Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
AppleBlossomTimeNow · 26/08/2023 16:49

If these national institutions can't catalogue & account for their collections then they should return items to countries of origin. You can't justify hanging on to them for research, or safeguarding, or for loaning to other institutions if you don't know what you have. It blows a huge hole in the argument that they are trustworthy custodians of material history & culture. I can see it is probably a funding issue but to some extent it must be due to a culture of complacency too.

CallumDansTransitVan · 26/08/2023 16:36

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 13:55

@AppleBlossomTimeNow, I was extremely surprised to hear on the Today programme this morning the the museum has no central catalogue of exhibits and stored holdings.

So odd …

This is the part that bemuses me. Imagine going to the police.
We've had some stuff stolen
What is missing Sir?
We're not sure, as we don't know what we have in the first place. 😅

Borough · 26/08/2023 16:36

People have always done this.

Anyone been to the bloody Vatican recently? The entire place is full of plundered shit. Gold, marble, the lot. In Venice they spent centuries robbing everyone they went near, and each time they came back home they had random bits of priceless treasures to stick all over the Doge's Palace.

Sometimeswinning · 26/08/2023 16:32

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 16:20

That's the thing, we helped to save the items for future generations and we acquired them legally at the time, why then should we now return the items just because they have new leaders ?

I don't think Elgin saved anything for anyone other than himself. The only thing I think should be done is to remove his name from the Marbles.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 26/08/2023 16:26

missmollygreen · 26/08/2023 16:13

So if someone was throwing a sofa away and you rescued it... they should just be able to take it back from you?

But what if someone breaks into your house and throws your sofa away? And in the course of you kicking him out of your house your other furniture gets trashed.
It’s so complicated.
I used to read and write a lot about this back when I was an academic- I have been interviewed on national radio about it- but I still can’t work out what I think about restitution. Both sides make a mixture of reasonable and unreasonable arguments imo.

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 16:20

missmollygreen · 26/08/2023 16:13

So if someone was throwing a sofa away and you rescued it... they should just be able to take it back from you?

That's the thing, we helped to save the items for future generations and we acquired them legally at the time, why then should we now return the items just because they have new leaders ?

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 16:14

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

By being gifted the item, buy conducting business all legit at the time of the acquisitions.

Back in history differerent times, different agreements.

Plus ask your selves. If the British m. Had not acquired these items, how many would be looted, how many in private collections, etc.

missmollygreen · 26/08/2023 16:13

Ypsilanti · 26/08/2023 08:45

That doesn’t mean we have a right to keep them.

So if someone was throwing a sofa away and you rescued it... they should just be able to take it back from you?

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 26/08/2023 16:09

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:49

By hacking them OFF the Parthenon. They weren't standalone statues you know. That's actually criminal damage. They were also damaged by chemical cleaning at the BM in the earlier part of the 20th century.

Many of those that remained are in the Acropolis Museum. So they too were presumably "saved from destruction" and not by Elgin.

Compare the state of the caryatid in the BM with the ones that stood on the Erechtheion for longer and suffered from the Athenian air pollution (now safe in the excellent climate controlled museum in Athens) though. It’s just not that simple.

JudgeJ · 26/08/2023 16:02

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:49

By hacking them OFF the Parthenon. They weren't standalone statues you know. That's actually criminal damage. They were also damaged by chemical cleaning at the BM in the earlier part of the 20th century.

Many of those that remained are in the Acropolis Museum. So they too were presumably "saved from destruction" and not by Elgin.

Many were destroyed by subsequent invaders long before the Greeks cared about them.

JudgeJ · 26/08/2023 16:00

BorgQueen · 26/08/2023 08:44

Britain saved the Elgin marbles from destruction 🙄

Bravo! I recall being on the Acropolis being harangued by the guide about the Elgin marbles being 'stolen', despite Elgin buying them from the then government. When she was asked what happened to the rest she breezily said Oh they were destroyed by the Turks and others in subsequent invasions, obviously too simple to see the irony of the fact that Elgin's marbles are still whole and can be freely seen! Does anyone ever take Germany to task about the Pergamon Museum or many others on Museum Island in Berlin or Nefertiti in the Neues Museum, both of which charge a lot ?

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:59

Elgin bought the marbles from an occupying power. People generally think it right that items sold on in World War II by occupying powers should be returned to the original owners.

So is it only acceptable if it happened 200 years ago, not 80?

ScottishIceCream · 26/08/2023 15:53

Got to admit I have laughed at the irony of the BM getting het up about stolen artefacts.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:49

BorgQueen · 26/08/2023 08:44

Britain saved the Elgin marbles from destruction 🙄

By hacking them OFF the Parthenon. They weren't standalone statues you know. That's actually criminal damage. They were also damaged by chemical cleaning at the BM in the earlier part of the 20th century.

Many of those that remained are in the Acropolis Museum. So they too were presumably "saved from destruction" and not by Elgin.

neverbeenskiing · 26/08/2023 15:39

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing.

Isn't the former still stealing but with added bloodshed? I think the point is that it's highly debatable whether "right of conquest" has any legitimacy in this day and age.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 26/08/2023 15:34

Wilkolampshade · 26/08/2023 15:12

DH works in this area.. And has worked with the BM in the past. It was his experience that an attitude of academe versus everyone else was entrenched and expertise from dealers etc often ignored. What he found most credible about this farce was the Museums lack of action when the issue was raised.
There's no surprise the catalogue is far from complete though, the collection is truly vast. Museums have few resources at the best of times and this work is often not seen as a priority by those higher up. Maybe this will change now... fingers crossed...

I am also unsurprised.
I did the sort of PhD that might have led to me working there but no openings came up at the right time. However I knew a number of people who applied there and it always seemed to be the case that the jobs went to the man whose face fitted rather than the better qualified woman. It therefore doesn’t surprise me that they have ended up with a bit of a boys’ club where they ignore evidence of theft because they all just know the others are jolly good chaps.

Sadly I don’t think the current chair of trustees is going to be much use in changing that culture.

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 15:25

Museums have few resources at the best of times and this work is often not seen as a priority

Without having given it an enormous amount of thought I had always assumed that every museum contained a back room full of serious experts and eager interns spending all their waking hours cataloguing and researching everything they held. Strange to realise this isn’t actually the case!

OP posts:
OleMioSole · 26/08/2023 15:14

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 15:05

I'm not saying it's OK I'm saying that things happened in history and trying to divide people into victims and perpetrators is naive. If Germans didn't want their eastern territories taken away they shouldn't have supported a vicious unprovoked war.

If the Manchus didn't want their palaces burned down then they shouldn't have tortured European diplomats. The Manchus had no more right to China than the British had to India. Both were invaders. The Moghuls were invaders too. They came from central Asia and were of Mongol and Turkic descent.

As for the Irish, they invaded western Scotland. Gaelic is not an indigenous language of Scotland, it was introduced by Irish invaders. At the same time Angles were invading south-eastern Scotland and their language became the Scots language.

Where I live Vikings who got kicked out of Ireland asked an English queen if they could settle in Wirral. She gave them permission so you could say that's not stealing. That makes them good guys I guess.

Yes.
@Naominumbers as much as it's silly for Britain to pretend that it was 'modernising' other nations it's disingenuous to imply that they were the only ones. Or that all negative effects are their fault.
Anybody with even a passing interest in history knows that empire, war and conquering as concepts have existed since the dawn of humanity.

Wilkolampshade · 26/08/2023 15:12

DH works in this area.. And has worked with the BM in the past. It was his experience that an attitude of academe versus everyone else was entrenched and expertise from dealers etc often ignored. What he found most credible about this farce was the Museums lack of action when the issue was raised.
There's no surprise the catalogue is far from complete though, the collection is truly vast. Museums have few resources at the best of times and this work is often not seen as a priority by those higher up. Maybe this will change now... fingers crossed...

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 15:05

Naominumbers · 26/08/2023 14:36

I find this mentality fascinating. You're viewing conquest as a kind of divine right or the spoils of war rather than stealing. It reminds me of British people who spout stuff like 'we built the railways in India' as a justification for what happened to India. British exceptionalism at work - when we do it, it's OK. It's not OK and many countries are dealing with the massive fallout still. Elizabeth the first sent settlers over to take Irish land. Of course it was stealing. That's what taking stuff that never belonged to you is generally called.

I'm not saying it's OK I'm saying that things happened in history and trying to divide people into victims and perpetrators is naive. If Germans didn't want their eastern territories taken away they shouldn't have supported a vicious unprovoked war.

If the Manchus didn't want their palaces burned down then they shouldn't have tortured European diplomats. The Manchus had no more right to China than the British had to India. Both were invaders. The Moghuls were invaders too. They came from central Asia and were of Mongol and Turkic descent.

As for the Irish, they invaded western Scotland. Gaelic is not an indigenous language of Scotland, it was introduced by Irish invaders. At the same time Angles were invading south-eastern Scotland and their language became the Scots language.

Where I live Vikings who got kicked out of Ireland asked an English queen if they could settle in Wirral. She gave them permission so you could say that's not stealing. That makes them good guys I guess.

CardamomGarden · 26/08/2023 14:58

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 14:44

I was being sarcastic, because it only ever seems to be a problem that us British have large collections of worldly treasures and artefacts yet you can view a whole heap of similar items in other 1st world nations selection of museums.

We hear a lot about the British Museum specifically because we’re in Britain and because there are particular high-profile examples like the Elgin Marbles and Benin bronzes. However, I have recently read about this topic with reference to similar museums in other parts of the world so this does concern them, yes.

One recent piece seemed disapproving of the very concept of ‘museums of everywhere’ and I hope that isn’t the end destination here. I’m not particularly interested in going to see 3D printout replicas as I’ve seen suggested. My hope would be more very long-term loans between collections, as well as the permanent exchange of items between nations.

Tessiebeare · 26/08/2023 14:58

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 14:44

I was being sarcastic, because it only ever seems to be a problem that us British have large collections of worldly treasures and artefacts yet you can view a whole heap of similar items in other 1st world nations selection of museums.

It is interesting isn’t it as loads of other countries have similar artefacts but without the angst to go with it.
The Pergamon museum in Germany houses the Ishtar gate for example which Iraq officially requested in 2002 but they have just ignored that request and now they won’t even be on display for years due to renovations in the museum.

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 14:47

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 14:44

I was being sarcastic, because it only ever seems to be a problem that us British have large collections of worldly treasures and artefacts yet you can view a whole heap of similar items in other 1st world nations selection of museums.

You can't move for Roman ruins in Rome ...

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 14:47

You're viewing conquest as a kind of divine right or the spoils of war rather than stealing.

Well to be fair, for all of recorded human history, Might has always been Right. Or to put it another way, who writes history ?

I seem to recall T H White was quite taken with the concept of Might is Right and wove it into "The Once And Future King" which was written in the 50s. (You'd never guess my DM was a leftie).

Biker47 · 26/08/2023 14:44

I was being sarcastic, because it only ever seems to be a problem that us British have large collections of worldly treasures and artefacts yet you can view a whole heap of similar items in other 1st world nations selection of museums.