Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘As ye sow, so shall ye reap.’ The British Museum; the writhing …

234 replies

SurpriseSparDay · 26/08/2023 08:29

I can’t be the only person utterly fascinated by the level of distraught handwringing disbelief the British Museum is experiencing right now.

Theft, eh?

How, pray, did this great institution acquire the artefacts contained therein? How?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SurpriseSparDay · 09/09/2023 08:04

You sound like Vicky Pollard: "Oooh my God, I so can't believe you just said that!!"

Only thing is, I don’t look like her.

I look more like “the Nigerians” whose artefacts you seem to believe “belong to the world”

We can read, y’know?

OP posts:
Sometimeswinning · 08/09/2023 17:58

Grammarnut · 08/09/2023 11:48

The British Museum bought the marbles from Lord Elgin, who had bought them from the governor of Greece at the time - Greece was part of the Ottoman Empire. The Parthenon was being broken up and the stone used to make lime. Elgin rescued the remaining pieces, which would have otherwise been destroyed. No-one in Greece at the time thought anything of the Parthenon (which was used as an arsenal and had blown up in the eighteenth century) but that it was a good source of limestone (this is the case for old buildings all over the world e.g. English castles and churches often incorporate stone from Roman buildings etc). The purchase was legal and also a wonderful rescue. Why should the BM return them to Greece, which I think might require an Act of Parliament and also open the doors to demands that other legally purchased artefacts be returned?

I mean… I don’t want to be pulled into this again but it really wasn’t as clear cut as this. As much as it annoys me the stupid comments saying “It’s been proven and they were definitely stolen” There is even less proof chance Elgin’s permission reached to the removal.

SuePine69 · 08/09/2023 14:48

Dizzybelle · 02/09/2023 14:10

You return it - what ever the object is, to the nation that it was taken from.

Did you know that there are two Chinas? Chiang Kai-shek reunited China and was for many years regarded as the legitimate ruler. The Communists renewed their insurgency and managed to take control of mainland China. Chiang Kai-shek retained control of Taiwan.

The Communists had no respect for Chinese culture and destroyed a lot of it including buildings. This got worse under the Cultural Revolution. So if we're going to give anything back it should be to Taiwan, but then the Communists would make a fuss about that.

The Kangxi Emperor was Buddhist. Tibetan Buddhism was patronised by the Manchus. I wonder if there are any artefacts in the British Museum looted by Elgin's forces from Beijing that are religious. We wouldn't want to return those to the Communists. These artefacts would be Tibetan or Manchu, not Chinese.

SuePine69 · 08/09/2023 14:27

SurpriseSparDay · 02/09/2023 15:49

Even more so the Benin Bronzes. Something like them can go to different parts of the world in exhibitions. Maybe the Nigerians could keep them part of the year and then they go to New York, Tokyo or wherever for part of the year. They belong to the world really. Do they belong to the world, to the Nigerians or to the Edo people? It doesn't really matter if plenty of people get to see them.

Shock

You actually wrote these words?

Fucking hell…

You sound like Vicky Pollard: "Oooh my God, I so can't believe you just said that!!"

Grammarnut · 08/09/2023 11:48

The British Museum bought the marbles from Lord Elgin, who had bought them from the governor of Greece at the time - Greece was part of the Ottoman Empire. The Parthenon was being broken up and the stone used to make lime. Elgin rescued the remaining pieces, which would have otherwise been destroyed. No-one in Greece at the time thought anything of the Parthenon (which was used as an arsenal and had blown up in the eighteenth century) but that it was a good source of limestone (this is the case for old buildings all over the world e.g. English castles and churches often incorporate stone from Roman buildings etc). The purchase was legal and also a wonderful rescue. Why should the BM return them to Greece, which I think might require an Act of Parliament and also open the doors to demands that other legally purchased artefacts be returned?

Sometimeswinning · 05/09/2023 06:28

Yeah I think they all pretty much say the same thing anyway. Hopefully one day it will be sorted.

Fimofriend · 05/09/2023 05:51

@Sometimeswinning Those were new articles.

I also figured it was best only to include links to articles in English.

Sometimeswinning · 04/09/2023 21:59

@Fimofriend I don’t think these articles mean what you think they mean. This is what happens when you think you know about a subject after 2 minutes on Google.

Fimofriend · 04/09/2023 06:20

@Sometimeswinning I googled for two minutes: The first two non-British homepages I found both stated that Elgin didn't have permission:
https://news.sky.com/story/elgin-marbles-what-are-they-and-how-did-they-end-up-in-the-british-museum-12779617
” He is said to have claimed he had been given permission by the Ottoman Empire for the transfer of the marbles - but despite the vast documentation from that period, nothing has been found to support his actions.”

https://greekreporter.com/2023/08/08/1801-when-lord-elgin-removed-the-first-sculptures-from-parthenon-to-take-to-england/ states that Elgin had permission to do excavations on Parthenon. Nothing else.

Not everything you read in British newspapers is true.

Elgin Marbles: What are they and how did they end up in the British Museum?

Seen as symbols of freedom in Greece, the Parthenon Marbles were controversially removed from the country by a British diplomat in a move which ignited a debate which has lasted for more than two centuries - and which could now be about to take another...

https://news.sky.com/story/elgin-marbles-what-are-they-and-how-did-they-end-up-in-the-british-museum-12779617

Sometimeswinning · 02/09/2023 21:54

@Fimofriend ah ok. Also known as I can’t share any link because it doesn’t exist!

Also not everything you read on Google is true.

The majority of people believe he stole them. As it is the British museum stand by the fact he had permission. There is no proof he didn’t, apart from Elgins word. There is no way to disprove this and Parliament back in the day decided he was to be believed. So that’s where we are. There is no proof beyond a doubt. There is speculation which is where you became confused.

Fimofriend · 02/09/2023 21:06

@Sometimeswinning I have found several articles. I am sure you can too. Try
www.google.com

Google

http://www.google.com

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 18:27

What ? Obeying orders

You could say that about Nazi orders. Also after German reunification the border guards who shot and killed the last two escapees over the Berlin Wall were tried in court though they too were obeying orders.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 17:45

Were any of the Red Guards ever punished for what they did?

What ? Obeying orders

Sometimeswinning · 02/09/2023 15:59

Fimofriend · 02/09/2023 15:01

@Sometimeswinning What are you on about? It has been proven without a doubt that the Parthenon marbles were stolen by Lord Elgin. He bribed a high-ranking Turkish official to look the other way. The Turkish government, who ruled Greece at the time, had NOT approved the removal of the marbles. It was theft and just like now it was also then a crime to buy stolen goods.

Well not quite. There is more a question as to whether he should have removed fixed artefacts.

I genuinely find it all very interesting and have obviously missed where it was proven (not speculated) that he stole them. (Which would not shock me. He wasn’t a very nice person) If you could send me the link I’d actually like to read it. TIA.

SurpriseSparDay · 02/09/2023 15:49

Even more so the Benin Bronzes. Something like them can go to different parts of the world in exhibitions. Maybe the Nigerians could keep them part of the year and then they go to New York, Tokyo or wherever for part of the year. They belong to the world really. Do they belong to the world, to the Nigerians or to the Edo people? It doesn't really matter if plenty of people get to see them.

Shock

You actually wrote these words?

Fucking hell…

OP posts:
Dizzybelle · 02/09/2023 15:26

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 14:54

You return it - what ever the object is, to the nation that it was taken from.

Dizzybelle does that apply to every museum in the world?

Yes, in an ideal world, this would apply to every museum. If something has been proven to have been stolen, or taken without permission then it should be returned, where ever possible.

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 15:11

Yes, the cultural revolution is widely considered a horrific nightmare that is regretted by the whole nation. There is an entire genre of modern Chinese literature called 'scar fiction' about experiences of that time and massive attention and care given to the artefacts and buildings that were hidden/protected and survived.

Thank you for your interesting post. I was unaware of that. Were any of the Red Guards ever punished for what they did?

AtLastShrugs · 02/09/2023 15:08

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 14:53

That's why they want Taiwan back, although they don't seem to be bothered about the Russian annexations or Mongolia either although the Emperor controlled that too.

I wonder if they’re bothered at the mass destruction of irreplaceable buildings, antiques and artefacts destroyed on the order of Chairman Mao.

Yes, the cultural revolution is widely considered a horrific nightmare that is regretted by the whole nation. There is an entire genre of modern Chinese literature called 'scar fiction' about experiences of that time and massive attention and care given to the artefacts and buildings that were hidden/protected and survived.

Fimofriend · 02/09/2023 15:01

@Sometimeswinning What are you on about? It has been proven without a doubt that the Parthenon marbles were stolen by Lord Elgin. He bribed a high-ranking Turkish official to look the other way. The Turkish government, who ruled Greece at the time, had NOT approved the removal of the marbles. It was theft and just like now it was also then a crime to buy stolen goods.

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 14:56

If the person is still alive that might be possible but not always desirable. If they are dead then who would you return it to?

The person’s descendants as in the various cases of art looted from Jewish families by the Nazis?

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 14:54

You return it - what ever the object is, to the nation that it was taken from.

Dizzybelle does that apply to every museum in the world?

Barbadossunset · 02/09/2023 14:53

That's why they want Taiwan back, although they don't seem to be bothered about the Russian annexations or Mongolia either although the Emperor controlled that too.

I wonder if they’re bothered at the mass destruction of irreplaceable buildings, antiques and artefacts destroyed on the order of Chairman Mao.

SerendipityJane · 02/09/2023 14:19

You return it - what ever the object is, to the nation that it was taken from.

Seems like we have arrived at the start again

Not all nations on the map now existed even 40 years ago. Let alone one or two centuries ago.

Dizzybelle · 02/09/2023 14:10

SuePine69 · 02/09/2023 12:06

If the person is still alive that might be possible but not always desirable. If they are dead then who would you return it to? The example I gave was the Nizam of Hyderabad with his diamond mines.

In 1860 Lord Elgin, ordered troops to loot and destroy both the Summer Palace and Old Summer Palace to avenge the killing of several British envoys to Beijing. The Xianfeng Emperor lost of precious things some of them probably ending up in the British Museum with the Greek marbles.

The Xianfeng Emperor wasn't ethnic Chinese, he was a Manchu. The Manchus conquered China and acquired its wealth. Was that stealing? So who should we give it all back to? Any descendants of the Xianfeng Emperor? The Manchu people? The Chinese government? The Taiwanese government?

At the same time the Xianfeng Emperor lost a lot of territory to the Russians. They're not going to give it back. That was more important than trinkets. The Chinese government seem to think that everywhere that was part of the Manchu empire should now belong to them. That's why they want Taiwan back, although they don't seem to be bothered about the Russian annexations or Mongolia either although the Emperor controlled that too.

The Poles didn't have any say in how they acquired German territory after WW2 but they did 25 years earlier when they occupied Ukrainian, Belorussian and Lithuanian territory. This included the cities of Vilnius and Lviv. Was that stealing? It's just as well they did because it stopped large numbers of Ukrainians from starving to death in Stalin's deliberate famine. Just goes to show how you can't see history in terms of black and white, heroes and villains.

You return it - what ever the object is, to the nation that it was taken from.

Swipe left for the next trending thread