Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“You are so lucky”

137 replies

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 11:04

Does anyone else hate this phrase when actually, luck has nothing to do with the situation?

We have recently bought our forever home. I’m not being modest when I say it’s nothing spectacular - it’s a standard sized three bed semi. It was recently done up before we bought it - not to a high spec or anything (eg you can tell the kitchen is not of high quality, cheap appliances, etc) - but basically nothing needs immediate attention but we will need to upgrade some things within the next 5 or so years.

Our previous home was smaller and needed quite a bit of work; we stuck it out for a long time, allowing us to save enough to afford this house.

We have had zero financial help from anyone to get this house; and we have made a lot of sacrifices for many years to be able to afford it. We both work full time, we have worked hard to get “decent” jobs (we are not wealthy by a long shot) and we have a fairly large mortgage which we will be paying until retirement (unless our financial position changes of course)

AIBU to hate it when other family and friends constantly tell us how “lucky” we are - especially friends who earn the same as us and have chose to prioritise travel/social life for the past 10+ years whilst we have stayed in almost every weekend and maybe spent a few nights away in the UK every second year, whilst our friends have been to Bali/the Maldives/cruises etc?

Now I understand that some of this is luck, for example we have been healthy enough to work, we have had healthy children who don’t need extensive care etc, but the friends who are making these comments have been similarly fortunate, and actually have had family helping them financially with deposits/with free childcare, so actually are probably more “lucky” than us.

AIBU to hate people assigning “luck” to situations which are nothing to do with luck, and actually a lot to do with hard work and sacrifice?

OP posts:
HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 14:25

peasblue · 26/08/2023 14:21

No.... we're not. We worked and saved and made sacrifices to get here. It's not luck!!

Of course there's an element of luck, it really would be nice if it was just a case of hard work = reward, but life isn't like that. You're lucky you had the ability to work hard and save, people are acting so entitled on this thread. It shocks me people are so arrogant they can't see the privilege they've almost definitely experienced, I'm imagining you all going up on stage to receive an award "yes well I absolutely deserve this, it was all me, all my hard work" mic drop.

And MNetters get really pissed off when high earners say they worked hard to get where they are and don't acknowledge the advantages they had...

peasblue · 26/08/2023 14:21

No.... we're not. We worked and saved and made sacrifices to get here. It's not luck!!

Of course there's an element of luck, it really would be nice if it was just a case of hard work = reward, but life isn't like that. You're lucky you had the ability to work hard and save, people are acting so entitled on this thread. It shocks me people are so arrogant they can't see the privilege they've almost definitely experienced, I'm imagining you all going up on stage to receive an award "yes well I absolutely deserve this, it was all me, all my hard work" mic drop.

CarPour · 26/08/2023 14:14

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/08/2023 14:08

On another flip side when I was a teenager (19-20) and in touch with my half siblings from my dad’s third marriage I was told by my younger half sister who’s 7 years younger how lucky we were to have a large Victorian house. Theirs was a 1930s semi and had to house parents, and 3 kids.

DM wanted and got the house in the divorce but then rented out rooms to lodgers and part of the top floor as a mini flat. She had social services coming to the door accusing her of being a prostitute with the lodgers and had to get a guarantor loan to be able to afford the mortgage from a close family friend. Her DM who is/was very wealthy did nothing to help apart from pay to put electric meters in. She helped put later. DM also had to cope with a severely asthmatic child who almost died twice when young.

But to several relatives she was “lucky”. When she inherited a significant sum of life changing money from an uncle when we were DC she was accused of sucking up to him even by her own father (not indirectly but she knew!) and of being “lucky”. She was the only niece who cared for him on his deathbed when he had cancer, visited and wrote to him beforehand.

I think to a 12yo living in a large victorian house is lucky!

They were a child ffs! She has no idea as to the complexities of life. She just sees a sibling in a bigger house, which is lucky.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/08/2023 14:08

On another flip side when I was a teenager (19-20) and in touch with my half siblings from my dad’s third marriage I was told by my younger half sister who’s 7 years younger how lucky we were to have a large Victorian house. Theirs was a 1930s semi and had to house parents, and 3 kids.

DM wanted and got the house in the divorce but then rented out rooms to lodgers and part of the top floor as a mini flat. She had social services coming to the door accusing her of being a prostitute with the lodgers and had to get a guarantor loan to be able to afford the mortgage from a close family friend. Her DM who is/was very wealthy did nothing to help apart from pay to put electric meters in. She helped put later. DM also had to cope with a severely asthmatic child who almost died twice when young.

But to several relatives she was “lucky”. When she inherited a significant sum of life changing money from an uncle when we were DC she was accused of sucking up to him even by her own father (not indirectly but she knew!) and of being “lucky”. She was the only niece who cared for him on his deathbed when he had cancer, visited and wrote to him beforehand.

CarPour · 26/08/2023 14:07

It's just something people say.

You've bought a standard 3 bed semi. I doubt people really care that much. They are just being nice. When your friends by houses you get excited and say "this is lovely, how lucky" or "I'm happy for you'

Most people work hard tbh. There's many people who work incredibly hard in this world and haven't just a bought their forever home. When things go well for me I do feel lucky, even though I've worked hard

Dwappy · 26/08/2023 14:05

I think it depends on how the person says it. You can often tell when someone is meaning it in a "lucky you off on a nice holiday" type way or more the "it's alright for some it's not fair" type way.
I had a friend as a teenager and we were both in very similar positions. Both only children. Both lived at home and we WERE both lucky that our parents were happy to fund us while we were studying etc. At 18 I chose to go to uni, she chose to "work". Only she didn't really work. She signed on (we're going back a lot of years when it was much easier to just get job seekers or whatever it was called). Her dad still continued to fund her as well though. We carried on not really discussing our different life choices as it really didn't matter to the friendship. We were just having fun as we always did. 3 years later after I finished uni I got offered a good job on fairly good wages for my age. My friend was still unemployed and living at home and being partially funded by her parents.
That's when she changed. When I told her I got my new job she just rolled her eyes and said "urgh it's alright for some being so lucky in life!" I wasn't any luckier than her. I'd just made different choices. Yet she seemed jealous and annoyed at me for now having more money. For the next few years our friendship struggled on but she always went on about how lucky I was and she never wanted to pay for anything, always expecting me to pay because I was so lucky having a well paid job etc. We drifted apart a few years later but 25 years later I still occasionally have the odd text with her. When I bought a new house a few years ago she only commented "lucky you!!!!!!". So I know exactly how she means that. She's now married with 2 kids. But still doesn't work as her husband earns the money. Which is totally fine. But it doesn't make me any luckier than she is not having to work. Her husband doesn't earn enough that they can buy a house so she thinks I'm lucky because i did. But they chose to prioritise her being a stay at home mum. Which is a perfectly fine choice. But that choice meant they can't buy a house. My choice meant I could.

likeafireworkshow · 26/08/2023 14:04

Could have written this op, exactly the same boat.

Spent the last 15 years scrimping and saving to buy our first home, at almost 40. Got it at a good price so have used to extra to re carpet and get some nicer things than we would usually get.

'Oh wow. You're very lucky'

'Hmm I couldn't justify new carpet, you're very lucky'

No.... we're not. We worked and saved and made sacrifices to get here. It's not luck!!

Enjoy your new home op Grin

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/08/2023 13:58

If it were me personally OP and the people/friends who are commenting you’re so lucky when they visit you, you either have the option to call them out on this or ignore them or just let friendship tail off/keep it at a controlled length.

My 4 best friends (yes I did used to have more!) are all people I’d say I’m not competitive with at all. When we see each others houses/meet the families we don’t comment as to how lucky each other is, as that’s not the basis on which our friendship is based.

The ex best friend who I’d say I was maybe competitive with (more from her side not mine) was always more about the big, perfectly decorated house and chose her partner partly based on that, when we fell out her best friend told me “S always wanted the big perfect house and would drop friendships for it”. Good for her but that’s not the way I work. I’m just not that competitive and don’t keep up with the Jones’.

Bananaramad · 26/08/2023 13:48

lapsedbookworm · 26/08/2023 12:03

I've worked damn hard my whole life and just been diagnosed with a rare, disabling, and incurable condition. Maybe I should have worked even harder 🤷‍♀️

Hard work can help create better "luck", agreed, but there's a huge element of chance in life too

Sorry you took me up wrong I meant it only in relation to having money , and slightly tongue in cheek not relationships health etc. As the OP is being told she's lucky she bought a house. I'm sorry for your diagnosis and nothing is worth more than our health, as I know only too well.

MasterBeth · 26/08/2023 13:44

You never know what's going on in other people's lives.

It's great you're living in a lovely house. The luck (that you admit to) that's led you there is a blessing.

Luck isn't a zero sum game. I think YABU.

Winter2020 · 26/08/2023 13:39

@SamAndEIIa
Quote "I posted a photo of the new keys on Facebook (no indication of where the new house was/what the house looked like/whether we owned or rented) and someone I worked with a decade ago messaged asking when the housewarming was 🙃

Its next Saturday, and you aren’t invited Susan."

I don't think people can win with you. You posted on Facebook inviting attention and then are annoyed by a perfectly ordinary comment. Would you prefer "no-one gives a fuck S&E?" Or you prefer they ignore you - easy solution to that- don't posted it on Facebook.

StopThatBloodyNoise · 26/08/2023 13:29

A "friend" of mine has often told me how "lucky" I am that I don't go to work - I'm 64, worked hard all my life, until a stroke 2 years ago put a stop to that. Lucky? Yes, I must be.....

Speedweed · 26/08/2023 13:28

I think it's the context. When I was single and didn't have children (not a situation I would have chosen), a friend kept saying I was so lucky I could be as selfish as I wanted, presumably unlike her who had had the luck to meet a lovely man who luckily wanted to marry her and then luckily had two healthy children, luckily exactly when she wanted them with no issues. Hmm.

When a few years later I was undergoing ivf, another friend trotted out the you're so lucky you can do ivf line during my first round, which failed. Again, not a situation I would have chosen, and this friend had been lucky enough not to need any fertility treatment to have her children.

So I think in a shitty situation which someone hasn't chosen and where they are just trying to make the best of things, it's probably the worst thing to say. It's like going up to someone in a wheelchair and telling them they're lucky not to have to get tired legs from walking around all day.

In your situation, op, when it's a situation you've chosen and worked hard for, I appreciate it might be infuriating, but it's just an expression. The problem is that the alternative of acknowledging the effort eg well done, you worked hard for that, could sound patronising, but that is really what they mean by saying you've been fortunate.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 13:27

HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 13:15

No. You're absolutely lucky. IVF statistics are not great, if you went through that then you know that?

Or did you have an IVF specialist that told you you're guaranteed a baby depending on how much you pay for more cycles?

I'd be extremely interested to hear about them. As would any medical regulatory body.

I'm veering towards thinking you're not telling the truth if you don't think you were lucky to conceive via IVF and you were rewarded with a baby because of the money you spent.

I was lucky to conceive through IVF (although I had all the statistics on my side - a known and treatable fertility issue, age, non smoker, living child, no male factor, weight, etc)

If we are looking at statistics, conceiving through IVF was far, far more likely than the issues which lead to needing IVF in the first place - the condition I have is pretty rare, far far far rarer than succeeding at IVF. I also had three ectopic pregnancies resulting in me losing both my fallopian tubes; to have one ectopic is pretty rare; to have three is very rare indeed.

I don’t think anyone who has been through IVF feels particularly lucky; I feel far more lucky that I had my first child without IVF than I do that I had my second with IVF.

OP posts:
Parques · 26/08/2023 13:24

Fair point 👍🏽

Highdaysandholidays1 · 26/08/2023 13:20

They were lucky to have a fab holiday, you are lucky you have a lovely house. A lot of people have neither. I couldn't be bothered to extract out exact acknowledgement of your sacrifice, it's all a bit of a pointless and negative conversation, have fun with friends and acknowledge you all spend your money a bit differently.

Desecratedcoconut · 26/08/2023 13:15

Is it just me who wants a 'You Made Good Choices' Hallmark card option now? 😁

HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 13:15

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 12:59

To suggest someone who has had to do IVF for their child(ren) due to a condition which caused them to lose several babies (including one in second trimester and one in third) is “lucky” is pretty fucked up.

In fact, it’s not pretty fucked up, it’s very fucked up.

No. You're absolutely lucky. IVF statistics are not great, if you went through that then you know that?

Or did you have an IVF specialist that told you you're guaranteed a baby depending on how much you pay for more cycles?

I'd be extremely interested to hear about them. As would any medical regulatory body.

I'm veering towards thinking you're not telling the truth if you don't think you were lucky to conceive via IVF and you were rewarded with a baby because of the money you spent.

Goldbar · 26/08/2023 13:11

Isn't it just something people say? Because it sounds better than "you made good choices". It's often said as a kind of half-truth as well. I might look around your house and think it's utilitarian and characterless with little potential (while living in a complete building-site myself but that I think has bags of character and potential in the long-term). But I'm hardly going to say that to you. So instead, I might say "Wow, you're so lucky you don't need to do anything, we're going to be living in a muddle for years with everything we've got to do". This has the merit of actually being sincere from my perspective (I would prefer not to have to do the work!) but it doesn't mean I prefer your house or want your life overall.

HawnyThorn · 26/08/2023 13:08

Parques · 26/08/2023 12:47

My mum made a sort of similar comment when she described our son as 'privileged' to have gone to private school! No, fucking hard work, old car, small house etc. paid for it! No silver spoons here!

What don't you understand?

I think you don’t understand what privilege means?

You do realise that lots of people could never afford private schools for their kids?

No matter how hard they worked?

If you look at your DCs school fees and can somehow figure how it would be affordable for any family, then it wouldn't be a privilege.

Can you do that? Do you know what privilege means?

Do you think your DM is lying and your DC is not privileged?

If its not a privilege, and the DC in state schools receive the same education and the same opportunities in life, why are you working so hard to pay for it?

That seems silly....

BubziOwl · 26/08/2023 13:05

Shinyandnew1 · 26/08/2023 11:16

People say, ‘lucky you’ to mean ‘how lovely for you’ I think. So if someone says they’re off to Spain for the week, they might get a ‘lucky you!’ in the same way. It’s nothing to do with luck-just means something nice is happening.

If you want to reply, you could say, ‘more years of saving, than luck, but we are happy!’

Exactly this. No one is thinking that deeply about it when they say it (except for you!)

My husband and I bought our house early in life and did so all on our own, saved incredibly hard and went without lots in order to get a deposit together very quickly. I feel very lucky indeed, and if someone remarks that I'm lucky then it's just another moment to remind myself to be grateful.

peasblue · 26/08/2023 13:05

@SamAndEIIa you need to learn to be grateful for what you have rather than being bitter for the work you've had to put in or the obstacles, because you need to realise that there are people out there who also work hard or have difficult journeys but don't end up with what you have.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 26/08/2023 13:04

There was one couple up the road from me who everyone thought was “so lucky”. Husband was good looking with his own business, his wife was rather cattily referred to by neighbours snd school mums as a character in a BBC sitcom. They seemed to have it all according to neighbours/school mums, did all the local neighbourhood trips like farmers market every weekend. Then this year the DH committed suicide (sorry if incorrect term) and turned out he’d been depressed for months.

Most people seem to be so lucky from external viewpoints. People see me as single in a smell house more cottage as being “so lucky” but I’ve had help to buy it, until recently was renting out a spare room to afford the mortgage and even now, yes, I have a job but it’s certainly not my perfect career and things are unstable. I work to pay the bills. Another friend of mine you’d think is so lucky because she’s constantly on holiday or seeing concerts but she can’t afford a mortgage and lost her sister tragically young due to sudden illness over covid. Another friend’s DH died after after battling cancer for 3 times in his early 50s, 6 months later she met her second DH and is travelling the world and living life yet she’s been told by some “you’re so lucky”. Well yes but she and her DC miss their dad/widow.

Comparison is the thief of joy.

SamAndEIIa · 26/08/2023 13:00

Inmybirthdaysuit · 26/08/2023 12:57

But she is luckier than someone whose mother dies and left them nothing. It's all relative.

Sure, I’ll tell her that. I’m sure she’ll be so grateful.

Yeah you watched your mum die a slow, painful death, but at least she was rich!

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 26/08/2023 13:00

If it bothers you that much respond. Say 'No, nothing to do with luck, more about sacrifices over the years. No trips to Bali for us.....Still, people have different priorities don't they. Ours was our home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread