Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
VeryQuaintIrene · 26/08/2023 14:41

"We're so lucky that apparently the only museum in the world which has artefacts from all around the world, seems to be the British Museum in London, proud to be British...."

Seriously untrue.

squaredcircles · 26/08/2023 14:36

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 10:14

We're so lucky that apparently the only museum in the world which has artefacts from all around the world, seems to be the British Museum in London, proud to be British....

??

What about the Louvre with Napoleon's "contributions"?

Naominumbers · 26/08/2023 14:36

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 09:05

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing. When Germany was defeated in 1945 Russia was the authority and did what it saw fit.

Russia annexed the area around Konigsberg. Poland annexed large areas of Germany including Breslau and Stettin. You can't really call this stealing and nobody would suggest that Russia and Poland should give all this land back to Germany.

You could say that the British and other Europeans looted Beijing. However, this was in revenge for the Manchu emperor murdering British and European ambassadors. Torturing them to death, in fact. Perhaps if we can find a descendent of the Manchu emperor, who wasn't ethnic Chinese, we should give all the porcelain, jade, ivory etc. I don't see a reason why it belongs to the Communist party of China.

I find this mentality fascinating. You're viewing conquest as a kind of divine right or the spoils of war rather than stealing. It reminds me of British people who spout stuff like 'we built the railways in India' as a justification for what happened to India. British exceptionalism at work - when we do it, it's OK. It's not OK and many countries are dealing with the massive fallout still. Elizabeth the first sent settlers over to take Irish land. Of course it was stealing. That's what taking stuff that never belonged to you is generally called.

Adelstrop · 26/08/2023 14:35

I was at the BM yesterday for their interesting exhibition about nineteenth century China. The place was heaving, and from the range of languages overheard, the majority of visitors were from overseas. All had free entry. I have been too many museums abroad, and it is usual to have to pay. Sometimes as a foreigner, you have to pay a lot more than the locals. I’m quite happy with the restitution of artefacts which can be proven to be acquired illegally, or even inappropriately by today’s standards. The Benin bronzes are a much more blatant case of this than the Parthenon frieze. However, if the museum ceases to be a world museum, and houses only British exhibits (of which it has many), there seems to me to be no argument for free entry to non locals.

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 14:27

There is a real problem with the provenance of antiquities.

Going slightly off topic (so sue me) but I reserve a special place in Hell for criminals who rip objects out of the ground with no thought for the scientific and historical context.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seuso_Treasure

Seuso Treasure - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seuso_Treasure

Barbadossunset · 26/08/2023 14:14

Another example of those in charge refusing to listen to concerns. Dr Ittai Gradel, the curator who looked closely into the thefts and had proof of what was happening was, according to him, treated like ‘the village idiot’.
Since there is, apparently, no proper catalogued archive the actual extent of thefts will never be discovered.

wightwine · 26/08/2023 14:14

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 09:05

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing. When Germany was defeated in 1945 Russia was the authority and did what it saw fit.

Russia annexed the area around Konigsberg. Poland annexed large areas of Germany including Breslau and Stettin. You can't really call this stealing and nobody would suggest that Russia and Poland should give all this land back to Germany.

You could say that the British and other Europeans looted Beijing. However, this was in revenge for the Manchu emperor murdering British and European ambassadors. Torturing them to death, in fact. Perhaps if we can find a descendent of the Manchu emperor, who wasn't ethnic Chinese, we should give all the porcelain, jade, ivory etc. I don't see a reason why it belongs to the Communist party of China.

What were the British and other Europeans doing in China that caused the emperor to take such violent action against them?

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 13:55

@AppleBlossomTimeNow, I was extremely surprised to hear on the Today programme this morning the the museum has no central catalogue of exhibits and stored holdings.

So odd …

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 26/08/2023 13:17

George Osborne is the chairman. With no experience in running any cultural institutions, and a poor track record at dealing with fraud, blackmail of a sort (think HSBC when he was Chancellor) or money laundering.

It's not just the director who should go.

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 12:57

Sometimeswinning · 26/08/2023 10:24

Yeah I'm not sure your feeling that this is the truth is going to change the palimentary decision made back then. As it stands they were legally obtained therefore they will not be returned.

Please read where I said I dislike Elgin and believe they should be returned. But until it is proven that the Marbles were stolen the British Museum would be crazy to start returning items!

Whilst we have to accept that Elgin acted lawfully, the fact that Greece was under Ottoman rule at the time compromises this in the eyes of many - including Greece.

I believe they should be returned but don't think they will.

lastminutewednesday · 26/08/2023 10:30

I've never understood the obsession with the Elgin marbles tbh. They're just not that interesting. I'd give them back happily and everyone could stop banging on about them.

Sometimeswinning · 26/08/2023 10:24

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 10:10

“Over the years, Greek authorities and the international scientific community have demonstrated with unshakeable arguments the true events surrounding the removal of the Parthenon sculptures,” she said. “Lord Elgin used illicit and inequitable means to seize and export the Parthenon sculptures, without real legal permission to do so, in a blatant act of serial theft.”

I am inclined to feel this is closest to the truth.

Yeah I'm not sure your feeling that this is the truth is going to change the palimentary decision made back then. As it stands they were legally obtained therefore they will not be returned.

Please read where I said I dislike Elgin and believe they should be returned. But until it is proven that the Marbles were stolen the British Museum would be crazy to start returning items!

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 10:14

We're so lucky that apparently the only museum in the world which has artefacts from all around the world, seems to be the British Museum in London, proud to be British....

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 10:10

Sometimeswinning · 26/08/2023 10:04

I don't think anyone has proved or disproved this. It was 200 years ago and even though I think Elgin was a pompous idiot and the Parthenon Marbles should be returned it's not as clear cut to say they were stolen.

“Over the years, Greek authorities and the international scientific community have demonstrated with unshakeable arguments the true events surrounding the removal of the Parthenon sculptures,” she said. “Lord Elgin used illicit and inequitable means to seize and export the Parthenon sculptures, without real legal permission to do so, in a blatant act of serial theft.”

I am inclined to feel this is closest to the truth.

Sometimeswinning · 26/08/2023 10:04

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 09:35

Clearly enough to go round then What an odd position to take.

The Parthenon marbles in question weren't for sale. They were stolen.

I don't think anyone has proved or disproved this. It was 200 years ago and even though I think Elgin was a pompous idiot and the Parthenon Marbles should be returned it's not as clear cut to say they were stolen.

AppleBlossomTimeNow · 26/08/2023 10:03

Totally blows apart the justification that national museums & galleries are best equipped to safeguard objects for the world/future generations. Do they not catalogue their collections or regularly audit them? Were they relying on the fact that their employees are all 'good chaps' and not going to steal? Beggars belief really.

EmmaEmerald · 26/08/2023 09:50

OP I have been pondering this as I've been unwell and it didn't really come to my attention till yesterday.Items sold on ebay I'm guessing were in a vault somewhere? Wondering if there was a group trying to profit off stuff not on display, or what.

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 09:46

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 09:35

Clearly enough to go round then What an odd position to take.

The Parthenon marbles in question weren't for sale. They were stolen.

It was a joke.

And I'll precis what followed as "it's complicated".

Not everything in a museum outside it's place of origin (assuming we agree something made with Indian gems found in an Essex field aren't on the list to be returned as "stolen") is there illegitimately.

Depending whose laws you follow.

Personally I'd like the Elgin saga to conclude with their being returned with the 2 century interval characterised as "an extended tour". However I am also aware that the subsequent calls for other items to be returned would still need to be considered on a case by case basis.

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 09:35

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 09:30

Clearly enough to go round then.

One of the fascinating outcomes of this debate (and I suspect it is very unwelcome in some quarters) is the spotlight it shines on exactly what the great Imperial powers were up to in the past. Even artefacts that appear to have a solid provenance may be questioned as to how that provenance was actually acquired. There is a long and proud history of Britain supporting "the right side" rather than "the legal side" in it's buccaneering. Especially in India.

However that said, it's also known that some totally legitimate regimes at the time did gift - or sell - artefacts to the British. Just because something is alien in a museum doesn't make it a priori stolen.

Clearly enough to go round then What an odd position to take.

The Parthenon marbles in question weren't for sale. They were stolen.

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 09:30

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 09:10

Yet the rest of the sculptures remain and are on display in Athens.

Clearly enough to go round then.

One of the fascinating outcomes of this debate (and I suspect it is very unwelcome in some quarters) is the spotlight it shines on exactly what the great Imperial powers were up to in the past. Even artefacts that appear to have a solid provenance may be questioned as to how that provenance was actually acquired. There is a long and proud history of Britain supporting "the right side" rather than "the legal side" in it's buccaneering. Especially in India.

However that said, it's also known that some totally legitimate regimes at the time did gift - or sell - artefacts to the British. Just because something is alien in a museum doesn't make it a priori stolen.

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 09:10

BorgQueen · 26/08/2023 08:44

Britain saved the Elgin marbles from destruction 🙄

Yet the rest of the sculptures remain and are on display in Athens.

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 09:09

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing.

There's a Mercedes the British troops captured from the Argentines during the Falklands at RAF Cosford. With a notice explaining that it was used for years in RAF bases in Germany until it needed a spare part. When the mechanics contacted Mercedes, they initially refused to help as the car was listed as "stolen". There was a court case where the British showed they had legally acquired the vehicle as spoils of war and Mercedes had to pony up.

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 09:05

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing. When Germany was defeated in 1945 Russia was the authority and did what it saw fit.

Russia annexed the area around Konigsberg. Poland annexed large areas of Germany including Breslau and Stettin. You can't really call this stealing and nobody would suggest that Russia and Poland should give all this land back to Germany.

You could say that the British and other Europeans looted Beijing. However, this was in revenge for the Manchu emperor murdering British and European ambassadors. Torturing them to death, in fact. Perhaps if we can find a descendent of the Manchu emperor, who wasn't ethnic Chinese, we should give all the porcelain, jade, ivory etc. I don't see a reason why it belongs to the Communist party of China.

Dontcallmescarface · 26/08/2023 08:58

BorgQueen · 26/08/2023 08:44

Britain saved the Elgin marbles from destruction 🙄

Well now there is no chance of them being destroyed Britain can give them back then.

Username1107 · 26/08/2023 08:56

🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread