Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
nidgey · 30/08/2023 13:35

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:19

And Britain did a pretty good job of destroying its own heritage in the Reformation, and destroying parts of Dublin (then part of Britain) in the 1916 Rising and War of Independence.

Sure, but is Britain asking for the return of British artefacts in museums overseas?

What British artefacts? I think it's why people balk at the 'British' museum being so full of material that isn't actually British.
It would be nice if they sent some of the Irish material they have back to Ireland

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:23

London Bridge was sold to America in 1968, dismantled, shipped and re-erected in Arizona.
Maybe we should ask for that back.

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:19

And Britain did a pretty good job of destroying its own heritage in the Reformation, and destroying parts of Dublin (then part of Britain) in the 1916 Rising and War of Independence.

Sure, but is Britain asking for the return of British artefacts in museums overseas?

Takoneko · 30/08/2023 13:16

I’m sympathetic to arguments about returning artefacts in some cases but I think it does need some careful thought. Especially where we are talking about China and Chinese artefacts. It’s all very well for us to send back a few jades and vases as a gesture of goodwill but it ramps up pressure on Taiwan and the National Palace Museum. I feel quite strongly that the collections in Taipei should stay where they are.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 12:50

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 10:03

I see China now wants its artefacts back after the thefts from the BM.
Hmm…..in the not too distant past their own leader did a pretty good job of destroying the country’s treasures - historial relics and artefacts, cultural and religious sites destroyed by Red Guards.

I look forward to the UK telling China to shove it. And indeed India.

nidgey · 30/08/2023 12:43

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 10:03

I see China now wants its artefacts back after the thefts from the BM.
Hmm…..in the not too distant past their own leader did a pretty good job of destroying the country’s treasures - historial relics and artefacts, cultural and religious sites destroyed by Red Guards.

And Britain did a pretty good job of destroying its own heritage in the Reformation, and destroying parts of Dublin (then part of Britain) in the 1916 Rising and War of Independence.

nidgey · 30/08/2023 12:41

SuePine69 · 30/08/2023 09:45

Working out who is an 'occupying power' is not as easy as you might think. Indonesia is an 'occupying power' of Irian Jaya. Turkey is an 'occupying power' of parts of Kurdistan. China is an 'occupying power' of Tibet and Xinjiang.

Perhaps in hundreds of years the people of Turkish Kurdistan will have adopted Turkish language and culture and regard themselves as loyal Turks. That has happened all over the world. People in Greece whose grandparents spoke Bulgarian now speak standard Greek. There is a lot of Slavic ancestry in Greece that isn't talked about. They prefer to think of themselves as descendants of Ancient Greek philosophers.

He didn't buy the marbles - he took them and sold them and it's highly contested whether he had permission to take them in the first place. Greece first requested their return in 1835, shortly after the Ottomans were displaced from power. Even in the 1820s, many many British experts and public figures disputed the legality of the sculptures' removal.

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 10:03

I see China now wants its artefacts back after the thefts from the BM.
Hmm…..in the not too distant past their own leader did a pretty good job of destroying the country’s treasures - historial relics and artefacts, cultural and religious sites destroyed by Red Guards.

SuePine69 · 30/08/2023 09:57

neverbeenskiing · 26/08/2023 15:39

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing.

Isn't the former still stealing but with added bloodshed? I think the point is that it's highly debatable whether "right of conquest" has any legitimacy in this day and age.

Russia didn't send its armies into Germany to annexe territory. They were attacked by Germany, managed with great difficulty to defend themselves, and then needed to destroy their attackers.

When they occupied eastern Europe they were the authority. They didn't have to ask Germany for permission to take parts of east Prussia for themselves. There wasn't a German government to ask. There was no 'added bloodshed'.

India invaded Kashmir. There were reasons for that, just as there were reasons for invading the princely state of Hyderabad and deposing the Nizam. That doesn't mean that India has the right to keep Kashmir. Who now owns the diamond mines that made the Nizam of Hyderabad one of the richest men in the world? Presumably India, but that only came about by conquest.

SuePine69 · 30/08/2023 09:45

StarbucksSmarterSister · 26/08/2023 15:59

Elgin bought the marbles from an occupying power. People generally think it right that items sold on in World War II by occupying powers should be returned to the original owners.

So is it only acceptable if it happened 200 years ago, not 80?

Working out who is an 'occupying power' is not as easy as you might think. Indonesia is an 'occupying power' of Irian Jaya. Turkey is an 'occupying power' of parts of Kurdistan. China is an 'occupying power' of Tibet and Xinjiang.

Perhaps in hundreds of years the people of Turkish Kurdistan will have adopted Turkish language and culture and regard themselves as loyal Turks. That has happened all over the world. People in Greece whose grandparents spoke Bulgarian now speak standard Greek. There is a lot of Slavic ancestry in Greece that isn't talked about. They prefer to think of themselves as descendants of Ancient Greek philosophers.

Lonicerax · 29/08/2023 09:08

I am wondering if our expanding population is affecting life - I’m not saying immigrants are to blame - many ‘immigrants ‘ have been here for decades but the population has gone up by 20% since the 60s but have the numbers of police, courts, teachers, doctors, nurses and everyone else? Ir is the same or less - hence the possibility for people to Nick things, damage things, steal bikes and just run away, So much is just out of control.

Other European countries have not increased like this.

nidgey · 29/08/2023 08:55

Sometimeswinning · 28/08/2023 19:51

Because more people have the chance to see them? I didn't think that needed explaining. It's one of 2 points I do kind of agree with.

Does that mean all museums should be in places with the highest population? Why not send them to Beijing then? The Louvre which has more than 9 million visitors every year have said they will lend (long term) their Parthenon sculptures to Greece, and the Vatican restituted their Parthenon sculptures - they also have more visitors than the BM annually (6.88 million).

The sculptures were not only taken to Britain under dodgy circumstances, they are completely identified with Athens given they are from the temple dedicated to the patron of the city - and the original building is still there, as are many of the sculptures that survived. If the sculptures were restituted, they would be installed alongside the other fragments, giving a more complete sense of the original context - and probably drawing more visitors.

The BM may profit from keeping them but there's no moral justification. And they really haven't cared for their collections properly - as per the current scandal - and even with the parthenon sculptures which were badly damaged by the use of abrasive cleaners to make them look whiter.

Sometimeswinning · 28/08/2023 19:51

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 14:44

Why is more visitor numbers a basis to refuse to give them back?

Because our gang is bigger than your gang ?

Because more people have the chance to see them? I didn't think that needed explaining. It's one of 2 points I do kind of agree with.

Sometimeswinning · 28/08/2023 19:48

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 16:04

The idea of the British as some sort of superhero saviours of world heritage is rather amusing to those people who know it was possible to rent chisels to allow you to sake souvenir chunks of Stonehenge home with you long after the Elgin Marbles were in Russell Square.

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/stonehenge-visitors-used-be-handed-chisels-take-home-souvenirs-180949976/

You're talking over 100 years ago to be fair. If you were talking today you would have a point. But you're not.

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 16:04

The idea of the British as some sort of superhero saviours of world heritage is rather amusing to those people who know it was possible to rent chisels to allow you to sake souvenir chunks of Stonehenge home with you long after the Elgin Marbles were in Russell Square.

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/stonehenge-visitors-used-be-handed-chisels-take-home-souvenirs-180949976/

Break me of a piece of that monolith.

Stonehenge Visitors Used To Be Handed Chisels to Take Home Souvenirs

Chisels were banned in the early 1900s, and in 1977, the stones were roped off so people couldn’t climb on them any longer

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/stonehenge-visitors-used-be-handed-chisels-take-home-souvenirs-180949976

StarbucksSmarterSister · 28/08/2023 15:09

The legality or not of their removal is highly debatable - most scholars agree that the only verifiable document is one which permitted Elgin to sketch the sculptures and remove what stone had already fallen - not to hack them off the actual building.

Exactly. But even if it was agreed that removal wasn't legal, just wait for "possession is 9/10ths of the law".

SerendipityJane · 28/08/2023 14:44

Why is more visitor numbers a basis to refuse to give them back?

Because our gang is bigger than your gang ?

nidgey · 28/08/2023 14:35

Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 22:51

A quick Google tells me the BM had 6 million. I was also 1 of them. So quite a few million more got to appreciate the Marbles (for free!)

Why is more visitor numbers a basis to refuse to give them back? The BM's argument that they're keeping them for 'all humankind' is deeply patronising.
The Acropolis Museum is literally a museum of the site and includes as many surviving sculptures from the different structures there as possible. Most other countries have sent back what fragments they have in recognition of this. It's also extremely beautiful and well designed (unlike the current position of the parthenon sculptures in the BM).
That the sculptures would be damaged in transit seems highly unlikely - there are specialist art handlers who deal with priceless material every day - the BM continually lone precious artefacts so that's hardly an argument.
The legality or not of their removal is highly debatable - most scholars agree that the only verifiable document is one which permitted Elgin to sketch the sculptures and remove what stone had already fallen - not to hack them off the actual building.

CardamomGarden · 28/08/2023 11:39

Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 22:51

A quick Google tells me the BM had 6 million. I was also 1 of them. So quite a few million more got to appreciate the Marbles (for free!)

The BM - which I also visited last year, as well as this one - is one of the world’s top museums in terms of visitor numbers, scope and scale.

For the Acropolis Museum to have a quarter of the BM’s visitor numbers absolutely confirms it as a major museum. Then consider that it isn’t a ‘museum of everywhere’, but has a very specific scope.

When I was at the BM last month I went to see their current Chinese exhibition and had a quick look at some of the Roman exhibits while I was there. I didn’t visit the Marbles. Nor on the visit or two before that. Whereas the Parthenon frieze accounts for the whole top floor in the museum in Athens and is the centrepiece of the whole collection.

SurpriseSparDay · 28/08/2023 08:40

(The relevant part was the museum representative arguing that they had believed the museum acquired the pole legitimately, so it took a lot of investigation to arrive at a different interpretation.)

OP posts:
OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 23:40

nidgey · 27/08/2023 23:17

Are you saying I’m lying? Your ‘belief’ is based on such scant evidence that it means nothing. I work in museology, have a PhD in an ancillary discipline and have expertise in the whole area. At this stage there’s very little justification for the government not to change the law and for the BM not to repatriate the sculptures (and a fair bit more of its collection), and seeing the fallacious, wrong headed and jingoistic arguments on here wouldn’t wash with anyone who actually understands the field in an international context. The BM is deeply politicised especially since the appointment of the current board/chair so yet again Britain is an outlier in this.

Luckily your PhD has enabled you to disagree and put forward a good argument 🤣 Im kidding. (Let's ignore the fact that I think the Marbles should return to Greece, I have said it in most of my posts!)

Of course it's all about the countries and who wins. What else would it be? Greece could have the Marbles but only on the terms of the BM. Neither side is backing down on that.

Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 23:27

nidgey · 27/08/2023 23:19

How is that any kind of argument? They belong with the rest of the sculptures so the whole scheme can be appreciated in its entirety

By less people.

Its a good argument. As the expert you say you are I thought you'd have known this is an argument for the BM keeping the Marbles.

nidgey · 27/08/2023 23:19

Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 22:51

A quick Google tells me the BM had 6 million. I was also 1 of them. So quite a few million more got to appreciate the Marbles (for free!)

How is that any kind of argument? They belong with the rest of the sculptures so the whole scheme can be appreciated in its entirety

nidgey · 27/08/2023 23:17

Sometimeswinning · 27/08/2023 22:10

I don't for one second believe you have read extensively. I think you have seen a bit of information. Judged. End of.

Therefore I find it difficult to add anything to what I've said over the thread.

Are you saying I’m lying? Your ‘belief’ is based on such scant evidence that it means nothing. I work in museology, have a PhD in an ancillary discipline and have expertise in the whole area. At this stage there’s very little justification for the government not to change the law and for the BM not to repatriate the sculptures (and a fair bit more of its collection), and seeing the fallacious, wrong headed and jingoistic arguments on here wouldn’t wash with anyone who actually understands the field in an international context. The BM is deeply politicised especially since the appointment of the current board/chair so yet again Britain is an outlier in this.