesn't mean you can afford. Hard work and being lucky means you can. It's really not that hard to understand, is it?

FigTreeInEurope · 26/08/2023 12:26

"You're so blessed to be such a talented pianist", because its talent, and being "gifted", rather than the result of twenty years bloody practice.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:26

Marynotsocontrary · 26/08/2023 12:21

So walking round someone’s new house repeating “I hope you realise how lucky you are” whilst comparing their belongings to your own is them saying “how lovely”

That is one person, who you really don't have to stay friends with if they get on your nerves all the time @SamAndEIIa.
Your OP said you were having issues with family and friends "constantly" telling you that you're lucky? I think you're overthinking it and I don't think it's doing you any good, because instead of feeling happy and delighted with your new house you're on here complaining.

No, we moved here two weeks ago and it’s happened in the two weeks since moving to our new house. It hasn’t been happening constantly for a long time, obviously. And I’m sure it’ll tail off now that the “newness” has worn off.

Friend was just here last night hence making post today.

I think most people are switched on enough to work out that having a 25 year mortgage at an astronomical interest rate to buy a three bed house in a council estate isn’t massively lucky 😂

OP posts:
HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 12:24

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:12

As you see if you read my posts, I am lucky because my own health is (now) good, and I have healthy children. These are both pure luck.

However, I had to pay for IVF to have my youngest.
I had a horrible journey to get both my children.
We had very serious health issues a while ago.
We both lost our jobs at different times, and for a long time we had more in bills than we did coming in, yet got no financial help.

None of our successes came easy to us, it was pure hard work and sacrifice. And I’d never say I’m “not lucky” to someone who is objectively less fortunate than us.

Even if we had been very lucky; we still wouldn’t have got to where we are today without a lot of hard work too.

And you're lucky or fortunate that you had the money to pay for IVF.

Can you not enjoy what you have without making judgement about other people and getting pissed off about your perception that they don't deserve the things you do because they made different choices?

You're healthy, you own a nice home and you've got children you wanted.

Honestly, can you not just enjoy your life?what is getting pissy about other people thinking you're lucky or fortunate adding to your life at this point?

Move on and let it go and be happy. Other people's opinions aren't taking anything away from you.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:22

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/08/2023 12:18

Agree with this.

Op your interpretation of the situation may be way off. We had people say that we are lucky to live in our home. I don’t take it as an insult or assume that they think that we haven’t worked hard or whatever. I just assume that it’s a nice comment and to be honest, we are lucky. I wouldn’t have taken the lamp comment as a negative either. I’d have thought my friend liked my lamp so much that she wants one for her own house.

I mean, you know better than we do as you were there but I do think that it might be worth stopping to look at how much of this is your own assumption rather than them enjoying looking down on you. If you really do feel like this then you should end the friendship.

I said elsewhere - you might have missed it - these people aren’t immediate friends in my close circle or anything. One was a work colleague (hence me knowing how much they earn!) and visited on the guise of bringing a housewarming present - it just seemed nosey and off from the get go as they aren’t particularly people we would normally have visit.

The lamp in question had been in our previous house too; which again shows how infrequently they visited 😂

OP posts:
Marynotsocontrary · 26/08/2023 12:21

So walking round someone’s new house repeating “I hope you realise how lucky you are” whilst comparing their belongings to your own is them saying “how lovely”

That is one person, who you really don't have to stay friends with if they get on your nerves all the time @SamAndEIIa.
Your OP said you were having issues with family and friends "constantly" telling you that you're lucky? I think you're overthinking it and I don't think it's doing you any good, because instead of feeling happy and delighted with your new house you're on here complaining.

LakeTiticaca · 26/08/2023 12:20

You are not being unreasonable and these are the same people who complain about those who inherited money from their parents, those parents who worked hard and went without luxuries to buy a family home, while others spent their mobey on sunshine holidays, nice cars, socialising etc

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/08/2023 12:18

Marynotsocontrary · 26/08/2023 12:06

The people in question earn roughly the same as us; they just enjoyed looking down on us previously and now that we have “come up in the world” they are uncomfortable that we now have something to show for our money whereas before we didn’t (since it was all tied up in savings which they didn’t necessarily know about)

You sound like you have quite a large chip on your shoulder. Forget about what other people do or think - you might well be wrong in your (over)analysis anyway.
As a pp said, most people use lucky simply to mean how lovely.

Agree with this.

Op your interpretation of the situation may be way off. We had people say that we are lucky to live in our home. I don’t take it as an insult or assume that they think that we haven’t worked hard or whatever. I just assume that it’s a nice comment and to be honest, we are lucky. I wouldn’t have taken the lamp comment as a negative either. I’d have thought my friend liked my lamp so much that she wants one for her own house.

I mean, you know better than we do as you were there but I do think that it might be worth stopping to look at how much of this is your own assumption rather than them enjoying looking down on you. If you really do feel like this then you should end the friendship.

TurquoiseDress · 26/08/2023 12:17

Shinyandnew1 · 26/08/2023 11:16

People say, ‘lucky you’ to mean ‘how lovely for you’ I think. So if someone says they’re off to Spain for the week, they might get a ‘lucky you!’ in the same way. It’s nothing to do with luck-just means something nice is happening.

If you want to reply, you could say, ‘more years of saving, than luck, but we are happy!’

Yes this is my interpretation when people Sat "oh lucky you" and similar!

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:16

LardoBurrows · 26/08/2023 12:03

I would be inclined to challenge their comment and their viewpoint by saying something like "I'm not sure luck had much to do with it, I think it was going without holidays abroad, spending evenings at home and saving like crazy that had more to do with it."

That’s a good response and much more measured with what I wanted to say, whilst covering the same sentiment.

OP posts:
ConsuelaHammock · 26/08/2023 12:16

Just tell them you sacrificed the social life
and the holidays for the house. And watch them squirm 😂

Maddy70 · 26/08/2023 12:16

I consider myself lucky. I have worked really hard to get what I have but other people do too and some have more barriers and privilege than others

I am lucky

xPaloma · 26/08/2023 12:16

Ah@SamAndEIIa I have a post about the one up/one down friendship dynamic I friendships. I was the one down in a lot of friendships that didn't run that deep. Now I have my own job, place, pension, plans, don't need "advice" or a bag of old clothes, those people don't know how to place me. It seems to matter. I just wanted friendships where you were allowed to grow/change, have good times, rough patches et cetera

Sad fact. A lot of people, what they need from a friendship is that you make them feel better about them self

OilOfRoses · 26/08/2023 12:15

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:12

As you see if you read my posts, I am lucky because my own health is (now) good, and I have healthy children. These are both pure luck.

However, I had to pay for IVF to have my youngest.
I had a horrible journey to get both my children.
We had very serious health issues a while ago.
We both lost our jobs at different times, and for a long time we had more in bills than we did coming in, yet got no financial help.

None of our successes came easy to us, it was pure hard work and sacrifice. And I’d never say I’m “not lucky” to someone who is objectively less fortunate than us.

Even if we had been very lucky; we still wouldn’t have got to where we are today without a lot of hard work too.

You still have elements of luck in there though. I'm lucky that I had no trouble conceiving. No work involved there. It's just that wasn't my battle in life (I've had others of my own). You are lucky that IVF worked. I don't think that is down to hard work. It doesn't work for everyone, it's lucky for you it did, just as I had the luck of not needing it. If you are lucky your children will stay healthy and you will stay healthy. Life is a mix of work and luck really.

Beezknees · 26/08/2023 12:15

I work hard and can't afford to save enough to buy a house. If I could I'd be so bloody happy that I wouldn't care about being called lucky.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:14

Cognitivedisonance · 26/08/2023 12:12

You’re doing it wrong. I moved here 2 years ago, only my siblings and parents have ever seen it once and that was because they were invited to DCs birthday party last year. I can’t imagine giving a toss where anyone lived or what in or whether they owned it.I doubt any of my friends or acquaintances have ever given my housing a second thought. My little place and garden is absolutely beautiful and I love it but I can’t imagine people being rude enough to show up and disturb our peace, much less make personal comments about finance and stuff. I don’t even know how much my sister paid for her house she just bought bloody rude to ask imo.

Someone I’m friendly with knows how much I paid; because they looked up my house on the website (and told me they had done so!) 😳😳

OP posts:
SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:13

Krustykrabpizza · 26/08/2023 12:11

I had a friend at uni who told me I was lucky when I got good marks... I don't think it was luck, maybe it was not doing it at 3am the night before like she did!

Haha, that never happened to me (probably because I didn’t get particularly good grades because I had to work almost full-time hours alongside my degree)

Be proud of your grades, you got them from hard work!

OP posts:
Cognitivedisonance · 26/08/2023 12:12

You’re doing it wrong. I moved here 2 years ago, only my siblings and parents have ever seen it once and that was because they were invited to DCs birthday party last year. I can’t imagine giving a toss where anyone lived or what in or whether they owned it.I doubt any of my friends or acquaintances have ever given my housing a second thought. My little place and garden is absolutely beautiful and I love it but I can’t imagine people being rude enough to show up and disturb our peace, much less make personal comments about finance and stuff. I don’t even know how much my sister paid for her house she just bought bloody rude to ask imo.

OilOfRoses · 26/08/2023 12:12

I think it's just a way of saying how lovely for you. It's one of those trite sayings people use that doesn't really have a lot of meaning. Maybe you're lucky that such a perfect home was on the market at the time you were looking? Luck of timing? Not that you couldn't have found another home but that one being available at just the right time could be put down to luck. Try not to overthink it and just think of it as people sharing how lovely they think it is.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:12

rand0mstuff · 26/08/2023 12:05

As someone with 2 disabled children and zero earning potential, I think YABU. You are lucky. Being healthy and having healthy children are jackpot! And often pure luck. How are you possibly not lucky???🤔

As you see if you read my posts, I am lucky because my own health is (now) good, and I have healthy children. These are both pure luck.

However, I had to pay for IVF to have my youngest.
I had a horrible journey to get both my children.
We had very serious health issues a while ago.
We both lost our jobs at different times, and for a long time we had more in bills than we did coming in, yet got no financial help.

None of our successes came easy to us, it was pure hard work and sacrifice. And I’d never say I’m “not lucky” to someone who is objectively less fortunate than us.

Even if we had been very lucky; we still wouldn’t have got to where we are today without a lot of hard work too.

OP posts:
Krustykrabpizza · 26/08/2023 12:11

I had a friend at uni who told me I was lucky when I got good marks... I don't think it was luck, maybe it was not doing it at 3am the night before like she did!

xPaloma · 26/08/2023 12:11

I agree, you're over thinking it.

It's a good thing, an exciting thing, and people are acknowledging it.
Nobody ever tells me I'm lucky! Maybe I'm lucky to be content about that though.

theresnolimits · 26/08/2023 12:10

Try this one : ‘the harder I work, the luckier I get’. With a smile.