Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mathanxiety · 26/08/2023 19:31

Longagonow96 · 26/08/2023 19:30

Pray do some fucking research, clever dick. Most was gifted or purchased.

For money? Or glass beads?

Longagonow96 · 26/08/2023 19:30

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

Pray do some fucking research, clever dick. Most was gifted or purchased.

mathanxiety · 26/08/2023 19:28

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 09:05

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing. When Germany was defeated in 1945 Russia was the authority and did what it saw fit.

Russia annexed the area around Konigsberg. Poland annexed large areas of Germany including Breslau and Stettin. You can't really call this stealing and nobody would suggest that Russia and Poland should give all this land back to Germany.

You could say that the British and other Europeans looted Beijing. However, this was in revenge for the Manchu emperor murdering British and European ambassadors. Torturing them to death, in fact. Perhaps if we can find a descendent of the Manchu emperor, who wasn't ethnic Chinese, we should give all the porcelain, jade, ivory etc. I don't see a reason why it belongs to the Communist party of China.

Clearly you don't appreciate the role of Churchill and Roosevelt in resetting the borders of Poland after WW2, with the "Curzon Line" (Curzon was neither a Pole or a Russian) forming the eastern border despite large swathes of Polish territory and millions of ethnic Poles to the east of it. It wasn't a case of "Poland annexed...".

Poland also lost territory to the Ukrainian SSR, to current day Lithuania, and what would become Belarus after the breakup of the Soviet Union. The Polish population of areas that became Ukrainian (Volhynia, Galicia) had been driven out /massacred by Ukrainian nationalists in 1943 and 1944. Lviv was once Lwow, a major Polish city and cuktural centre.

FrippEnos · 26/08/2023 19:15

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 18:05

Nobody is claiming they were being looked after. Greece was under Turkish occupation and I imagine they had other worries... But times have moved on, and their rightful place is back in Athens - where they were taken from.

Continuing to call them the Elgin Marbles also irks.

If they had not been removed it is debatable as to how many would even remain today.
And I have already said that they should go back.

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 19:10

@StarbucksSmarterSister
As for why the difference with modern occupation and the looting of artefact's, that's out of my area of knowledge.

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 19:09

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:41

But if we acquired them legally etc at the time

But as I said upthread, it's not generally considered "legal" to keep stuff sold by WW2 occupying powers so why is this legal? Is it because it was longer ago, or because the occupation lasted much longer? Or because it's us?

I would presume in ancient times it's due to gifts by x rulers of the country especially if they are the ones in power at that time and if the govt controlled the items at the time they were gifted to other countries, either as tokens or as business deals etc

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 19:06

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:46

there is a risk that returning said items could mean either theft, destroyed or sold for profit to a private collector

What evidence is there that this would happen? Do you seriously think a government having spent decades trying to get them back would sell them or destroy them? And why would they be more likely to be stolen there than here?

These days whos to say what truly happens, besides I'm sure our intelligence services would have the evidence needed even if the public don't.

Barbadossunset · 26/08/2023 19:02

MidnightOnceMore · Today 18:32

Because it's the right thing to do.

Works of art stolen by the Nazis should be returned to their original owners descendants - if proven, which isn’t always easy to do - and there have been several examples of this happening.
‘The Russians stole a lot of art from Germany, some it stolen by Nazis first. Do you think Russia should have to return this art to the descendants of the original German owners?

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:46

there is a risk that returning said items could mean either theft, destroyed or sold for profit to a private collector

What evidence is there that this would happen? Do you seriously think a government having spent decades trying to get them back would sell them or destroy them? And why would they be more likely to be stolen there than here?

7Worfs · 26/08/2023 18:43

RhymesWithTangerine · 26/08/2023 08:44

I am gripped! I am waiting for the Netflix doc then the BBC mini-series starring Anthony Head.

It’s the new Crooked House.

Excellent casting choice!

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:41

But if we acquired them legally etc at the time

But as I said upthread, it's not generally considered "legal" to keep stuff sold by WW2 occupying powers so why is this legal? Is it because it was longer ago, or because the occupation lasted much longer? Or because it's us?

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:36

There are many, many paintings and objects produced in this country that I'd love to see, but I can't because rich Americans have bought them and taken them to the USA. That includes several paintings by Turner, Leighton, Waterhouse and the Pre-Raphaelites – all of them British.

Indeed. But people do have the right to sell their own property. If a legitimate Greek government had chosen to sell off various statues that would be a different issue (although I'm sure modern Greeks would not be happy about it.)

However not only did the occupying Turks sell off someone else's heritage Elgin didn't buy freestanding statues, he caused immense criminal damage and there is also a dispute as to whether or not he actually had the permission to do that since the original plan was to make casts and drawings of the frieze, not physically rip it off. This is why it's so controversial and it can't be compared to a property owner selling off their own possessions.

As it is I'd be shocked if the BM relinquished possession, even though I think they should.

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 18:35

MidnightOnceMore · 26/08/2023 18:32

Because it's the right thing to do.

But if we acquired them legally etc at the time and there is a risk that returning said items could mean either theft, destroyed or sold for profit to a private collector, then it could also be the right and more moral thing to do, is keep them in the British museum for future generations.

MidnightOnceMore · 26/08/2023 18:32

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 16:20

That's the thing, we helped to save the items for future generations and we acquired them legally at the time, why then should we now return the items just because they have new leaders ?

Because it's the right thing to do.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:25

and I do believe that they should go back especially as they would be going to a specially designed museum for them.

I have to say I was really surprised the first time I saw them at the BM as I thought for such famous pieces they were quite poorly displayed. The Acropolis Museum is very well designed.

unicornhair · 26/08/2023 18:21

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 15:25

Museums have few resources at the best of times and this work is often not seen as a priority

Without having given it an enormous amount of thought I had always assumed that every museum contained a back room full of serious experts and eager interns spending all their waking hours cataloguing and researching everything they held. Strange to realise this isn’t actually the case!

My experience is in local authority museums but management are far more interested in spending resources on public facing events than cataloging. Proper documentation is specialised and slow work, there’s no way round it. To management though it’s a waste of time or should just happen magically without putting resources into it. The job creation schemes in the 1980s were utilised and made a massive mess of things.
someone mentioned auditing and I would say it’s an impossible task and would take years. In LA we were audited but it would be a random selection of a few items every year.

Truthlikeness · 26/08/2023 18:20

No museum has a complete catalogue of everything they own - it's simply impossible given the scale of the collections, the backlog of undocumented objects and the levels of resource that museums struggle to make do with. Documentation is carried out on a rolling basis but it's a constant balance with lower and lower levels of funding to keep the buildings secure and operating as visitor attractions. That said, the BM has some particular cultural issues which hopefully this incident will shine a light on.

JaneyGee · 26/08/2023 18:20

Museums and art galleries throughout the world contain paintings, statues, coins, swords, etc, from other countries. That's kind of the definition of a museum. There are many, many paintings and objects produced in this country that I'd love to see, but I can't because rich Americans have bought them and taken them to the USA. That includes several paintings by Turner, Leighton, Waterhouse and the Pre-Raphaelites – all of them British. Tolkien said that he wrote Lord of the Rings as a dedication "to England, my country." Yet so many things connected with him (including the desk at which he wrote his books) are now in the USA.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 18:17

So if someone was throwing a sofa away and you rescued it... they should just be able to take it back from you?

Nobody was "throwing away" the Parthenon marbles though.

AppleBlossomTimeNow · 26/08/2023 18:10

@TheCountessofFitzdotterel but my point is that they use their world class stewardship & scholarship as a justification for hanging on to the big important stuff. If they can't keep track of their collections (no matter how fragmented & insignificant artefacts may seem) then they can't claim this superior status. It's hypocritical.

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 18:05

FrippEnos · 26/08/2023 17:38

Many are not on display as they were destroyed.
Some are on display.
Some of the Elgin Marbles were being destroyed as he saved them. Some of them may have been Taken by more illicit means. But lets not pretend that they were being looked after at the time.

and I do believe that they should go back especially as they would be going to a specially designed museum for them.

Nobody is claiming they were being looked after. Greece was under Turkish occupation and I imagine they had other worries... But times have moved on, and their rightful place is back in Athens - where they were taken from.

Continuing to call them the Elgin Marbles also irks.

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 17:59

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:49

By hacking them OFF the Parthenon. They weren't standalone statues you know. That's actually criminal damage. They were also damaged by chemical cleaning at the BM in the earlier part of the 20th century.

Many of those that remained are in the Acropolis Museum. So they too were presumably "saved from destruction" and not by Elgin.

👏

FrippEnos · 26/08/2023 17:38

ArightPacificState · 26/08/2023 10:10

“Over the years, Greek authorities and the international scientific community have demonstrated with unshakeable arguments the true events surrounding the removal of the Parthenon sculptures,” she said. “Lord Elgin used illicit and inequitable means to seize and export the Parthenon sculptures, without real legal permission to do so, in a blatant act of serial theft.”

I am inclined to feel this is closest to the truth.

Many are not on display as they were destroyed.
Some are on display.
Some of the Elgin Marbles were being destroyed as he saved them. Some of them may have been Taken by more illicit means. But lets not pretend that they were being looked after at the time.

and I do believe that they should go back especially as they would be going to a specially designed museum for them.

Hawkins009 · 26/08/2023 17:24

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 26/08/2023 16:26

But what if someone breaks into your house and throws your sofa away? And in the course of you kicking him out of your house your other furniture gets trashed.
It’s so complicated.
I used to read and write a lot about this back when I was an academic- I have been interviewed on national radio about it- but I still can’t work out what I think about restitution. Both sides make a mixture of reasonable and unreasonable arguments imo.

I think for some items that if they had to be returned or potentially is how secure the items would be, how long before they potentially end up in a private collection etc.

Yes not all countries would be like that.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 26/08/2023 17:20

AppleBlossomTimeNow · 26/08/2023 16:49

If these national institutions can't catalogue & account for their collections then they should return items to countries of origin. You can't justify hanging on to them for research, or safeguarding, or for loaning to other institutions if you don't know what you have. It blows a huge hole in the argument that they are trustworthy custodians of material history & culture. I can see it is probably a funding issue but to some extent it must be due to a culture of complacency too.

But the stuff they can’t account for isn’t the same as the stuff that is wanted back. They won’t have lost bits of Parthenon frieze, it will be smaller less exciting objects that they have in multiples, and I assure you that UK museums aren’t unique in having funding crises, overloaded and inadequate storage, documentation backlogs, not to mention security problems.

It is terrible PR for the British Museum but it doesn’t really mean that the collection would be better off dispersed and looked after elsewhere.