Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SuePine69 · 02/09/2023 12:06

If the person is still alive that might be possible but not always desirable. If they are dead then who would you return it to? The example I gave was the Nizam of Hyderabad with his diamond mines.

In 1860 Lord Elgin, ordered troops to loot and destroy both the Summer Palace and Old Summer Palace to avenge the killing of several British envoys to Beijing. The Xianfeng Emperor lost of precious things some of them probably ending up in the British Museum with the Greek marbles.

The Xianfeng Emperor wasn't ethnic Chinese, he was a Manchu. The Manchus conquered China and acquired its wealth. Was that stealing? So who should we give it all back to? Any descendants of the Xianfeng Emperor? The Manchu people? The Chinese government? The Taiwanese government?

At the same time the Xianfeng Emperor lost a lot of territory to the Russians. They're not going to give it back. That was more important than trinkets. The Chinese government seem to think that everywhere that was part of the Manchu empire should now belong to them. That's why they want Taiwan back, although they don't seem to be bothered about the Russian annexations or Mongolia either although the Emperor controlled that too.

The Poles didn't have any say in how they acquired German territory after WW2 but they did 25 years earlier when they occupied Ukrainian, Belorussian and Lithuanian territory. This included the cities of Vilnius and Lviv. Was that stealing? It's just as well they did because it stopped large numbers of Ukrainians from starving to death in Stalin's deliberate famine. Just goes to show how you can't see history in terms of black and white, heroes and villains.

wightwine · 02/09/2023 11:51

SuePine69 · 01/09/2023 16:25

You might think that I would have a problem with the return of the Parthenon marbles or Benin Bronzes but actually I don't. We could say to the Greeks give us a year and we can make accurate copies. Then we keep the copies and give the originals back to you.

Even more so the Benin Bronzes. Something like them can go to different parts of the world in exhibitions. Maybe the Nigerians could keep them part of the year and then they go to New York, Tokyo or wherever for part of the year. They belong to the world really. Do they belong to the world, to the Nigerians or to the Edo people? It doesn't really matter if plenty of people get to see them.

So, SuePine, the Greeks/Europeans can have their property back but the Nigerians property 'belongs to the world really'. Really?

Barbadossunset · 01/09/2023 16:36

SuePine do you think individuals should have stolen property returned or only museums?

SuePine69 · 01/09/2023 16:25

Barbadossunset · 01/09/2023 15:17

In many cases you wouldn't want them to give it back.

SuePine in which cases would you want them to give it back?

You might think that I would have a problem with the return of the Parthenon marbles or Benin Bronzes but actually I don't. We could say to the Greeks give us a year and we can make accurate copies. Then we keep the copies and give the originals back to you.

Even more so the Benin Bronzes. Something like them can go to different parts of the world in exhibitions. Maybe the Nigerians could keep them part of the year and then they go to New York, Tokyo or wherever for part of the year. They belong to the world really. Do they belong to the world, to the Nigerians or to the Edo people? It doesn't really matter if plenty of people get to see them.

nidgey · 01/09/2023 16:02

SuePine69 · 01/09/2023 14:46

I know that the Poles had no influence in changes of their borders. That doesn't change the fact that Poland is in possession of land that formerly belonged to Germany. Nobody is expecting them to give it back.

Israel is in possession of land that formerly belonged to Palestinians. Nobody is expecting them to give it back.

Nobody alive today had any say in what was transferred from one country or another, whether it is land or treasures. In many cases you wouldn't want them to give it back. I don't know who owns the diamond mines that up till about 1948 belonged to the Nizam of Hyderabad. I hope diamonds are sold and the money used to help the people on India. I don't think we should give the mines back to his son or grandson.

Eh people are certainly lobbying for the restoration of much territory particularly when taken by force! Land is obviously different than artefacts, and the Parthenon marbles is a fairly clear-cut case.

Barbadossunset · 01/09/2023 15:17

In many cases you wouldn't want them to give it back.

SuePine in which cases would you want them to give it back?

Barbadossunset · 01/09/2023 15:16

The former GDR had a practice which was theft dressed up as something else.:

Kommerzielle Koordinierung or KoKo which was run by a Stasi officer as a means for raising money for 1980s for the increasingly impoverished East Germany - for example they would sell prisoners to the West (and would give long sentences as the longer the sentence the higher the price).
There was an all embracing surveillance system and when they got to hear of a citizen being in possession of a possibly valuable work of art - or in a one case, stamp collection - they didn’t actually confiscate the item but would then send in a high tax bill so that the owner was forced to hand over the work of art in lieu.
I don’t know whether anyone hasn’t tried to claim back property taken in this way.

SuePine69 · 01/09/2023 14:46

Dizzybelle · 30/08/2023 15:08

If you are talking post WW2, Poland absolutely did not annex any part of Germany. After Poland, and the rest of Eastern Europe, was effectively given to Stalin, to become a soviet satellite, by Churchill and Roosevelt, at Potsdam in 1945 - and Poland had zero say in this. They were not even allowed to participate in these “negotiations”. Subsequently, as some sort of “compensation”to Poles was given - for having lost land to the east, to Stalin, they - Churchill, Stalin & Roosevelt moved Polands borders west to encompass former German lands.

In all of this Poland had no say, they were utterly powerless. Poland was doing any of the annexation.

I know that the Poles had no influence in changes of their borders. That doesn't change the fact that Poland is in possession of land that formerly belonged to Germany. Nobody is expecting them to give it back.

Israel is in possession of land that formerly belonged to Palestinians. Nobody is expecting them to give it back.

Nobody alive today had any say in what was transferred from one country or another, whether it is land or treasures. In many cases you wouldn't want them to give it back. I don't know who owns the diamond mines that up till about 1948 belonged to the Nizam of Hyderabad. I hope diamonds are sold and the money used to help the people on India. I don't think we should give the mines back to his son or grandson.

SurpriseSparDay · 31/08/2023 08:38

Thanks to all for these fascinating snippets of history - and perceptions thereof!

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 16:33

nidgey · 30/08/2023 16:25

Why would you look forward to that? What a strange attitude, and not exactly in line with museological practice. India are planning a concerted campaign for the return of artefacts, and the BM are under huge pressure in terms of the restitution of the Benin bronzes which were stolen in 1897 - the Horniman and university museums have given their Benin material back or plan to, as have other museums worldwide. Decolonisation and deaccessioning of material forcibly taken won't go away as issues.

Not everything I say is serious. Or indeed true.

nidgey · 30/08/2023 16:25

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 12:50

I look forward to the UK telling China to shove it. And indeed India.

Why would you look forward to that? What a strange attitude, and not exactly in line with museological practice. India are planning a concerted campaign for the return of artefacts, and the BM are under huge pressure in terms of the restitution of the Benin bronzes which were stolen in 1897 - the Horniman and university museums have given their Benin material back or plan to, as have other museums worldwide. Decolonisation and deaccessioning of material forcibly taken won't go away as issues.

Fightyouforthatpie · 30/08/2023 15:12

SerendipityJane · 26/08/2023 09:09

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing.

There's a Mercedes the British troops captured from the Argentines during the Falklands at RAF Cosford. With a notice explaining that it was used for years in RAF bases in Germany until it needed a spare part. When the mechanics contacted Mercedes, they initially refused to help as the car was listed as "stolen". There was a court case where the British showed they had legally acquired the vehicle as spoils of war and Mercedes had to pony up.

In fact Mercedes listed this as stolen before the Falklands war, because Argentina hadn't paid them.

Dizzybelle · 30/08/2023 15:08

SuePine69 · 26/08/2023 09:05

There's a difference between getting something by right of conquest and getting something by stealing. When Germany was defeated in 1945 Russia was the authority and did what it saw fit.

Russia annexed the area around Konigsberg. Poland annexed large areas of Germany including Breslau and Stettin. You can't really call this stealing and nobody would suggest that Russia and Poland should give all this land back to Germany.

You could say that the British and other Europeans looted Beijing. However, this was in revenge for the Manchu emperor murdering British and European ambassadors. Torturing them to death, in fact. Perhaps if we can find a descendent of the Manchu emperor, who wasn't ethnic Chinese, we should give all the porcelain, jade, ivory etc. I don't see a reason why it belongs to the Communist party of China.

If you are talking post WW2, Poland absolutely did not annex any part of Germany. After Poland, and the rest of Eastern Europe, was effectively given to Stalin, to become a soviet satellite, by Churchill and Roosevelt, at Potsdam in 1945 - and Poland had zero say in this. They were not even allowed to participate in these “negotiations”. Subsequently, as some sort of “compensation”to Poles was given - for having lost land to the east, to Stalin, they - Churchill, Stalin & Roosevelt moved Polands borders west to encompass former German lands.

In all of this Poland had no say, they were utterly powerless. Poland was doing any of the annexation.

nidgey · 30/08/2023 14:57

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 14:19

I saw a penknife in the San Jacinto memorial museum, Houston TX, a few years ago. It had been passed over by a soldiers family after the battle.

The card underneath it conjectured that it must have belonged to an important man called "Sheffield" as that was finely engraved on the blade.

Having seen the Union Flag upside down outside Baton Rouge Museum earlier that month, I wasn't surprised.

The display of materials from non-British and especially non-European cultures in British museums also leaves a lot to be desired in many cases, such as ritual objects taken from various African adventurers that are labelled completely wrongly.

nidgey · 30/08/2023 14:56

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 13:55

unless you want to argue the people selling the bridge had no right to.

Well the City of London sold it, not some dodgy and destructive aristo going through a tricky and expensive divorce who needed cash (Elgin).

Louloulouenna · 30/08/2023 14:52

@SerendipityJane That’s hilarious 😂

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 14:19

Louloulouenna · 30/08/2023 14:11

British exceptionalism? Do other countries not have museums stuffed full of things from around the globe then?

I saw a penknife in the San Jacinto memorial museum, Houston TX, a few years ago. It had been passed over by a soldiers family after the battle.

The card underneath it conjectured that it must have belonged to an important man called "Sheffield" as that was finely engraved on the blade.

Having seen the Union Flag upside down outside Baton Rouge Museum earlier that month, I wasn't surprised.

Louloulouenna · 30/08/2023 14:11

British exceptionalism? Do other countries not have museums stuffed full of things from around the globe then?

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 14:07

unless you want to argue the people selling the bridge had no right to.

I was being tongue in cheek serendipity.
Obviously such a sale would never be allowed now but up until the late 1970s there was scant regard in UK for built heritage. Look at all the fine buildings which have been demolished since WW2 - many country houses, Euston station, Baltic Exchange, General Post Office Manchester to name but very few.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 13:55

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:23

London Bridge was sold to America in 1968, dismantled, shipped and re-erected in Arizona.
Maybe we should ask for that back.

unless you want to argue the people selling the bridge had no right to.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 30/08/2023 13:44

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 30/08/2023 13:40

The Yale Center For British Art has a bit!

I very much doubt it’s dodgy. But you seem to be implying there isn’t British art overseas.

SerendipityJane · 30/08/2023 13:44

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:23

London Bridge was sold to America in 1968, dismantled, shipped and re-erected in Arizona.
Maybe we should ask for that back.

"sold"

nidgey · 30/08/2023 13:42

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 30/08/2023 13:40

The Yale Center For British Art has a bit!

Well if acquired in dodgy circumstances, yes it would seem fair enough to ask for them back

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 30/08/2023 13:40

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:38

What British artefacts?

Works of art, paintings, furniture, sculpture etc. in museums overseas. Plenty in American museums.

The Yale Center For British Art has a bit!

Barbadossunset · 30/08/2023 13:38

What British artefacts?

Works of art, paintings, furniture, sculpture etc. in museums overseas. Plenty in American museums.